Senate Finance Committee Issues Testimony From Families USA Executive Director Isasi
* * *
Introduction
Chairman Wyden, Ranking Member Crapo, members of the Committee, thank you for the opportunity to testify today. My name is
It is an honor to be with you this morning. Thanks to extraordinary leadership by members of this Committee, as well as your colleagues elsewhere in government, American families have experienced major gains in health coverage during the past decade. But as we all know, our work is not yet done. On behalf of
Recent History of
As the 21st century dawned, the state of American health insurance was increasingly grim, with the number of people who had no health coverage steadily rising, year after year./1
America's leaders finally turned the tide in 2010 by passing the Affordable Care Act. From 2010 through 2016, 20 million people gained health insurance,/2 many for the first time in their lives.
To be sure, the individual market still had problems after passage of the ACA, with too many people charged premiums and deductibles they couldn't afford. But the ACA took a terrible individual market and made it much, much better. For example, national surveys taken both before and after the law took full effect showed that people buying their own insurance experienced dramatic overall improvements:/3
* Before the ACA, 60% of consumers trying to buy insurance in the individual market reported that it was "very difficult or impossible to find affordable insurance." The ACA cut that proportion to 34%.
* More than two out of five (43%) consumers trying to buy individual insurance before the ACA said that it was "very difficult or impossible to find the coverage they needed." After the ACA, just one in four (25%) experienced this problem.
* Altogether, just 46% of those who tried to buy individual coverage before the ACA wound up actually purchasing insurance. By contrast, two-thirds (66%) of people exploring the ACA's individual market bought coverage.
The ACA also prohibited insurance companies from discriminating against people with preexisting conditions; guaranteed essential preventive care, free from copayments and deductibles, to hundreds of millions of Americans who get health care on the job; and slashed prescription drug costs for millions of senior citizens as the infamous Medicare "prescription drug donut hole" shrank, then closed. Put simply, the Affordable Care Act provided the greatest advance in American health coverage since
Starting in 2017, however, health coverage in America changed course.
promoted the sale of so-called "junk" insurance plans that let insurance companies discriminate against people with preexisting conditions. The number of people without health insurance once again began rising, growing from 27 million in 2016 to nearly 30 million in 2019./4
In a particularly shocking development, the number of children without any health insurance whatsoever rose for the first time since
These insurance losses proved still more tragic in 2020, when the worst pandemic of deadly disease in more than a century and the steepest economic drop since the 1929 stock market crash devastated our country. As millions of workers lost their jobs, the number of people receiving health coverage from their employers fell by nearly 6 million -- one of the largest losses in history./6
The fallout would have been far worse, but thanks to Medicaid and health insurance marketplaces, 70% of people who lost employer-sponsored insurance were able to obtain other forms of coverage./7
All told, the number of uninsured still rose by 1.8 million people in 2020. Notably, the only statistically significant increases in the number of uninsured people reported by the
Many of us weathered the storm, but many did not; this signals that our work to secure affordable and equitable health care is far from complete. Earlier this year, the members of this Committee and other national leaders once again stepped forward to protect the American people. By passing the American Rescue Plan, you made health care substantially more affordable for people who buy their own insurance. You guaranteed that, through the end of 2022, no one in America will be forced to pay more than 8.5% of their income for benchmark private insurance./9
At the same time, you dramatically lowered premiums charged to millions of hard-working families who buy their own insurance, unable to get health care on the job.
Almost before the ink was dry from
Average premium costs dropped by 50%, as nearly half of families coming to the federal marketplace were charged
The median deductible for families new to the federal marketplace fell by 90%, from
Think about the impact on a family of four making
That's enormous progress.
And behind every one of these numbers is a real person's story:
*
*
*
Your hard work earlier this year has already paid off for Kristen and Sheryl and April and millions of other struggling families. In 2010,
Building Back Better
Build Back Better legislation gives America's leaders an opportunity to finish the job we started in 2010, to finally make sure that everyone in this country is guaranteed access to affordable, high-quality health care. If you act boldly and decisively in the coming weeks, you can provide real relief to so many people in America who are currently forced to choose between feeding their family and filling their prescription.
But the focus of today's hearing is Medicaid and marketplace coverage. I'm therefore going to center my remaining remarks on two proposals: guaranteeing essential health care to low-income adults who are uninsured because of their states' stubborn refusal to provide Medicaid to their poorest residents; and ensuring that the American Rescue Plan's dramatic improvements to the affordability of private insurance won't be taken away from the millions of families who now rely on them.
Closing the Medicaid Coverage Gap
The Medicaid program is a cornerstone of American health care. It covers nearly half of all births and, together with the
It is the country's largest source of funding for substance use treatment and prevention, covering almost 40% of adults suffering from opioid use disorders./15
Medicaid is America's leading source of coverage for long-term services and supports, serving six out of every ten nursing home residents./16
And after controlling for socioeconomic factors, low-income families often have better access to care and more financial protection in Medicaid than in private coverage, at a cost that is 10% lower for children and 25% lower for adults./17
The Affordable Care Act built on that record of accomplishment, extending Medicaid coverage to adults with incomes up to 138% of the federal poverty level, with very generous federal financial support. In more than three out of every four American states, governors and state legislators from both parties have gratefully taken advantage of federal financial incentives to implement this extension--and for good reason. An impressive research base now confirms that Medicaid expansion saves lives, protects people from cancer and other serious diseases, helps combat the scourge of addiction, prevents bankruptcy, saves money for state budgets, boosts employment, and keeps the doors open in rural hospitals./18
And there is no clearer example of the whole community's need for health coverage than the COVID-19 pandemic: newly infected people without insurance delay seeking care because of cost, which lets the virus spread, undetected and untreated. Based on peer-reviewed literature, insurance gaps in
Truly, in places where many of us are uninsured, all of us are at risk.
More than two million adults in this country are currently uninsured because they have the misfortune of being poor while living in one of the dozen states that stubbornly refuse to extend Medicaid coverage to their lowest-income residents. In these states, parents cannot get Medicaid unless they have extremely low incomes. In
And adults who are neither pregnant nor caring for dependent children are flatly ineligible for health care, no matter how low their income and how severe their need. This cruel exclusion denies health care to desperately poor people who are homeless, who have been diagnosed with a life-threatening illness, or are struggling with severe and untreated mental health or substance use disorders. It makes no sense to say that those who need help the most receive the least, but that is exactly what happens in coverage-gap states.
Many of us believe that public benefits should support rather than undermine work. But if that
This is not a hypothetical concern. Consider the stories of Della and Wendy.
'Wendy is a restaurant manager from
'That let her go to the doctor, who diagnosed Wendy as having a thyroid condition. The doctor quickly prescribed medication to keep it managed. As a result, she's healthier, feeling better, and losing weight. There is no telling how her health would have degenerated without Medicaid - quality coverage which she never believed was possible for her.
'Just 500 miles away from Wendy, Della is a kidney transplant recipient living in
'
In America, your health and financial self-sufficiency should not vary by zip code. Both Della and Wendy should be able to find the quality, affordable coverage they need to remain healthy and thrive, but Della is still stuck in the Medicaid coverage gap.
And make no mistake: people of every race and ethnicity have their lives and economic security endangered by their states' refusal to offer them Medicaid. But families of color are in particular danger. Compared to white adults in non-expansion states, Black adults are 46% more likely and Latinos more than twice as likely to lack insurance because they fall into the coverage gap./23
Put simply, anyone who believes in health equity must also be committed to closing the Medicaid coverage gap.
Making Health Care Affordable for People who buy their
The American Rescue Plan fixed one of the biggest remaining holes in America's health insurance system: unaffordable costs that prevent people from buying insurance when they don't get health benefits on the job. Before that plan took effect, almost 75% of uninsured families said they lacked health care because they could not afford insurance./24
As I noted earlier, the American Rescue Plan cut families' average premium costs by 50% in the health insurance marketplace and lowered median deductibles by 90%./25
The American people showed how much this improved their ability to afford health care for their families: During the COVID-19 special enrollment period that ended on
People of all races and ethnicities need affordable health care, but working-class people in communities of color have a particularly large stake in making sure that American Rescue Plan's affordability assistance remains in place. Based on the most recent available
By keeping affordability assistance in 2023 and beyond, you will be doing more than helping millions of families obtain affordable health care, vital though that goal is. You will also give peace of mind to nearly 170 million people who get health coverage on the job./28
In America, if you lose your job, your family can lose its health insurance. By making it truly affordable for people to buy their own insurance, Build Back Better legislation can guarantee that a pink slip will no longer take away health insurance. As a result, parents will no longer spend sleepless nights worrying that, if they lose their job, they might not be able to take their sick child to the doctor, or may be forced to choose between paying the utility bills and paying for Dad's blood-pressure medicine that he needs to prevent another heart attack.
American entrepreneurship will also receive a much-needed boost. Instead of forcing people to stay in dead-end jobs just to keep their insurance, people can finally start that business they've always dreamed of, knowing that, if they go out on their own, they are guaranteed the ability to buy affordable health care. From 1978 through 2010, new business formation in America plummeted, falling from more than 15% of all companies to just 9%./29
Since 2010 that number has stabilized, but now it's time to reverse the trend and galvanize the creation of new American businesses. One crucial step towards that end is making the American Rescue Plan's affordability improvements permanent. That will help people start their own companies by guaranteeing that, after they go out on their own, entrepreneurs will still able to get affordable health insurance for themselves and their families.
Now is the Time for Action
We face tremendous challenges as a country, but we also have an extraordinary chance to learn from the mistakes of the past and make an historic investment in our collective health and economic recovery. Improving access to affordable health care for every family in America is a cornerstone of that opportunity, and I urge every single member of this Committee, and all of your colleagues in
* * *
Footnotes:
1
2
3
4
5 For estimates from 1997 through 2015, see
6 From 2019 to 2020, the number of people with employer-sponsored insurance fell by 5.8 million, according to
7
8 Keisler-Starkey and Bunch. Health Insurance Coverage in
9 American Rescue Plan Act of 2021, P.L. 117-2,
10
11 CMS. 2021 Final Marketplace Special Enrollment Period Report.
12 CMS. 2021 Final Marketplace Special Enrollment Period Report.
13 Before the ARP, a family of four at 175% of the federal poverty level (FPL) purchasing coverage with premiums at national average levels would have had to pay
14
15
16 Kaiser Family foundation. Medicaid's Role in
17
18
19
20
21
22
23 Analysis of Figure 3, results for adults ages 19-64, in
24 The second most common reason given in response to the survey, ineligibility for coverage, was cited by only 25% of uninsured families. Survey respondents could give more than one explanation for lacking insurance.
26 By the end of the Special Enrollment period, 8.0 million people previously receiving marketplace coverage were joined by an additional 2.8 million new members, representing a 35% increase. CMS. 2021 Final Marketplace Special Enrollment Period Report.
27 In 2019, the most recent year for which data are available, among citizens and lawfully present immigrants age 19-64, 10.0% of whites qualified for premium tax credits, including both those who enrolled in individual-market coverage and those who were uninsured despite qualifying for assistance. Among adults of color, 14.5% were eligible for premium tax credits and either uninsured or enrolled in individual-market plans, including 16.4% of Indigenous adults, 15.4% of
28
29



Ping An Reports Steady Growth of 9.2% in Operating Profit Attributable to Shareholders of Parent Company in 9M 2021
Potential legal woes mount after 'Rust' shooting tragedy
Advisor News
- Addressing the ‘menopause tax:’ A guide for advisors with female clients
- Alternative investments in 401(k)s: What advisors must know
- The modern advisor: Merging income, insurance, and investments
- Financial shocks, caregiving gaps and inflation pressures persist
- Americans unprepared for increased longevity
More Advisor NewsAnnuity News
- Globe Life Inc. (NYSE: GL) Making Surprising Moves in Monday Session
- Aspida Life and WealthVest Offer a Powerful New Guaranteed Income Product with the WealthLock® Income Builder
- Lack of digital tools drives wedge between insurers, advisors
- LIMRA: Annuity sales notch 10th consecutive $100B+ quarter
- AIG to sell remaining shares in Corebridge Financial
More Annuity NewsHealth/Employee Benefits News
- Studies from Denise Wolff et al Have Provided New Data on Atopic Dermatitis (AMCP Market Insights: Beyond skin deep on the role of managed care in moderate to severe atopic dermatitis): Skin Diseases and Conditions – Atopic Dermatitis
- New Clinical Trials and Studies Findings from RAND Corporation Described (Benefit design and consumer information: results from a randomized trial): Clinical Research – Clinical Trials and Studies
- School, BOCES healthcare costs up 22%, here’s why
- Healthcare cuts threaten Sullivan's reelection chances in Alaska
- Health insurance marketplace feels growing tremors from GOP cuts
More Health/Employee Benefits NewsLife Insurance News
- Globe Life Inc. (NYSE: GL) Making Surprising Moves in Monday Session
- Dan Scholz to receive NAIFA’s Terry Headley Lifetime Defender Award
- Best’s Special Report: US Property/Casualty and Health Insurers Exceed Cost of Capital; Life Insurers Narrowly Miss
- Aspida Life and WealthVest Offer a Powerful New Guaranteed Income Product with the WealthLock® Income Builder
- Lack of digital tools drives wedge between insurers, advisors
More Life Insurance News