Feedback on My Blog Post on Electrical Power Impacts from Ida
Sep. 7—It is unfortunate, but the platform I blog on does not allow for direct comments to be posted. However, I sometimes do get readers who write me separately at my email address.
I got one such reply below to this blog post, "Hurricane Ida — Getting the Power Back On," which highlighted the work by the mutual aid system for electrical utilities for moving utility crews and trucks from around the nation to help in
"I don't think EMA managers are well served by your comments. 'The situation there in
"Suggest solutions please, don't just tell us the obvious. How would you harden the distribution system against 150 MPH wind gusts? At what cost? Who will pay? Should the utility pay, via increased power bills to the citizens; should the state government pay via increased state taxes; should the federal government pay so that farmers in
"Burying electrical power lines is not the answer: it is extremely costly, and they can be accidentally dug up, or severed by earthquakes. Overhead high voltage distribution is the norm all over the world. There are no easy solutions or they would have been implemented years ago.
"Consumers complain all the time about electricity rate increases, transmission line towers anywhere near their homes, they object to nuclear energy and fossil fuel energy, but they are not willing to have a public debate about what alternatives are best for replacement. Our electrical grid infrastructure has not seen significant investment in decades because of these and other reasons.
"Not mentioned is the fact that the grid is also very vulnerable to cybersecurity attacks because of the reliance on poorly implemented alarm and control systems. This is slowly being fixed, but meanwhile
"I was present right after Katrina to assist with communications, and as a result of that experience had drafted into the NFPA 1221 standard (soon to be 1225), which defines public safety communications, the requirement to have the ability to connect a roll-up generator via an outlet and plug. This allows these roll-up generators to supplement or replace emergency generators at communications sites, which may fail to start or require servicing during extended outages.
"Please in future suggest improvements.
Thank you,
In emergency management terms, he was accusing me of "admiring the problem" instead of suggesting solutions.
As for direct "electrical grid solutions,"
I'll add my
We need to "sound the retreat" from the water's edge. The barrier island that took the direct hit in
The billions of dollars spent to protect portions of
If you want to live in the forest, go ahead, but don't expect that government is going to bail you out when everything burns. No, we will not subsidize your home fire insurance because you can't get commercial insurance that is affordable — because the insurance carriers are becoming very aware of the risks they are incurring by insuring your property.
"Location, location, location" is the word of the day. Retreat from the water's edge, be it the ocean, river or stream. Want a cliffside view? Great, but you assume the risk, not your fellow citizens.
Mandatory building codes that are enforced would help — not every place in the
None of the above that I suggest is anywhere near possible in today's environment where government handouts post-disaster are expected. The only thing that will change is when our national budget and economy are near collapse and elected officials are faced with the reality that government cannot be Uncle Sugar any more. Until then, we'll keep building new homes, businesses, and public infrastructure that puts all of these in harm's way at some point in the future. For now it is great for business — until finally it isn't.
Basically, we are setting ourselves up for future failure in order to get tax revenue today. Local elected officials, developers, builders and building trade associations, along with homeowners, are the ones digging us into this hole.
Eventually the piper will be paid, but please, not on my watch!
___
(c)2021 Government Technology
Visit Government Technology at www.govtech.com
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
Bill to aid firefighters, teachers and police officer first time home-buying unveiled
From NFL To Finance, Mitch Lyons Forges Own Path
Advisor News
Annuity News
Health/Employee Benefits News
Life Insurance News