Quin Hillyer: Gov. Jeff Landry's insurance bill remains an abominable mess
State legislators failed to show enough spine to block or even improve a terribly misguided insurance-regulating bill, pushed by Gov.
House Bill 148, as now passed by both the state
Every legislator with an ounce of sense knows how important the difference is between the words "may" and "shall" in legislation. And every legislator claiming to be in any way a constitutional conservative should heed the antipathy the nation's founders held against highly concentrated arbitrary power. As
HB148 falls horribly on the wrong side of both the may/shall test and of the warnings against arbitrary, concentrated authority.
The first bad provision is one about which I have written twice this spring. Legislators still got it wrong.
As originally introduced, the bill would have given the insurance commissioner, acting alone, the ability to reject requests for rate increases that he determines are "excessive," but specified that he "shall not make such a determination if the rate is actuarially justified." In other words, even when assuming additional, unilateral power, the commissioner at least would be obliged to justify his decisions by reference to real data from actuarial tables and evidence.
Every Louisianan should want regulatory decisions to rely on empirical data, not on personal whims or political favors.
At Landry's personal direction, the House passed HB148 without any reference at all to actuarial data. Such a provision could be an open invitation to corruption.
Sensing blowback, the
Repeat: "May." And even then, actuarial soundness is only afforded a passing "consideration." That's a long, long way from the original prohibition against arbitrary power as expressed in the language that had said the commissioner "shall not" disapprove a rate request if it is actuarially justified.
Indeed, with the
By contrast,
The new law also contains several other serious flaws, but of course, a number of legislators felt pressured to give the governor a "win" of some sort on this issue on which he has staked so much political capital. Yet even if that pressure seemed overwhelming, they should have fixed at least one other bad provision.
As amended, the law also gives the commissioner power not just to decline rate requests, but to order "a refund of any sums deemed to be discriminatory or excessive." Not only is this "deemed to be ... excessive" language untethered to actuarial data, but it also has no time limit. A commissioner could order refunds for premiums paid five years ago, or even ten.
How, pray tell, can a company feel confident in a state in which a sole, arbitrary decision-maker could punish them for business done years ago in full accordance with law at the time? For purely political reasons, a future commissioner could use this provision essentially to bankrupt the
Insurers likely would flee the state altogether rather than be governed by such whims. With less competition, rates eventually wouldn't fall, but instead rise even more.
Because of the provisions on refunds and on actuarial requirements, this new law is downright abominable. Voters should consider punishing any legislators who approved it — and do likewise to the governor who shoved it down their throats.


Best’s Market Segment Report: Florida’s Property Insurance Market Showing Stabilization; Turns First Underwriting Profit in Eight Years
A Medicaid Patient Had a Heart Attack While Traveling. He Owed Almost $78,000.
Advisor News
- Semi-retirement: helping clients balance flexibility with financial security
- The 6X Formula for leveraging content marketing with AI
- When a home becomes difficult to insure, the plan changes
- The inheritance gap: Helping clients plan for money that hasn’t arrived
- After the midterms: Addressing your clients’ tax concerns
More Advisor NewsAnnuity News
- Athene CEO criticizes offshore reinsurance, risk-taking by competitors
- DOL, trade groups, state AGs file briefs supporting Alcoa in PRT lawsuit
- John Hancock launches new fixed indexed annuity suite
- Annuities to play a larger role in workplace retirement plans
- FHLBank Pittsburgh Announces Results in 2026 Board Election
More Annuity NewsHealth/Employee Benefits News
- Rising hospital, drug costs boost health insurance premiums at fastest pace since start of Obamacare
- Patients with 3 health insurance plans lose access to Miami health network
- Weld County deputy struggling after being injured by DUI driver (photo gallery)
- Changes to Medicare Advantage plan offerings affect Montana seniors
- Medicaid work rules don’t apply to Native Americans. They could still lose coverage.
More Health/Employee Benefits NewsLife Insurance News
- Best’s Market Segment Report: AM Best Maintains Stable Outlook on New Zealand’s Non-Life Insurance Segment
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Fubon Insurance Vietnam Co., Ltd.
- Three lawsuits put life insurers’ cost-of-insurance practices under scrutiny
- Military Briefs: November 12-18
- Security Benefit Series B Preferred Stock Dividend Rate Resets to 10.286%
More Life Insurance News