Sen. Murphy Lays Out Facts of Just-Released Republican Health Care Bill
Senator
"This process is an embarrassment. We are about to reorder one-fifth of the American health care system, and we are going to have two hours to review a bill which at first blush stands essentially as health care system arson. This bill is lighting the American health care system on fire with intentionality, and to use the word 'freedom' at its center? There's freedom in this bill. There's the freedom to go bankrupt. There's the freedom to get sick and not be able to find a doctor. There's freedom in this bill to die early," said Murphy.
"This isn't a game," continued Murphy. "This is real life, and if this bill becomes law, real people will be hurt."
The full text of Murphy's remarks is below:
Thank you, Mr. President.
This process is an embarrassment. This is nuclear-grade bonkers what is happening here tonight. We are about to reorder one-fifth of the American health care system and we are going to have two hours to review a bill which at first blush stands essentially as health care system arson. This bill is lighting the American health care system on fire with intentionality, and to use the word "freedom" at its center? There's freedom in this bill. There's the freedom to go bankrupt. There's the freedom to get sick and not be able to find a doctor. There's freedom in this bill to die early.
That's not hyperbole, guys. That's what happens when, overnight, 16 million people lose insurance. And don't tell us that's because people all of a sudden won't be mandated to buy it. This is a vicious cycle that happens. When you get rid of the mandate, every single insurance company will tell you that rates skyrocket because you're not getting rid of the provision that requires insurance companies to price sick people the same as healthy people. CBO says that rates go up immediately by 20%, then 20% after that, then 20% after that. And so all of a sudden you can't have the individual mandate because nobody can afford to buy the product.
There's a lot of freedom in this bill. It's just not the kind of freedom that we all thought was at the heart of this reform measure. And this is real life. It is not a game. I know lots of members on the Republican side are voting for this because they've got some promise that even though this bill is terrible and everybody admits it doesn't solve any problems, it'll get to a forum in which the problems can be truly solved. That's gamesmanship. That's not senatorial. That's not what this place was supposed to be.
This was supposed to be the great deliberative body where we solved big problems, and this bill surrenders to the
There's nothing in the rules that locks this bill into the conference committee once it is there.
This is the same thing. This won't be a hammer sufficient enough to solve the dysfunction that has always been present in this process. Thus, the
We are begging our colleagues to vote for the motion to recommit. Take us at our word. We want to work with you. We acknowledge that there are still problems that need to be solved, though we maintain that there are parts of the Affordable Care Act that are working. What if we owned the problem and the solution together? What if this wasn't a perpetual political football? There is still time for us to work this out together, if you support us and vote for the motion to recommit.
This process is an embarrassment to the
Mr. President, it doesn't have to be this way. I yield the floor.


Sen. Murphy Issues Statement on Defeat of Health Care Repeal Bill
Rep. Kaptur Issues Statement on Senate Rejection of Harmful Health Care Bill
Advisor News
- Inflation, competing priorities and uncertainty erode retirement security
- As health premiums rise, 1 in 8 workers cut retirement savings
- CT governor’s candidates claims: What’s true, and what’s misleading
- Retaining clients by giving them a memorable experience
- Addressing the longevity paradox
More Advisor NewsAnnuity News
- National Life Group expands annuity portfolio
- AM Best to Join Life/Annuity Insurance-Focused Panel Discussion at Capitol Forum Event
- USAA Earns No. 1 Ranking in JD Power Individual Annuity Study for the Third Consecutive Year
- How flexible annuities fit today’s retirement portfolios
- Foresters Financial appoints Tom Ross as chief distribution officer for U.S. annuity sales
More Annuity NewsHealth/Employee Benefits News
- Pennsylvania Law Mandates No-Cost Coverage for Colorectal Cancer Blood Tests
- Open Enrollment set to begin Nov. 1
- Advice for health care open enrollment beginning November 1
- Plans with cheaper premiums are risky business for Americans seeking lower healthcare costs
- Who inherits the homeowners insurance when someone dies?
More Health/Employee Benefits NewsLife Insurance News