Court Chooses 'Could' Over 'Would' In Insurance Benefits Case - Insurance News | InsuranceNewsNet

InsuranceNewsNet — Your Industry. One Source.™

Sign in
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
Home Now reading INN Exclusives
Topics
    • Advisor News
    • Annuity Index
    • Annuity News
    • Companies
    • Earnings
    • Fiduciary
    • From the Field: Expert Insights
    • Health/Employee Benefits
    • Insurance & Financial Fraud
    • INN Magazine
    • Insiders Only
    • Life Insurance News
    • Newswires
    • Property and Casualty
    • Regulation News
    • Sponsored Articles
    • Washington Wire
    • Videos
    • ———
    • About
    • Meet our Editorial Staff
    • Advertise
    • Contact
    • Newsletters
  • Exclusives
  • NewsWires
  • Magazine
  • Newsletters
Sign in or register to be an INNsider.
  • AdvisorNews
  • Annuity News
  • Companies
  • Earnings
  • Fiduciary
  • Health/Employee Benefits
  • Insurance & Financial Fraud
  • INN Exclusives
  • INN Magazine
  • Insurtech
  • Life Insurance News
  • Newswires
  • Property and Casualty
  • Regulation News
  • Sponsored Articles
  • Video
  • Washington Wire
  • Life Insurance
  • Annuities
  • Advisor
  • Health/Benefits
  • Property & Casualty
  • Insurtech
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Editorial Staff

Get Social

  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
INN Exclusives
INN Exclusives RSS Get our newsletter
Order Prints
March 29, 2016 INN Exclusives
Share
Share
Post
Email

Court Chooses ‘Could’ Over ‘Would’ In Insurance Benefits Case

By Cyril Tuohy InsuranceNewsNet

A circuit court has upheld an insurance company’s suspension of long-term disability benefits after the court found the insurer hadn’t met the “abuse of discretion” standard in denying disability benefits to a Minnesota doctor who suffered from the effects of a car accident and a subsequent unrelated knee injury.

When the case involves a conflict of opinion between a claimant’s treating physicians and the plan administrators’ reviewing physicians, the administrator, in this case the insurance carrier, has discretion to deny benefits “unless the record does not support denial,” the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit wrote.

“In resolving this conflict, Standard was not required to give special deference to the opinions of Whitley’s treating physicians,” the three-judge panel found, in a 13-page decision issued earlier this month in Gwendolyn Whitley v. Standard Insurance Company.

Under the abuse of discretion standard, the administrator’s decision stands so long as a “reasonable person could have reached a similar decision, given the evidence before him, not that a reasonable person would have reached that decision,” the court wrote.

A lower court had agreed previously with Whitley when it found the insurance company had abused its discretion in discontinuing benefits because the carrier’s doctors dismissed Whitley’s physicians’ findings that she could return to work part time under supervision.

Standard Insurance Co. appealed the district court’s finding. Standard Insurance Co., which had been paying Whitley’s long-term disability benefits since May 2011, suspended payments July 31, 2012 after doctors retained by the carrier found Whitley fit to work full time under the occupational scope of her family medical license.

In her internal appeal to the carrier, however, Whitley said she was only ready to return to her employer, Lake Regional Hospital in Fergus Falls, Minn., on a part-time basis and cited opinions from her attending physicians to bolster her case.

“I am improved; I am happy to be better,” Whitley wrote in an August 2012 appeal to the insurer, according to court documents. “I do want to return to full-time work as an emergency medicine physician. I am not ready to return to work full time yet.”

Employer’s Accommodation at Issue

Lake Region Hospital couldn’t accommodate her part-time request on her terms, but was agreeable to an alternative arrangement, according to court documents.

Subsequent to knee surgery, however, Whitley in January 2013 amended her original claim, which she filed under her employer’s group long-term disability coverage, to say she was disabled and suffering from “chronic pain.”

Doctors and consultants retained by the insurer found that Whitley was able not only to work from July 31, 2012, up until her knee surgeries ending in December 2012, and would be able to return to work full time once more as of March 11, 2013, after recovering from surgery.

When the insurer in March 2013 finally affirmed its decision to stop its long-term disability payments related to the car accident, Whitley sued.

There was “substantial evidence” to show that the insurance carrier had offered Whitley a “full and fair review” as required by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) before denying her appeal, the appeals court also found.

InsuranceNewsNet Senior Writer Cyril Tuohy has covered the financial services industry for more than 15 years. Cyril may be reached at cyril.tuohy@innfeedback.com.

© Entire contents copyright 2016 by InsuranceNewsNet.com Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this article may be reprinted without the expressed written consent from InsuranceNewsNet.com.

 

Cyril Tuohy

Cyril Tuohy is a writer based in Pennsylvania. He has covered the financial services industry for more than 15 years. He can be reached at cyril.tuohy@innfeedback.com.

Older

The Rule Without Rules – Is A Principles-Based Rule Really A Rule?

Newer

SEC Compliance Chief Is Getting More Muscle This Year

Advisor News

  • Survey: Most Americans still feel prosperous despite economic worries
  • SEC settlement would require Tai Lopez, two others, to pay $6.8 million
  • The Gen Z money paradox
  • NAIFA applauds final SECURE 2.0 regulations
  • What will Democrats in Congress do about healthcare and retirement?
More Advisor News

Annuity News

  • AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Global Atlantic Financial Group Limited and Its Subsidiaries
  • Best’s Market Segment Report: AM Best Maintains Stable Outlook on US Life/Annuity Insurance Segment
  • AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company and Its Subsidiaries
  • Boomers want retirement protection, but their actions don’t match their mindset
  • NAIC task force to address LTC riders
More Annuity News

Health/Employee Benefits News

  • Luzerne County health insurance rising 19.4%
  • OHA plans to roll back Medicaid programs for youth
  • EXPLORING INSULIN COST-SHARING CAPS FOR PATIENTS WITH PRIVATE COVERAGE
  • THE AMERICAN DIABETES ASSOCIATION FIGHTS TO MAINTAIN ACCESS TO HEALTH INSURANCE
  • Grand jury accuses veteran of making false disability claims that defrauded VA
More Health/Employee Benefits News

Life Insurance News

  • FORMER PRINCE GEORGE'S COUNTY INSURANCE AGENT SENTENCED FOR FELONY INSURANCE THEFT SCHEME
  • AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Ameriprise Financial, Inc. and Its Subsidiaries
  • AM Best Takes Various Credit Rating Actions on Certain Subsidiaries of Auto-Owners Insurance Group
  • AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Global Atlantic Financial Group Limited and Its Subsidiaries
  • AM Best Downgrades Credit Ratings of CICA Life Insurance Company of America
More Life Insurance News

NEWS INSIDE

  • Companies
  • Earnings
  • Economic News
  • INN Magazine
  • Insurtech News
  • Newswires Feed
  • Regulation News
  • Washington Wire
  • Videos

FEATURED OFFERS

Press Releases

  • OpenRoad Insurance Data Shows 40% of Collector Vehicles Are Model Year 1980 or Newer
  • Insurvoice Lets Independent Insurance Agency Owners Analyze Every Customer Call in ChatGPT or Claude
  • Spectrum Weather & Specialty Insurance Celebrates 15 Years and Welcomes the Next Generation
  • Royal Neighbors of America® Increases Service Capacity
  • Benefits Studio Launches to Fill the Missing Middle of Benefits Navigation at $49/mo
More Press Releases > Add Your Press Release >

How to Write For InsuranceNewsNet

Find out how you can submit content for publishing on our website.
View Guidelines

Topics

  • Advisor News
  • Annuity Index
  • Annuity News
  • Companies
  • Earnings
  • Fiduciary
  • From the Field: Expert Insights
  • Health/Employee Benefits
  • Insurance & Financial Fraud
  • INN Magazine
  • Insiders Only
  • Life Insurance News
  • Newswires
  • Property and Casualty
  • Regulation News
  • Sponsored Articles
  • Washington Wire
  • Videos
  • ———
  • About
  • Meet our Editorial Staff
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Newsletters

Top Sections

  • AdvisorNews
  • Annuity News
  • Health/Employee Benefits News
  • InsuranceNewsNet Magazine
  • Life Insurance News
  • Property and Casualty News
  • Washington Wire

Our Company

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Meet our Editorial Staff
  • Magazine Subscription
  • Write for INN

Sign up for our FREE e-Newsletter!

Get breaking news, exclusive stories, and money- making insights straight into your inbox.

select Newsletter Options
Facebook Linkedin Twitter
© 2026 InsuranceNewsNet.com, Inc. All rights reserved.
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • InsuranceNewsNet Magazine

Sign in with your Insider Pro Account

Not registered? Become an Insider Pro.