Oakland cities settle sewage lawsuit for $11.5M, but homeowners will see little
When
The cities involved were at fault along with Oakland County’s drain bosses, he decided.
Flaherty, a semi-retired civil and environmental engineer, quickly made himself an expert on what he says were defects in his neighborhood’s sewers. Then, with a large dollop of humor, he reached out to others with a website he named schittsfoundation.com, adorned with photos of his basement filled with brown water on
Since then, more than 125 other homeowners have contacted him about their sewage-drenched basements. Yet, as indignant as Flaherty became over the
His website reviews the law that governs such lawsuits, Public Act 222, calling it an unfair law “that stacks the deck against homeowners affected by defective combined sewage systems.”
A “combined sewage system” is one that mixes sanitary waste with stormwater. That’s the troublesome design that afflicts most of metro
As Flaherty contemplates filing a lawsuit, warned by his own lawyer about the small odds of winning, a huge batch of such lawsuits — joined in a single big class-action case — is headed toward a settlement and payouts for
That storm left cars submerged on
Damage per house was in many cases in the thousands of dollars. But the checks that
It’s making the rounds of city councils on its way to a court hearing on
The total settlement for property owners in the 10 cities is expected to be
“The proposed agreement has Troy paying
If Troy's
Some cities declined to talk about their proposed settlements, citing attorney-client privilege that they said is in effect until the hearing on
"I can tell you this. It isn't costing us much more than we would expect to pay just defending this lawsuit, and we would've cost us more if we'd taken it all the way through a jury trial," even assuming that the county won, Nash said.
'A 300-year storm'
"We tried to be as fair as possible. Remember, this was a 300-year storm and declared a national disaster by the president," Nash said.
Improvements to the county's and region's sewer systems are constantly aimed at lowering the risk of future flooding, he said.
"Right now, they're building a tunnel under
The lawyer representing the plaintiffs in the massive class-action case —
"It's been a long six years, and costs were multiple six figures to research this," Dubin said. To win, lawyers must hire experts who can testify about how sewers operate and what can go wrong in complex systems of giant pumps, miles of piping, pressure and gravity. The total number of claimants in the class-action case was about 19,000 in the 10 cities, Dubin said.
His firm’s website says it has “successfully recovered millions of dollars on behalf of thousands of clients claiming damages as a result of a sewage backup or flooding event” caused by “a governmental entity.”
As promising as that sounds, Michigan’s law sets a high bar for property owners seeking compensation after a sewage backup.
Flint attorney
“Ironically, we got flooded in the basement pretty good in
“I may know all about litigating these cases but I’m like everybody else. I have a million other things to do, and these cases are extremely difficult to prove. I’d have to prove the elements," he said.
By that he meant that he’d have to show a jury exactly how he’d fulfilled five elements required under Michigan Public Act 222 before a property owner can win a sewage backup case. Here's a summary of the five elements:
Identify the government agency in charge of the property owner's sewer system and notify it of the problem within 45 days of the sewage backup. Establish that the sewage system involved had a defect. Prove that the government agency knew or should’ve known about the defect. Show that the agency failed to take reasonable steps in a reasonable time to remedy the defect. Demonstrate that the defect was the “substantial proximate cause” of the basement backup — meaning, it was more than 50% of the cause.
“At the end of the day, this legislation was supposed to make everything streamlined in these cases,” Yeotis said. But it ended up leading to far fewer lawsuits and fewer successful ones, he said.
Still, Yeotis said, he's determined to pursue legal action on behalf of Flaherty and many other homeowners struck by this year's storm on
"Engler knew they couldn't abolish the flooding cases, so they just made the bar higher. It's really a high burden" for plaintiffs to prove, said Olsman, who is an attorney. He said leaders in
"We realized that people were really angry about this. It put us in a dilemma. You want people to come out of this with something, but we just can't dip into the city treasury for hundreds of thousands of dollars," Olsman said. In the end, the city's entire payout of about
Sewers aren't perfect
"I think half the houses in the city flooded," Olsman said. "But it was approaching an insurmountable legal hurdle to satisfy the kind of proof you need under that statute. Look, we have a 75-to-100-year-old sewer system. It's not going to be perfect.".
Some residents were able to get insurance to cover their damage, but not many, Olsman added.
"I think a lot of people learned a lot about their homeowners' insurance from this – what it does and doesn't cover." Such policies typically exclude coverage of basement sewage backups unless the policyholder pays considerably more for supplemental coverage.
Flaherty’s website opens with a zinger he aims at the county, city and village sewer bosses that he blames for his damaged home: "Dedicated to preventing
There is, of course, no Mrs. O'Schitts. Flaherty's wife is
“I’ve lived here 22 years, and we’d never had a backup before. And then I had 8,000 gallons of sewage in my basement,” he said.
As much as by the damage, Flaherty said he's upset that local officials at a
"I just think that's unacceptable," Flaherty said.
As an engineer, he said he was sure that the area's sewers were faulty. It didn't take him long to turn up something he considers a serious defect.
By poring over engineering maps of his town’s sewers, Flaherty said he’s turned up several examples of large pipes in his neighborhood that force their sewage to flow into smaller ones.
“Anyone knows, that’s going to cause backups,” he said.
More:
More: Can you save money and the environment? New plan for metro
Contact: blaitner@freepress.com
This article originally appeared on
___
(c)2020 the Detroit Free Press
Visit the Detroit Free Press at www.freep.com
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.


More PPP Loans Coming: Here’s How Businesses Can Get A 2nd One
Dalrada Financial Corporation Announces Acquisitions In Healthcare And Engineering
Advisor News
- SEC settlement would require Tai Lopez, two others, to pay $6.8 million
- The Gen Z money paradox
- NAIFA applauds final SECURE 2.0 regulations
- What will Democrats in Congress do about healthcare and retirement?
- Election results cloud retirement legislation outlook, experts say
More Advisor NewsAnnuity News
- Best’s Market Segment Report: AM Best Maintains Stable Outlook on US Life/Annuity Insurance Segment
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company and Its Subsidiaries
- Boomers want retirement protection, but their actions don’t match their mindset
- NAIC task force to address LTC riders
- ‘It’s really shocking:’ Regulators scrutinize assets backing annuity sellers
More Annuity NewsHealth/Employee Benefits News
- Picking Medicare insurance plan is daunting task – Healthful Hints
- November Issue of Best’s Review Ranks US Life Reinsurers and More
- New York Life Announces Record $3.1 Billion in Policy Owner Dividends for 2027
- New Va. subsidies help lure people back to health insurance
- 3 ways Crowley can make Healthcare more affordable in Wisconsin
3 ways to make healthcare more affordable in Wisconsin | Coleman Drake (Copy)
More Health/Employee Benefits NewsLife Insurance News
- November Issue of Best’s Review Ranks US Life Reinsurers and More
- Nebraska widow’s big win against life insurer in legal limbo
- New York Life Announces Record $3.1 Billion in Policy Owner Dividends for 2027
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company and Its Subsidiaries
- U-Haul Holding Company to Participate in Deutsche Bank Conference
More Life Insurance News