Federal Reserve independence secures an important, but not final, victory at US Supreme Court
The
In Trump v. Cook, the justices took up the case involving Trump’s decision to terminate
The high court also held that Trump didn’t meet the due process requirements for dismissing a board governor when he “fired” her via a social media post. Trump claimed Cook had committed mortgage fraud, even though she had not been found guilty of any wrongdoing.
As a scholar of employment law, I had expected the court to side with Cook to some degree. But other recent
Same court, different opinions
The court’s Cook decision and its constraints on presidential power stand in contrast to its rulings regarding other federal agencies. On the same day, the conservative majority sided with Trump when it ruled in Trump v. Slaughter that a “for cause” provision limiting his right to fire the head of the
In earlier rulings, the court similarly affirmed a president’s right to fire leadership at the
As I’ve previously written, it’s important to remember that a vast majority of
The same was true, however, at the
In Cook’s case, the government didn’t try to argue that the “cause” provision was unconstitutional. It waived that argument early on in the case. However, in upholding the lower court ruling in Cook, the court more or less assumed that the cause provision in the Federal Reserve Act is valid.
How to make sense of this contradiction?
As Justice
Justice
When facts matter as much as the law
It’s difficult to reconcile the two cases based on legal reasoning alone. That doesn’t necessarily make the outcome wrong. But it does suggest it’s important to consider other factors at play – namely, what’s happening out in the real world, beyond the courthouse. This interpretation of the law is known as “legal realism.”
Legal realism dates back to the 1930s, based on the commonsense critique that predictions about the law require some incorporation of the facts rather than purely abstract notions of legal rights.
Legal realism extends beyond the idea that a judge’s political ideology might influence outcomes, which is today a common basis for pundits to explain court decisions. Instead, legal realism acknowledges that facts on the ground sometimes matter more than the law.
Legal realism is useful here because there’s one overriding fact that makes Cook’s case distinct from the others involving presidential power over federal agencies. Simply put, the Fed is special. It preserves price stability and safeguards the economy as a whole over the long term by rescuing it in bad times and preventing it from overheating in good times. Former Fed Chair
But to do its job well, the Fed needs to be insulated from outside political forces. That’s why
The Fed’s unique role
In Cook, both the majority and concurring opinions frequently referred to the Fed’s vital role in the modern economy.
The majority opinion invoked “the Federal Reserve’s unique historical status and role” and warned of the economic “calamaties” that would come with “political manipulation of monetary policy.” And Roberts seemed to suggest that the Cook opinion is all the more important in light of the Slaughter ruling, noting the importance of leaving no public “doubt” as to the independence of “one of our Nation’s (and the world’s) most important financial institutions.”
Of the dissenters, only Justice
That is, at least by today’s standards, something like a consensus.


A major risk area every business owner should know about
Researchers from European Central Bank Report on Findings in Economics and Statistics (Consumption Response To Minimum Wages: Evidence From Chinese Households): Economics – Economics and Statistics
Advisor News
- The Gen Z money paradox
- NAIFA applauds final SECURE 2.0 regulations
- What will Democrats in Congress do about healthcare and retirement?
- Election results cloud retirement legislation outlook, experts say
- Planning for the missing chapter
More Advisor NewsAnnuity News
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company and Its Subsidiaries
- Boomers want retirement protection, but their actions don’t match their mindset
- NAIC task force to address LTC riders
- ‘It’s really shocking:’ Regulators scrutinize assets backing annuity sellers
- Jackson Launches Direct-to-Consumer Annuity Offering
More Annuity NewsHealth/Employee Benefits News
- Hays City Commission to consider bids for health insurance, sports complex improvements
- CHOICE arrangements: Not your father’s workplace health insurance
- Picking a Health Plan This Fall? Check the Addiction Treatment Benefits First
- A worthy subject for Rep. Neal's Ways and Means Committee | Letters to The Republican
- Forms, phone calls and portals: The hidden work that keeps American institutions functioning burdens parents most
More Health/Employee Benefits NewsLife Insurance News
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company and Its Subsidiaries
- U-Haul Holding Company to Participate in Deutsche Bank Conference
- NAIC task force to address LTC riders
- Protective names Kurt Meyers Chief Legal Officer and Fernando Levy Chief Digital & AI Officer
- Best’s Commentary: Shanghai Cross-Border Investment Pilot Unlocks Overseas Growth Potential of China Non-Life Companies
More Life Insurance News