Texas judge deals DOL another setback on rollover regulation - Insurance News | InsuranceNewsNet

InsuranceNewsNet — Your Industry. One Source.™

Sign in
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
Home Now reading Top Stories
Topics
    • Advisor News
    • Annuity Index
    • Annuity News
    • Companies
    • Earnings
    • Fiduciary
    • From the Field: Expert Insights
    • Health/Employee Benefits
    • Insurance & Financial Fraud
    • INN Magazine
    • Insiders Only
    • Life Insurance News
    • Newswires
    • Property and Casualty
    • Regulation News
    • Sponsored Articles
    • Washington Wire
    • Videos
    • ———
    • About
    • Meet our Editorial Staff
    • Advertise
    • Contact
    • Newsletters
  • Exclusives
  • NewsWires
  • Magazine
  • Newsletters
Sign in or register to be an INNsider.
  • AdvisorNews
  • Annuity News
  • Companies
  • Earnings
  • Fiduciary
  • Health/Employee Benefits
  • Insurance & Financial Fraud
  • INN Exclusives
  • INN Magazine
  • Insurtech
  • Life Insurance News
  • Newswires
  • Property and Casualty
  • Regulation News
  • Sponsored Articles
  • Video
  • Washington Wire
  • Life Insurance
  • Annuities
  • Advisor
  • Health/Benefits
  • Property & Casualty
  • Insurtech
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Editorial Staff

Get Social

  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
Regulation News
Top Stories RSS Get our newsletter
Order Prints
July 7, 2023 Top Stories
Share
Share
Post
Email

Texas judge deals DOL another setback on rollover regulation

Image shows a gavel pounding down against a backdrop of the Department of Labor building.
A Texas judge gave plaintiffs a partial summary judgment last week in a lawsuit against the investment advice rule.
By John Hilton

A second federal court dealt a blow last week to the Department of Labor's ongoing bid to extend fiduciary status to more rollover transactions.

U.S. Magistrate Judge Rebecca Rutherford recommended against the DOL's broad interpretation of the "five-part test" to determine what constitutes investment advice. Dating to 1975, the five-part test is utilized to determine fiduciary status under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974.

Rutherford issued her recommendation in a 75-page “findings, conclusions, and recommendations” in response to a suit filed in February 2022 by the Federation of Americans for Consumer Choice.

"Based on ERISA’s text and purpose, coupled with the common law understandings of fiduciary relationships, the Court should find the DOL’s new interpretation of the five-part test narrowly conflicts with ERISA and the DOL’s own regulations," the judge wrote. "In view of this conflict, the Court should conclude that the DOL exceeded its statutory authority in promulgating the new interpretation and that the new interpretation is an arbitrary and capricious interpretation."

The judge also recommended denial of motions for summary judgment by both the DOL and FACC.

"We are pleased to see the magistrate judge has recommended District Judge Kinkeade vacate portions of DOL’s overreaching reinterpretation of the five-part test to the extent it combines IRAs with employer ERISA plans to determine who is a fiduciary," said Kim O'Brien, CEO of FACC.

O'Brien declined further comment "until we have completed our review and decide on next steps."

Second loss in court

The recommendation is the second loss in court by the DOL this year. In February, Judge Virginia M. Hernandez Covington sided with the American Securities Association in striking down a portion of guidance the DOL issued in 2021 that expanded the definition of a retirement plan fiduciary.

The judge ruled that a portion of the department’s frequently-asked-questions guidance illegally widened its regulatory lane, and failed to comply with the agency’s own regulations.

Rutherford cited the Florida court decision in her recommendation. Both ASA and FACC sued just days after the Trump administration's investment advice rule took effect in February 2022.

Included in the rule was a new prohibited transaction exemption allowing advisors to provide conflicted advice for commissions; and a reinstatement of the five-part test to determine what constitutes investment advice.

The DOL initially appealed the Florida ASA decision, then withdrew its appeal in May. Meanwhile, the agency is pursuing a fiduciary rule rewrite that it has said it will unveil next month. Some analysts doubt the DOL can produce the rule that quickly.

Concern for rollover decisions

The DOL is most concerned about rollovers, or retirement plan decisions involving retirement dollars.

When recipients retire and the money is "rolled" out of those plans, many advisors earn a commission. Regulators consider that a conflict of interest and want to expand the definition of fiduciary. One of the five-part test prongs is whether the advisor and client are in an "ongoing relationship."

In order to satisfy that prong, the DOL claims a one-time rollover contains the expectation of future advice rendered.

Judge Covington reminded the DOL with her decision that the agency does not have jurisdiction over Individual Retirement Plans (IRAs). The DOL has enforcement authority over workplace retirement plans.

Rutherford acknowledged the DOL concerns on rollover transactions, but said it must be done lawfully. She referenced a 2018 appeals court ruling tossing out an Obama administration fiduciary rule effort.

"While the Court may view the DOL’s new interpretation as part of the agency’s well-intentioned efforts to update its regulations to ensure that fiduciary advice providers adhere to stringent standards designed to ensure that investment recommendations by financial institutions and professionals reflect the best interests of plan and IRA investors, the Court must also recognize that other similar agency efforts have not held up well under judicial scrutiny."

Senior Editor John Hilton covered business and other beats in more than 20 years of daily journalism. John may be reached at john.hilton@innfeedback.com. Follow him on Twitter @INNJohnH.

© Entire contents copyright 2023 by InsuranceNewsNet.com Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this article may be reprinted without the expressed written consent from InsuranceNewsNet.com.

John Hilton

InsuranceNewsNet Senior Editor John Hilton has covered business and other beats in more than 20 years of daily journalism. John may be reached at john.hilton@innfeedback.com. Follow him on Twitter @INNJohnH.

Older

‘Annuity King’ partner claims bipolar disorder in presentence report

Newer

Short-term health plans subject to new rules

Advisor News

  • NAIFA applauds final SECURE 2.0 regulations
  • What will Democrats in Congress do about healthcare and retirement?
  • Election results cloud retirement legislation outlook, experts say
  • Planning for the missing chapter
  • Semi-retirement: helping clients balance flexibility with financial security
More Advisor News

Annuity News

  • ‘It’s really shocking:’ Regulators scrutinize assets backing annuity sellers
  • Jackson Launches Direct-to-Consumer Annuity Offering
  • Global Atlantic launches ForeIncome Flex
  • Athene CEO criticizes offshore reinsurance, risk-taking by competitors
  • DOL, trade groups, state AGs file briefs supporting Alcoa in PRT lawsuit
More Annuity News

Health/Employee Benefits News

  • Oscar Highlights Tailored New Health Products in Florida for 2027 Open Enrollment
  • Oscar Highlights Tailored New Health Products in Texas for 2027 Open Enrollment
  • States get until July to cut Medicaid coverage over work requirement
  • CRUSH Rule could crush health insurance agents, industry group says
  • Despite rising healthcare costs, enrollment on Nevada insurance exchange is 'pretty steady'
More Health/Employee Benefits News

Life Insurance News

  • Best’s Commentary: Shanghai Cross-Border Investment Pilot Unlocks Overseas Growth Potential of China Non-Life Companies
  • Military Briefs: November 19-25
  • California’s new solvency rules: What should life insurance advisors watch?
  • Navigating delayed death certificates: A guide for life insurance advisors
  • Jackson Launches Direct-to-Consumer Annuity Offering
More Life Insurance News

NEWS INSIDE

  • Companies
  • Earnings
  • Economic News
  • INN Magazine
  • Insurtech News
  • Newswires Feed
  • Regulation News
  • Washington Wire
  • Videos

FEATURED OFFERS

Press Releases

  • OpenRoad Insurance Data Shows 40% of Collector Vehicles Are Model Year 1980 or Newer
  • Insurvoice Lets Independent Insurance Agency Owners Analyze Every Customer Call in ChatGPT or Claude
  • Spectrum Weather & Specialty Insurance Celebrates 15 Years and Welcomes the Next Generation
  • Royal Neighbors of America® Increases Service Capacity
  • Benefits Studio Launches to Fill the Missing Middle of Benefits Navigation at $49/mo
More Press Releases > Add Your Press Release >

How to Write For InsuranceNewsNet

Find out how you can submit content for publishing on our website.
View Guidelines

Topics

  • Advisor News
  • Annuity Index
  • Annuity News
  • Companies
  • Earnings
  • Fiduciary
  • From the Field: Expert Insights
  • Health/Employee Benefits
  • Insurance & Financial Fraud
  • INN Magazine
  • Insiders Only
  • Life Insurance News
  • Newswires
  • Property and Casualty
  • Regulation News
  • Sponsored Articles
  • Washington Wire
  • Videos
  • ———
  • About
  • Meet our Editorial Staff
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Newsletters

Top Sections

  • AdvisorNews
  • Annuity News
  • Health/Employee Benefits News
  • InsuranceNewsNet Magazine
  • Life Insurance News
  • Property and Casualty News
  • Washington Wire

Our Company

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Meet our Editorial Staff
  • Magazine Subscription
  • Write for INN

Sign up for our FREE e-Newsletter!

Get breaking news, exclusive stories, and money- making insights straight into your inbox.

select Newsletter Options
Facebook Linkedin Twitter
© 2026 InsuranceNewsNet.com, Inc. All rights reserved.
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • InsuranceNewsNet Magazine

Sign in with your Insider Pro Account

Not registered? Become an Insider Pro.