Colorado justices say insurers may access policyholders' medical info in denied-benefits litigation - Insurance News | InsuranceNewsNet

InsuranceNewsNet — Your Industry. One Source.™

Sign in
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
Home Now reading Newswires
Topics
    • Advisor News
    • Annuity Index
    • Annuity News
    • Companies
    • Earnings
    • Fiduciary
    • From the Field: Expert Insights
    • Health/Employee Benefits
    • Insurance & Financial Fraud
    • INN Magazine
    • Insiders Only
    • Life Insurance News
    • Newswires
    • Property and Casualty
    • Regulation News
    • Sponsored Articles
    • Washington Wire
    • Videos
    • ———
    • About
    • Meet our Editorial Staff
    • Advertise
    • Contact
    • Newsletters
  • Exclusives
  • NewsWires
  • Magazine
  • Newsletters
Sign in or register to be an INNsider.
  • AdvisorNews
  • Annuity News
  • Companies
  • Earnings
  • Fiduciary
  • Health/Employee Benefits
  • Insurance & Financial Fraud
  • INN Exclusives
  • INN Magazine
  • Insurtech
  • Life Insurance News
  • Newswires
  • Property and Casualty
  • Regulation News
  • Sponsored Articles
  • Video
  • Washington Wire
  • Life Insurance
  • Annuities
  • Advisor
  • Health/Benefits
  • Property & Casualty
  • Insurtech
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Editorial Staff

Get Social

  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
Newswires
Newswires RSS Get our newsletter
Order Prints
June 13, 2026 Newswires
Share
Share
Post
Email

Colorado justices say insurers may access policyholders' medical info in denied-benefits litigation

Michael KarlikColoradopolitics.com

The Colorado Supreme Court declined on Monday to expand its narrow prohibition on insurance companies accessing policyholders' medical information, clarifying that a dispute over an insurer's bad-faith decision to deny benefits is the only situation where a company is limited to the information it knew at the time of the decision.

In 2018, the Supreme Court addressed a scenario in which a policyholder sued her insurance company and the insurer sought to dispute the cause of her injuries by obtaining a medical examination. In that case, Schultz v. GEICO Casualty Company, the Supreme Court decided that the reasonableness of an insurance company's decision to deny coverage "must be evaluated based on the information that was before the insurer at the time it made its coverage decision."

Eight years later, plaintiff Samantha Pinto of Colorado Springs asked the Supreme Court to similarly rule that her insurance company, United Services Automobile Association, was not entitled to obtain her medical records and evaluate her through its medical expert after it decided not to pay benefits for a car accident. Otherwise, USAA would be allowed to "create new medical evidence" to support its decision that it did not have at the time, her lawyers argued.

But the Supreme Court determined its Schultz decision did not apply to Pinto. In Schultz, the question was whether the insurance company acted in bad faith in its decision-making, wrote Justice Susan Blanco in the June 8 opinion. Pinto, on the other hand, was seeking benefits allegedly owed under her policy.

"Schultz does not extend to breach of contract claims because, unlike bad faith claims, the reasonableness of the insurer's conduct is not a consideration. Instead, the only consideration is whether the insured can establish an entitlement to the benefits under the policy," Blanco wrote.

Pinto sued USAA after she was injured in a 2020 rear-end accident. The insurer for the at-fault driver paid her $500,000, but Pinto's estimated losses from her inability to work totaled nearly $1.4 million. Consequently, she sought the maximum of $300,000 under her USAA policy.

In September 2023, the USAA claims department offered her "$0.00 to settle" the claim. Pinto's lawsuit sought the benefits under her policy and also brought a bad-faith-related claim.

Pinto challenged USAA's requests for her medical records related to other accidents that happened in 1999 and 2022. Pinto also disputed that she should sit for a neuropsychological exam with USAA's medical expert.

Her attorney, Timothy G. Buxton, argued USAA was trying to "create new medical evidence that was not before the adjuster at the time the adjuster made her decision and USAA denied the claim," in violation of Supreme Court precedent.

District Court Judge Eric Bentley noted that Pinto had a bad-faith claim, to which Schultz would apply. But there was also a breach-of-contract claim.

"You're saying that the damages exceeded the amount paid out on the underlying policy, and so USAA owes your client," he said. "So, your arguments all may be relevant to the claim number 2 for bad faith, but I am looking at … all claims."

Bentley ordered Pinto to provide medical records, including documentation from her other accidents, and to sit for a psychological evaluation. Although Bentley referenced a recent Supreme Court decision that shot down a different judge's order requiring a personal injury plaintiff to be examined by that same doctor, he did not explain why he was ruling differently.

Pinto immediately turned to the Supreme Court.

"It is well settled law in Colorado that a denial of underinsured motorist benefits … is evaluated based on the evidence and information available to the insurer at the time it made its coverage decision, not on evidence developed later during litigation or trial," her lawyers wrote. "Defendant is doing what this Court has already said it is not allowed to do: attempting to create new evidence to justify its position."

Members of the Colorado Supreme Court participate in oral arguments at Holyoke Junior/Senior High School in Holyoke, Colo. on April 16, 2026 as part of the "Courts in the Community" program. Michael Karlik, Colorado Politics.Members of the Colorado Supreme Court participate in oral arguments at Holyoke Junior/Senior High School in Holyoke, on April 16, 2026, as part of the "Courts in the Community" program. (Michael Karlik, Colorado Politics)

The Colorado Defense Lawyers Association wrote in support of USAA, arguing the question of whether an insurer acted reasonably in its decision-making was separate from whether benefits were actually owed.

"'Freezing the frame' of a breach of contract claim to include only pre-suit (evidence) would encourage insureds to file suit to prevent unfavorable evidence from being discovered by their insurers," the group wrote. "An insured's medical records are not 'newly created evidence' under Schultz, but rather evidence that should have been shared with an insurer during the claim investigation."

As for whether Pinto should sit for a psychological evaluation with the defense's expert, USAA argued that Pinto was asserting a link between the 2020 car accident and her cognitive condition.

"The purpose of the (exam) is to evaluate Pinto's claimed cognitive impairment, to ascertain its extent and relationship to the December 2022 accident, to rule out other possible causes, and to determine the relationship, if any, between her pre-existing cognitive impairment and the impairment claimed from the subsequent accident," wrote USAA's attorneys.

The Supreme Court agreed with the company.

"Pinto placed her mental health at issue when she asserted that her cognitive impairments should be covered," wrote Blanco. "As a result, USAA reasonably inquired whether causes other than the motor vehicle accident contributed to her alleged cognitive deficits."

Further, the limitation on medical evidence for to bad-faith claims does not apply elsewhere.

"Accordingly, Schultz does not extend to breach of contract claims that do not involve a reasonableness inquiry," added Blanco.

The case is Pinto v. United Services Automobile Association.

Older

Castleark Management LLC Buys 39,520 Shares of Citigroup Inc. $C

Newer

Michael Hudson: Debts That Cannot Be Paid Won’t Be

Advisor News

  • Survey: Most Americans still feel prosperous despite economic worries
  • SEC settlement would require Tai Lopez, two others, to pay $6.8 million
  • The Gen Z money paradox
  • NAIFA applauds final SECURE 2.0 regulations
  • What will Democrats in Congress do about healthcare and retirement?
More Advisor News

Annuity News

  • AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Global Atlantic Financial Group Limited and Its Subsidiaries
  • Best’s Market Segment Report: AM Best Maintains Stable Outlook on US Life/Annuity Insurance Segment
  • AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company and Its Subsidiaries
  • Boomers want retirement protection, but their actions don’t match their mindset
  • NAIC task force to address LTC riders
More Annuity News

Health/Employee Benefits News

  • EXPLORING INSULIN COST-SHARING CAPS FOR PATIENTS WITH PRIVATE COVERAGE
  • THE AMERICAN DIABETES ASSOCIATION FIGHTS TO MAINTAIN ACCESS TO HEALTH INSURANCE
  • Grand jury accuses veteran of making false disability claims that defrauded VA
  • States push short-term insurance as healthcare costs climb
  • Study Findings on Managed Care Are Outlined in Reports from Massachusetts General Hospital (A RUC Rescue of Primary Care?): Managed Care
More Health/Employee Benefits News

Life Insurance News

  • FORMER PRINCE GEORGE'S COUNTY INSURANCE AGENT SENTENCED FOR FELONY INSURANCE THEFT SCHEME
  • AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Ameriprise Financial, Inc. and Its Subsidiaries
  • AM Best Takes Various Credit Rating Actions on Certain Subsidiaries of Auto-Owners Insurance Group
  • AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Global Atlantic Financial Group Limited and Its Subsidiaries
  • AM Best Downgrades Credit Ratings of CICA Life Insurance Company of America
More Life Insurance News

NEWS INSIDE

  • Companies
  • Earnings
  • Economic News
  • INN Magazine
  • Insurtech News
  • Newswires Feed
  • Regulation News
  • Washington Wire
  • Videos

FEATURED OFFERS

Press Releases

  • OpenRoad Insurance Data Shows 40% of Collector Vehicles Are Model Year 1980 or Newer
  • Insurvoice Lets Independent Insurance Agency Owners Analyze Every Customer Call in ChatGPT or Claude
  • Spectrum Weather & Specialty Insurance Celebrates 15 Years and Welcomes the Next Generation
  • Royal Neighbors of America® Increases Service Capacity
  • Benefits Studio Launches to Fill the Missing Middle of Benefits Navigation at $49/mo
More Press Releases > Add Your Press Release >

How to Write For InsuranceNewsNet

Find out how you can submit content for publishing on our website.
View Guidelines

Topics

  • Advisor News
  • Annuity Index
  • Annuity News
  • Companies
  • Earnings
  • Fiduciary
  • From the Field: Expert Insights
  • Health/Employee Benefits
  • Insurance & Financial Fraud
  • INN Magazine
  • Insiders Only
  • Life Insurance News
  • Newswires
  • Property and Casualty
  • Regulation News
  • Sponsored Articles
  • Washington Wire
  • Videos
  • ———
  • About
  • Meet our Editorial Staff
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Newsletters

Top Sections

  • AdvisorNews
  • Annuity News
  • Health/Employee Benefits News
  • InsuranceNewsNet Magazine
  • Life Insurance News
  • Property and Casualty News
  • Washington Wire

Our Company

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Meet our Editorial Staff
  • Magazine Subscription
  • Write for INN

Sign up for our FREE e-Newsletter!

Get breaking news, exclusive stories, and money- making insights straight into your inbox.

select Newsletter Options
Facebook Linkedin Twitter
© 2026 InsuranceNewsNet.com, Inc. All rights reserved.
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • InsuranceNewsNet Magazine

Sign in with your Insider Pro Account

Not registered? Become an Insider Pro.