Uncovered: How Florida’s governor and CFO candidates plan to fix your property insurance
Property insurance has emerged as a leading issue in the runup to Florida’s November election.
As part of our Uncovered project exploring the impacts of the state’s 2022-23 insurance reforms, the
We asked what policyholders most want to know: How are you going to lower my insurance premiums? Can you get claims paid faster and fairer? And do you favor legislation requiring more transparency on insurers’ profits and practices?
The candidates outlined sharply different approaches to the issue, with distinctions particularly between
Of particular note are the contrasts at the top of the ticket between the candidates for governor, Republican
Donalds believes competition is already driving down rates, but says insurers must disclose more information about their business operations so Floridians understand what they’re buying.
Jolly is pushing to rethink the fundamentals of disaster protection for homeowners by shifting hurricane insurance to a state-controlled fund, with private companies handling more conventional coverage.
Here are the unedited responses to our questions:
Candidates for governor
Republican
What is your plan to lower property insurance premiums for Floridians?
Donalds: My Bring Down the Bill Plan builds on what’s working and goes after the costs still driving premiums up. First, we protect the 2022 and 2023 reforms that brought carriers back to
Jolly: Under David Jolly’s proposal, instead of forcing every
Does the insurance industry have too much power in
Donalds: No insurance company should have more power than the people paying the premiums. My job as governor is going to be to make sure Floridians have choices, carriers are held accountable, and families aren’t getting crushed by their insurance bills. For years,
Jolly: Floridians are living with higher costs because our insurance system is fundamentally broken. It’s created and protected by politicians who’ve been captured by special interests, including the insurance industry, through our corrupt campaign finance system. We allow undercapitalized firms to come into
In 2022 and 2023,
Donalds: The reforms are working, and I will not repeal them. Since they passed, 21 new insurance companies have entered
Jolly:
Should any pre-reform coverage limitations — such as limits on water or roof coverage and 1% matching limits — be rescinded?
Donalds: I do not support rescinding them across the board. Florida’s insurance market is finally recovering, and wiping out coverage options that regulators approved would put upward pressure on premiums just as rates are starting to come down. What I do support is transparency. Homeowners should understand any roof, water or matching limit before they buy a policy, not discover it after a storm. Every policy with one of these limits should explain it in plain language. The better long-term answer is stronger homes. My Bring Down the Bill Plan restructures mitigation grants around the projects that produce the biggest insurance savings, and roofs are the clearest example. A homeowner with a new, hardened roof is far less likely to face a costly claim in the first place.
Jolly: David Jolly’s model, moving to a state catastrophic fund that covers all the wind and storm perils for homes, would change the broken insurance system and make these limits no longer apply.
Should
Donalds: Yes. Floridians deserve to know their premiums are paying for coverage, not being drained through inflated fees to affiliated companies. A state-commissioned review found that some insurers’ affiliate fees were not fair and reasonable. That’s unacceptable.
Jolly:
What changes should
Donalds: Florida’s reforms already put insurers on a much tighter clock. Since 2023, companies have had to acknowledge a claim within 7 days instead of 14, inspect damage within 30 days instead of 45, including for hurricane claims, and pay or deny within 60 days instead of 90. Late payments accrue interest. As governor, I’ll make sure those deadlines mean something.
Jolly: The private market for hurricane insurance in
Insurers frequently invoke trade secret designations to shield information about how they set premiums, handle claims, and shift profits. Do consumers have access to the information they need to make informed choices, and would you support limiting the use of trade secret exemptions?
Donalds: Floridians should be able to compare insurers on what matters most: price, financial strength and how a company treats its customers after a storm. Right now, too much of that information is hard to find.
Jolly: Requiring more transparency from property insurance companies is something
Candidates for chief financial officer
Republican
What is your plan to lower property insurance premiums for Floridians?
Ingoglia: Don’t undo the only thing that’s lowering rates. Before our 2022-23 reforms,
Taddeo:
Does the insurance industry have too much power in
Ingoglia: The power that matters is the power
Taddeo: Yes.
In 2022 and 2023,
Ingoglia: They worked and the data is undeniable. Before the reforms, a few loose shingles on a roof turned into a lucrative business model for unscrupulous lawsuit abusers and every Floridian paid for it. We ended that. Since the reforms, lawsuit abuse has fallen sharply, insurers are coming back and creating competition that drives down rates. Unlike my opponent, I won’t repeal them and I won’t let anyone “modify” them into the same lawsuit mill under a new name. According to an actuarial analysis by the
Taddeo: Insurers asked for these changes and said they would bring rates down. They got the reforms.
Should any pre-reform coverage limitations, such as limits on water or roof coverage and 1% matching limits, be rescinded?
Ingoglia: This question mixes up two different things. The 1% matching limits and water damage limits were never part of the 2022-23 reforms, and they aren’t required by law. Insurers filed them, regulators approved them, and if a homeowner wants broader coverage, it’s available. Here’s what I voted for on roofs: Insurers can offer a separate roof deductible, and a few damaged shingles on an older roof no longer automatically means a brand-new roof. Before that, a simple
Taddeo: Yes, I would fight to revisit them. Families pay record premiums and get less coverage in return. No homeowner should discover after a storm that the roof, the water damage, or a matching repair was quietly limited. At a minimum, every limitation should be disclosed in plain language before a family buys or renews a policy. My report card will show which companies limit roof and water coverage, so families can compare before they buy. I will use the bully pulpit to fight for coverage that makes homeowners whole, especially for older homes and roofs, where these limits hit hardest. Changing these laws requires the Legislature. As CFO, I will make the case every session, backed by the consumer complaint records my own department keeps.
Should
Ingoglia: Yes, and I’ve already acted on it. In 2025, as Chairman of the
Taddeo: Yes. The state’s own report, kept hidden for four years, found that from 2017 to 2019 insurers claimed
What changes should
Ingoglia: I enforce the deadlines and laws already on the books, and I go after what’s really slowing claims down. A claim doesn’t move while it’s waiting on an overbooked adjusting firm to show up. It doesn’t move while a public adjuster is chasing the loss and building a second estimate the insurer then has to re-inspect. I’m rooting those delays out. My department also runs a mediation program that helps to close claims fast, without the cost and delay of a lawsuit, and I’m getting the word out so every Floridian knows it’s there. Any insurer that sits on a legitimate hurricane claim will answer to me. Just ask the ten that already got fined.
Taddeo: Two years after Milton and Helene, families are still fighting to get their claims paid. Right now, when an insurer stalls, homeowners are on their own. As CFO, I will send storm strike teams from the
Insurers frequently invoke trade secret designations to shield information about how they set premiums, handle claims, and shift profits. Do consumers have access to the information they need to make informed choices, and would you support limiting the use of trade secret exemptions?
Ingoglia: No, consumers don’t, and I’ve already fought to change that. Floridians should know exactly how an insurer justifies what it charges, so they can choose who they do business with. I passed a bill out of my committee that would have required it. With every rate filing, consumers should see what percentage of their premium goes where, including how much and why. As CFO, I run the consumer protection side of insurance regulation, and I take that seriously. If an insurer has nothing to hide, it has nothing to fear from transparency. Your premium isn’t a trade secret. It’s your money.
Taddeo: No. Floridians buy the most expensive insurance in the nation with the least information about where their money goes. The affiliate report proves it. Floridians paid for it, and it was kept hidden for four years. When your newspapers obtained it through a public records request, the
Legislative leaders
Sen.
Boyd chose to not answer the questions, but his campaign provided this statement:
Over the last five years, the Legislature has instituted major reforms to offer homeowners more choice and lower costs when it comes to property insurance. The changes have attracted new insurance companies to the state, increasing competition and stabilizing rates. The expansion of options for homeowners has enabled us to roll off more than 1 million policies from the state-run
Davis provided the following answers:
What is your plan to lower property insurance premiums for Floridians?
Davis: Floridians deserve accountability and real relief they have earned when it comes to solving our property insurance crisis. I believe we should be implementing rate caps to stop policyholders from continuing to be gouged and an excess profits tax, modeled on our currently existing statute regarding auto insurance, so hardworking Floridians can protect what they’ve built and first-time homebuyers get their shot at the American Dream. We should also look at state-backed universal windstorm coverage, which would lower rates, spread out risk, and safeguard policyholders from predatory private insurance corporations while giving families and seniors the protection and peace of mind they’ve paid for.
Does the insurance industry have too much power in
Davis: It is clear that the focus from Republican leadership has been to prioritize the needs of the insurance industry over what’s best for the people we were elected to serve. The so-called “reforms” that were passed over the last few years were a laundry list of the industry’s demands that has made it more difficult for policyholders to be made whole after disaster strikes and we are now seeing almost 50% of claims being denied without payment as a result. Additionally, instead of providing real relief to hardworking Floridians, the legislature passed
In 2022 and 2023,
Davis: As I mentioned previously, I do believe these “reforms” have been a disaster for policyholders in the state and I would absolutely support their repeal. We should be working to make it easier for Floridians to be made whole after what’s often one of the most traumatic experiences they will endure, but instead we rolled out the welcome mat for greedy insurance companies to deny legitimate claims. Those are backwards priorities and we should do what we can to reverse these policies before more damage is done.
Should any pre-reform coverage limitations — such as limits on water or roof coverage and 1% matching limits — be rescinded?
Davis: I believe these provisions are another example of stacking the deck in favor of insurance companies and I would support their repeal. These are often arbitrary limits on water or roof coverage and the 1% matching limit artificially limits what a policyholder can receive in order to complete their repairs.
Should
Davis: Yes. The recently released report highlighting how these companies were claiming losses while passing their profits through their affiliates was infuriating. What made it even more egregious is that instead of getting this information out to Floridians, the state has tried to cover it up. We need more transparency in the process and limits on the amount of money that can be passed through these affiliate companies to ensure that insurers are not using false claims of large losses to justify unreasonable rate increases on policyholders.
What changes should
Davis: The first step would be reversing the “reforms” passed over the last few years that have made this process easier for insurance companies to deny or lowball legitimate claims. While outright denials are a serious issue, not enough is being done to stop insurance companies from offering far below what the claim should pay because they know there is not the same threat of litigation when the state has removed the ability of attorneys to be fairly compensated for their work. This limits the ability of policyholders to be made fully whole and preys on people in potentially desperate situations who may be willing to take the offer simply because they need what they can get to begin the recovery process.
Insurers frequently invoke trade secret designations to shield information about how they set premiums, handle claims, and shift profits. Do consumers have access to the information they need to make informed choices, and would you support limiting the use of trade secret exemptions?
Davis: Unfortunately, without the help of licensed insurance agents to aid them in the process, I do fear that many Floridians are not getting the full picture of how their rates are set or the actual profitability of companies who have claimed massive losses to justify large premium increases. Rolling back the use of trade secret exemptions would allow consumers to more closely examine their options when choosing a carrier. I support limiting their use in cases where the information does not pertain to internal business practices, but could allow for more informed choices for consumers. Doing what’s best for Floridians and providing them more transparency should be our priority, not helping insurance companies hide relevant information from consumers.
NOTE: State Rep.
©2026 South Florida Sun-Sentinel. Visit sun-sentinel.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.


4th Circuit Refuses to Expand Exemptions from Anti-Discrimination Laws for Religious Employers
AINewsBreaks – ECGI Holdings Inc. (OTC: ECGI) Featured in AINewsWire Editorial on Shift Toward Preventive, AI-Enabled Healthcare
Advisor News
- The Gen Z money paradox
- NAIFA applauds final SECURE 2.0 regulations
- What will Democrats in Congress do about healthcare and retirement?
- Election results cloud retirement legislation outlook, experts say
- Planning for the missing chapter
More Advisor NewsAnnuity News
- Best’s Market Segment Report: AM Best Maintains Stable Outlook on US Life/Annuity Insurance Segment
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company and Its Subsidiaries
- Boomers want retirement protection, but their actions don’t match their mindset
- NAIC task force to address LTC riders
- ‘It’s really shocking:’ Regulators scrutinize assets backing annuity sellers
More Annuity NewsHealth/Employee Benefits News
- Picking Medicare insurance plan is daunting task – Healthful Hints
- November Issue of Best’s Review Ranks US Life Reinsurers and More
- New York Life Announces Record $3.1 Billion in Policy Owner Dividends for 2027
- New Va. subsidies help lure people back to health insurance
- 3 ways Crowley can make Healthcare more affordable in Wisconsin
3 ways to make healthcare more affordable in Wisconsin | Coleman Drake (Copy)
More Health/Employee Benefits NewsLife Insurance News
- November Issue of Best’s Review Ranks US Life Reinsurers and More
- Nebraska widow’s big win against life insurer in legal limbo
- New York Life Announces Record $3.1 Billion in Policy Owner Dividends for 2027
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company and Its Subsidiaries
- U-Haul Holding Company to Participate in Deutsche Bank Conference
More Life Insurance News