Court OK's insurance company's painful extraction from disabled dentist
Sep. 9—A deal is a deal, right? Well, at least until one of the parties decides they don't like the deal and goes to court.
That was the case with Dr.
Not to worry, though, because the good dentist had disability insurance with the
Then the company discovered that the disabled doctor, while not practicing dentistry, held part-time teaching positions and earned other income working for two professional dental associations.
The insurance company terminated Caraba's benefits because it concluded that he had a "gainful occupation," meaning he did not suffer from a "total disability."
Caraba sued, but a federal appeals court ruled recently that the insurance company followed the rules as written in the policy and was within its legal rights to terminate Caraba's benefits.
Caraba's argument was clear — because of his health issues, he is unable to work as a dentist. Isn't that total ability for a professional like himself?
It certainly could be.
But his insurance contract states that "total disability" because of injury or sickness is defined by a three-part test:
* The insured is "unable to perform to the important duties of (his) occupation."
* The insured is "not engaged in any other gainful employment."
* The insured is "receiving physician's care."
Caraba was definitely employed, but was his employment "gainful"? He argued that the insurance company "incorrectly concluded that his part-time teaching and professional association work constituted 'gainful occupation.'"
One of the interesting aspects of a court decision like this is the extent to which the judges interpret the issues.
First, they noted the contract language is, according to legal precedent, "presumed to speak for the intention of the parties" and bars courts from "artificially" creating ambiguity "where none exists."
That being the case, what does "gainful employment" mean? That depends on the type of policy Caraba purchased.
An "occupational" disability policy pays if the insured is unable "to perform his regular job." A "general" disability policy pays if the insured is "unable to perform any job" for which he is qualified.
Caraba purchased a "general" disability policy, meaning "he was required to show that he could not make a reasonable living from any job for which he was qualified, not just his prior occupation as a dentist."
"A claimant need not be utterly helpless to be considered disabled under a general disability policy," wrote appeals court Justice
So was his employment "gainful," meaning Caraba could "earn a reasonably substantial income"? The court noted that Caraba earned about
That income fell to about
The court noted that Caraba's "post-disability income was still higher than the median wage of
"Caraba asked that we inject ambiguity into a policy term where none is present and then construe that term in a light most favorable to him," Jackson-Akiwumi wrote.
No can do under the law, the court ruled: Dentist loses and insurance company wins.
© 2026 The News-Gazette (Champaign, Ill.). Visit www.news-gazette.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.


More tariff costs are being passed on to consumers
Best’s Market Segment Report: AM Best Maintains Stable Outlook on Malaysia’s Non-Life Insurance Segment
Advisor News
- SEC settlement would require Tai Lopez, two others, to pay $6.8 million
- The Gen Z money paradox
- NAIFA applauds final SECURE 2.0 regulations
- What will Democrats in Congress do about healthcare and retirement?
- Election results cloud retirement legislation outlook, experts say
More Advisor NewsAnnuity News
- Best’s Market Segment Report: AM Best Maintains Stable Outlook on US Life/Annuity Insurance Segment
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company and Its Subsidiaries
- Boomers want retirement protection, but their actions don’t match their mindset
- NAIC task force to address LTC riders
- ‘It’s really shocking:’ Regulators scrutinize assets backing annuity sellers
More Annuity NewsHealth/Employee Benefits News
- Hooksett, Auburn, Candia, Londonderry schools face steep SchoolCare health insurance hikes
- 'Everybody missed this': Nevada's state worker insurance mismanaged for years, officials say
- Picking Medicare insurance plan is daunting task – Healthful Hints
- November Issue of Best’s Review Ranks US Life Reinsurers and More
- New York Life Announces Record $3.1 Billion in Policy Owner Dividends for 2027
More Health/Employee Benefits NewsLife Insurance News
- November Issue of Best’s Review Ranks US Life Reinsurers and More
- Nebraska widow’s big win against life insurer in legal limbo
- New York Life Announces Record $3.1 Billion in Policy Owner Dividends for 2027
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company and Its Subsidiaries
- U-Haul Holding Company to Participate in Deutsche Bank Conference
More Life Insurance News