Obamacare: The Cure That Made Insurance Sick
Insurance used to be a relatively straightforward proposition. People voluntarily pooled their money to protect themselves against financial disasters that might otherwise ruin them. Homeowners purchased insurance against fires, motorists against accidents, and families against catastrophic medical expenses. Because millions contributed to the pool, sufficient funds were available to compensate the unfortunate few who suffered serious losses.
It was an ingenious arrangement based upon a simple recognition: risk can be shared, but it cannot be abolished.
Then came the politicians.
Dissatisfied with health insurance merely protecting people against financial catastrophe,
When
Consider automobile insurance. Motorists purchase protection against accidents, theft, and liability. But nobody expects an automobile insurer to pay for oil changes, tire rotations, or routine tune-ups. These are predictable expenses associated with owning a vehicle, not unforeseen catastrophes.
Imagine
The costs would simply be incorporated into premiums, along with the additional expense of processing claims, negotiating reimbursements, and administering government requirements. What motorists previously purchased directly would now be purchased through an expensive intermediary.
And because these services appeared to be covered by insurance, consumers would have less incentive to compare prices or question costs. Politicians might call this progress, but economists would identify it as stupidity.
Insurance was designed to protect against financial catastrophe, not to transform every expense into an insurance claim.
Another fundamental principle of insurance is that premiums should reflect risk. A motorist with twenty accident-free years represents a different risk than someone who has totaled three automobiles in eighteen months. Consequently, insurers charge different premiums. Nobody seriously expects the safer driver to subsidize the reckless one indefinitely.
Yet when it comes to health insurance, politicians have increasingly insisted that premiums be divorced from individual medical risk.
Under ObamaCare, insurers generally cannot adjust individual-market premiums according to medical history or health status. Premium differences are largely restricted to age, geography, tobacco use, family size, and plan category.
The political justification sounds compassionate: Everyone deserves affordable healthcare. But compassion does not repeal arithmetic.
When insurers cannot charge premiums reflecting expected medical expenses, those expenses do not disappear. They are redistributed. Lower-risk customers subsidize higher-risk ones, regardless of whether they understand or approve of the arrangement.
There may be legitimate humanitarian reasons to assist people with expensive medical conditions. But that is a question of providing assistance, not a justification for pretending everyone represents the same insurance risk.
ObamaCare further institutionalized the confusion by requiring individual and small-group insurance policies to cover ten categories of essential health benefits, including hospitalization, maternity care, prescription drugs, preventive services, and mental health treatment.
Customers are forced to pay for services that are not only unrequested but downright irrelevant.
A sixty-year-old man has little personal use for maternity coverage. A healthy young adult might prefer an inexpensive catastrophic policy rather than comprehensive coverage with benefits he rarely expects to use.
But
Comprehensive coverage and preventative medicine can be valuable. But making these services available is entirely different from compelling everyone to purchase them through insurance. There is an enormous difference between offering people protection and denying them the freedom to decide what protection they need.
When consumers purchase goods or services directly, they have reason to compare prices, evaluate alternatives, and determine whether the benefits justify the costs. But when medical expenses are routinely routed through insurance companies, these incentives fade.
Patients frequently have little idea what procedures cost. Providers negotiate reimbursement arrangements with insurance companies. The actual consumer often becomes the least informed participant in the transaction.
Nobody expects someone suffering a heart attack to shop around for the lowest-priced emergency room. Such catastrophes are precisely why insurance exists.
But routine examinations, diagnostic services, and other nonemergency medical procedures offer opportunities for transparent prices and meaningful competition.
Imagine a healthcare marketplace in which providers openly advertise prices, patients compare services, and insurance concentrates primarily on protecting against extraordinary expenses.
The resulting competition would encourage lower prices, greater efficiency, and improved service. This can be accomplished by simply restoring insurance to its original purpose.
Americans should be free to purchase genuine catastrophic medical insurance without being compelled to buy an extensive government-prescribed package of benefits.
Those wanting comprehensive coverage could purchase it. Those preferring high-deductible protection could choose that alternative. Routine expenses could be paid directly, through health savings accounts, or through voluntary subscription arrangements.
Insurance companies would compete for customers by offering coverage people actually wanted, rather than merely satisfying mandates imposed by politicians.
Premiums would more closely reflect risk, just as they do in other insurance markets.
A free-market system need not abandon those who develop expensive illnesses through no fault of their own or are unable to afford adequate coverage.
A carefully designed safety net could provide targeted assistance through publicly funded reinsurance, high-risk arrangements, or direct subsidies.
The fundamental problem with government-directed healthcare is not just the layer of bureaucracy that injects itself between the doctors and the patients, but the presumption to know what insurance Americans must purchase, which services they must finance, and how much personal choice they must surrender.
A healthcare system should be judged by its actual consequences: affordability, accessibility, quality, innovation, and individual freedom -- not the generosity of political promises.
When government mandates increasingly comprehensive coverage, it can make insurance more expensive for those who would otherwise choose less. When third-party payments replace direct purchasing, price competition weakens. When political decisions replace consumer preferences, the marketplace becomes less responsive to the people it supposedly serves.
Insurance was designed to protect people against financial risk, not relieve them of responsibility for every predictable expense of living.
A sensible system would allow Americans to select the protection they need, pay premiums that meaningfully reflect risk, and purchase routine medical services with greater control over their own money.
The choice is not between compassion and capitalism. It is between a system that acknowledges costs, respects incentives, and preserves individual choice -- and one that substitutes political intentions for economic reality.
Image:
Distributed by Newsbank, inc.


NM’s ‘insurer of last resort’ to make all enrollees reapply
Advisor News
- The Gen Z money paradox
- NAIFA applauds final SECURE 2.0 regulations
- What will Democrats in Congress do about healthcare and retirement?
- Election results cloud retirement legislation outlook, experts say
- Planning for the missing chapter
More Advisor NewsAnnuity News
- ‘It’s really shocking:’ Regulators scrutinize assets backing annuity sellers
- Jackson Launches Direct-to-Consumer Annuity Offering
- Global Atlantic launches ForeIncome Flex
- Athene CEO criticizes offshore reinsurance, risk-taking by competitors
- DOL, trade groups, state AGs file briefs supporting Alcoa in PRT lawsuit
More Annuity NewsHealth/Employee Benefits News
- Obamacare: The Cure That Made Insurance Sick
- Health insurers leave Ohio marketplace
- Blue Cross flags $5.5B in added medical coding costs at NAIC meeting
- MEDICAL FRAILTY AND MEDICAID WORK REQUIREMENTS: CHALLENGES FOR PEOPLE WITH MENTAL HEALTH CONDITIONS
- HOW NEW PHYSICIANS CAN AVOID PAYMENT PITFALLS IN MEDICARE AND MEDICAID
More Health/Employee Benefits NewsLife Insurance News
- Best’s Commentary: Shanghai Cross-Border Investment Pilot Unlocks Overseas Growth Potential of China Non-Life Companies
- Military Briefs: November 19-25
- California’s new solvency rules: What should life insurance advisors watch?
- Navigating delayed death certificates: A guide for life insurance advisors
- Jackson Launches Direct-to-Consumer Annuity Offering
More Life Insurance News