evr 2023
2023 Embedded Value Report
for Manulife's Insurance1 Businesses
(Excludes the value of in-force business for Global Wealth and Asset Management, Bank and Property and Casualty Reinsurance businesses)
1 Includes variable and fixed annuities, and single premium products sold in
Overview:
Manulife's Embedded Value ("EV")1 was
Background:
EV is a measure of the present value of shareholders' interests in the expected future distributable earnings on in-force business reflected in the Consolidated Statements of Financial Position of the Company. It does not include any value associated with future new business. The change in EV between reporting periods is used by Manulife's management as a measure of the value created by the Company's operations in the reporting period. NBV is the change in EV due to sales in the reporting period.
We use a traditional deterministic discounted cash flow methodology for determining our EV and NBV. This methodology makes implicit allowance for all material sources of risk embedded in our products using a risk-adjusted discount rate. It should be noted that this allowance for risk is approximate and may not correspond with the allowance determined using market consistent techniques.
The calculation of EV and NBV necessarily requires several assumptions with respect to future experience. Future experience may vary from that assumed in the calculation, which may materially impact EV and NBV. See "Caution Regarding Forward- Looking Statements" below.
- For more information on NBV, NBV margin, and EV, see "Methodology and Definitions" below.
- Percentage growth in NBV is stated on a constant exchange rate basis.
- The 2022 EV was restated to reflect the International Finance Reporting Standard 17 ("IFRS 17") and
National Association of Insurance Commissioners ("NAIC") framework on NBV and EV as ofJanuary 1, 2023 . For more information, see "Methodology and Definitions" below.
Page 2 of 12
Willis Towers Watson Review Opinion on Embedded Value
Manulife and its subsidiaries have prepared EV results for the year ended
Our scope of work covered:
- a review of methodology and assumptions used to determine the EV results for the year ended 2023, and the NBV for 2023, on standards in place at
December 31 2023 , and - a review of the results of Manulife's calculation of the EV results.
- the methodology used for the North American and Asian business is consistent with recent industry practice in each respective region as regards to traditional embedded value calculations based on discounted values of projected deterministic after-tax cash flows. This methodology makes an overall allowance for risk for the Company using risk discount rates which incorporate risk margins which vary by business, together with an explicit allowance for the cost of holding required capital.
Willis Towers Watson has not considered how this compares to a capital markets valuation of such risk (so called "market consistent valuation"), - the economic assumptions used have made allowance for the Company's current and expected future asset mix and investment strategy and are internally consistent, and
- the operating assumptions have been set with appropriate regard to past, current, and expected future experience, considering the nature of the business.
Our opinion on the Embedded Value of
Page 3 of 12
Embedded Value Results
Embedded Value Summary
|
As at |
2023 |
2022 (1) |
||
|
(C$ millions) |
||||
|
Adjusted net worth excluding holding company activities (2) |
$ |
55,546 |
$ |
54,033 |
|
Present value of future profits |
$ |
39,704 |
$ |
38,570 |
|
Cost of capital |
(14,853) |
(14,147) |
||
|
Value of in-force business (3) |
$ |
24,851 |
$ |
24,423 |
|
Holding company activities |
||||
|
Carrying value of debt, preferred shares, and other equity |
$ |
(19,398) |
$ |
(19,016) |
|
Embedded value |
$ |
60,999 |
$ |
59,440 |
- The 2022 figures were restated to reflect the
$(4.5) billion restatement impact to IFRS 17 and NAIC. For more information, see "Methodology and Definitions" below. - Adjusted net worth excluding holding company activities ("adjusted net worth") reflects the equity for the Company, adjusted for the items listed under the "Summary of Adjusted Net Worth Excluding Holding Company Activities" table below.
- The value of in-force business excludes Global WAM, Bank and P&C Reinsurance businesses.
As at
|
For the year ended |
2023 |
2022 |
||
|
(C$ millions) |
||||
|
Embedded value as at |
$ |
63,944 |
$ |
64,803 |
|
Impact of restatement (1) |
(4,504) |
- |
||
|
Restated embedded value as of |
59,440 |
64,803 |
||
|
Current period earnings from Global WAM, Bank and P&C Reinsurance businesses (2) |
1,829 |
1,483 |
||
|
Interest on embedded value |
5,477 |
5,195 |
||
|
New business value |
2,324 |
2,063 |
||
|
Changes in operating assumptions and operating experience |
535 |
(879) |
||
|
Unallocated overhead expenses (3) |
(397) |
(254) |
||
|
Embedded value before non-operating variances |
$ |
69,208 |
$ |
72,411 |
|
Changes in investment assumptions and investment experience (4) |
(1,627) |
(5,808) |
||
|
Other non-operating items and exchange rates (5) |
(2,319) |
1,738 |
||
|
Embedded value before returns to shareholders |
$ |
65,262 |
$ |
68,341 |
|
Common shareholder dividends |
(2,668) |
(2,513) |
||
|
Share repurchases |
(1,595) |
(1,884) |
||
|
Embedded value as at |
$ |
60,999 |
$ |
63,944 |
- The restatement impact of
$(4.5) billion reflects replacing IFRS 4 with IFRS 17 (for Canadian business, International HighNet Worth business, as well as business ceded to an affiliate reinsurer), and replacing IFRS 4/ LICAT with NAIC/ RBC (forU.S. business). For more information, see "Methodology and Definitions" below. - The value of in-force business excludes Global WAM, Bank and P&C Reinsurance businesses. As a result, the current period earnings from Global WAM, Bank and P&C Reinsurance businesses contribute to the total embedded value movement.
- Unallocated overhead expenses include Group unallocated expenses,
Asia regional office unallocated expenses, and non-directly attributable expenses. - Changes in investment assumptions and investment experience includes changes in the fair value adjustments made for the Company's long-term debt, preferred shares, other equity, and surplus assets.
- Other non-operating items and exchange rates in 2022 EV includes a reduction in EV from reinsuring over 80% of our legacy
U.S. Variable Annuity block, which reflects the earnings impact of the transaction adjusted for the reduced future earnings, net of the Cost of Capital release, included in Embedded Value, as well as the impact to adjusted net worth in 2022 related to the Manulife TEDA acquisition. Also includes share issues, option exercises, preferred share dividends, as well as other equity distributions.
Page 4 of 12
Embedded Value Components by Segment
|
As at |
|
|
|
Corporate |
Total |
|||||
|
(C$ millions) |
and Other (1) |
|||||||||
|
Required capital (2) |
$ |
4,072 |
$ |
8,080 |
$ |
11,776 |
$ |
134 |
$ |
24,062 |
|
Allocated surplus (2) |
8,314 |
3,079 |
7,066 |
13,025 |
31,484 |
|||||
|
Adjusted net worth excluding holding company activities (3) |
$ |
12,386 |
$ |
11,159 |
$ |
18,842 |
$ |
13,159 |
$ |
55,546 |
|
Present value of future profits |
$ |
18,286 |
$ |
12,112 |
$ |
8,947 |
$ |
359 |
$ |
39,704 |
|
Cost of capital |
(2,581) |
(4,758) |
(7,477) |
(37) |
(14,853) |
|||||
|
Value of in-force business (4) |
$ |
15,705 |
$ |
7,354 |
$ |
1,470 |
$ |
322 |
$ |
24,851 |
|
Embedded value excluding holding company activities |
$ |
28,091 |
$ |
18,513 |
$ |
20,312 |
$ |
13,481 |
$ |
80,397 |
|
Holding company activities |
||||||||||
|
Carrying value of debt, preferred shares, and other equity |
$ |
(19,398) |
||||||||
|
Total embedded value |
$ |
60,999 |
- Adjusted net worth related to the Global WAM segment is grouped with Corporate and Other.
- Required capital is based on the required capital ratios as outlined in the "Assumptions" section below. The allocated surplus by segment is based on our capital ratio operating range for each territory in
Asia ,Canada , and theU.S. , with the remainder allocated to Corporate and Other. - Adjusted net worth reflects the equity for the Company, adjusted for the items listed under the "Summary of Adjusted Net Worth Excluding Holding Company Activities" table below.
- The value of in-force business excludes Global WAM, Bank and P&C Reinsurance businesses.
Summary of Adjusted Net Worth Excluding Holding Company Activities
|
As at |
2023 |
2022 (1) |
||
|
(C$ millions) |
||||
|
Common shareholders' equity (2) |
$ |
40,379 |
$ |
40,216 |
|
Carrying value of debt, preferred shares, and other equity |
19,398 |
19,016 |
||
|
Fair value adjustments (3) |
1,031 |
1,752 |
||
|
|
(9,488) |
(9,693) |
||
|
Impact of differences between IFRS and statutory values of insurance and investment contract |
4,226 |
2,742 |
||
|
liabilities and assets in |
||||
|
Adjusted net worth excluding holding company activities |
$ |
55,546 |
$ |
54,033 |
- The 2022 figures were restated to reflect a
$(4.5) billion restatement impact to IFRS 17 and NAIC. For more information, see "Methodology and Definitions" below. - Common shareholders' equity is equal to total shareholders' equity minus preferred shares and other equity on the Consolidated Statements of Financial Position of the Company.
- Fair value adjustments are made for the Company's long-term debt, preferred shares, and other equity which are measured at amortized cost under IFRS reporting and fair value for EV reporting. Adjustments are also made for certain surplus assets which are measured at amortized cost under IFRS reporting but fair value for EV reporting.
Goodwill and intangible assets are a component of adjusted net worth; however, they are excluded from EV, net of deferred tax.- This adjustment represents the difference between adjusted net worth for our Asian &
U.S. businesses as measured under IFRS and adjusted net worth for our Asian &U.S. businesses as measured under the relevant local statutory accounting bases.
Page 5 of 12
Projected After-tax Discounted Distributable Earnings
|
(C$ millions) |
Discounted Amount |
|
|
|
$ |
12,086 |
|
2024 - 2028 |
15,671 |
|
|
2029 - 2033 |
9,296 |
|
|
2034 - 2038 |
8,606 |
|
|
2039 - 2043 |
6,073 |
|
|
2044 and later |
9,267 |
|
|
Total embedded value |
$ |
60,999 |
The discounted distributable earnings value as at
New Business Value Results
|
New Business Value (1) |
APE Sales (2) |
New Business Value Margin (3) |
|||||||||
|
(C$ millions) |
2023 |
2022 |
2023 |
2022 |
2023 |
2022 |
|||||
|
|
$ |
490 |
$ |
362 |
$ |
1,408 |
$ |
1,261 |
34.8% |
28.7% |
|
|
|
207 |
164 |
562 |
599 |
36.8% |
27.4% |
|||||
|
|
726 |
581 |
1,220 |
744 |
59.5% |
78.1% |
|||||
|
|
158 |
133 |
354 |
400 |
44.6% |
33.3% |
|||||
|
Asia Other (4) |
743 |
823 |
2,373 |
2,306 |
31.3% |
35.7% |
|||||
|
|
1,627 |
1,537 |
3,947 |
3,450 |
41.2% |
44.6% |
|||||
|
Total (5) |
$ |
2,324 |
$ |
2,063 |
$ |
5,917 |
$ |
5,310 |
39.3% |
38.9% |
- In 2023 New Business Value ("NBV"),
Canada and International HighNet Worth business reflect IFRS 17 reserving requirements and LICAT required capital.Asia and theU.S. reflect local regulatory reserving and capital requirements, except business ceded to an affiliate reinsurer, where it reflects IFRS 17 reserving and LICAT required capital. - Annualized Premium Equivalent ("APE") sales are calculated as 100% of regular premiums/deposits sales and 10% of single premiums/deposits sales. APE Sales excludes non-controlling interest and does not include the Global WAM or Bank businesses.
- NBV margin is calculated as NBV divided by APE sales excluding non-controlling interest.
Asia's NBV includes International HighNet Worth business.- NBV does not include Global WAM, Bank and P&C Reinsurance businesses.
Manulife's NBV was
1 Growth in NBV is stated on a constant currency basis.
Page 6 of 12
Potential Impact on Embedded Value and New Business Value Arising from Changes in Assumptions
The "Potential Impact on Embedded Value Arising from Changes in Assumptions" table below outlines the potential impact on EV at
This includes sensitivities due to specific changes in market prices and interest rate levels projected using internal models as at a specific date. The sensitivities measure the impact of changing one factor at a time and assume that all other factors remain unchanged. For example, the discount rate, public equity return, and alternative long-duration asset ("ALDA") returemain unchanged when we test a 50 basis points ("bps") increase or decrease in fixed income market yields. Actual results can differ significantly from these estimates for a variety of reasons including the interaction among these factors when more than one changes; changes in investment retuand future investment activity assumptions; changes in business mix, effective tax rates and other market factors; and the general limitations of our internal models.
The potential impact on EV of changes in assumptions includes impacts due to changes in adjusted net worth, the present value of expected future earnings, and the present value of the cost of holding capital to support the in-force business. The potential impact on NBV of changes in assumptions includes impacts due to changes in the present value of expected future earnings on new business, and the present value of the cost of holding capital to support new business. We reflected a change in reserve assumptions only where the assumptions are set with reference to current market rates. This applies to the change in fixed income market yield in
These estimates assume that the dynamic hedging program continues to operate effectively under the economic scenarios reflected in the EV calculation.
The sensitivities should only be viewed as directional estimates of the underlying sensitivities for the respective factors based on the changes in assumptions outlined below. Given the nature of these calculations, we cannot provide assurance that the actual impact on EV or NBV will be as indicated.
Page 7 of 12
Potential Impact on Embedded Value Arising from Changes in Assumptions (1), (2)
|
As at |
|
|
|
Corporate |
Total |
||||
|
(C$ millions) |
and Other |
||||||||
|
Embedded Value excluding holding company activities |
$ |
18,513 |
$ |
20,312 |
|
$ |
13,481 |
$ |
80,397 |
|
Carrying value of debt, preferred shares, and other equity |
(19,398) |
||||||||
|
Total Embedded Value |
60,999 |
||||||||
|
Potential impact on Embedded Value of changes in assumptions: |
|||||||||
|
100 bps increase in discount rate |
$ |
(1,462) |
$ |
(1,622) |
|
$ |
- |
$ |
(4,808) |
|
100 bps decrease in discount rate |
1,786 |
1,993 |
2,138 |
- |
5,917 |
||||
|
50 bps increase in fixed income market yields for all future years |
(52) |
637 |
(224) |
(349) |
12 |
||||
|
50 bps decrease in fixed income market yields for all future years |
(234) |
(539) |
33 |
385 |
(355) |
||||
|
100 bps increase in public equity and ALDA returns (3) |
1,069 |
1,894 |
1,180 |
- |
4,143 |
||||
|
100 bps decrease in public equity and ALDA returns (3) |
(1,062) |
(1,861) |
(1,255) |
- |
(4,178) |
||||
|
10% immediate increase in public equity and ALDA market |
739 |
1,515 |
1,308 |
97 |
3,659 |
||||
|
values (3) |
|||||||||
|
10% immediate decrease in public equity and ALDA market |
(660) |
(1,464) |
(1,316) |
(96) |
(3,536) |
||||
|
values (3) |
|||||||||
|
Required surplus - relative 25% increase (4) |
(1,516) |
(1,869) |
(1,216) |
- |
(4,601) |
- For general fund adjustable benefit products subject to minimum rate guarantee, the sensitivities assume that credited rates are floored at the minimum.
- The EV sensitivities include impacts from both adjusted net worth, where applicable, and the value of in-force business. The adjusted net worth is affected by the 50 bps changes in fixed income market yields, which causes changes in the fair value of fixed income assets held, and by the 10% immediate increase and decrease in public equity and ALDA market values.
- ALDA includes commercial real estate, power and infrastructure, timber and farmland real estate, oil and gas, and private equities.
- This shows the impact of increasing required capital levels by a relative 25% above those shown in the assumptions table below. For businesses subject to LICAT, this was modeled as 125% Base Solvency Buffer - Surplus Allowance - Eligible Deposits - Par Surplus - Contractual Service Margin.
The sensitivity to a 50-bps decrease in fixed income market yields for all future yields is a decrease in EV of
The sensitivity to a 50-bps increase in fixed income market yields for all future yields is an increase in EV of
Page 8 of 12
Potential Impact on New Business Value Arising from Changes in Assumptions (1), (2)
|
(C$ millions) |
|
|
|
Hong |
|
Total |
||||||
|
Kong |
Other |
|||||||||||
|
New Business Value for the period |
$ |
490 |
$ |
207 |
$ |
158 |
$ |
726 |
$ |
743 |
$ |
2,324 |
|
100 bps increase in discount rate |
$ |
(53) |
$ |
(17) |
$ |
(25) |
$ |
(34) |
$ |
(76) |
$ |
(205) |
|
100 bps decrease in discount rate |
61 |
20 |
30 |
45 |
90 |
246 |
||||||
|
50 bps increase in fixed income market yields for all future years |
2 |
8 |
3 |
(8) |
56 |
61 |
||||||
|
50 bps decrease in fixed income market yields for all future years |
(2) |
(8) |
(4) |
5 |
(59) |
(68) |
||||||
|
100 bps increase in public equity and ALDA retu(3) |
8 |
3 |
0 |
5 |
63 |
79 |
||||||
|
100 bps decrease in public equity and ALDA retu(3) |
(9) |
(3) |
(0) |
(4) |
(61) |
(77) |
||||||
|
10% immediate increase in public equity and ALDA market values (3) |
4 |
1 |
0 |
30 |
7 |
42 |
||||||
|
10% immediate decrease in public equity and ALDA market values (3) |
(5) |
(1) |
0 |
(31) |
(7) |
(44) |
||||||
|
Required surplus - relative 25% increase (4) |
(21) |
(18) |
(24) |
(19) |
(32) |
(114) |
- For general fund adjustable benefit products subject to minimum rate guarantee, the sensitivities assume that credited rates are floored at the minimum.
- For the purpose of NBV sensitivities, assumption changes have been assumed to occur after the point-of-sale. Therefore, the NBV sensitivity gives an indication of how the NBV written during the year would have been affected by an economic shock occurring after the point-of-sale. NBV sensitivities consider hedging strategies on new business which are intended to be implemented shortly after sale. Actual changes in NBV due to experience being different from assumed may vary from what is shown above due to changes in product mix.
- ALDA include commercial real estate, timber and farmland real estate, oil and gas, and private equities.
- This shows the impact of increasing required capital levels by a relative 25% above those shown in the "Assumptions" table below. For businesses subject to LICAT, this was modeled as 125% Base Solvency Buffer - Surplus Allowance - Eligible Deposits - Par Surplus - Contractual Service Margin.
The potential impact of changes in fixed income market rates for all future years is relatively higher for NBV than EV. This occurs because invested assets partially mitigate exposure to changes in fixed income market yields, and EV has relatively higher invested assets than NBV.
Methodology and Definitions
With the implementation of IFRS 17 in 2023, the accounting bases underlying Manulife's EV and NBV changed as follows:
- Canadian businesses, International High
Net Worth business, as well as business ceded to an affiliate reinsurer, reflect IFRS 17 earnings and LICAT required capital, instead of IFRS 4 earnings and LICAT required capital; U.S. businesses reflect local statutory earnings (NAIC) and capital requirements (RBC), instead of IFRS 4 earnings and LICAT required capital; and- Asian businesses remained on local statutory bases.
The 2022 EV was restated for the above changes. The impact of the earnings and capital framework restatement was
Embedded value ("EV") is a measure of the present value of shareholders' interests in the expected future distributable earnings on in-force business reflected in the Consolidated Statements of Financial Position of Manulife, excluding any value associated with future new business. EV is calculated as the sum of the adjusted net worth and the value of in-force business calculated as at
Adjusted net worth is the IFRS shareholders' equity adjusted for goodwill and intangible assets, fair value of surplus assets, the fair value of debt, preferred shares, and other equity, and local statutory balance sheet, regulatory reserve, and capital for our
Value ofin-force business in
Page 9 of 12
New business value ("NBV") is the change in embedded value as a result of sales in the reporting period. NBV is calculated as the present value of shareholders' interests in expected future distributable earnings, after the cost of capital calculated under the LICAT framework in
New business value margin ("NBV margin") is calculated as NBV divided by APE sales excluding non-controlling interests. APE sales are calculated as 100% of regular premiums/deposits sales and 10% of single premiums/deposits sales. NBV margin is a useful metric to help understand the profitability of our new business.
Assumptions
Investment assumptions are consistent with the Company's best estimate assumptions reflected in the valuation of policy liabilities, updated to reflect market assumptions consistent with the market environment in the quarter the business was sold. Best estimate fixed income yields are updated quarterly, and long-term expected yields for ALDA are typically reviewed during the annual review of actuarial methods and assumptions.
The principal economic assumptions used in the EV calculation as at
Principal Economic Assumptions as at
|
Territory |
|
|
|
|
|
Required capital |
100% LICAT (1) |
250% RBC (CAL) (2) |
400% Solvency Margin |
150% Solvency Margin |
|
Discount rate |
7.75% |
8.50% |
7.00% |
9.75% |
|
Public equity return |
9.00% |
10.00% |
6.00% |
9.50% |
|
Jurisdictional income tax rate (3) |
27.80% |
21.00% |
28.00% |
16.50% |
|
Reinvestment assumption for 10-year government bonds: |
||||
|
Immediate |
3.10% |
3.88% |
0.62% |
3.19% |
|
10 years & beyond in future |
3.25% |
3.25% |
1.50% |
2.85% |
- 100% of
LICAT Required Capital = 100% Base Solvency Buffer - Surplus Allowance - Eligible Deposits - Par Surplus - Contractual Service Margin. - Company Action Level (CAL) RBC = 2 x Authorized Control Level (ACL) RBC.
- For
Hong Kong , individual insurance products are taxed on a premium tax basis due to a Company election underHong Kong tax regulations.
|
Assumption |
Additional information |
||||
|
The capital ratios in jurisdictions not included in the table above are as follows: |
|||||
|
Mainland |
100% of required capital as specified under |
||||
|
|
120% of regulatory risk-based capital requirement |
||||
|
|
160% of regulatory capital adequacy ratio |
||||
|
|
|
125% of regulatory risk-based capital requirement |
|||
|
|
120% of regulatory capital adequacy ratio |
||||
|
|
100% of required minimum solvency margin |
||||
|
International |
100% LICAT |
||||
|
High |
|||||
|
A risk-adjusted discount rate is used which is based on the risk profile of the business and makes an allowance for all material |
|||||
|
sources of risk embedded in our products, the risk that actual experience in future years differs from that assumed, and for the |
|||||
|
Discount rate: |
economic cost of capital. For |
||||
|
assumes that 25% of the capital is in the form of debt. For |
|||||
|
interest rate. For 2023 EV, the discount rates in |
|||||
|
The 2023 EV discount rates are used for 2024 NBV. |
|||||
|
Public equity |
The equity retuassumptions are based on long-term historical observed experience. The retuassumptions for public equity |
||||
|
returns: |
in |
||||
Page 10 of 12
Attachments
Disclaimer


slides 2024 q1
news release q1 2024
Advisor News
- Flourish brings private-bank-like cash solution to MassMutual’s network
- Majority of Americans concerned recent market highs are unsustainable
- GLP-1 users choose between medication and retirement saving
- Gen X and millennials seek new retirement model
- Are families ready for the costs of aging at home?
More Advisor NewsAnnuity News
- New class-action lawsuit targets Delaware Life over annuity disclosures
- A client remarried: Does their annuity still fit?
- Gen X and millennials seek new retirement model
- Global Atlantic names Dan Farrelly head of IMO and IBD channels
- A rising retirement challenge: The license to spend
More Annuity NewsHealth/Employee Benefits News
Life Insurance News