Expanding Health Care Access Through Education: Dissemination and Implementation of the ECHO Model
ABSTRACT Project ECHO (Extension for Community Healthcare Outcomes) is an evidence-based model that provides high-quality medical education for common and complex diseases through telementoring and comanagement of patients with primary care clinicians. In a one to many knowledge network, the ECHO model helps to bridge the gap between primary care clinicians and specialists by enhancing the knowledge, skills, confidence, and practice of primary care clinicians in their local communities. As a result, patients in rural and urban underserved areas are able to receive best practice care without long waits or having to travel long distances. The ECHO model has been replicated in 43 university hubs in
*UNM Health Sciences Center Project ECHO,
?Defense and
?UNM Health Sciences Center Project ECHO,
?Army Project ECHO, Rehabilitation & Reintegration Division (R2D),
?
?
**
??Defense and
??
??
??UNM Health Sciences Center Project ECHO,
doi: 10.7205/MILMED-D-15-00044
INTRODUCTION
The ECHO Model: Proof of Concept
Dr.
In addition to hepatitis C and chronic pain, Project ECHO currently conducts teleECHO clinics for other chronic yet complex conditions including integrated addictions and psychiatry, rheumatology, HIV/AIDS, dementia, complex care, palliative care, women's health/genomics as well as endocrinology. Each program fulfills the six characteristics recognized vital to the success of the ECHO model: (1) the condition is common, (2) requires complex management, (3) has critical impact to public health and cost to society, (4) that best practices treatments continue to evolve, (5) improved outcomes with condition management, and (6) high societal burden if there is no treatment.4 Multipoint videoconferencing is used to connect specialists at regional centers (hubs) to primary care clinicians working in rural and urban underserved sites (spokes). The integrated team of specialists provide didactics and case-based learning while monitoring outcomes.1
Challenge for Project ECHO: Replication of the ECHO Model with Fidelity
Soon after the success of ECHO's prospective study, the interest in replicating the ECHO model grew significantly and at a very fast pace.2 Dozens of academic medical centers and other large organizations including the
ECHO Pain: Development of a Robust Replication Tool with the
ARMY PAIN ECHO
In 2009, the
The
In 2012, the
Given the magnitude of this global replication of ECHO, the intent of the
The Hub Readiness Replication Model was created to
(1) Ensure fidelity of the Four-Point ECHO Model.3
(2) Create consistency in the replication process.
(3) Be adaptable for use by all ECHO disease-specific clinical and nonclinical ECHO replication programs.
METHODS
Echo Replication: Hub Readiness Replication Model
Four specific sequential phases were designed with a unique set of objectives. The learning acquired from each phase of training builds upon the next in this 5-month process (Table I).
Phase I (Preparatory Phase) allots adequate time for video technology installation and testing at the hub and spoke sites and establishes adequate administrative and staffing requirements. These processes are essential to the effective roll-out of any teleECHO clinic given the technology and administrative capabilities needed to implement such a program. This phase typically lasts for 4 weeks.
Phase II (Preliminary Phase) educates hub and spoke teams via a 1-month observation phase of Project ECHO. Teams review pertinent Project ECHO literature and videos, as well as participate in an ECHO Pain Boot Camp. The ECHO Pain Boot Camp is an intensive 2-day training intended to give participants a preliminary introduction and overview of the ECHO model which is similar in idea to a traditional boot camp which trains new military personnel. A modified ECHO Pain Boot Camp is provided to
Phase III (Training Phase) was developed to unite the hub team (specialty care) and spoke teams (primary care pain champion) from the same region. All clinicians (hubs and spokes) participated as spokes to the ECHO Pain team for 6 weeks of clinical immersion. Clinicians presented cases to the ECHO Pain team as guided practice. The hub clinicians benefit from modeling effective, noncritical feedback and interpersonal skills while they participate as spoke clinicians for this training period. Teaching strategies include case-based learning and evidence-based didactics.
Phase IV (Hub Roll-Out Phase) allows the hub team of pain specialists to launch an independent Army Pain ECHO although still maintaining partial connection to ECHO Pain. The ECHO Pain team synchronously observes via video to provide written constructive feedback within 48 hours to the Army Pain ECHO hub team, providing ongoing telementoring. Technological and administrative assistance is also provided.
RESULTS
A mixed methods study used both quantitative and qualitative analyses to determine the success of the Army Pain ECHO Hub Readiness Replication Model. Successful completion of each phase was imperative to establish a functional and independent ECHO hub. Continuing medical education credits were quantified, ECHO Pain Boot Camp surveys were evaluated, and a focus group for hub clinicians was also performed. Institutional review board approval was obtained from UNMHSC.
Key findings from the ECHO Pain Boot Camp surveys demonstrated that both the on-site and virtual participants had an increase in knowledge of pain management, as well as an increased motivation to learn new skills and teach others. Additionally, the majority of clinicians rated their training of the Mock ECHO experience as highly effective. Both the on-site boot camp and the virtual boot camp were rated as effective training methods (Table II).
Continuing Medical Education Credits
The Army Pain ECHO participants obtained continuing medical education and continuing education units from the
The diverse group of interprofessionals participating in the ECHO Pain Boot Camp training is reflected in Table IV. Almost 25% of the participants in the Army Pain ECHO replication project were physicians, 18% were mid-level providers (nurse practitioners, physician assistants, pharmacists, or psychologists), 10% were licensed to provide rehabilitation services, and 12% were nurses or nursing assistants. There was a large category for other specialists ranging from complementary integrative medicine providers to health technicians.
Hub Clinician Focus Group Results
To obtain insights and feedback from this deliberate approach to hub education, training, and support, we invited hub leaders from the four
A range of one to four members from each of the
There were four broad focus group questions. They included (1) What is the impact of Army Pain ECHO in education of colleagues and primary care clinicians?, (2) What is the influenceofArmyPainECHOtraining(HubReadiness Phases) on facilitation of an independent ECHO?, (3) How has your involvement with Army Pain ECHO influenced you in training others?, and (4) What are the benefits and challenges of Army Pain ECHO? The focus group was facilitated by evaluation team members from Project ECHO, and the focus group was recorded and transcribed. The focus group transcript was analyzed by the evaluation team members for general themes. The analysis and report were reviewed by the ECHO Pain team and later forwarded to the participants.
THE IMPACT OF ARMY PAIN ECHO
What Is the Impact of Army Pain ECHO in Education of Colleagues and Primary Care Clinicians?
Participation in the ECHO Pain training changed several teams' approach to education. One region reported transformation in their approach to case discussions from prescriptive conferences to a focus on education.
"Now we have open communication with these various providers who not only communicate with us through ECHO, but they also communicate with us on the more difficult cases through email and sometimes over the phone." "It has given us a tool for educating the primary care clinicians."
"It's impacted not just our clinical practice but the practices ...in other clinics."
"It's a way to treat complicated patients in a comprehensive approach."
"Primary care providers were initially very overwhelmed by how to wean people off opioids."
"Through Army Pain ECHO trainings the spoke clinicians learned how valuable behavioral health is and how important it is to have multidisciplinary meetings, and support case managers."
Videoconferencing also helped further support a longterm regional pain program among the participating hubs and spokes. The ECHO model helps to address primary care clinicians' feelings of isolation in care of patients by fostering on-going virtual face-to-face interactions.
What Is the Influence of Army Pain ECHO Training (Hub Readiness Phases) on Facilitation of an Independent ECHO?
Team members learned about preparing and preplanning for the teleECHO clinics including recruiting participants and the importance of strong interpersonal skills. Most said they could not have launched Army Pain ECHO in their region without the help of Project ECHO, especially related to developing the didactic presentations and prepared curriculum.
"Spending a lot of quality time with our acupuncturists, our chiropractors, and our medical massage therapists was a really good team building process for our clinic. The boot camp really helped, as they participated with it, to see where we were going."
"The boot camp and the preliminary phase were important to be able to get out there and see how ECHO actually works from hub site. That helped us be able to establish it here ...."
"It was valuable to have to present cases to UNM. We realized how time consuming it is to ...prepare the case and how ...uncomfortable you are when you don't know the answer."
"You're more careful and kind when your (spoke) participant doesn't know the answer, and you're more considerate to them when they have issues and they're kind of fumbling around."
"It gave us time to work on how we wanted to proceed ... and made us a much better working team..."
How Has Your Involvement With Army Pain ECHO Influenced You in Training Others?
One hub team indicated that they reframed their thinking about how they interacted with the primary care clinicians; instead of offering advice specific to one patient, they generalized the information about recommendations and suggested that these were things to think about and include in approaches to patients like this.
"From our end, making the spokes comfortable to ask questions and not feel like they're going to be berated. They tend to interact much more."
"What I've learned from ECHO is a lot of those soft skills ...encouraging clinicians who are busy. They haven't presented in years. They've been out of medical school for a long time, and it's daunting sometimes. You do not want to scare them away."
Several hub participants emphasized their greater appreciation for interdisciplinary team care and the knowledge and skill offered by others, as well as the expanding roles of different professionals on the team.
"This forum expands the role of the clinical pharmacist. It expands the role of the behavioral health specialist in the pain practice as well."
What Are the Benefits and Challenges of Army Pain ECHO?
The focus group participants also discussed the importance of dedicated time and leadership support to sustain their successful Army Pain ECHO replication efforts. Participants identified the limitations of dedicated time and multiple competing priorities as constraints that their primary care colleagues reported.
"We are struggling with getting sites to value the time. Just getting time set aside to participate ...."
"Sometimes there is poor (teleECHO clinic) attendance due to time constraints."
Leadership can play a larger role in supporting the Army Pain ECHO clinic. Several participants suggested that there are "competing missions from a primary care level, and it can be difficult to participate with busy panels" as constraints for leadership to consider and address. The frequency of concepts discussed is illustrated in Figure 2.
DISCUSSION
Hub Readiness Phases
The goal of Project ECHO is to increase the knowledge, confidence, and improve the skills of the primary care spoke clinicians who are managing patients in rural and underserved communities. The Hub Readiness Replication Model educates both the primary care and the specialty team in the essential components of the ECHO model. This unique model reduces the gap between primary and specialty care by demonopolizing medical knowledge, which is traditionally confined to academic medical centers and specialists located in major cities.1 By demonopolizing medical knowledge and with ongoing telementoring, primary care clinicians can effectively manage many of their patients who may have previously been referred to a specialist, or even a super-specialist.15 Training clinicians through deliberate guided practice is the essential component of the Hub Readiness Replication Model. The Army Pain ECHO roll-out has been successful for all
The ECHO Pain Boot Camp trainings during Phase II of the Hub Readiness Replication Model are highlighted by the Mock ECHO simulation trainings. Real, deidentified cases are practiced among the hub and spoke clinicians outside of an official teleECHO clinic, offering the clinician a safe environment to practice and learn through the many trainings offered. The clinicians' skills, confidence, interpersonal communication, and interest increase at each session of this guided and deliberate practice.16-19
The Phase III (Training Phase) allowed both the primary and specialty teams to present cases to ECHO Pain. The focus group results suggest that this was critical for the specialists to understand how it felt to "wear the shoes of the primary care clinician presenting the case." The primary focus of the Hub Readiness Replication Model prepares the hub specialty team to effectively facilitate a teleECHO clinic. It is assumed that the hub specialist does not need improvement in knowledge and skills within their specialty, but that they have the interpersonal skills and professionalism necessary to educate primary care clinicians in front of a large videoconferencing network. These interpersonal skills are an important aspect of social cognitive theory. They are rarely learned in medical school, but are critical to the success of a teleECHO clinic. Effective mentorship and role modeling have a positive effect on the hub clinicians' ability to facilitate a successful teleECHO clinic.20,21
The hub specialists benefit from the Hub Readiness Replication Model in many critical and diverse ways. The Army Pain ECHO focus group highlighted the increased confidence that the pain specialists have developed in their primary care colleagues, the improved care coordination between primary and specialty care services, the improved work satisfaction noted by specialists because of enjoyment related to teaching others, and the interprofessional team environment.
Modeling of the ECHO Pain training facilitators' behavior also occurs during all 4 phases of the Hub Readiness Replication Model, beginning with observation of the teleECHO clinics, intensifying during the boot camp Mock ECHO trainings, and continuing throughout the training phase.3,22 This modeling helps to maintain the fidelity and the integrity of the ECHO model necessary for behavioral change.23
Phase II of the Hub Readiness Replication Model included the 2-day ECHO Pain Boot Camp training. Findings from the participant surveys revealed that both on-site and virtual ECHO Pain Boot Camp trainings improved clinician motivation to learn new skills and teach others. The on-site trainings were significantly more effective in providing Mock ECHO trainings, however. The in-person Mock ECHO simulation trainings both increased skills and improved social connectivity among hub and spoke team members. The in person training is easier to facilitate a dynamic exercise such as the Mock ECHO, although, even the virtual Mock ECHO training was rated highly. Each participant from the virtual boot camp trainings was able to participate on-site with the ECHO Pain team. This could have explained the high ratings and social connectivity of this experience.
Continuing Medical Education Credits
Tremendous opportunity exists for no-cost continuing medical education credits for clinicians in all disciplines utilizing the ECHO Hub Readiness Replication Model. Project ECHO is particularly beneficial for chronic and complex diseases in which access to care is limited and primary care specialists need assistance with management of a large population of patients in rural and underserved areas. During the Army Pain ECHO roll-out, participants were eligible to receive over 9,689 no-cost continuing medical education hours. This averages to 969 no-cost continuing medical education hours eligible per regional medical command per year. Direct health care system benefits include clinician satisfaction, maintenance of license, maintenance of clinician at practice site rather than traveling to medical conference with resulting loss of patient care days, and social connectivity during the teleECHO clinic. Indirect health care system benefits may include decreased referrals to specialty care out of network, decreased travel costs, better control of chronic conditions if pain treated earlier, decreased use of expensive interventions and medications if unnecessary, and many other possible returns on investment.
Diversity of Participants
In a specialty such as chronic pain, interprofessional and interdisciplinary engagement is now considered best practices both in prelicensure education and in the clinical setting.5,6,24 As the shortage of primary care clinicians continues to increase in
CONCLUSION
In addition to collaboration with the Army MEDCOM's Pain Program, ECHO Pain is now engaged with the
The four phases of the Hub Readiness Replication Model are deliberate and add fidelity to the original Four-Point ECHO Model. This ECHO replication tool can easily be adopted for all chronic and complex diseases and conditions across a large enterprise. It provides the flexibility necessary to account for personnel and geographic variation. Even non-health care related entities, such as the
The ECHO model may be considered for other conditions within the
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We thank the following individuals for helping to develop and implement the Hub Readiness Replication Model:
REFERENCES
1. Arora S, Kalishman S, Dion D, et al: Quality profi le: partnering urban academic medical centers and rural primary care clinicians to provide complex chronic disease care. Health Aff 2011; 30(6): 1176 - 84.
2. Arora S, Thornton K, Murata G, et al: Outcomes of treatment of hepatitis C virus infection by primary care providers. N Engl J Med 2011; 364(23): 2199 - 07.
3. Arora S, Kalishman S, Thornton K, et al: Expanding access to hepatitis virus treatment-Extension for Community Healthcare Outcomes (ECHO) project: disruptive innovation in specialty care. Hepatology 2010; 52(3): 1124-33.
4. Arora S, Geppert CM, Kalishman S, et al: Academic health center management of chronic diseases through knowledge networks: project ECHO. Acad Med 2007; 82: 154 - 60.
5. Doorenbos AZ, Gordon D, Tauben D, et al: A blueprint of pain curriculum across prelicensure health sciences programs: one
6. Fishman SM, Young HM,
7. Katzman J: Making connections: using telehealth to improve the diagnosis and treatment of complex regional pain syndrome, an underrecognized neuroinflammatory disorder. J Neuroimmune Pharmacol 2013; 8(3): 489- 93.
8. Katzman JG, Comerci G, Boyle JF, et al: Innovative telementoring for pain management Project ECHO Pain. J Cont Ed Health Prof 2014; 34(1): 68- 74.
9. Katzman J, Comerci G, Landen M. Rules and values: a coordinated regulatory approach to the public health crises of chronic pain and addiction.
10. Barnett S, Jones SC, Bennett S, Iverson D, Bonney A. General practice training and virtual communities of practice: a review of the literature. BMC Fam Prac 2012; 13: 87.
11. Buckenmaier CC III, Rupprecht C, McKnight G, et al: Pain following battlefield injury and evacuation: a survey of 110 casualties from the wars in
12. Kerns R, Otis J, Rosenberg R, Reid MC. Veterans' reports of pain and associations with ratings of health, health-risk behaviors, affective distress, and use of the health care system. JRRD 2003; 40(5): 371- 80.
13.
14.
15. Arora S, Thornton K, Komaromy M, Kalishman S, Katzman J, Duhigg D: Demonopolizing medical knowledge. Acad Med 2014; 89(1): 30 - 2.
16. Bandura A: Self-Efficacy: The Exercise of Control.
17. Lateef F: Simulation-based learning: just like the real thing. J Emerg Trauma Shock 2010; 3(4): 348-52.
18. Kaufman DM:
19. Lave J, Wenger E: Situated Learning: Legitimate Peripheral Participation.
20. Bastable SB: Applying learning theories to healthcare practice. In: Nurse as Educator: Principles of Teaching and Learning for Nursing Practice, Ed 4, pp 63 - 110. Edited by Braungart MM, Braungart RG, Gramet PR.
21. Arora S, Kalishman S, Dion D, et al: Knowledge networks for treating complex diseases in remote, rural, and underserved communities. In: Learning Trajectories, Innovation and Identity for Professional Development Innovation and Change in Professional Education, pp 47 - 70. Edited by McKee A, Eraut M.
22. Vygorsky L: Mind in Society: The Development of Higher Psychological Processes.
23. Mars T, Ellard D, Carnes D, et al: Fidelity in complex behaviour change interventions: a standardized approach to evaluate intervention integrity. BMJ 2013; 3:e003555.
24.
25.
26. Eaton LH, Gordon DB, Wyant S, et al: Development and implementation of a telehealth-enhanced intervention for pain and symptom management. Contemp Clin Trials 2014; 38(2): 213-20.
27. Scott JD, Unruh KT, Catlin MC, et al: Project ECHO: a model for complex, chronic care in the
28. Mchaourab AS, Ober S, Gaudino CP: Innovation in specialty care delivery to rural areas. Poster no. 152 presented at 2013
29. Mendonca KB: SCAN-ECHO: an effective way to provide patientcentered care.



Randy Zipse Joins AXA’s Life Insurance Advanced Markets Team
Advisor News
- Why you should discuss insurance with HNW clients
- Trump announces health care plan outline
- House passes bill restricting ESG investments in retirement accounts
- How pre-retirees are approaching AI and tech
- Todd Buchanan named president of AmeriLife Wealth
More Advisor NewsAnnuity News
- Great-West Life & Annuity Insurance Company Trademark Application for “EMPOWER READY SELECT” Filed: Great-West Life & Annuity Insurance Company
- Retirees drive demand for pension-like income amid $4T savings gap
- Reframing lifetime income as an essential part of retirement planning
- Integrity adds further scale with blockbuster acquisition of AIMCOR
- MetLife Declares First Quarter 2026 Common Stock Dividend
More Annuity NewsHealth/Employee Benefits News
- Trump wants Congress to take up health plan
- Iowa House Democrats roll out affordability plan
- Husted took thousands from company that paid Ohio $88 million to settle Medicaid fraud allegations
- ACA subsidy expiration slams Central Pa. with more than 240% premium increases
- Kaiser affiliates will pay $556M to settle a lawsuit alleging Medicare fraudKaiser affiliates will pay $556M to settle a lawsuit alleging Medicare fraudKaiser Permanente affiliates will pay $556 million to settle a lawsuit that alleged the health care giant committed Medicare fraud and pressured doctors to list incorrect diagnoses on medical records to receive higher reimbursements
More Health/Employee Benefits NewsLife Insurance News