CTA fires operator of train that struck and killed woman retrieving phone, says in-cab video shows ‘failure to devote attention to duty’

SouthtownStar, The (Tinley Park, IL)

Jul. 26--The CTA has fired the operator of a train that struck and killed a woman who climbed down on the tracks last month to retrieve her phone.

The operator was looking away from the tracks ahead of him for about 12 seconds before the June incident at the 69th Street Red Line stop, according to a video recording taken inside the train cab and provided by the CTA in response to a Freedom of Information Act request.

In the video, the operator is seen laughing and appears to be pointing at someone or something outside the train side window. He then abruptly stands and exits the cab.

Felon N. Smith, 37, of the 6600 block of South Maplewood Avenue, was pronounced dead shortly after the incident, which happened on the afternoon of June 27.

"The employee's behavior is unacceptable and in violation of CTA's policy and procedures," CTA spokesman Brian Steele said. The employee was fired last week for "failure to devote attention to duty and ensuring safe train operations," Steele said.

The CTA did not identify the employee, who had been a rail operator since 2006 and had no previous safety violations. Steele said that operators are supposed to be focused on the track ahead.

Steele said it is impossible to say if the operator could have stopped the train on time if he had been paying attention.

"There are myriad factors that contributed to this incident," Steele said. "It's impossible to answer that question."

Steele noted that trains do not have the ability to make immediate stops because of their momentum. A single 5000-series ?L" car weighs 55,000 pounds or 27.5 tons, so an eight-car train would weigh 220 tons.

A video posted on social media early this month shows Smith standing on the northbound side of the platform before she climbs down to pick up an object that authorities later identified as a dropped cellphone. As Smith climbs down, a security officer with a dog emerges from behind another part of the platform, then slowly begins to walk toward Smith in the six seconds it takes her to climb down to the tracks.

Steele said the guard spoke to Smith, who begins to move briskly up the tracks and past the guard as he stands on the platform with the dog. The video shows Smith heading in the direction of the train, moving toward a point where the platform ends, when she was struck.

Steele said the guard, an employee of AGB K-9 Security, Inc., followed protocol in calling out to the woman and promptly notified CTA after the train struck her. Steele said that because of the noise levels at the station, which runs on the median of the Dan Ryan Expressway, the guard and other customers were not immediately aware of the imminent danger of the approaching train.

The guard went on medical leave after the incident. Steele said he has not returned to work on CTA property since the incident.

Smith's sister, Brandy Martin, told the Tribune that Smith had been returning from downtown carrying food for herself and her three children when she received a call that she'd passed training for a job as an insurance broker. So Smith decided to reverse course, got off the southbound train and, while waiting for the northbound train, was speaking with her children on the phone when it dropped.

Steele said that all rail operators have to go through refresher training, and an incident like this will be used to remind operators to stay focused on the right-of-way.

"We take instances like this very seriously ..." said Steele. "The actions depicted in this video do not reflect the overwhelming majority of the men and women who operate CTA trains."

Joe Mahr contributed.

mwisniewski@chicagotribune.com

___

Visit The Daily Southtown (Tinley Park, Ill.) at www.chicagotribune.com/suburbs/daily-southtown

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.