SCOTUS declines to hear lawsuit over Country Mutual Insurance profits - Insurance News | InsuranceNewsNet

InsuranceNewsNet — Your Industry. One Source.™

Sign in
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
Home Now reading Top Stories
Topics
    • Advisor News
    • Annuity Index
    • Annuity News
    • Companies
    • Earnings
    • Fiduciary
    • From the Field: Expert Insights
    • Health/Employee Benefits
    • Insurance & Financial Fraud
    • INN Magazine
    • Insiders Only
    • Life Insurance News
    • Newswires
    • Property and Casualty
    • Regulation News
    • Sponsored Articles
    • Washington Wire
    • Videos
    • ———
    • About
    • Meet our Editorial Staff
    • Advertise
    • Contact
    • Newsletters
  • Exclusives
  • NewsWires
  • Magazine
  • Newsletters
Sign in or register to be an INNsider.
  • AdvisorNews
  • Annuity News
  • Companies
  • Earnings
  • Fiduciary
  • Health/Employee Benefits
  • Insurance & Financial Fraud
  • INN Exclusives
  • INN Magazine
  • Insurtech
  • Life Insurance News
  • Newswires
  • Property and Casualty
  • Regulation News
  • Sponsored Articles
  • Video
  • Washington Wire
  • Life Insurance
  • Annuities
  • Advisor
  • Health/Benefits
  • Property & Casualty
  • Insurtech
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Editorial Staff

Get Social

  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
Top Stories
Top Stories RSS Get our newsletter
Order Prints
May 14, 2024 Top Stories
Share
Share
Post
Email

SCOTUS declines to hear lawsuit over Country Mutual Insurance profits

Image shows the Country Financial logo in front of a courthouse scene.
The U.S. Supreme Court rejected a petition brought by Country Mutual Insurance policyholders this week.
By John Hilton

The U.S. Supreme Court declined to intervene Monday and a lawsuit brought by Country Mutual Insurance Co. policyholders alleging the insurer is hoarding profits will revert to Illinois state court.

In a one-sentence response, the high court passed on reviewing an October decision by the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit sending the case back to state court.

Country Mutual policyholders claim the insurer is in breach of contract as a mutual insurance company by not providing insurance at cost and returning surplus premiums to policyholders. The company collected an "excess surplus of over $3.5 billion," court documents say.

Plaintiffs Angela M. Sudholt, Kyhl A. Sudholt, Kara Jones, and Benjamin Jones filed a class-action lawsuit in 2022 in the St. Clair County Circuit Court against the Country Mutual, its officers and its directors, citing breach of contract.

The lawsuit makes a straightforward argument: that since a mutual insurance company is owned by the policyholders rather than stockholders, it has an obligation to provide insurance to policyholders at cost. And any excess in premiums paid that exceed the cost of providing insurance should be returned to the policyholders.

Country Mutual: federal court applies

Country Mutual petitioned the court to move the lawsuit to federal court under the Class Action Fairness Act of 2005.

CAFA is designed to reduce "forum shopping" by plaintiffs in friendly state courts by extending federal diversity jurisdiction to class actions where there is not "complete diversity," thereby giving federal subject-matter jurisdiction over a broader set of class actions.

Plaintiffs countered with an appeal to keep the case in state court, arguing that it satisfied one of the three exceptions to CAFA: the internal-affairs exception, the home-state controversy exception, and the local controversy exception

The plaintiffs named 46 current and former board directors and executives as individual defendants, including Robert Bateman, a Massachusetts citizen. The fact that Bateman was not a citizen of Illinois, the federal district court in southern Illinois ruled that the class action did not qualify as a home-state controversy.

The Seventh Circuit three-judge panel saw the evidence differently.

"The complaint identifies [Bateman] as the company’s chief financial officer for two years of the decade-long surplus accumulation, but it does not otherwise say much about him," the panel wrote. "There is no allegation, for example, that Mr. Bateman played a particular or significant role in the alleged accumulation of excess surplus. In these circumstances ... we cannot conclude that Mr. Bateman is a primary defendant within the meaning of CAFA’s home-state controversy exception."

The appeals court panel also ruled that the internal-affairs exception also applies to the Country Mutual lawsuit due to the level of management decisions that were taking place.

'A substantial question'

In applying for a writ of certiorari to the SCOTUS, Country Mutual attorneys argued that the case presents "a substantial question" for the high court.

"[T]he [Appeals] Court’s opinion splits with other Circuits and therefore creates confusion in the law with respect to two exceptions to federal court jurisdiction under the Class Action Fairness Act of 2005," the petition states. "The petition will ask the Supreme Court (a) to determine what factors are relevant when trying to identify 'primary' defendants for purposes of CAFA’s home state exception, and (b) what issues should be considered when ascertaining whether CAFA’s internal-affairs exception applies."

Country Mutual is part of Country Financial, a group of insurance and financial services companies with customers in 19 states. The group of companies offers a range of insurance and financial products and services, including auto, home, life, farm, commercial insurance, retirement planning, investment management and trust services.

The corporate headquarters are in Bloomington, Illinois.

InsuranceNewsNet Senior Editor John Hilton covered business and other beats in more than 20 years of daily journalism. John may be reached at john.hilton@innfeedback.com. Follow him on Twitter @INNJohnH.

© Entire contents copyright 2024 by InsuranceNewsNet.com Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this article may be reprinted without the expressed written consent from InsuranceNewsNet.com.

John Hilton

InsuranceNewsNet Senior Editor John Hilton has covered business and other beats in more than 20 years of daily journalism. John may be reached at john.hilton@innfeedback.com. Follow him on Twitter @INNJohnH.

Older

New annualized life insurance premium dips in Q1, LIMRA reports

Newer

How insurers can leverage AI to drive innovation within the policy lifecycle

Advisor News

  • The Gen Z money paradox
  • NAIFA applauds final SECURE 2.0 regulations
  • What will Democrats in Congress do about healthcare and retirement?
  • Election results cloud retirement legislation outlook, experts say
  • Planning for the missing chapter
More Advisor News

Annuity News

  • AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company and Its Subsidiaries
  • Boomers want retirement protection, but their actions don’t match their mindset
  • NAIC task force to address LTC riders
  • ‘It’s really shocking:’ Regulators scrutinize assets backing annuity sellers
  • Jackson Launches Direct-to-Consumer Annuity Offering
More Annuity News

Health/Employee Benefits News

  • CHOICE arrangements: Not your father’s workplace health insurance
  • Picking a Health Plan This Fall? Check the Addiction Treatment Benefits First
  • A worthy subject for Rep. Neal's Ways and Means Committee | Letters to The Republican
  • Forms, phone calls and portals: The hidden work that keeps American institutions functioning burdens parents most
  • 3 ways to make healthcare more affordable in Wisconsin | Coleman Drake
More Health/Employee Benefits News

Life Insurance News

  • AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company and Its Subsidiaries
  • U-Haul Holding Company to Participate in Deutsche Bank Conference
  • NAIC task force to address LTC riders
  • Protective names Kurt Meyers Chief Legal Officer and Fernando Levy Chief Digital & AI Officer
  • Best’s Commentary: Shanghai Cross-Border Investment Pilot Unlocks Overseas Growth Potential of China Non-Life Companies
More Life Insurance News

NEWS INSIDE

  • Companies
  • Earnings
  • Economic News
  • INN Magazine
  • Insurtech News
  • Newswires Feed
  • Regulation News
  • Washington Wire
  • Videos

FEATURED OFFERS

Press Releases

  • OpenRoad Insurance Data Shows 40% of Collector Vehicles Are Model Year 1980 or Newer
  • Insurvoice Lets Independent Insurance Agency Owners Analyze Every Customer Call in ChatGPT or Claude
  • Spectrum Weather & Specialty Insurance Celebrates 15 Years and Welcomes the Next Generation
  • Royal Neighbors of America® Increases Service Capacity
  • Benefits Studio Launches to Fill the Missing Middle of Benefits Navigation at $49/mo
More Press Releases > Add Your Press Release >

How to Write For InsuranceNewsNet

Find out how you can submit content for publishing on our website.
View Guidelines

Topics

  • Advisor News
  • Annuity Index
  • Annuity News
  • Companies
  • Earnings
  • Fiduciary
  • From the Field: Expert Insights
  • Health/Employee Benefits
  • Insurance & Financial Fraud
  • INN Magazine
  • Insiders Only
  • Life Insurance News
  • Newswires
  • Property and Casualty
  • Regulation News
  • Sponsored Articles
  • Washington Wire
  • Videos
  • ———
  • About
  • Meet our Editorial Staff
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Newsletters

Top Sections

  • AdvisorNews
  • Annuity News
  • Health/Employee Benefits News
  • InsuranceNewsNet Magazine
  • Life Insurance News
  • Property and Casualty News
  • Washington Wire

Our Company

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Meet our Editorial Staff
  • Magazine Subscription
  • Write for INN

Sign up for our FREE e-Newsletter!

Get breaking news, exclusive stories, and money- making insights straight into your inbox.

select Newsletter Options
Facebook Linkedin Twitter
© 2026 InsuranceNewsNet.com, Inc. All rights reserved.
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • InsuranceNewsNet Magazine

Sign in with your Insider Pro Account

Not registered? Become an Insider Pro.