House Financial Services Subcommittee Issues Statement From Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers
* * *
I. Introduction
This written statement for the record is intended to support the oral testimony of
Founded in 1896, the Big "I" is the nation's oldest and largest national association of independent insurance agents and brokers, representing more than 25,000 agency locations united under the Trusted Choice brand. Trusted Choice independent agents offer consumers all types of insurance--property, casualty, life, health, employee benefit plans and retirement products--from a variety of insurance companies. As explained further below, the Big "I" supports a modernized and transparent NFIP that would increase take-up rates for flood insurance, both in the NFIP and the private market.
II. The need for flood insurance continues to grow and the Big "I" supports policies to increase take-up rates, whether in the NFIP or the private market.
The 2020 hurricane season ended with a record-breaking 30 named storms and seven of those classified as major hurricanes with winds topping 111 miles per hour. The following year saw four major hurricanes, and in 2022 there were two major hurricanes, one of which (Ian) became the third costliest storm on record, according to the
While encouraging property owners and communities to mitigate before disaster strikes and enforcing floodplain management standards and building codes in high-risk areas will go a long way in minimizing risk, flood insurance will always remain a necessary safety net for property owners. In that regard the NFIP is a vital government program as it is the primary source of flood insurance for
Outside of the NFIP there is a small but growing private insurance market. Historically, flooding has been a difficult risk to underwrite in the private market; however, advances in modeling and underwriting technology have contributed to some market growth in recent years. According to the
Yet to date, the private insurance market covers only a small portion of flood risk nationally. While commercial flood insurance markets are more developed, private flood insurance on residential properties remains less common. Nonetheless, even
While some have expressed concern that a growing private market will harm the NFIP because private insurers will select the best risks from the NFIP, the Big "I" like
III. The Big "I" supports making statutory and regulatory reforms to increase participation in the flood insurance market.
The Big "I" supports making legislative or regulatory changes to some aspects of the NFIP to facilitate continued private market growth in high-risk flood zones, protect consumers, and help ensure consumers have affordable insurance choices. For example, the Big "I" strongly supports H.R.900, which was recently introduced by Representatives
The risk of a substantial NFIP rate increase should the consumer later wish to return to the NFIP often makes insurance agents and brokers hesitant to recommend private flood insurance policies. As such, the Big "I" encourages
The Big "I" also supports allowing refunds for unearned premiums for the mid-term cancelation of NFIP policies if a consumer elects to purchase a policy from the private flood insurance market. In the private property insurance market if a consumer cancels an insurance policy because they obtained insurance elsewhere that better meets their needs, they are generally entitled to a refund for any unearned premiums remaining on the term of the policy. However, under current NFIP guidance and regulations it is unclear if and when policy holders can obtain such refunds. This is also an important consumer protection and affordability issue.
Prior to Risk Rating 2.0, the NFIP's "Preferred Risk" product written in most parts of the country not considered to be high risk, was significantly underpriced. In fact, this segment was the most unprofitable segment of the NFIP. While Risk Rating 2.0 corrected that problem by introducing actuarially correct premiums, these premiums are often much higher than those under the prior rating system. Ultimately, the Big "I" believes that Risk Rating 2.0 has the potential to improve the NFIP experience for consumers and improve financial sustainability, but it may also lead to fewer people purchasing flood insurance in certain parts of the country. While the NFIP has stated it believes accurate premiums are the best indicator of flood risk to a consumer, that only leads to increased participation if consumers believe the premiums to be accurate and affordable. Widespread education regarding flood risk that is universally delivered but narrowly focused for local geographic areas will be essential to achieve policy growth in these areas.
Finally, under the National Flood Disaster Protection Act, flood insurance is required for federally related loans if the property securing the loan is in a Special
IV. Independent insurance agents and brokers play in a critical role in the sale and delivery of flood insurance and must continue to do so for consumer participation to increase.
Agents prefer to work with Write Your Own (WYO) insurers because they offer greater expertise and are more responsive than NFIP Direct. Agents find it easier to place policies and serve policyholders when working with a WYO insurer. One reason for this is that WYO insurers have greater freedom to listen to policyholders and agents and adjust staffing and resources better than the NFIP Direct Facility, which operates under constraints of the
NFIP policies, procedures, and requirements are complex, and agents serve as a vital conduit between the NFIP, the companies, and consumers. Agents generally serve as the first point of contact for a consumer to explain the necessity for flood insurance. The sale, servicing and underwriting of NFIP policies is complicated; and where the purchase of flood insurance is not required by statute, regulation or otherwise by mortgage lender, property owners are often reluctant to purchase flood insurance as they have often been erroneously led to believe they are "not in a flood zone" and therefore do not need flood insurance when, in fact, more than 20% of flood losses occur outside a SFHA.
Despite the need for flood insurance, purchasing flood insurance can be a daunting and complex process, especially within the SFHA. Insurance agents and brokers, whether selling in the NFIP or via a private insurer, help consumers estimate flood risk and insurance cost and discuss several "what if" scenarios with potential policyholders. Insurance agents and brokers help to prepare quotes, ensure consumers understand the impact of different policy limits and deductibles, and work to explain different policy provisions to inform the consumer's purchase decision.
Independent agents and WYO insurers work closely together to provide policyholder service and resolve issues over the life of a policy. For example, agents and WYO insurers process lender requests, and execute policy changes resulting from map changes, rule/underwriting changes, changes in risk, make coverage changes and respond to policyholder and lender questions. Further, agents play a critical role in retaining NFIP flood policies. When a policyholder pays off a mortgage or is no longer required to carry flood insurance due to a map change, agents are the people who speak with homeowners and recommend they retain coverage. To achieve the goal of increasing the number of households insured for the peril of flood, policy retention is just as important as writing new policies.
This is all to say that flood is an extremely complicated product to sell and must be done by a live person who understands the intricacies. In this digital age there is often a rush to cut corners under the erroneous notion that an automated process can replace human interaction and expertise. In the case of flood insurance, which protects the very property that liberty provides, this could not be farther from the truth. Any kind of proposal that undercuts the valuable and trusted role that independent insurance agents and brokers play in this process could have a negative impact on increasing flood insurance participation rates.
V. Conclusion
In conclusion, the Big "I" supports a transparent and modernized NFIP that would increase take-up rates for flood insurance, both in the NFIP and the private market. Specifically, the Big "I" urges
* * *
Original text here: https://docs.house.gov/meetings/BA/BA04/20230310/115462/HHRG-118-BA04-Wstate-HeidrickC-20230310.pdf
House Financial Services Subcommittee Issues Testimony From Dual Special Flood President Small
House Financial Services Subcommittee Issues Testimony From Marsh McLennan
Advisor News
Annuity News
Health/Employee Benefits News
Life Insurance News