Appeals court vacates sentences in unemployment fraud case
The court sent their cases back to U.S. District Judge
The Khans pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit mail fraud for devising and participating in a fictitious wage scheme to defraud the
Federal prosecutors said
"This is one of the longest-running, most sophisticated fraud schemes that I have ever seen," England said in sentencing
In its decision, the court said England failed to allow the Khans to object to the estimates of losses attributed to them in their presentence reports.
"The district court here made no factual findings on the Khans' objections regarding the loss amounts. The (presentence reports) estimated an actual loss of
England "summarily overruled those objections and adopted the estimated loss amounts set forth in the PSRs without making any specific factual finding on the Khans' objections. A district court may not simply rely on the factual statements in a (presentence report) when a defendant objects to those facts," the appeals court said in its decision last month.
England "clearly erred" when he "accepted the estimates of the loss amounts set forth in the (presentence reports) to apply a 20-level enhancement to their sentences ... for a loss exceeding
The enhancement "for loss amount unquestionably had a material impact on the Khans' sentences. Indeed, it was the most significant factor in the calculation of their offense levels under the sentencing guidelines," the appeals court said.
According to the opinion, there was "no explanation or analysis of how those estimates were calculated, what proportion of those estimates were attributable to legitimate payments made by EDD for legitimate benefits claims and why those payments were included in the estimates" provided to England.
The omission was "particularly problematic," the appeals court said, especially when as much as 30 percent of the EDD payments went to "legitimate claimants."
The appeals court said it was "left guessing as to the explanation or analysis supporting the loss amounts."
___
(c)2017 the Appeal-Democrat (Marysville, Calif.)
Visit the Appeal-Democrat (Marysville, Calif.) at www.appeal-democrat.com
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
Lying to an Auto Insurance Agent Has Serious Consequences
Campaign finance reports put Pantelides, Astle on top
Advisor News
Annuity News
Health/Employee Benefits News
Life Insurance News