EQUITABLE FINANCIAL LIFE INSURANCE CO – 10-Q – Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations
Management's discussion and analysis of financial condition and results of operations is presented pursuant to General Instruction (H)(2)(a) of Form 10-Q. The management's narrative that follows should be read in conjunction with the consolidated financial statements and the related Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements included elsewhere herein, with the information provided under "Note Regarding Forward-looking Statements and Information" included elsewhere herein and Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations ("MD&A") in Part II, Item 7 and "Risk Factors" in Part I, Item 1A included in Equitable Financial's Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year endedDecember 31, 2021 ("2021 Form 10-K"). The management's narrative that follows represents a discussion and analysis of Equitable Financial's financial condition and results of operations and not the financial condition and results of operations of Equitable Holdings, Inc. ("Holdings").
Executive Summary
Overview
We are one of America's leading financial services companies, providing advice and solutions for helping Americans set and meet their retirement goals and protect and transfer their wealth across generations. We operate as a single segment entity based on the manner in which we use financial information to evaluate business performance and to determine the allocation of resources. We benefit from our complementary mix of product offerings. This mix in product offerings provides diversity in our earnings sources, which helps offset fluctuations in market conditions and variability in business results, while offering growth opportunities.
EQUI-VEST Reinsurance Transaction
OnOctober 3, 2022 , Equitable Financial completed the transactions (the "EQUI-VEST Transaction") contemplated by the previously announced Master Transaction Agreement, datedAugust 16, 2022 , by and between Equitable Financial andFirst Allmerica Financial Life Insurance Company , aMassachusetts -domiciled insurance company (the "Reinsurer"), a wholly owned subsidiary ofGlobal Atlantic Financial Group . At the closing of the EQUI-VEST Transaction, Equitable Financial and the Reinsurer entered into a Coinsurance and Modified Coinsurance Agreement (the "EQUI-VEST Reinsurance Agreement"), pursuant to which Equitable Financial ceded to the Reinsurer, on a combined coinsurance and modified coinsurance basis, a 50% quota share of approximately 360,000 legacy Group EQUI-VEST deferred variable annuity contracts issued by Equitable Financial between 1980 and 2008 supported by general account assets of approximately$4 billion and$5 billion of separate account value (the "Reinsured Contracts"). The Reinsured Contracts predominately include certain of Equitable Financial's contracts that offer the highest guaranteed general account crediting rates of 3%. At the closing of the EQUI-VEST Transaction, Reinsurer deposited assets supporting the general account liabilities relating to the Reinsured Contracts into a trust account for the benefit of Equitable Financial, which assets will secure its obligations to Equitable Financial under the EQUI-VEST Reinsurance Agreement. Equitable Financial reinsured the separate accounts relating to the Reinsured Contracts on a modified coinsurance basis.Commonwealth Annuity and Life Insurance Company , an insurance company domiciled in theCommonwealth of Massachusetts and affiliate of Reinsurer ("Commonwealth"), provided a guarantee of Reinsurer's payment obligation to Equitable Financial under the EQUI-VEST Reinsurance Agreement. In addition, the investment of assets in the trust account is subject to investment guidelines, and the EQUI-VEST Reinsurance Agreement requires enhanced funding upon certain capital adequacy related triggers. The EQUI-VEST Reinsurance Agreement also contains additional counterparty risk management and mitigation provisions. At the closing of the EQUI-VEST Transaction,AllianceBernstein L.P. entered into an investment advisory agreement with Reinsurer pursuant to whichAllianceBernstein L.P. will serve as the preferred investment manager of certain general account assets transferred to the trust account. Equitable Financial will continue to administer the Reinsured Contracts.
Revenues
Our revenues come from three principal sources:
•fee income derived from our products;
•premiums from our traditional life insurance and annuity products; and
•investment income from our General Account investment portfolio.
Our fee income varies directly in relation to the amount of the underlying AV or benefit base of our life insurance and annuity products which are influenced by changes in economic conditions, primarily equity market returns, as well as net flows. 62 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents Our premium income is driven by the growth in new policies written and the persistency of our in-force policies, both of which are influenced by a combination of factors, including our efforts to attract and retain customers and market conditions that influence demand for our products. Our investment income is driven by the yield on our General Account investment portfolio and is impacted by the prevailing level of interest rates as we reinvest cash associated with maturing investments and net flows to the portfolio.
Benefits and Other Deductions
Our primary expenses are:
•policyholders' benefits and interest credited to policyholders' account
balances;
•sales commissions and compensation paid to intermediaries and advisors that
distribute our products and services; and
•compensation and benefits provided to our employees and other operating
expenses.
Policyholders' benefits are driven primarily by mortality, customer withdrawals and benefits which change in response to changes in capital market conditions. In addition, some of our policyholders' benefits are directly tied to the AV and benefit base of our variable annuity products. Interest credited to policyholders varies in relation to the amount of the underlying AV or benefit base. Sales commissions and compensation paid to intermediaries and advisors vary in relation to premium and fee income generated from these sources, whereas compensation and benefits to our employees are more constant and impacted by market wages and decline with increases in efficiency. Our ability to manage these expenses across various economic cycles and products is critical to the profitability of our company.
Net Income Volatility
We have offered and continue to offer variable annuity products with GMxB features. The future claims exposure on these features is sensitive to movements in the equity markets and interest rates. Accordingly, we have implemented hedging and reinsurance programs designed to mitigate the economic exposure to us from these features due to equity market and interest rate movements. Changes in the values of the derivatives associated with these programs due to equity market and interest rate movements are recognized in the periods in which they occur while corresponding changes in offsetting liabilities not measured at fair value, are recognized over time. This results in net income volatility as further described below. See "-Significant Factors Impacting Our Results-Impact of Hedging and GMxB Reinsurance on Results." In addition to our dynamic hedging strategy, we have static hedge positions designed to mitigate the adverse impact of changing market conditions on our statutory capital. We believe this program will continue to preserve the economic value of our variable annuity contracts and better protect our target variable annuity asset level. However, these static hedge positions increase the size of our derivative positions and may result in higher net income volatility on a period-over-period basis. An additional source of net income (loss) volatility is the impact of the Company's annual actuarial assumption review. See "-Significant Factors Impacting Our Results-Effect of Assumption Updates on Operating Results", for further detail of the impact of assumption updates on net income (loss) in first quarter 2022. COVID-19 Impact The COVID-19 pandemic is still evolving. We continue to closely monitor COVID-19 developments and the impact on our business, operations and investment portfolio. The future impact of the COVID-19 pandemic is dependent on many unknown factors and remains highly uncertain, including as to the emergence and spread of COVID-19 variants, the availability, adoption and efficacy of COVID-19 treatments and vaccines, and future actions taken by governmental authorities, central banks and other parties in response to COVID-19. As the COVID-19 pandemic has not yet subsided, it is not possible to predict or estimate the longer-term effects of the COVID-19 pandemic, on the economy and on our business, results of operations, and financial condition, including the impact on our investment portfolio or the need for us to revisit or revise targets previously provided to the markets and/or aspects of our business model. For additional information regarding the actual and potential impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic and action we have taken to mitigate certain impacts, see "Risk Factors-Risks Relating to Conditions in the Financial Markets and Economy-The coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic", "Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations-Executive Summary-COVID-19 Impact" and "Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations-General Account Investment Portfolio" in the 2021 Form 10-K.
Significant Factors Impacting Our Results
63 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents The following significant factors have impacted, and may in the future impact, our financial condition, results of operations or cash flows.
Impact of Hedging and GMxB Reinsurance on Results
We have offered and continue to offer variable annuity products with GMxB features. The future claims exposure on these features is sensitive to movements in the equity markets and interest rates. Accordingly, we have implemented hedging and reinsurance programs designed to mitigate the economic exposure to us from these features due to equity market and interest rate movements. These programs include: •Variable annuity hedging programs. We use a dynamic hedging program (within this program, generally, we reevaluate our economic exposure at least daily and rebalance our hedge positions accordingly) to mitigate certain risks associated with the GMxB features that are embedded in our liabilities for our variable annuity products. This program utilizes various derivative instruments that are managed in an effort to reduce the economic impact of unfavorable changes in GMxB features' exposures attributable to movements in the equity markets and interest rates. Although this program is designed to provide a measure of economic protection against the impact of adverse market conditions, it does not qualify for hedge accounting treatment. Accordingly, changes in value of the derivatives will be recognized in the period in which they occur with offsetting changes in reserves partially recognized in the current period, resulting in net income volatility. In addition to our dynamic hedging program, we have a hedging program using static hedge positions (derivative positions intended to be held-to-maturity with less frequent re-balancing) to protect our statutory capital against stress scenarios. This program in addition to our dynamic hedge program has increased the size of our derivative positions, resulting in an increase in net income volatility. •GMxB reinsurance contracts. Historically, GMIB reinsurance contracts were used to cede to affiliated and non-affiliated reinsurers a portion of our exposure to variable annuity products that offer a GMIB feature. We account for the GMIB reinsurance contracts as derivatives and report them at fair value. Gross GMIB reserves are calculated on the basis of assumptions related to projected benefits and related contract charges over the lives of the contracts. Accordingly, our gross reserves will not immediately reflect the offsetting impact on future claims exposure resulting from the same capital market or interest rate fluctuations that cause gains or losses on the fair value of the GMIB reinsurance contracts. Because changes in the fair value of the GMIB reinsurance contracts are recorded in the period in which they occur and a majority of the changes in gross reserves for GMIB are recognized over time, net income will be more volatile. In addition, onJune 1, 2021 , we ceded the Block, comprised of non-New York "Accumulator" policies containing fixed rate GMIB and/or GMDB guarantees. As this contract provides full risk transfer and thus has the same risk attributes as the underlying direct contracts, the benefits of this treaty are accounted for in the same manner as the underlying gross reserves.
Effect of Assumption Updates on Operating Results
Our actuaries oversee the valuation of the product liabilities and assets and review the underlying inputs and assumptions. We comprehensively review the actuarial assumptions underlying these valuations and update assumptions during the third quarter of each year. Assumptions are based on a combination of Company experience, industry experience, management actions and expert judgment and reflect our best estimate as of the date of the applicable financial statements. Changes in assumptions can result in a significant change to the carrying value of product liabilities and assets and, consequently, the impact could be material to earnings in the period of the change. Most of the variable annuity products, variable universal life insurance and universal life insurance products we offer maintain policyholder deposits that are reported as liabilities and classified within either Separate Accounts liabilities or policyholder account balances. Our products and riders also impact liabilities for future policyholder benefits and unearned revenues and assets for DAC and DSI. The valuation of these assets and liabilities (other than deposits) is based on differing accounting methods depending on the product, each of which requires numerous assumptions and considerable judgment. The accounting guidance applied in the valuation of these assets and liabilities includes, but is not limited to, the following: (i) traditional life insurance products for which assumptions are locked in at inception; (ii) universal life insurance and variable life insurance secondary guarantees for which benefit liabilities are determined by estimating the expected value of death benefits payable when the account balance is projected to be zero and recognizing those benefits ratably over the accumulation period based on total expected assessments; (iii) certain product guarantees for which benefit liabilities are accrued over the life of the contract in proportion to actual and future expected policy assessments; and (iv) certain product guarantees reported as embedded derivatives at fair value. 64 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents For further details of our accounting policies and related judgments pertaining to assumption updates, see Note 2 of the Notes to the Consolidated Financial Statements and "Summary of Critical Accounting Estimates-Liability for Future Policy Benefits included in the 2021 Form 10-K".
Assumption Updates
We conduct our annual review of our assumptions during the third quarter of each year. We also update our assumptions as needed in the event we become aware of economic conditions or events that could require a change in assumptions that we believe may have a significant impact to the carrying value of product liabilities and assets and consequently materially impact our earnings in the period of the change.
Impact of Assumption Updates on Income from Continuing Operations before income
taxes and Net income (loss)
The table below presents the impact of our actuarial assumption update during the three months endedSeptember 30, 2022 and 2021 to our income (loss) from continuing operations, before income taxes and net income (loss). Three Months Ended September 30, (1) 2022 2021 (in millions) Impact of assumption update on Net income (loss): Variable annuity product features related assumption update$ 156 $ (146) All other assumption updates (17) (16)
Impact of assumption updates on Income (loss) from
continuing operations, before income tax
139 (162) Income tax (expense) benefit on assumption update (29) 34 Net income (loss) impact of assumption update
_____________
(1)The amounts for the three months and the nine months ended
each year represented the same amounts.
2022 Assumption Updates
The impact of the assumption update in the third quarter 2022 was an increase of$139 million to income (loss) from continuing operations, before income taxes and an increase to net income (loss) of$110 million .
The net impact of this assumption update on income (loss) from continuing
operations, before income taxes of
policy charges and fee income of
benefits of
account balances of
million
2021 Assumption Updates
The impact of the assumption update in the third quarter 2021 was a decrease of$162 million to income (loss) from continuing operations, before income taxes and a decrease to net income (loss) of$128 million . As part of this annual update completed as ofSeptember 30, 2021 , the reference interest rate utilized in our GAAP fair value calculations was updated from the LIBOR swap curve to theUS Treasury curve, which represents a reasonable proxy of the cost of funding the derivative positions backing our GMxB liabilities. Concurrently, our GAAP fair value liability risk margins were increased. which when considered with the change from LIBOR, resulted in an immaterial impact to overall valuation as our view regarding market participant pricing of our guarantees has not changed at the time of this update.
The net impact of this assumption update on income (loss) from continuing
operations, before income taxes of
policy charges and fee income of
benefits of
a decrease in the amortization of DAC of
Macroeconomic and Industry Trends
Our business and consolidated results of operations are significantly affected by economic conditions and consumer confidence, conditions in the global capital markets and the interest rate environment. 65
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table of Contents
Financial and Economic Environment
A wide variety of factors continue to impact financial and economic conditions. These factors include, among others, increased volatility in the capital markets, equity markets declines, rising interest rates, inflationary pressures, plateauing or decreasing economic growth, high fuel and energy costs, changes in fiscal or monetary policy and geopolitical tensions. The invasion ofUkraine byRussia and the sanctions and other measures imposed in response to this conflict significantly increased the level of volatility in the financial markets and have increased the level of economic and political uncertainty. Stressed conditions, volatility and disruptions in the capital markets, particular markets, or financial asset classes can have an adverse effect on us, in part because we have a large investment portfolio. In addition, our insurance liabilities and derivatives are sensitive to changing market factors, including equity market performance and interest rates. During the third quarter 2022, equity markets continued their decline, while interest rates continued to rise, and are anticipated to continue to rise throughout the year based on statements of members of theBoard of Governors of theFederal Reserve System . An increase in market volatility could continue to affect our business, including through effects on the yields we earn on invested assets, changes in required reserves and capital and fluctuations in the value of our AUM and AV, from which we derive our fee income. These effects could be exacerbated by uncertainty about future fiscal policy, changes in tax policy, the scope of potential deregulation and levels of global trade. The potential for increased volatility, coupled with prevailing interest rates remaining below historical averages despite recent increases, could pressure sales and reduce demand for our products as consumers consider purchasing alternative products to meet their objectives. In addition, this environment could make it difficult to consistently develop products that are attractive to customers. Financial performance can be adversely affected by market volatility and equity market declines as fees driven by AV and AUM fluctuate, hedging costs increase and revenues decline due to reduced sales and increased outflows We monitor the behavior of our customers and other factors, including mortality rates, morbidity rates, annuitization rates and lapse and surrender rates, which change in response to changes in capital market conditions, to ensure that our products and solutions remain attractive and profitable. For additional information on our sensitivity to interest rates and capital market prices, see "Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market Risk".
Interest Rate Environment
We believe the interest rate environment will continue to impact our business
and financial performance in the future for several reasons, including the
following:
•Certain of our variable annuity and life insurance products pay guaranteed minimum interest crediting rates. We are required to pay these guaranteed minimum rates even if earnings on our investment portfolio decline, with the resulting investment margin compression negatively impacting earnings. In addition, we expect more policyholders to hold policies with comparatively high guaranteed rates longer (lower lapse rates) in a low interest rate environment. Conversely, a rise in average yield on our investment portfolio should positively impact earnings. Similarly, we expect policyholders would be less likely to hold policies with existing guaranteed rates (higher lapse rates) as interest rates rise. •A prolonged low interest rate environment also may subject us to increased hedging costs or an increase in the amount of statutory reserve required to hold for GMxB features, lowering statutory surplus, which would adversely affect the ability to pay dividends. In addition, it may also increase the perceived value of GMxB features to our policyholders, which in turn may lead to a higher rate of annuitization and higher persistency of those products over time. Finally, low interest rates may continue to cause an acceleration of DAC amortization or reserve increase due to loss recognition for interest-sensitive products.
For a discussion on derivatives we used to hedge interest rates, see Note 4 of
the Notes to the Consolidated Financial Statements in this Form 10-Q.
Regulatory Developments
We are regulated primarily by the NYDFS, with some policies and products also subject to federal regulation. On an ongoing basis, regulators refine capital requirements and introduce new reserving standards. Regulations recently adopted or currently under review can potentially impact our statutory reserve, capital requirements and profitability of the industry and 66 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents result in increased regulation and oversight for the industry. For additional information on the regulatory developments and risk we face, see "Business-Regulation" and "Risk Factors-Legal and Regulatory Risks" in the 2021 Form 10-K. Climate Risks. InMarch 2022 , theSEC released proposed rule changes on climate-related disclosure. The proposed rule changes would require companies to include certain climate-related disclosures including information about climate-related risks that have had or reasonably likely to have a material impact on their business, results of operations, or financial condition, and certain climate-related financial statement metrics in a note to the audited financial statements. Among other things, the required information about climate-related risks also would include disclosure of a company's greenhouse gas emissions, information about climate-related targets and goals, and if a transition plan, has been adopted as part of climate-related risk management strategy, and requires extensive attestation requirements. If adopted as proposed, the rule changes are expected to result in additional compliance and reporting costs. Privacy and Security of Customer Information and Cybersecurity Regulation. InMarch 2022 , theSEC released proposed rules enhancing cybersecurity risk and management disclosure requirements for companies. If enacted, the proposed rules would, among other things, require disclosure of any material cybersecurity incident on its Form 8-K within four business days of determining that the incident it has experienced is material. They would also require periodic disclosures of, among other things, (i) details on the company's cybersecurity policies and procedures, (ii) cybersecurity governance, oversight policies and risk management policies, including the board of directors' oversight of cybersecurity risks, (iii) the relevant expertise of members of the board of directors with respect to cybersecurity issues and (iv) details of any cybersecurity incident that was previously disclosed on Form 8-K, as well as any undisclosed incidents that were non-material, but have become material in the aggregate. InJuly 2022 , the NYDFS proposed amendments to the New York Cybersecurity Requirements for Financial Services Companies promulgated by the NYDFS inMarch 2017 . The amendments, if adopted, would require new reporting, governance and oversight measures to be implemented, enhance certain cybersecurity safeguards (e.g., annual audits, vulnerability assessments, and password controls and monitoring), and mandate notifications in the event that a covered entity makes a cyber-ransom payment. The pre-proposal comment period on these draft amendments ended inAugust 2022 , and an additional comment period is expected in the future. Fiduciary Rules / "Best Interest" Standards of Conduct. The NYDFS' amendments to Regulation 187 - Suitability and Best Interests in Life Insurance and Annuity Transactions ("Regulation 187") incorporate the "best interest" standard for annuity transactions and they expand the scope of the regulation to include sales of life insurance policies to consumers. InApril 2021 , the Appellate Division of theNew York Supreme Court overturned Regulation 187 for being unconstitutionally vague, although theNew York State Court of Appeals reversed this ruling onOctober 20, 2022 . We cannot predict whether any rules or rule amendments will be adopted by either theSEC or NYDFS, what form any such final rules may take, or what effect adoption of such rules or amendments would have on our business or compliance costs. 67
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table of Contents
Consolidated Results of Operations
Our consolidated results of operations are significantly affected by conditions in the capital markets and the economy because we offer market sensitive products. These products have been a significant driver of our results of operations. Because the future claims exposure on these products is sensitive to movements in the equity markets and interest rates, we have in place various hedging and reinsurance programs that are designed to mitigate the economic risk of movements in the equity markets and interest rates. The volatility in net income attributable to Equitable Financial for the periods presented below results from the mismatch between: (i) the change in carrying value of the reserves for GMDB and certain GMIB features that do not fully and immediately reflect the impact of equity and interest market fluctuations; (ii) the change in fair value of products with the GMIB feature that have a no-lapse guarantee; and (iii) our hedging and reinsurance programs.
The following table summarizes our consolidated statements of income (loss) for
the nine months ended
Georgia flood insurance prices may rise due to climate change
American Property Casualty Insurance Association: What is Driving the Affordability and Accessibility Challenges for Homeowners Insurance in High-Risk Western States
Advisor News
Annuity News
Health/Employee Benefits News
Life Insurance News