San Diego ready to reverse Proposition B pension cuts, potentially ending 9-year legal battle
The nearly nine-year legal fight over
The end of the legal fight comes nearly three years after the state
Proposition B eliminated pensions for all new hires after
The city's cost to create pensions for those workers was estimated at somewhere between
That's because court rulings say the city gets financial credit for providing employees hired since Proposition B with 401(k)-style retirement plans instead of traditional pensions.
Those retirement plans have surged in value because stocks have done so well during the last nine years, increasing how much credit the city will get and shrinking what the city will owe to create pensions for the workers.
Court rulings say the amount the city must pay is the cost of creating pensions for the affected workers, minus half the value of the 401(k)-style plans those workers received in lieu of pensions.
Half the value would be subtracted instead of the full value because the city and the individual employee have made equal contributions to the 401(k)-style plans.
But the city's cost for creating the pensions will also essentially be half the overall cost. That's because the affected workers will have to follow normal city procedures that require workers to cover half the contributions to their pension.
During the early stages of the legal fight, there was speculation that if Proposition B was overturned the affected workers would be given a choice between entering the pension system or just sticking with the 401(k)-style plan.
But under federal tax law, all workers must be required to have pensions in order for a city's pension system to maintain its tax-exempt status.
The affected workers will likely be given a choice of receiving a pension that starts this summer or receiving a retroactive pension with the same start date that they were hired.
The retroactive pensions, which will be more valuable and allow the worker to retire sooner than a pension that starts this summer, will be costly for the employees because they will have to pay — in a lump sum — years of pension contributions that they missed.
A worker hired in 2019 or 2020 who chooses a retroactive pension will pay far less than a worker hired in 2012 or 2013, who could owe tens of thousands of dollars in retroactive pension contributions.
Also pension reforms approved by the
Many affected workers are still expected to consider opting for retroactive pensions.
Details of how this will all work are expected to be negotiated this spring between city labor unions, attorneys for the city, the city's pension system and officials at
Just after the court ruling in January ordering the city to overturn the pension cuts, Mayor
City Attorney
The 90-day window to appeal the
Officials of the city's pension system, the
"The city is not waiting until time runs out and has begun addressing how to restore SDCERS benefits to the affected employees," Chief Executive
Zucchet, general manager of the
A key element that must be negotiated is a 7 percent penalty courts have ruled the city must pay for illegally implementing the pension cuts. One possible resolution is requiring one-time contributions by the city to the 401(k)-style plans of the affected workers.
The negotiating process will be overseen by the state's Public Employment Relations Board.
The end of the legal fight starts a procedural process at
The council must twice approve an ordinance that removes the language of Proposition B from the city charter. Those votes, which should take place this spring or summer, will allow workers other than police officers to receive pensions.
When the state
Instead the matter was kicked back to
This story originally appeared in
___
(c)2021 The San Diego Union-Tribune
Visit The San Diego Union-Tribune at www.sandiegouniontribune.com
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
NAIC Survey: Homeowners Concerned About Climate-Related Threats
Carlisle school board leans toward a 2% tax hike for next year
Advisor News
Annuity News
Health/Employee Benefits News
Life Insurance News