Insurance industry ads continue to be among top watched

By Doug Bailey

You can be forgiven if you are among those who grow weary of the incessant auto insurance commercials on broadcast and streaming channels featuring colorful and memorable characters like Emus, Geckos, Mayhem Men, Jake from State Farm, the Farmer’s Insurance professor, and, of course, Flo, the Progressive cashier.

Yet, despite their ubiquity and maybe annoying tendencies, surveys continue to rank the ostensibly humorous come-ons as among the most popular with consumers, and the industry stands by their cost effectiveness and brand awareness raising.

“Probably three or four of the top 10 brands across all of TV advertising are insurance brands,” said Tyler Bobin, a senior analyst at iSpot.tv, which measures the brand and business impact of TV and streaming advertising. “Some of the ads are over the top but they’re more lifestyle type ads in which you immediately recognize the people and characters in the ads and the company they represent.”

iSpot’s latest analysis of how insurance brands covered TV in the first half or 2022 found that out of the 50-most-seen insurance ads, a Liberty Mutual spot ranked as the most likable, followed closely by Farmer’s Insurance, featuring the irrepressible museum curator played by actor J.K .Simmons, and of course one with the GEICO Gecko. Like most successful ads, they win with funny vignettes, ear worm jingles, and repetitive slogans.

“Creatively we aim to break through the hyper-competitive market so that consumers remember Liberty Mutual,” said Jena Lebel, Liberty Mutual chief marketing officer for global retail markets. “In our TV ads, we leverage memorable, humorous moments and characters, and we drive brand linkage via effective brand cues such as LiMu Emu & Doug and our jingle.”

How insurance company ads compare.

More important than likability, however, were the number of times the ads were seen on screen by viewers, or what the ad industry calls “impressions.”

“The top five insurers had about 33 billion or more impressions in the first half of the year,” Bobin said. “That is a substantial amount.”

Yet in spite of the seemingly endless volume of auto insurance company ads, estimated spending by insurers in the first half of 2022 – $1.22 billion – was flat, or slightly lower than previous periods, iSpot found. Bobin explained the industry ad buys tend to be far less than the amount spent by automakers, fast-food chains, and streaming services, because insurers typically advertise regularly during the day as opposed to during primetime or special highly rated events such as NFL games and March Madness when ad rates are much higher.

“Insurance brands are dominant on television no matter the time of year,” the iSpot.tv analysis said. “Since Jan. 2021, insurance brands – life, health, auto & general – have accounted for 9.32% of estimated national TV ad spend and 6.25% of TV ad impressions during new-airing programming. Also, four of the five most-seen brands in that timeframe were insurance brands.”

The fact that the ads emphasize humor, lifestyle, emotion, and characters over hard selling techniques is doubtlessly the result of the slight product differential from one company’s premium to another. The intent is to grab attention, brand recognition, and comfort, without ever mentioning costs or features. Liberty’s Lebel said only that the creative strategy is “rooted in our business objectives.”

“It’s definite an interesting contrast,” said Bobin. “Automakers are quick to give you a price; streaming services tell you upfront what the basic cost is; wireless companies boldly feature the monthly costs; even fast food restaurants focus on the price. So, you're really only seeing the insurance category not mentioning their prices.”

Doug Bailey is a journalist and freelance writer who lives outside of Boston. He can be reached at [email protected].