House Oversight Committee Issues Testimony From National Partnership for Women & Families
* * *
Good morning Chairwoman Maloney, Ranking Member Comer, and members of the committee. I am pleased to join you to discuss the importance of paid leave for federal employees, including congressional employees. Now, more than ever, it is evident that paid leave benefits working people, businesses, our economy, and public health. And this issue is deeply personal for me, having spent more than a decade working in the Administration and
My name is
At the center of this work is addressing the paid leave crisis, which the
Growing up from modest means, I always promised myself if I had children that I would ensure that they had the best start to life I could give them. I came to understand the importance of access to paid family and medical leave when I was just 16, working at a family restaurant in
When we didn't have a lot of diners, Toni would tell her story about when she went into labor at the restaurant and then went across the street to the hospital, delivered her baby and was back the next day for the Sunday morning rush. People would nod their heads in admiration, but even then, without my years of work in this field, I knew the sacrifice she made at the expense of her well-being and her family's. Toni was faced with an impossible choice - risking losing her job and her paycheck or caring for herself and her family.
In January of 2013, when my husband and I discovered I was pregnant, we were excited and scared like most couples. I was working at the
At the time, the federal government did not have a paid leave policy - workers were forced to either take time off without pay to have a child or use your accrued vacation and sick days, if you had any available. At that time I hadn't accumulated enough paid sick and vacation days to last twelve weeks. I had spoken with many colleagues who shared that they took six weeks or less off when they had a child because they had no choice - I was devastated. I felt strongly that 12 weeks was what I needed to give my family a good start. I knew I wouldn't be paid fully for my time, but I hoped that through the leave donation program I could get 9 or 10 weeks of pay.
While my husband and I saved and I accrued more time off, we found out that I had an incompetent cervix and I was immediately put on bed rest for the next four months, until my baby was born. Thankfully, I was given a pregnancy accommodation that allowed me to work from home while on bed rest. This was an unusual circumstance in the federal government and because it felt like a privilege, I worked extra hard throughout my difficult pregnancy to avoid the appearance that I was taking advantage of the situation. The diagnosis also meant I needed to go to the doctor every week and a specialist every few weeks, requiring more time off work. Taking an hour or two each week for doctor's appointments chipped away at the time I could afford to take off after the birth of my son.
These factors together left me wondering if I would still have a job if I had to take leave early and ultimately how it would impact myself and my baby. Like so many women of color/1, I faced the challenge of navigating pregnancy health complications without the paid leave I needed to care for myself and my family.
Although I was at home for the remainder of my pregnancy, I was sent to the hospital twice which eroded my paid sick leave and the accrual of leave time that was standing in for true paid parental leave. I tried to make up the time, answering emails and making phone calls because every moment I spent caring for myself and my pregnancy meant losing money and time later.
In July of 2013, my son Jack was born 6 weeks prematurely and was immediately brought to the NICU (Neonatal Intensive Care Unit). His birth also came the same day that the Transportation-HUD Appropriations bill was on the
As a former federal employee with this experience, working to pass paid parental leave for federal employees was a privilege because I knew firsthand the challenges that lack of access to paid leave can bring. Due to the tireless efforts of Chairwoman Maloney and Chairman Smith, other Congressional champions, and advocates around this table, the federal government - the nation's largest employer - began providing 12 weeks of paid parental leave for federal employees last October, becoming a national leader in family-friendly workplace policies.
Studies show that longer paid leave policies improves maternal and infant health. Less than eight weeks of paid leave is linked to a reduction in overall health status and increased depression./2
Every additional week of paid leave a mother takes reduces the likelihood of reporting poor mental well-being by 2 percent./3
Paid leave also significantly increases the benefits to moms and babies, giving them the needed time to breastfeed, which improves babies' immune systems and reduces risk of breast and ovarian cancer, diabetes, and obesity for the mother. One literature review found that, compared with mothers who were only able to take unpaid leave or no leave at all, mothers who took paid leave had their chances of being re-hospitalized reduced by more than half (51 percent); had the likelihood of their infants being re-hospitalized in the first year reduced by almost half (47 percent); and were almost twice as likely to have more success in managing stress and engaging in regular exercise./4
Enabling working parents to care for and bond with a new baby lays the foundation for healthy child development. Children who form strong emotional bonds or "attachment" with their parents are more likely to do well in school and have positive relationships with others./5
This policy is also expected to save the federal government money through reduced turnover and replacement costs, and to help attract and retain younger workers. Paid leave is particularly important to younger workers, like I was, who are less likely to have accrued significant amounts of sick or vacation time and are more likely to be forced to choose between a paycheck and caring for a new child.
During the effort to expand access to paid leave for federal employees, I often reflected on my experience and how the emotional, physical and financial stress of my situation could have been significantly relieved if I had access to paid leave during that time. I wonder if I could have carried Jack to full-term.
America Needs National Paid Family and Medical Leave for a Full and Equitable Recovery
Since coming to the
Prior to the pandemic, our economy lost more than
Additional labor force participation losses due to the pandemic could amount to tens of billions more lost each year if nothing is done./8
Thanks to critical economic supports provided through the American Rescue Plan and a historic vaccination campaign overseen by the Biden administration,
For millions of adults, health and family caregiving needs continue to be a barrier to employment. As June began, 2.1 million people were unable to work because they were sick or caring for an ill family member with COVID-19. The number of adults not working because they were caring for a child - the majority women - was 1.5 million higher than it was during the Spring of 2020./10
One-quarter of unemployed people who are not currently looking for work say it is due to family or child care needs./11
The barriers to return to work are high so long as nearly four-fifths of worker do not have access to paid family leave at their jobs, and six in ten do not have paid medical leave./12
Our economic recovery will continue to lag, especially for women, as long as workers do not have the protections they need for their health and family caregiving needs. A national paid family and medical leave program covering all working people is essential to help women, people of color, and people with serious health conditions and disabilities including long-haul COVID return to the workforce and to create a more equitable economy in which all people can thrive.
National Paid Leave Will Build on Lessons from Successful State and Federal Policies
Longstanding laws and recent innovations at the state and federal level provide direction for a common-sense federal program that will be fair and workable for working people, employers and taxpayers.
The Family and Medical Leave Act Was a Major Advance, But Too Many Are Ineligible or Cannot Afford Unpaid Leave
Over more than a quarter-century, the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) has given millions of working people the opportunity to take the time off they needed to care for themselves and their families. The FMLA allows qualified individuals to take up to twelve weeks of unpaid leave to care for themselves, for a family member or for a new child. Since it was signed into law in 1993, it has been used more than 300 million times,/13 with almost 15 million workers taking FMLA-type leaves each year./14
More than half (52 percent) of the individuals who take leave under the FMLA do so for personal medical care, with 21 percent taking leave to care for a new child and 23 percent taking leave to care for a family member, including for military exigency leave./15
Despite strong concerns about potential negative impacts on the nation's businesses or the potential for fraud or misuse by employees in the lead up to its passage, the FMLA has turned out to be good for employers, with most employers reporting neutral or positive effects when employees take FMLA leave. The majority of worksites report no noticeable effect from complying with the FMLA, and more than one-third experienced positive effects./16
Furthermore, there is little evidence that employees misuse leave - fewer than 2 percent of worksites report any misuse of the FMLA./17
But while the FMLA has helped to transform workplaces in
And among those who do qualify for the FMLA, too many people cannot afford to take unpaid leave./19
Additionally, the FMLA's restrictive definition of who is considered a family member - a spouse, parent, or minor child - does not reflect what families today look like. An estimated 8.4 million people each year (5.3 percent of all workers) take leave for a non-FMLA-covered individual - meaning their
jobs are not protected during leave - and among workers who did not take leave when they needed it, 14 percent said the person they needed to care for was not covered./20
Paid Parental Leave for Federal Employees and Private Sector Innovation Set a Competitive Standard
Last year, the federal government - the nation's largest employer - began providing 12 weeks of paid parental leave for federal employees, becoming a national leader in family-friendly workplace policies. But while paid parental leave will help countless federal employees, as it would have helped me when I became a parent, parental leave is not enough to meet the needs of the federal workforce. In 2017, the number of full-time federal employees older than 50 years old was nearly eight times the number under 30,/21 and in some agencies, more than half of senior staff are eligible to retire./22
No one should have to choose between their income and caring for a new child or their income and caring for themselves or a loved one.
Comprehensive paid leave for federal employees will also help improve the health and well-being of our civil servants. In addition to the many benefits of paid parental leave, comprehensive paid leave lets people help older family members recover from serious illnesses, fulfill treatment plans, and avoid complications and hospital readmissions./23
This is why the
Private sector innovation has also moved the conversation forward on paid leave.
But while the federal government and the private sector have made innovative and critical strides toward providing paid leave, we know that the only way to ensure that every working person has access to paid leave is for
State Programs Have Proven the Benefits of Paid Leave for Workers and Employers
State programs provide a successful model for a permanent federal program. To date, ten states, including the
Evidence from these programs shows that, when designed correctly, they can have tremendous benefits for workers, families, and public health, and can respond quickly and nimbly to adjust benefits during a public health crisis./25
Paid leave helps people with health conditions maintain their incomes and jobs while enabling them to seek timely treatment and rest./26
Paid leave supports elder care/27 and keeps family caregivers in the labor force/28, including after a health shock./29
Paid leave also reduces nursing home utilization/30 - a vital need given that nearly 40 percent of COVID-19 deaths have been connected to nursing homes and long-term care facilities,/31 and deaths have been higher in facilities with a higher percentage of residents of color./32
Paid leave will also help address the maternal health crisis, particularly among Black and Native American women. When
State paid family leave programs increased parity in the duration of maternity leave taken between white women and women of color, as well as in rates of initiation of breastfeeding,/34 reduced rates of food insecurity in the year following a birth, especially for households with very low food security, which are disproportionately likely to be Black or Latinx,/35 and improved rates of on-time vaccinations, with the strongest impact on families below the poverty line./36
Paid leave programs improve the physical and mental health of new mothers, with the strongest effects for single mothers and mothers with low incomes, who are disproportionately women of color./37
Evidence also shows that these programs have remained fiscally sound and are workable for employers. The vast majority of
Firm-level analysis of employers in
In
Small and mid-size employers in
Best Practices for an Inclusive, Equitable National Paid Leave Program
Decades of research on state paid leave programs and the FMLA show that a paid leave program must meet certain basic standards to be workable, affordable and meet its potential to advance gender and racial equity, support public health, and improve the economy. These lessons have informed promising paid leave proposals in
Comprehensive coverage. Paid leave must cover the range of common health and caregiving needs identified in the FMLA. More than half (52 percent) of the individuals who take leave under the FMLA do so for personal medical care, with 21 percent taking leave to care for a new child and 23 percent taking leave to care for a family member, including for military exigency leave./42
A national program should cover all workers, including those working part-time, holding multiple jobs or working in the gig economy, and provide an inclusive eligibility standard so that recent entrants to the workforce or those who recently experienced unemployment are not disadvantaged.
Adequate duration. A national program should provide at least 12 weeks of leave for all purposes, aligning with public health recommendations for child bonding and birth recovery and a meaningful amount for most workers' health needs./43
While some state programs cover much longer leaves for workers' own health conditions - up to 26 weeks in
Progressive wage replacement rate. Evidence from state programs shows that a too-low wage replacement rate is not adequate for the lowest income workers to be able to afford to take leave, disproportionately affecting workers of color,/45 and may prevent the program from fulfilling its potential to advance gender equity./46
New and updated state laws have adopted progressive rates, replacing between 80 and 100 percent of wages up to a certain threshold to ensure low-income workers can take leave, and a smaller share of wages above that point and high enough weekly cap that leave remains accessible to middle-income workers as well.
Inclusive family definition. A national program must define "family" inclusively to reflect the reality of our diverse country. More than 80 percent of households do not fit the so-called nuclear family model (a married couple living together with minor children)./47
For example, one in five people (about 64 million nationwide) live in a multigenerational household, and people of color are especially likely to do so./48
And, whether due to small family size, living a great distance from relatives, or even divorce or estrangement from a birth family, many adults - in fact, nearly one-third of people in
Coverage for these "chosen family" members, which is included
National Paid Leave Will Help Create an Economy That Works for All Families
This transformational program will provide families financial security and peace of mind at some of the most challenging moments in life, making the largest impacts on the families currently struggling the most. It will enable more women to remain in the workforce, allow parents to invest more time and care in their children, and help older Americans to age with dignity and support from their loved ones. More than 100 million working people in this country cannot afford to wait.
* * *
Footnotes:
1/ Coombs, S. (2021) Moms and Babies Series: Paid Leave is Essential for Healthy Moms and Babies. Retrieved
2/ Chatterji, P. and Markowitz, S. (2012) Family Leave After Childbirth and the Mental Health of New Mothers,
3/ Ibid.
4/ Jou, J., Kozhimannil, K.B., Abraham, J.M., Blewett, L.A., and McGovern, P.M. (2018, February) Paid Maternity Leave in
5/
6/ Glynn, S. J. (2020,
7/ Shierholz, H. (2014, December). Paid Leave Is Good for Business.
8/ Kashen, J., Glynn, S., & Novello, A. (2021,
9/
10/
11/
12/
13/ Calculation is based on the number of covered and eligible workers multiplied by the rates of leave taking (the percentage of the people who were eligible for FMLA leave who actually took it) for each period covered by an FMLA survey to determine total leave takers for each period and then summed to determine total uses. The number of covered and eligible workers for each period is based on the average civilian noninstitutionalized, employed workforce calculated using 1994-2020
14/ Brown, S., Herr, J., Roy, R., & Klerman, J. A.. (2020, July) Employee and Worksite Perspectives of the Family and Medical Leave Act: Supplemental Results from the 2018 Surveys (Exhibits B6-2 and B6-4). Retrieved
15/ Ibid. Exhibit B4-3 on p.22. The percentage for people taking leave to care for a family member is calculated by adding the percentages of those providing care of an FMLA-covered adult's health condition, care for a child's health condition, and care of an elderly FMLA-covered adult's health condition.
16/ Klerman, J. A., Daley, K., & Pozniak, A. (2012,
17/ Ibid, p. 156.
18/ Ibid, p. 21.
19/ Ibid, p. iii and Appendix Exhibit B6-2, Rate of Unmet Need for Leave for a Qualifying FMLA Reason in the Past 12 Months, by Demographic Characteristics and Appendix B6-4, Reasons That Needed Leave Was Not Taken..
20/
21/
22/ Ibid.
23/ See e.g.,
24/
25/ Boyens, C. (2020,
26/ See note 14, (Brown, Herr, Roy, & Klerman).
27/ Kim, S. (2021, February). Access to employer-provided paid leave and eldercare provision for older workers. Community, Work & Family. Online first. doi:10.1080/13668803.2021.1885346
28/ Saad-Lessler, J. (2020, October). How does paid family leave affect unpaid care providers?
29/ Anand, P., Dague, L, & Wagner, K. L. (2020, June). The Role of Paid Family Leave in Spousal Labor Supply Responses to a Disability or Health Shock. Paper presented at the Annual Conference of the American Society of Health Economists,
30/ Arora, K., & Wolf, D. A. (2018). Does Paid Family Leave Reduce Nursing Home Use? The California Experience.
31/
32/ Gorges, R. J., & Konetzka, R. T. (2021, February). Factors Associated With Racial Differences in Deaths Among Nursing Home Residents With COVID-19 Infection in the US. JAMA Network Open. 4(2), e2037431. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.37431
33/ Stearns, J. (2015, September). The effects of paid maternity leave: Evidence from
34/ Appelbaum, E., & Milkman, R. (2013). Unfinished Business: Paid Family Leave in
35/ Lenhart, O. (2021, January). The effects of paid family leave on food insecurity--evidence from
36/ Choudhury, A. R., & Polachek, S. W. (2019, July). The Impact of Paid Family Leave on the Timing of Infant Vaccinations.
37/ Pal, I. (2018, January). Effect of
38/ Appelbaum, E., & Milkman, R. (2013). Unfinished Business: Paid Family Leave in
39/ Bedard, K., & Rossin-Slater, M. (2016,
40/ Ramirez, M. (2012). The Impact of Paid Family Leave on New Jersey Businesses.
41/ Bartel, A., Rossin-Slater, M., Ruhm, C., Slopen, M., & Waldfogel, J. (2021,
42/ See note 14 (Brown, Herr, Roy, & Klerman).
43/
44/
45/
46/ Evidence from
47/ Bowman, M., Durso, L. E., Gruberg, S., Kocolatos, M., Krishnamurthy, K., Make, J., McGovern, A.,
48/ Cohn, D., & Passel, J. S. (2018,
49/
50/ Ibid.
51/ Ramchand, R., Tanielian, T., Fisher, M. P., Vaughan, C. A., Trail, T. E., Batka, C., Ghosh-Dastidar, B . (2014).


Congressional Research Service Report: 'Need-Tested Benefits – Who Receives Assistance?'
Mercury Insurance Launches MercuryGO for Florida Drivers
Advisor News
- Election results cloud retirement legislation outlook, experts say
- Planning for the missing chapter
- Semi-retirement: helping clients balance flexibility with financial security
- The 6X Formula for leveraging content marketing with AI
- When a home becomes difficult to insure, the plan changes
More Advisor NewsAnnuity News
- Jackson Launches Direct-to-Consumer Annuity Offering
- Global Atlantic launches ForeIncome Flex
- Athene CEO criticizes offshore reinsurance, risk-taking by competitors
- DOL, trade groups, state AGs file briefs supporting Alcoa in PRT lawsuit
- John Hancock launches new fixed indexed annuity suite
More Annuity NewsHealth/Employee Benefits News
- Best’s Special Report: Rising Costs Could Offset AI-Driven Efficiency Gains at US Health Insurers
- Free Medicare counseling provided through LTADD
- Illinois consumers see higher prices and fewer choices for Obamacare health insurance
- COMPREHENSIVE REGULATIONS TO UNCOVER SUSPICIOUS HEALTHCARE (CRUSH) PROPOSED RULE (CMS-6098-P)
- CMS CRUSH PROPOSED RULE AIMS TO REAP NEARLY $90 BILLION FOR TAXPAYERS IN SAVINGS BY TARGETING FRAUD ACROSS MEDICARE, MEDICAID/CHIP, AND THE MARKETPLACE
More Health/Employee Benefits NewsLife Insurance News
- Navigating delayed death certificates: A guide for life insurance advisors
- Jackson Launches Direct-to-Consumer Annuity Offering
- Best’s Market Segment Report: AM Best Maintains Stable Outlook on New Zealand’s Non-Life Insurance Segment
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Fubon Insurance Vietnam Co., Ltd.
- Three lawsuits put life insurers’ cost-of-insurance practices under scrutiny
More Life Insurance News