Condo living could be more costly in the post-collapse world

South Florida Sun Sentinel (FL)

One thing has become clear since the fall of the Champlain Towers South condo: many condos are falling apart, often because owners don’t want to spend the money to maintain them. Soon, they might have no choice but to pay.

On Monday, a Broward County task force agreed, informally, to recommend a change in state law that would make it harder for condos to waive the proper funding of reserves and to require more frequent inspections for coastal condos. The changes, if adopted by the state, could make condo living move expensive, but safer.

“It’s going to hurt in the beginning, but that’s where we have to get,” insurance expert Paul Handerhan, President of the Federal Association for Insurance Reform (FAIR), told the committee Monday, echoing many of their own opinions. “… There’s no way to get out of this without paying.”

Monday’s was the second of three meetings for the Broward County Condominium Structural Issues Committee, set up by Mayor Steve Geller to quickly offer recommendations to the state Legislature, whose committee meetings begin next month.

The Florida Bar and the Community Associations Institute trade group also are studying issues arising from the June 24 condo collapse in Surfside, and will offer recommendations to the governor and Legislature.

All are focused on just a few topics, including the issues of reserves and inspections.

Currently, reserves can be waived by majority vote of those present at a condo meeting. And the first major inspection is not required in Broward until a building turns 40.

“We’re here to try to come up with creative ways to make buildings safe. What Surfside has done is made city officials, building officials, condo residents, everybody aware of the widespread lack of maintenance in older condos,” said Hollywood Commissioner Caryl Shuham, who has a degree in civil engineering and is an attorney.

She recommended, and the committee conceptually agreed, that condos should have to present a reserve study to unit owners and secure a super-majority vote to waive full funding of reserves. She also suggested reserves not be waived unless an engineer has inspected the building and issued a report.

The potential cost to condo owners is not lost on state, county and city officials or the civic and industry leaders huddling on the issue.

While some million-dollar condo owners might have no trouble forking over extra money, many unit owners are not in that category. Even the inspections are costly, one condo representative said. Unit owners could be forced out and condo sales could be stifled, some said.

“In certain cases, you could be mandating the death of a building,” said Fred Nesbitt, president of the Galt Ocean Mile condo association in Fort Lauderdale, which opposes reserve mandates. “I think we should still give owners choice.”

Geller said condos that don’t properly save for repairs face sticker shock with giant special assessments. By the time a major problem is found, he said, it’s too late to start paying into reserves.

“You can’t insure a burning building, and you can’t start reserving for an emergency that has already arrived,” he said.

The cause of the Champlain collapse remains unknown but is under investigation. Because there was evidence of poor maintenance and crumbling, cracking concrete at the Champlain, there has been a sharp focus on how government can ensure that condos are kept in good repair.

“It’s terrifying to me that we’re in this place,” said state Sen. Lauren Book, one of four state legislators on the county committee. Book complained that there’s no one keeping track of individual condos - where they stand with insurance, reserves, and repairs.

The committee also debated whether more frequent inspections are needed. Broward is one of two counties in Florida - the other being Miami-Dade - that requires buildings to be inspected for electrical and structural safety at age 40 and every 10 years subsequently.

Dr. Jennifer Jurado, Broward County’s climate change sustainability director, said the striking increase in sea level here - more than a foot over 20 years - could increase deterioration of concrete in buildings along the coast. She also cited temperate change and flood levels in saying that inspections should begin earlier, at 25 or 30 years.

But Dan Lavrich, a structural engineer and chairman of the Broward County Board of Rules and Appeals, which oversees application of the building code, questioned the need. Any change in the inspection program would have to be approved by Rules and Appeals, and the Florida Building Commission.

“The rest of the state has no program at all,” he said of the 40-year safety program, “and they don’t have any problems.”

The Broward committee will hold what it expects to be its final meeting in a week, on Aug. 30, where formal recommendations will be voted on.