Jacobsen: Insurers have a legal duty to exercise good faith when processing claims
Twenty-plus years ago, one Saturday lunchtime, I lifted a plate out of the microwave. And wow! Pain gripped my forearm. It was a not-kidding kind of pain, ten times more than necessary to get my attention. I let out a yelp and dropped the plate on the counter and stood there, rubbing my arm, while my wife and kids stared at me in alarm.
It's a flashbulb memory, clear in every detail, because it was as strange as it was painful. The pain came out of nowhere. I had no explanation for it. And it was ridiculous. Who injures himself lifting a plate from the microwave?
I avoided using the arm until I could see my GP. He listened, poked, manipulated and sent me for an x-ray, just to be on the safe side, and then asked me questions about my computer use at work.
A light bulb flickered on. This all happened around the same time the legal profession was completing its transition from book research to fully online research, and my job as an appellate attorney required a lot of research. I wrote briefs on the same computer on which I researched, using equipment — keyboard and mouse — designed by computer scientists who knew nothing about human physiology and, to judge by the results, cared even less.
The X-ray came back negative, as expected, and I dutifully filed a workers' compensation claim. Within days I was receiving treatment for a classic computer-related repetitive stress injury. The personal computer is, among its many other attributes, a weird thing we do to our bodies.
And then my regular health insurance provider refused to pay for that initial doctor visit. I could see why a computer would spit the claim out, since it involved a work-related injury, making it properly a comp claim. But I didn't know it was a work-related injury until my GP told me.
Obviously, it's absurd for an insurer to require a patient to diagnose themselves correctly before choosing which doctor to consult for a diagnosis. I was sure I could get the denial reversed on appeal. But my appeal was denied, too, without further explanation. The fine print gave the option of pursuing a second-level appeal. I pursued it, repeating my arguments. This time the denial was reversed and the claim was paid.
It's my strong suspicion that the second-level appeal was the first time a human being looked at my claim. The denial was based on the answer to a yes/no question ("Was the injury work-related?"), which computers are good at. By contrast, evaluating my counter-argument ("a person injured at home has no reason to know the injury is work-related") required human judgment.
I was reminded of the episode earlier this year when I read a ProPublica article headlined "How Cigna saves millions by having its doctors reject claims without reading them." The article reported that Cigna, which provides or administers health coverage for 18 million Americans, uses a computer to reject "mismatches between diagnoses and what the company considers acceptable tests and procedures for those ailments."
That sounds reasonable enough. But government regulations (and simple decency) require that staff doctors review the patient file to confirm computer's determination. Cigna's doctors spent "an average of 1.2 seconds on each such case," according to the article. One doctor reportedly rubber-stamped the denial of 60,000 claims in a single month.
The article explained: "Cigna knows that many patients will pay such bills rather than deal with the hassle of appealing a rejection." The company estimated only about 5% of small-dollar denials are appealed. And there's no reason to think Cigna is unique in the industry. The story exactly matched my experience.
Insurers have a legal duty to exercise good faith when processing claims. They can be sued for the bad faith denial of claims. But filing such a lawsuit is a big deal. It means going to war with a massive corporation. Realistically, the arbitrary denial of small claims raises no risk of provoking a lawsuit. But the money saved with that kind of nickel-and-dime bad faith, repeated often enough, adds up.
What we need is a low-cost, quick-and-easy administrative system by which patients can appeal small-scale denials to an independent body, without any need to hire a lawyer. Insurers who are found to have denied a small claim without meaningful human review, or without a substantial and reasonable basis, could be required to pay double.
Such a relatively modest fine wouldn't spark all-out war. But it would put the shoe on the other foot. Insurers rather than patients might well decide that pursuing the matter isn't worth the hassle. Good faith would be incentivized.


Health insurance options expanding for farmers
Vehicle Insurance Market Gain Momentum: Major Giants Zurich Insurance, HSBC, Aetna, Allianz, AXA
Advisor News
- Election results cloud retirement legislation outlook, experts say
- Planning for the missing chapter
- Semi-retirement: helping clients balance flexibility with financial security
- The 6X Formula for leveraging content marketing with AI
- When a home becomes difficult to insure, the plan changes
More Advisor NewsAnnuity News
- Jackson Launches Direct-to-Consumer Annuity Offering
- Global Atlantic launches ForeIncome Flex
- Athene CEO criticizes offshore reinsurance, risk-taking by competitors
- DOL, trade groups, state AGs file briefs supporting Alcoa in PRT lawsuit
- John Hancock launches new fixed indexed annuity suite
More Annuity NewsHealth/Employee Benefits News
- Soaring drug costs squeeze largest Mass. insurer, fueling $43.5M loss
- Health insurers leave Ohio marketplace
- Rising hospital, drug costs boost health insurance premiums at fastest pace since start of Obamacare
- Patients with 3 health insurance plans lose access to Miami health network
- Weld County deputy struggling after being injured by DUI driver (photo gallery)
More Health/Employee Benefits NewsLife Insurance News
- Navigating delayed death certificates: A guide for life insurance advisors
- Jackson Launches Direct-to-Consumer Annuity Offering
- Best’s Market Segment Report: AM Best Maintains Stable Outlook on New Zealand’s Non-Life Insurance Segment
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Fubon Insurance Vietnam Co., Ltd.
- Three lawsuits put life insurers’ cost-of-insurance practices under scrutiny
More Life Insurance News