Home insurance market may be stabilizing, study finds

By Staff Reports

The home insurance market experienced significant shifts in 2024, showing early signs of stabilization after two years of steep premium hikes and coverage challenges, according to a recent report from Matic.

While premiums remain high, industry trends suggest a possible slowdown in growth, even as climate risks and regulatory challenges persist, according to the report. Here’s a look at the key developments from 2024 and what they mean for homeowners, insurers, and the broader market in 2025.

Rising premiums slow, challenges persist

The year began with record-breaking increases in home insurance premiums, with new policies seeing an average rise of 17.4%. By comparison, homeowners who had renewed their policies in 2024 after purchasing them in 2021 faced nearly 69% higher costs, amounting to an additional $865 annually. However, by mid-year, the rate of premium increases began to slow, with the average hike dropping from 10.7% in the first half to 6.6% in the second half.

“We’re seeing signs of improvement in the home insurance market , driven by a few key factors,” said Ben Madick, CEO and co-founder of Matic. “Inflation has started to slow, easing the pressure on repair and claims expenses. On top of that, many carriers received long-awaited approvals for rate increases, which has helped them align premiums with current costs and return to profitability.”

Looking ahead to 2025, premiums are expected to continue rising, albeit at a more controlled pace, as insurers benefit from easing inflationary pressures. However, the threat of severe weather events, especially in high-risk states, could still disrupt this trend.

Insurer market re-entry offers hope

Homeowners in 2024 faced significant difficulties securing coverage as insurers withdrew from high-risk regions or tightened underwriting standards. However, by mid-year, most major carriers returned to profitability, aided by regulatory approval for overdue rate adjustments and a slowdown in inflation-related repair costs.

By November, major national insurers such as Safeco, Travelers, and Nationwide had re-entered several restricted markets, increasing the availability of quotes per homeowner by 60% compared to the year's low point in March. The Excess and Surplus (E&S) market also stepped up to provide alternative coverage options in areas where traditional carriers remained scarce.

Despite this progress, challenges remain. Regulatory constraints in states like California and New Jersey could limit the ability of insurers to adjust rates, potentially affecting market stability in 2025.

Climate change continues to reshape the industry

The impact of climate change remains a defining challenge for the home insurance market. While 2024 saw a relatively quiet early hurricane season, later events, including Hurricanes Helene and Milton, resulted in an estimated $55 billion in losses. Rising wind and hail claims have prompted some insurers to modify policies, shifting roof coverage from replacement cost to actual cash value to mitigate expenses.

Flood risks are also expanding beyond coastal areas. Events like Hurricane Helene’s flooding of western North Carolina highlight the need for broader flood insurance education, even in regions historically considered low-risk. In 2025, the focus on flood insurance is expected to grow, with increased attention on the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) and private market alternatives.

Housing market, mortgage industry feel pressure

Despite the Federal Reserve’s recent interest rate cuts, mortgage rates remained above 6% in November 2024, adding to affordability challenges for homeowners. The Mortgage Bankers Association predicts a 28% increase in mortgage originations for 2025, signaling increased housing activity, but rising insurance costs continue to strain household budgets.

Elevated premiums have also impacted mortgage qualification, with 63% of lenders reporting challenges securing affordable home insurance for borrowers. In response, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, which back most U.S. mortgages, temporarily eased enforcement of certain insurance requirements, underscoring the need for more robust systems to protect both homeowners and lenders.

2025 outlook: Cautious optimism

The home insurance market is poised for cautious stabilization in 2025. Slower inflation, increased carrier re-entry, and expanded coverage options are promising signs. However, the industry remains vulnerable to severe weather events and regulatory decisions, which could drive further premium increases.

For homeowners, the year ahead will likely bring moderated rate hikes and more coverage options, but climate risks and economic pressures may continue to shape the market.