NAIC adopts credit rating agency framework despite industry concerns
State insurance regulators took a big step toward oversight of credit ratings agencies Wednesday with a working group adoption of a framework document.
The vote by the Credit Rating Provider Working Group drew support from several industry groups but criticism over its legal authority and potential impact on competition. The meeting took place at the National Association of Insurance Commissioners' fall meeting in Dallas.
The framework establishes a structured process for assessing credit rating providers, including nationally recognized statistical rating organizations, whose ratings are used to produce NAIC designations for securities held by insurers.
According to the law firm Mayer Brown, the NAIC adopted a “filing-exempt” system in 2004. That change means any security with a rating assigned by an NAIC-recognized CRP will generally receive the NAIC designation equivalent to that CRP rating.
“In 2024, more than 152,000 securities received their NAIC designations based on their CRP ratings,” Mayer Brown wrote in a recent insight.
The framework divides corrective action of CRPs into Tier 1 and Tier 2 categories, Mayer Brown explained. Corrective actions range from enhanced monitoring to removal of filing-exempt status for an asset class.
Regulators: Just a guide
The NAIC said the framework is only intended to help regulators determine whether credit ratings are appropriate for regulatory purposes. It does not give the organization authority to dictate how rating agencies develop their methodologies or govern their businesses.
The revised draft incorporated several industry recommendations, including clarification that remediation actions generally would apply prospectively and would not require insurers to revise previously filed statutory financial statements or risk-based capital calculations.
“I kind of look at this framework as more like the Constitution,” said Jake Garn, director of financial regulation and licensing Utah Insurance Department. “It's a broad framework, and individual circumstances, specific points can definitely be worked through and with open communication lines, with both NAIC staff and with members of the working group.”
However, regulators retain discretion to require revisions when necessary for their own regulatory purposes, potentially in extraordinary circumstances involving fraud or gross misconduct.
Other recommendations were not adopted. The working group declined to change its three-notch threshold for identifying material differences among credit ratings, agreeing that the threshold was intended to be consistent with an existing NAIC discretion process.
Regulators also rejected suggestions that they rely more heavily on the Securities and Exchange Commission's oversight of rating agencies. The SEC focuses on transparency and the consistent development and implementation of rating methodologies, while the NAIC's assessment goes further by examining whether ratings are suitable for insurance regulatory purposes.
Working group members emphasized that state regulators are users of credit ratings, not regulators of the rating agencies themselves.
“If our decision were to lead to CRPs to alter methodologies, that would be an issue for the SEC and not the NAIC,” Garn said.
'Flexibility is important'
The American Council of Life Insurers backed the revised framework, praising regulators for responding to industry concerns. Adam Knepp is the senior director of accounting policy for ACLI.
He highlighted provisions allowing insurers to request extensions when practical constraints prevent completion of remediation within the standard 120-day period.
“We think that flexibility is important, particularly where a remediation action could affect a significant number of securities and obtaining alternative ratings or [Securities Valuation Office] designations may take additional time,” Knepp added.
The Pinpoint Policy Institute urged regulators to delay adoption and expose the framework for another 60 days, arguing that portions of the proposal could exceed the NAIC's legal authority.
Eric Ventimiglia, executive director of PPI, said the Securities Exchange Act restricts the SEC and states from regulating the substance of credit ratings or the procedures and methodologies used to determine them.
He argued that the framework's provisions for independently analyzing sampled securities, reviewing rating agency methodologies and addressing persistent inconsistencies could cross that boundary.
The framework's emphasis on identifying differences among rating agencies could discourage methodological diversity and favor certain approaches to credit analysis, Ventimiglia said.
“Calling the NAIC a consumer doesn't change what that does to how CRPs build models,” he said. “We aren't saying every review is barred. We're saying no legal analysis has been published showing where the line sits.”
Ventimiglia recommended that regulators obtain an independent legal analysis before proceeding.
Ratings agencies weigh in
Representatives from S&P Global Ratings and Kroll Bond Rating Agency acknowledged improvements but urged regulators to preserve analytical diversity and ensure implementation remains proportionate and risk-based.
Jim Wiemken, global head of rating services for S&P Global Ratings, said different rating methodologies can capture the same credit risk through different analytical approaches.
“Credit worthiness expressed in our ratings is multifaceted and encompasses not only likelihood of defaults but also credit stability, as well as the prospect of recovery following a default,” he explained.
Garn said regulators would continue to refine the framework as they gain experience implementing it and as investment markets, products and risk assessments evolve.
© Entire contents copyright 2026 by InsuranceNewsNet.com Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this article may be reprinted without the expressed written consent from InsuranceNewsNet.com.
InsuranceNewsNet Senior Editor John Hilton has covered business and other beats in more than 20 years of daily journalism. John may be reached at john.hilton@innfeedback.com. Follow him on Twitter @INNJohnH.



Insurance’s AI ‘black box’: Can auditors trust the results?
Advisor News
- The Gen Z money paradox
- NAIFA applauds final SECURE 2.0 regulations
- What will Democrats in Congress do about healthcare and retirement?
- Election results cloud retirement legislation outlook, experts say
- Planning for the missing chapter
More Advisor NewsAnnuity News
- Best’s Market Segment Report: AM Best Maintains Stable Outlook on US Life/Annuity Insurance Segment
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company and Its Subsidiaries
- Boomers want retirement protection, but their actions don’t match their mindset
- NAIC task force to address LTC riders
- ‘It’s really shocking:’ Regulators scrutinize assets backing annuity sellers
More Annuity NewsHealth/Employee Benefits News
- New York Life Announces Record $3.1 Billion in Policy Owner Dividends for 2027
- New Va. subsidies help lure people back to health insurance
- 3 ways Crowley can make Healthcare more affordable in Wisconsin
3 ways to make healthcare more affordable in Wisconsin | Coleman Drake (Copy)
- Vermont public schools expect the lowest health insurance increase in years. For districts, it’s only a small relief.
- Vt. public schools expect the lowest health insurance increase in years
More Health/Employee Benefits NewsLife Insurance News
- Nebraska widow’s big win against life insurer in legal limbo
- New York Life Announces Record $3.1 Billion in Policy Owner Dividends for 2027
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company and Its Subsidiaries
- U-Haul Holding Company to Participate in Deutsche Bank Conference
- NAIC task force to address LTC riders
More Life Insurance News