Senate Banking Subcommittee Issues Testimony From Committee for Responsible Federal Budget Policy Analyst Holt
* * *
The federal student loan program has gained increased attention as the size of the portfolio has grown from
In this testimony, I will make the following points:
* Despite its shortcomings, the federal student loan program, on average, represents a good investment for students.
* Blanket debt forgiveness does not have a high "bang-for-your-buck" in terms of stimulating the economy. While more targeted relief may be needed, it's a poor use of resources to cancel loans for everyone, especially highly educated students who are most likely to be high earners. There are much better ways to spend
* Blanket debt forgiveness would introduce a moral hazard that could encourage students to borrow more and reduce incentives for schools to contain costs.
* Reforms should be made with the objective in mind. If the goal is to help struggling borrowers, then give them targeted relief without giving a windfall to the wealthy. Those who are able to pay back the full amount should be expected to do so. If the goal is to help low-income students afford the cost of college, programs like Pell Grants are much better forms of direct assistance.
* Given the nation's unsustainable fiscal outlook, any student loan relief or changes to federal higher education financing should be offset either with savings from within the student loan program or elsewhere in the federal budget in the form of increased revenue, decreased spending, or some combination. It may be worthwhile to provide targeted loan relief, but that does not mean it is free.
The Role of Student Loans in Completion and Earnings
Despite its flaws, the federal student loan program is currently one of the country's primary tools for expanding access to higher education. While increased access to borrowing does tend to increase personal debt, it also leads to students taking more and harder classes, taking on fewer second jobs and less credit card debt while in school, completing college at higher rates, defaulting at lower rates, and increasing earnings./1
On average, the increase in lifetime earnings far exceeds the cost of the loan./2
While repaying loans can be burdensome, not having access to the loans in the first place would prevent many from pursuing and completing higher education. Proposals to make college free, even in their most expansive forms, are estimated to decrease borrowing by just 15 percent./3
Making undergraduate public colleges and universities tuition-free does not change the cost for those undergraduates attending private colleges (3.6 million in 2018) or graduate school (3 million in 2018)./4
Furthermore, many students attending "free" public colleges would still need to borrow to cover the cost of living while attending school full-time.
To be sure, there are problems with the federal student loan program. Because going to college doesn't always lead to higher earnings, owing a fixed monthly payment can be burdensome to many. Policymakers should find ways to alleviate some risks of borrowing to pay for education, either by reforming the loan program or finding a different financing mechanism altogether. But for many people, borrowing to pay for their education is the right decision in the long run, leading to a long-term increase in earnings that more than makes up for the short-term cost of paying off their loans.
Blanket Student Loan Forgiveness Would Do Little to Stimulate Economy
A common argument for blanket loan forgiveness is that it would be a form of economic stimulus. However, the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget estimated in November that canceling all federal student debt would have a fiscal multiplier between 0.08x and 0.23x, far lower than the major provisions contained in the various pandemic relief bills to date./5
For comparison, the
Fig. 1: Fiscal Multipliers of Student Loan Cancellation and CARES Relief. Source:
Figure omitted: https://www.banking.senate.gov/download/holt-testimony-4-13-21
Blanket student loan forgiveness is a relatively ineffective form of economic stimulus for a few reasons. First, forgiving all student debt would not suddenly unleash
Further, only 8 percent of all federal student loan dollars (10 percent of borrowers) are in active repayment right now given the
Fig. 2: Percentage of Student Loan Dollars in Repayment. Source:
Figure omitted: https://www.banking.senate.gov/download/holt-testimony-4-13-21
There would likely be a small additional boost in spending from people knowing they no longer have debt. However, this tendency - known as the "wealth effect" - would be unlikely to increase spending by more than
We expect that more tailored proposals to forgive
Second, blanket loan forgiveness is a poor way to target stimulus because it gives the most benefit to higher-income households and those with no trouble repaying their loans, even if the dollar amount of forgiveness is capped at
An additional dollar given to someone with a high income is much more likely to be saved and provide little economic boost to demand.
Before the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, over 70 percent of monthly student loan payments were paid by the top 40 percent of earners./10
The median weekly income of a full-time worker with a bachelor's degree is
Almost half of all outstanding federal student loan dollars were used to attend graduate school./12
Fig. 3: Share of Student Debt by
Figure omitted: https://www.banking.senate.gov/download/holt-testimony-4-13-21
Especially considering the uneven, "k-shaped" recovery from the early months of the pandemic, in which higher-educated workers were more likely to retain their jobs and workers with lower levels of education lost work or had their hours cut back, forgiving debt of those who fared better financially during this crisis is a particularly poor use of resources. More than 70 percent of currently unemployed workers do not have a bachelor's degree, including 43 percent who never attended college.
Blanket Debt Forgiveness Could Create a
Absent other reforms to higher education financing, blanket student debt forgiveness would likely result in increased borrowing and reduce incentives for schools to keep costs under control.
The people who would benefit from student debt forgiveness are those who have already taken out loans and have outstanding balances. If student debt were cancelled without other significant changes to the student loan system, a reasonable person might expect the moral case for blanket debt forgiveness to be just as strong next year as it is now. The expectation that
That same expectation would lead many borrowers to be less sensitive to tuition increases, which would alleviate pressure on schools to rein in costs, especially graduate schools where student loan amounts are not capped./13
This could create a vicious feedback loop where students borrow more, incentivizing schools to raise prices, which in turn forces students to borrow even more.
In the meantime, pressure would build on
Issues with the Current Federal Student Loan System
While federal student loans are still a good bet on average, there are significant problems within the portfolio. Before the pandemic, about half of the loans that ought to have been in repayment were not. That is to say, over 20 million borrowers who should have been making progress towards paying off their loans were instead delinquent, in forbearance or a hardship deferment, or were in default./14
The causes of this non-repayment are multifaceted, but for a large number of borrowers, their education investment did not pay off./15
Keep in mind, this non-repayment number does not include the additional 9 million borrowers enrolled in Income-Driven Repayment (IDR) plans, which now accounts for 34 percent of all dollars in the portfolio. 75 percent of borrowers in these plans are not paying enough to cover the interest owed each month, so their loan balances are increasing over time./16
There are several groups of people we should be concerned about in the current student loan program. The first are those who borrow to attend school and either do not earn a degree or do earn a degree but not a sufficient increase in income to justify the loan. Various forms of Income-Driven Repayment programs exist for these borrowers, all of which reduce a borrower's monthly payment to an amount that is considered affordable based on their income, even to the point of having a
However, the fact that over 9 million borrowers are currently in default shows that simply having these options available is not a cure-all. More can be done to target relief for struggling borrowers. Policymakers could also consider changes to loan availability for schools where a large group of students leave with high debt levels and no increase in income.
The next group of people that policymakers should be concerned about under the current system are parents. The original premise of the student loan program was that the increase in future income from a student's education would allow them to pay back the loan affordably over time, thus justifying taking out a loan in the first place. We don't run credit checks for student loans, because a backward-looking credit score doesn't reflect a student's future earnings potential. However, this same logic does not hold for parents, who experience no increase in income due to their child's education, and thus have no increased ability to pay back the loan after the child graduates. Thus, in the current system, the federal government increasingly acts as a subprime lender to low-income parents, saddling them with high levels of debt that they won't be able to pay back.
There is also concern related to the amount of student debt that Black households are taking on. A higher percentage of Black households hold student debt compared to white and Hispanic households, and the average amount of debt they hold is also higher./18
Research has also found that Black students with bachelor's degrees are more likely than their white counterparts to pursue graduate education. Black households have less wealth on average and are more likely to borrow for college than white households./19
The large gap in wealth between Black and white households in
Finally, much of the perceived student loan crisis is related to borrowing for graduate school. Graduate school loans now account for almost half of the federal student loan portfolio in terms of dollars./20
Graduate students can borrow an unlimited amount up to the cost of attendance, meaning unlike undergraduate loans which have set caps, whatever the school decides to charge determines how much a graduate student is allowed to borrow. The more generous version of IDR enacted in 2012 (and subsequent versions thereafter) represents a windfall for graduate students who accumulate high levels of debt, even after they begin earning high incomes./21
Fig. 4: Share of Student Loan Portfolio, by Total Outstanding Balance (4th Quarter 2020) Source:
Figure omitted: https://www.banking.senate.gov/download/holt-testimony-4-13-21
At this point, the IDR program is subsidizing high-debt graduate degrees. Borrowers with over
Fig. 5: Share of Loans in Income Driven Repayment, by Total Outstanding Balance (4th Quarter 2020) Source:
Figure omitted: https://www.banking.senate.gov/download/holt-testimony-4-13-21
One way to prevent students from amassing these eye-popping amounts of debt is to cap borrowing for graduate students. Uncapped borrowing for graduate school has only been in place since 2006 and is therefore a relatively new phenomenon. If lawmakers think the absence of firm caps on borrowing for graduate school leads to economic gains, then they should structure the IDR program so that graduates who earn high incomes pay back the full amount. If such high levels of debt are considered unconscionable and immoral, then lawmakers should cap graduate student borrowing.
While blanket forgiveness of student debt would be extremely wasteful, additional targeted relief may be necessary due to the variation in outcomes for those attending college. This feature is already reflected in the current IDR system, but more can be done to help struggling borrowers. The IDR system should be reformed and streamlined to be easier to use. Ballooning balances as a result of IDR payments that cover less than accruing interest may also be a significant impediment to enrolling more borrowers into IDR. A variety of proposals to address this issue have been put forward across ideological lines, and a more equitable IDR program could likely make some of these proposals budget neutral or even save money for the government. By ensuring that high-debt, high-income borrowers enrolled in IDR pay their fair share, the program could be restructured so that relief could be more quickly targeted towards borrowers whose loans do not lead to an expected increase in income. In addition, loans that are forgiven under the normal IDR process should not be taxed as normal income. Doing so essentially shifts a portion of a debt that is 20-25 years old from the
We Should Not Be Borrowing to Fix Student Loans
Policymakers authorized over
There are many worthwhile policies that policymakers should consider, including increasing targeted relief to struggling borrowers. But if a policy is worth doing, it's worth paying for. Paying for a policy helps it become permanent, decreasing uncertainty about future education policy and allowing students to plan for their future.
Blanket student debt forgiveness is not one of those worthwhile policies. It is unfair and unequitable, providing the highest benefit to high-income earners with graduate and professional degrees. Whether the goal is to stimulate the economy, stop the rise in the cost of college, close the racial wealth gap, help low-income families, or reduce reliance on borrowing student loans, blanket debt cancellation is an extremely expensive policy that offers very low or no returns to those policy goals. And not only does it not reduce the cost of education for future students, it may actually increase them. And it could cost up to
An economic relief package shouldn't forgive the loans of doctors and lawyers in the name of sending a small fraction of those dollars to struggling borrowers. Even
Each dollar our federal government spends reflects our priorities as a country, and not all of these policies are created equal. While the federal economic response to COVID-19 has thus far proven remarkably successful in many ways, lockdown policies and the virus itself disproportionately affected certain groups of Americans. Those with lower levels of educational attainment and lower earnings were far more likely to lose their jobs during the pandemic, while many with higher levels of education were able to keep their jobs and actually saw their savings increase. As a nation, our priorities should be continuing the economic recovery and ensuring whatever relief our government provides is targeted directly towards those struggling the most.
* * *
Footnotes:
1
2
3
4 "Digest of Education Statistics,"
5 "Canceling Student Loan Debt is Poor Economic Stimulus," Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget,
6
7 "Portfolio by Loan Status,"
8
9 For an exhaustive analysis of the redistributive effects of blanket student loan forgiveness, see
10
11
12 "The Volume and Repayment of Federal Student Loans: 1995 to 2017,"
13 After factoring out any other forms of financial aid, students enrolled in graduate school (as well as parents) can borrow up to the cost of attendance (tuition plus cost of living).
14
15 Borrowers who don't complete school make up a large share of defaulters, see:
16
17 Loans are forgiven after 10 years of payments in an IDR program while working for a full-time for a government or nonprofit employer. This is known as Public Service Loan Forgiveness.
18 Survey of Consumer Finances Interactive Chartbook, https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/scf/dataviz/scf/chart/.
19
20 CBO, "The Volume and Repayment of Federal Student Loans."
21
22


Rep. Deutch: U.S. Representatives Send Bipartisan Letter to Sec. Blinken on Ending Yemen Blockade
Advisor News
- Survey: Most Americans still feel prosperous despite economic worries
- SEC settlement would require Tai Lopez, two others, to pay $6.8 million
- The Gen Z money paradox
- NAIFA applauds final SECURE 2.0 regulations
- What will Democrats in Congress do about healthcare and retirement?
More Advisor NewsAnnuity News
- Best’s Market Segment Report: AM Best Maintains Stable Outlook on US Life/Annuity Insurance Segment
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company and Its Subsidiaries
- Boomers want retirement protection, but their actions don’t match their mindset
- NAIC task force to address LTC riders
- ‘It’s really shocking:’ Regulators scrutinize assets backing annuity sellers
More Annuity NewsHealth/Employee Benefits News
- States push short-term insurance as healthcare costs climb
- WYDEN, SANDERS, SENATE DEMOCRATS CALL OUT INSURANCE COMPANY COLLUSION WITH TRUMP ADMINISTRATION TO KICK THOUSANDS OF AMERICANS OFF HEALTH INSURANCE
- WYDEN STATEMENT ON FINANCE COMMITTEE DEMOCRATIC MAJORITY AGENDA
- Health insurance switch costs city
- New LTC solutions fill a critical gap for clients
More Health/Employee Benefits NewsLife Insurance News
- AM Best Downgrades Credit Ratings of CICA Life Insurance Company of America
- AM Best Upgrades Credit Ratings of CTBC Insurance Company Ltd
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of NongHyup Property and Casualty Insurance Company Limited
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Delphi Financial Group, Inc. and Its Subsidiaries; Upgrades Issuer Credit Rating of Standard Security Life Insurance Company of New York
- November Issue of Best’s Review Ranks US Life Reinsurers and More
More Life Insurance News