AI belongs on your organizational chart, and that’s a good thing

“So Mike, isn’t AI really just going to take our jobs?”

I had just finished delivering a keynote on how artificial intelligence can help independent insurance agents, and I could feel the excitement leave the room.

I could have chuckled and easily dismissed the idea, as so many others tend to do. But that would have been a betrayal of the hundreds of agencies in the audience.

Because here’s the truth.

AI absolutely is going to take portions of your jobs. In fact, I believe it should.

The most secure agents, the ones who are confident in their position and their results, are the heaviest AI users. They’re pointing AI at the robot work; the McKinsey Global Institute found that as much as 60% of the tasks that insurance sales agents perform could be automated.

What they aren’t doing is pointing AI at clients.

First, they’re using AI to research and compare plan options before they sit down with the client. Reams of documentation are reviewed in moments, with the agent verifying everything against the actual plans.

Second, before every call, all important information and life changes from the past year worth asking about are surfaced.

And after every call, AI assists with drafting recap letters and to-do lists, keeping agents on track while keeping them in the driver’s seat.

I confidently turned to the agent in the audience and replied that no AI can nurture relationships with your clients. That’s your job. You’re the one on the call or sitting at their kitchen table, helping them to understand your recommendation and walking them through enrollment.

Anything throughout the chain of enrollment stays human. That’s the part of your job that is not only safe but deserves to be protected and expanded.

But I understand why agents might wonder about the future of their roles.  Dr. Mehmet Oz, administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, publicly shared the idea of using AI as a decision-support and navigation tool for Medicare beneficiaries.

National Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors’ Carroll Golden told InsuranceNewsNet that AI has a place in the enrollment process, but won’t replace an advisor, and she’s right. Ronnell Nolan, Health Agents for America president and CEO, made it clear in her arguments to CMS that “a bot cannot replace agents and brokers.” In response, Alexander Aramanda, principal deputy director at CMS, said the agency is not “seeking to eliminate brokers or limit their ability to help people with Medicare.”

Reassuring? Absolutely. But reassurance is not a license to point AI anywhere you like.

For example, CMS retention rules define a “complete and accurate transcript” as the full record. An AI recap doesn't qualify as a compliance document.

Compliant adoption of AI starts with these four guardrails:

1. Write the policy. According to the Big "I" ACT 2026 Tech Trends Report, 55% of agencies have no written AI use policy. A single page is all that’s needed to start.
2. Never use personal AI accounts to review clients' protected health information.
3. Always review anything that your AI assistant produces that is client-facing.
4. Know your carrier and field marketing organization rules before deploying any client-adjacent AI solution.

Turning hours and hours of paperwork over to an AI employee hands those hours back for the one thing a bot cannot do: be present with your clients. Give AI a seat on your organizational chart, with a manager attached, and start delegating.

© Entire contents copyright 2026 by InsuranceNewsNet.com Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this article may be reprinted without the expressed written consent from InsuranceNewsNet.com.

Mike Allton is the founder of The AI Hat and creator of the AI Adoption Reality Check for insurance agencies and producers (theaihat.com/reality-check). Contact him at [email protected].