Moderates Are ‘Politically Homeless.’ Does Either Party Want Them?
"The problem has been that the folks on the extremes, they're the most vocal and they're where the money tends to show up," says
So where does that leave moderate voters?
More and more Americans are expressing their unhappiness with the two parties by registering as independents. In a Gallup poll this month, 42 percent of respondents identified as independents -- a dozen points more than Democrats and 16 points higher than
"Moderates and the traditional conservatives are politically homeless right now," says
There appears to be ample room left for candidates to appeal to centrist voters. But it's not clear what centrists want. It's generally been the case that voters who think of themselves as moderate actually hold quite liberal views on some issues and more conservative views on others. They aren't looking for politicians who find some sweet spot in the middle of important questions.
"They're all disaffected for very different reasons," says
Few voters actually swing their votes from one party to the other. Political science research has repeatedly shown that voters who identify as independents may not consider themselves partisan, but they almost invariably do vote in party-line fashion. According to the
"I don't think there are a lot of moderate voters who are going to flip back and forth," says
Still, there are a number of voters who are dissatisfied with American politics and the divergent directions the parties are heading. Is either party interested in winning them over?
Campaign Like a Centrist, Govern Like a Partisan
One key factor in
Trump won 206 counties that had supported Obama in 2008 and 2012, which were heavily concentrated in the Midwestern states that propelled him to an
"I think
Trump pledged allegiance to conservatives on issues like abortion, gun rights and federal judges, and he has taken a hard line on immigration. But he broke with Republican orthodoxy on issues like trade and foreign intervention, while promising to protect entitlement programs and casting himself as a stronger defender of LGBT rights than Clinton.
"On some levels, he was the least ideologically conservative candidate in 2016 on the Republican side," says
It's easy to forget that Trump campaigned as something of a centrist because he has governed as a staunch conservative. In contrast with his campaign stances, he has supported deep cuts to Medicaid funding and ordered a ban on transgender people serving in the military, while promoting tax cuts and abortion restrictions.
On Trump's watch, the remaining moderate
Having won by seizing part of the center, Trump has governed by appealing almost strictly to his base. Will Democrats claim the political space he's left vacant?
Democrats Move Further Left
The
Such proposals may excite the party's progressive wing, but they threaten to put off moderate voters who would otherwise be willing to vote against Trump.
"When I said I'm Never Trump, I mean 'Never,' and will vote for anyone who isn't Trump,"
Democrats scored most of their gains at the congressional and legislative levels last fall in affluent suburbs. Sizable numbers of Republican voters -- particularly women -- who had held their nose and voted for Trump over Clinton in 2016 expressed their dissatisfaction with the president by breaking with his party in the midterms. According to the
There is now a liberal consensus within the Democratic Party on social issues such as LGBT rights, immigration, marijuana legalization and same-sex marriage, says
He notes that during last year's campaign, Democratic candidates in targeted House races often ran ads on health care, but they raised issues such as affordability, preexisting conditions and Medicare.
"Just two ads, total, talked about single-payer health care," Pougiales says. "Both those Democrats ended up losing."
Still, the party's large and wide-open presidential contest thus far has been a contest to see who can move farthest to the left. That may change, but for now progressives appear to be convinced of the correctness and popularity of their positions, spurning any candidate who veers toward the center or hints at cooperating with the other party.
Progressives nowadays like to deride moderates as wanting only "some" global warming or offering health care to most but not all Americans. The traditional way of finding the center -- working out compromises with political opponents -- has become politically radioactive.
"The problem is that we continue to be in a situation where legislators are concerned that if they're viewed as working with the other side, they're going to lose in their primaries," says Bond, the Common Ground Committee CEO.
Voting on Identity, Not Issues
Progressives are convinced that no matter who the Democratic nominee ends up being or what positions she or he may take, Trump will deride that candidate as a socialist.
That is likely correct. But it's possible to be progressive on many issues while signaling to voters a willingness to seek the center when appropriate. The new Democratic governors of
"The Democrat who can win is progressive but can show a pragmatic side," says
"With Democrats embracing neo-socialist policies to eliminate private health insurance and fossil fuels, America's political center is up for grabs,"
That assumes that Trump will spend the campaign curbing his usual instincts to appeal to his base and demonize his enemies -- something he's shown little discipline for during his presidency.
Support for the parties is now split not just on ideological lines but by all manner of demographic factors, such as race, gender, geography and church attendance.
"If you're in a rural or small-town area and you're white, at this point you're a Republican," says Kabaservice, "and if you're in a city and you went to college, you're a Democrat."
American politics has largely become a contest of "us vs. them." Firing people up has become less a business of defining who "we" are and more about making certain that a majority of voters find "them" completely unacceptable. During next year's general election, candidates may seek to find persuadable voters, but they'll spend more time making sure their most likely voters are terrified at the prospect of four years of "them."
With Trump on the ballot, partisan polarization of a type that's been familiar now through four presidencies will continue.
"In a traditional election, it's about the middle," Democratic strategist
This story has been updated. It appears in the Politics newsletter. Subscribe for free.
___
(c)2019 Governing
Visit Governing at www.governing.com
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
Rep. Sherrill Opposes Reckless Move to Tear Down Affordable Care Act
Advisor News
Annuity News
Health/Employee Benefits News
Life Insurance News