House Judiciary Committee Issues Report on Protecting Access to Care Act (Part 2 of 2) - Insurance News | InsuranceNewsNet

InsuranceNewsNet — Your Industry. One Source.™

Sign in
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
Home Now reading Newswires
Topics
    • Advisor News
    • Annuity Index
    • Annuity News
    • Companies
    • Earnings
    • Fiduciary
    • From the Field: Expert Insights
    • Health/Employee Benefits
    • Insurance & Financial Fraud
    • INN Magazine
    • Insiders Only
    • Life Insurance News
    • Newswires
    • Property and Casualty
    • Regulation News
    • Sponsored Articles
    • Washington Wire
    • Videos
    • ———
    • About
    • Meet our Editorial Staff
    • Advertise
    • Contact
    • Newsletters
  • Exclusives
  • NewsWires
  • Magazine
  • Newsletters
Sign in or register to be an INNsider.
  • AdvisorNews
  • Annuity News
  • Companies
  • Earnings
  • Fiduciary
  • Health/Employee Benefits
  • Insurance & Financial Fraud
  • INN Exclusives
  • INN Magazine
  • Insurtech
  • Life Insurance News
  • Newswires
  • Property and Casualty
  • Regulation News
  • Sponsored Articles
  • Video
  • Washington Wire
  • Life Insurance
  • Annuities
  • Advisor
  • Health/Benefits
  • Property & Casualty
  • Insurtech
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Editorial Staff

Get Social

  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
Newswires
Newswires RSS Get our newsletter
Order Prints
March 26, 2017 Newswires
Share
Share
Post
Email

House Judiciary Committee Issues Report on Protecting Access to Care Act (Part 2 of 2)

Targeted News Service

Targeted News Service

WASHINGTON, March 26 -- The House Judiciary Committee issued a report (H.Rpt. 115-55) on legislation (H.R. 1215) to improve patient access to health care services and provide improved medical care by reducing the excessive burden the liability system places on the health care delivery system. The report was advanced by Rep. Bob Goodlatte, R-Va., on March 22.

Continues from Part 1 of 2

Dissenting Views

H.R. 1215, the "Protecting Access to Care Act of 2017," will do little to protect Americans' access to safe and affordable health care. Instead, it will undermine the ability of victims of medical malpractice and defective medical products to be fully compensated for their injuries. It does this by imposing onerous restrictions on lawsuits against health care providers concerning their provision of health care goods or services, regardless of the merits of a case, the misconduct at issue, or the severity of the victim's injury. By imposing these one-size-fits-all Federal standards on traditionally state court proceedings, H.R. 1215 would also trample states' rights. The Committee has considered similar so-called medical malpractice reforms on 11 prior occasions going back to 1995 and, like the prior iterations of this bill, H.R. 1215 raises the same core issues of fairness and federalism with little regard for the consequences.

H.R. 1215 is highly problematic for many reasons. To begin with, it intrudes deeply on state sovereignty by preempting several areas of tort law that traditionally have been governed by the jurisprudence of each individual state or by state legislatures. Additionally, the bill's scope is broader than medical malpractice, potentially imposing new restrictions on claims concerning nursing home negligence and defective pharmaceuticals or medical devices. Further yet, H.R. 1215 could prevent victims from having their day in court by providing unjustified immunity for health care providers who dispense defective or dangerous pharmaceuticals or medical devices, by instituting an extremely short statute of limitations period, and by imposing limitations on attorney contingent fee arrangements that will discourage lawyers from representing victims. Finally, H.R. 1215 imposes various requirements that will significantly diminish a victim's ability to be fully compensated for their injuries, including: (1) the elimination of joint and several liability with respect to claims for both economic and noneconomic damages, (2) an extremely low cap on noneconomic damages such as those for pain and suffering, which will particularly limit compensation for members of vulnerable groups like the poor, the elderly, children, women, and other groups who tend to have less in terms of lost wages or other economic loss, and (3) the allowance for periodic payments of future damages of $50,000 or more, which will put the risk of future loss on plaintiffs rather than defendants.

In recognition of these significant concerns, a coalition of 30 consumer and public interest groups, including the Center for Justice and Democracy, Consumer Federation of America, National Association of Consumer Advocates, National Women's Health Network, and Public Citizen, oppose H.R. 1215 because it "would limit the legal rights of injured patients and families of those killed by negligent health care" as well as those injured by "unsafe drugs and nursing home abuse and neglect."1 Similarly, Consumers Union opposes H.R. 1215 because the bill "would put patient safety at higher risk, by significantly undermining the accountability of those who provide patients with medical care."2 In addition, the American Bar Association, in its opposition to the bill, observes that for "200 years, the authority to determine medical liability law has rested in the states" and that this "is a hallmark of the American justice system."3

1Letter from 30 consumer groups to Chairman Bob Goodlatte (R-VA) and Ranking Member John Conyers, Jr. (D-MI), H. Comm. on the Judiciary (Feb. 27, 2017) (on file with H. Comm. on the Judiciary Democratic Staff).

2Letter from George P. Slover, Senior Policy Council, Consumers Union, to Members of the H. Comm. on the Judiciary (Feb. 27, 2017) (on file with H. Comm. on the Judiciary Democratic Staff).

3Letter from Thomas M. Susman, Director of the Governmental Affairs Office, American Bar Association, to Chairman Bob Goodlatte (R- VA) and Ranking Member John Conyers, Jr. (D-MI), H. Comm. on the Judiciary (Feb. 27, 2017) (on file with H. Comm. on the Judiciary Democratic Staff).

For these reasons, and for those discussed below, we respectfully dissent from the Committee's report and oppose H.R. 1215.

DESCRIPTION AND BACKGROUND

DESCRIPTION

H.R. 1215 would preempt state law generally to the extent that state laws are more protective than the bill's provisions of the rights of medical malpractice victims and the victims of defective medical products. It would replace such victim- protective laws with new requirements and limitations that would restrict or undermine the ability of injured persons to be fully compensated for their injuries or even to have their claims heard in court. The following describes some of the bill's most troubling provisions.

Section 10(a) sets forth the general rule that the bill's provisions preempt state law. It specifies that, except as otherwise provided in the bill, the legislation's provisions governing health care lawsuits preempt state law to the extent that state law prevents the application of any provisions of law established by or under this legislation. The bill at various points sets forth exceptions to this general preemption provision generally for state laws that are more restrictive for plaintiffs than the bill's provisions would be. Section 10(c) specifies that no provision of this legislation may be construed to preempt any defense available to a party in a health care lawsuit under any provision of state or Federal law.

The bill defines "health care lawsuit" to include not only medical malpractice claims, but also claims concerning medical products. Specifically, section 8(7) defines "health care lawsuit" to mean "any health care liability claim concerning the provision of goods or services for which coverage was provided in whole or in part via a Federal program, subsidy or tax benefit, or any health care liability action concerning the provision of goods or services for which coverage was provided in whole or in part via a Federal program, subsidy or tax benefit." This definition appears to cover any claim arising from health care products or services paid for at least in part by programs such as Medicare, Medicaid, a subsidy under the Affordable Care Act (ACA),4 Veterans Administration-provided health care, or the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974. Moreover, "health care lawsuit" includes lawsuits brought in state and Federal courts or pursuant to an alternative dispute resolution (ADR) system against a health care provider, regardless of the theory of liability, but does not include criminal liability, civil fines and penalties, or antitrust claims.

4Pub. L. No. 111-148, 124 Stat. 119 (2010).

The bill defines "health care liability action" as a civil action brought in state or Federal court or pursuant to an ADR system against a health care provider in which the plaintiff alleges a health care liability claim. "Health care liability claim," in turn, is defined as "a demand by any person, whether or not pursuant to ADR, against a health care provider . . . which [is] based upon the provision or use of (or the failure to provide or use) health care services or medical products." The bill defines "health care provider" as "any person or entity required by law to be licensed, registered, or certified to provide health care services" and defines "health care services" to mean "the provision of any goods or services by a health care provider" or any individual working under such person's supervision that relates to the diagnosis, prevention, or treatment of human disease or impairment or an assessment or care of human health. This definition is broad enough that it could include not just physicians and hospitals, but also nursing homes and long-term care facilities.

Section 2 creates a statute of limitations for "health care lawsuits." Claimants must commence a health care lawsuit within 3 years of the date of injury or within 1 year after the claimant discovers, or through the use of reasonable diligence should have discovered, the injury, whichever occurs first.

Section 3 caps non-economic damages in "health care lawsuits" at $250,000 regardless of the number of parties against whom the action is brought or the number of separate claims or actions brought with respect to the same injury. This section also eliminates joint and several liability in health care lawsuits for both economic and noneconomic damages claims. Joint and several liability means that where there are several defendants each is liable jointly with the others for the amount of the judgment against them, and that each is also individually liable for the full amount. In sum, the plaintiff can collect from any one of them or any group. By eliminating joint and several liability for health care lawsuits, each defendant would be liable only for that defendant's share of any damages and not for the share of any other person and each party is liable only for the amount of damages allocated to such party in direct proportion to such party's percentage of responsibility. When a judgment of liability is rendered as to any party, a separate judgment must be rendered against each such party for the amount allocated to such party.

Section 4 places limitations on the amount of contingent fees that a plaintiff's lawyer may recover as compensation in a "health care lawsuit." In particular, section 4(a) provides that the total of all contingent fees for representing all claimants in a health care lawsuit must not exceed the following limits: (1) 40 percent of the first $50,000 recovered by the claimant(s); (2) 331/3 percent of the next $50,000 recovered by the claimant(s); (3) 25 percent of the next $500,000 recovered by the claimant(s); or (4) 15 percent of any amount by which the recovery by the claimant(s) is in excess of $600,000.

Section 6 provides that where a claim for future damages of $50,000 or more is made against a party with sufficient insurance or other assets to fund a periodic payment of such a judgment, the court must, at the request of any party, enter a judgment order that the future damages be paid by periodic payments.

Finally, section 7 provides complete immunity for health care providers who prescribe or dispense pursuant to a prescription a medical product "approved, licensed, or cleared by the Food and Drug Administration" in a product liability lawsuit involving such product and provides that health care providers shall not be liable to a plaintiff in a class action lawsuit against the manufacturer, distributor, or seller of such product.

BACKGROUND

Every year, as many as 440,000 Americans die from preventable medical errors, making it the third leading cause of death.5 Even where death does not result from such errors, the injuries suffered by patients can be severe and permanent. In fact, there are 20 times as many serious, yet nonfatal, preventable injuries to patients. According to the National Patient Safety Foundation, "The health care system continues to operate with a low degree of reliability, meaning that patients frequently experience harms that could have been prevented or mitigated."6 Common medical errors include the 40 surgeries per week in the United States performed on the wrong patient or the wrong body part,7 the average of more than 100 incidents per year of foreign objects being left inside patients,8 and failures to properly diagnose life- threatening conditions like cancer or to prescribe proper medication.9 In addition to cases of medical errors are instances where a health care provider intentionally harms a patient, including cases where a provider rapes or sexually assaults a patient.

5Marla Paul, How to Prevent 440,000 Yearly Deaths Due to Medical Errors, Northwestern Now, Nov. 16, 2016, available at https:// news.northwestern.edu/stories/2016/11/how-to-prevent-440000-yearly- deaths-due-to-medical-errors.

6National Patient Safety Foundation. Free from Harm: Accelerating Patient Safety Improvement Fifteen Years after To Err Is Human. National Patient Safety Foundation, 2015, available at http:// www.npsf.org/?page=freefromharm.

7According to the American Association for Justice, there are 40 wrong-patient or wrong-site procedures performed every week. American Ass'n for Justice, Medical Negligence: The Role of America's Civil Justice System in Protecting Patients' Rights (Feb. 2011) (citing Joint Commission Center for Transforming Healthcare, Wrong Site Surgery Project http://www.centerfortransforminghealthcare.org/projects/ display.aspx?projectid=4).

8The Joint Commission, Sentinel Event Alert, Issue 51, Oct. 17, 2013, available at https://www.jointcommission.org/assets/1/6/ SEA_51_URFOs_10_17_13_FINAL.pdf.

9Failure to diagnose a disease and medication errors are the two most common bases for filing a medical malpractice lawsuit. Rachel Rettner, Failure to Diagnose Is No. 1 Reason for Suing Doctors, Live Science, Jul. 18, 2013, available at http://www.livescience.com/38289- malpractice-claims-missed-diagnoses.html

A medical malpractice claim is a tort-based legal claim for damages arising out of an injury caused by a health care provider. Tort claims are part of "common law" or judge-made law of the U.S. civil justice system and typically reserved to the states.10

10"Tort law at present is almost exclusively state law rather than federal law [.]" Federal Tort Reform Legislation: Constitutionality and Summaries of Selected Statutes, Congressional Research Service, Rep. No. 95-797A, at 1.

Product liability actions are actions brought against the manufacturer or seller of a defective or dangerous product by a consumer who is injured as a result of that product. Like other areas of tort law, products liability is governed by state laws on negligence, breach of warranty, or strict liability.

The tort system provides various benefits to society. First, it compensates victims who have been injured by the negligent conduct of others. Second, it deters future misconduct and carelessness that may cause injury and punishes wrongdoers who inflict such injury. Third, it prevents future injury by removing dangerous products and practices from the marketplace. Fourth, it informs an otherwise unknowing public of such harmful products or practices thereby expanding public health and safety.11

11Joan Claybrook, Consumers and Tort Law, 34 Fed. B. News & J. 127 (1987).

Most medical malpractice claims are based on the tort of "negligence," defined as conduct "which falls below the standard established by law for the protection of others against unreasonable risk and harm."12 In medical malpractice cases, this legal standard is based on the practices of the medical profession,13 and is usually determined based on testimony of expert witnesses. As with other torts, remedies for medical malpractice may consist of: (1) compensatory damage awards for economic losses such as medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, reduced life expectancy and diminished quality of life; and (2) punitive damages to punish and deter willful and wanton conduct.

12Restatement (Second) of Torts Sec. 282 (1965).

13David M. Harney, Medical Malpractice Sec. 21.2, at 413 (2d ed. 1987).

Medical malpractice liability insurance has historically attracted the attention of Congress during industry "crisis" periods, which occurred during the mid-1970's, the mid-1980's, and the early 2000's. These periods were all marked by increases in insurance premiums, difficulties in finding malpractice insurance for certain medical specialties, and reports of physicians leaving geographical areas or retiring to avoid insurance difficulties. Currently, the medical liability insurance market is not exhibiting crisis symptoms. Indeed, according to a 2016 article in a medical malpractice insurance industry trade publication, the "medical professional liability insurance industry is continuing its unprecedented run of consecutive profitable years in 2016. Never before has the industry witnessed such an unbroken string of annual favorable results, many of which were very favorable."14 That same publication, describing a survey of medical professional liability insurance rates, noted that for the "vast majority (75 percent) of [medical malpractice] insurers in the survey, rates have remained flat between 2015 and 2016."15

14Paul Greve & Allison Milford, Do Still Waters Still Run Deep? Medical Professional Liability in 2016, Medical Liability Monitor, Vol. 41, No. 10 (Oct. 2016).

15Id. at 5.

CONCERNS WITH H.R. 1215

I. H.R. 1215 VIOLATES STATE SOVEREIGNTY.

H.R. 1215, like many so-called "tort reform" measures that the Committee has considered, represents a deep intrusion into state sovereignty. Although tort law is an area historically developed and shaped by the states, H.R. 1215 raises broad federalism concerns as it preempts several areas of tort law that traditionally have been governed by the jurisprudence of each individual state or by state legislatures. The bill mandates that, with certain very limited and defendant-friendly exceptions, each of the bill's provisions "governing health care lawsuits set forth in this Act preempt . . . State law to the extent that State law prevents the application of any provisions of law established by or under this Act."16 In particular, H.R. 1215 preempts state law governing joint and several liability, the availability of damages, attorneys' fees, and periodic payments of future damages. In short, H.R. 1215 does nothing to address the fundamental concerns about states' rights raised by our Republican Committee colleagues as it intrudes just as deeply as its predecessor bills into areas traditionally determined by the states.

16H.R. 1215, 115th Cong. Sec. 10(a) (2017) (as amended).

As with previous versions of this legislation, many provisions of H.R. 1215 are written to be "one-way preemptive"--that is, they only supersede state laws that are generally more favorable to victims, rather than preempting state law equally across the board. For instance, the bill does not preempt any defenses available to defendants under state law. In addition, H.R. 1215 leaves intact damage caps determined by states even if they exceed those in the bill, but would impose them on states lacking such damage caps. Similarly, the bill leaves in place state limitations periods that are shorter than those provided for in the bill, but not those that may be longer; state laws that provide for lower contingent fee payments to plaintiffs' attorneys, but not those that may authorize higher payments; and state laws that specify periodic payments for future damages at any amount other than $50,000, but not those state laws that prohibit periodic payments. This is true even though the absence of the defendant-protective features provided in H.R. 1215 represent a state judiciary's established legal precedents or the valid public policy choices made by a state's legislature.

Examples of state provisions that H.R. 1215 would preempt include state constitutional provisions in Arizona, Arkansas, Kentucky, Pennsylvania, and Wyoming that prohibit caps on damages.17 In addition, 22 states' laws provide for some form of joint and several liability, which would be preempted by this bill.18 By applying a numerically specific sliding scale on contingent fee arrangements, the bill also preempts the law in 33 states and the District of Columbia that either do not have any specific statutory limits on attorneys' fees, require or allow a court to determine a "reasonable" fee award, leave attorney compensation arrangements entirely to the parties to determine, or impose a sliding scale with higher compensation limits than the bill provides.19

17The relevant state constitutional provisions are Arizona (Article 2 sec. 31 and Article 18 sec. 6); Arkansas (Article 5, Sec. 32); Kentucky (Section 54); Pennsylvania (Article III sec. 18); and Wyoming (Section 97-10-004 (a)).

18Alabama, Hawaii, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, and Virginia.

19Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, District of Columbia, Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, New Hampshire, New Mexico, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Texas, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, and West Virginia.

In light of the fact that H.R. 1215 fundamentally upends our Nation's Federal constitutional structure, Representative Hank Johnson (D-GA) offered an amendment that would have added a rule of construction requiring that the bill not be construed to preempt any state constitutional provision. In support of his amendment, Representative Johnson noted that "the bill only overrides those [state] laws which are more protective of injured patients and families so that defendants . . . can gain an unfair advantage in courts"20 and that such "sweeping preemption of state law . . . comes at the expense of individuals hurt by medical malpractice or dangerous products, as well as families suffering under the weight of crippling medical bills and lost wages caused by medical negligence."21 The Committee initially adopted this amendment by a bipartisan 16 to 15 vote.22 In response to the adoption of this amendment, however, the Committee Majority proceeded to engage in a number of extraordinary procedural maneuvers to reconsider the amendment,23 cut off debate,24 and hold a second vote on whether to adopt this amendment.25 On the second vote, the Committee rejected the amendment by a tie vote of 17 to 17, notwithstanding continued bipartisan support in favor of adopting the amendment.26

20Unofficial Tr. for Markup of H.R. 1215, the "Protecting Access to Care Act of 2017," by the H. Comm. on the Judiciary, 115th Cong. 105 (Feb. 28, 2017) [hereinafter "Markup Tr."], available at https:// judiciary.house.gov/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/2.28-Markup- Transcript.pdf.

21Id.

22Id. at 119.

23Id. at 132-36, 148.

24Id. at 136, 142, 153, 158.

25Id. at 158.

26Id. at 164.

II. H.R. 1215 APPLIES WELL BEYOND MEDICAL MALPRACTICE.

H.R. 1215 makes sweeping changes to the ground rules for "any health care lawsuit brought in a Federal or State court, or subject to an alternative dispute resolution system, that is initiated on or after the enactment of this Act. . . ."27 The bill, in turn, defines a "health care lawsuit" as:

27H.R. 1215, 115th Cong. Sec. 11 (2017) (as amended).

any health care liability claim concerning the provision of health care goods or services for which coverage was provided in whole or in part via a Federal program, subsidy or tax benefit, or any health care liability action concerning the provision of goods or services for which coverage was provided in whole or in part via a Federal program, subsidy or tax benefit, brought in a State or Federal court or pursuant to an alternative dispute resolution system, against a health care provider regardless of the theory of liability on which the claim is based. . . .28

28Id., Sec. 8(7).

Importantly, H.R. 1215 defines "health care provider" to include a person or entity licensed or certified to provide health care services, which could include hospitals, surgery centers, nursing homes, assisted living facilities, rehabilitation facilities, and insurance companies. Although it is often described as a "medical malpractice" measure, H.R. 1215 is not limited to medical malpractice lawsuits because its health care lawsuit definition covers all "health care liability claims," including claims based on the provision of medical products by a health care provider, and to "any theory of liability on which the claim is based," including those based on actions taken by drug and medical device manufacturers, nursing homes, insurance companies, and health maintenance organizations.

Finally, although H.R. 1215's proponents may assert the bill is narrower than its predecessors, it is, in fact, almost as broad. The definition of "health care lawsuit" attempts to limit the bill's scope to claims arising from Federal Government-subsidized health insurance programs, such as Medicare, Medicaid, the ACA, and veterans health plans. If anything, the addition of this language to the definition of "health care lawsuit" means that the bill's onerous provisions would be particularly targeted at claims by the elderly, the poor, veterans, and other vulnerable groups, who disproportionately depend on government-subsidized health insurance.

Given the bill's broad scope, including its potential application to claims for abuse or negligence against nursing homes and long-term care facilities, Representative Hank Johnson (D-GA) offered an amendment that would have exempted from H.R. 1215's unjustified and burdensome provisions all claims concerning nursing homes and long-term care facilities. The Committee, however, rejected this amendment by a party-line vote of 13 to 15.29

29Markup Tr. at 101.

III. H.R. 1215 RESTRICTS HEALTH CARE LAWSUITS THAT WILL DIMINISH OR COMPLETELY BLOCK VICTIMS' ABILITY TO BE COMPENSATED FOR THEIR INJURIES.

A. LH.R. 1215 Provides Unjustifiable Immunity for Health Care Providers Who Dispense Defective or Dangerous Pharmaceuticals or Medical Devices.

H.R. 1215 threatens to undermine the ability of victims of defective or dangerous medical products, including prescription pharmaceuticals and medical devices, to be made whole. The bill adds a new provision, not contained in previous iterations of this measure, that gives a complete liability shield for health care providers who provide defective or dangerous products to a plaintiff if such product was "approved, licensed, or cleared by the Food and Drug Administration."30 Specifically, this provision prohibits any health care provider from even being named in any lawsuit concerning the prescribing or dispensing of a drug or medical device under such circumstances. Moreover, a health care provider cannot be held liable in any product liability class action against a manufacturer of such defective or dangerous drug or medical device.

30H.R. 1215, 115th Cong. Sec. 7 (2017) (as amended).

This provision could prevent victims from receiving just compensation for injuries in many cases. For example, where the health care provider is also the manufacturer of the defective or dangerous product, such as in the case of certain pharmacists, the victim may be left without someone to sue for his or her injury. Similarly, where a manufacturer successfully shifts blame onto the provider for negligent dispensing or use of a drug or device, a victim may lose any access to restitution since she cannot sue the provider. This excessively broad liability shield for health care providers--which, effectively, could also provide legal protection for drug and device manufacturers--is both unjust and unjustifiable. B. LH.R. 1215 Imposes an Excessively Short Statute of Limitations Period.

H.R. 1215 imposes an extremely restrictive statute of limitations for medical malpractice actions that significantly reduces the time that an injured person has to file a lawsuit. It provides that "the time for the commencement of a health care lawsuit shall be no later than 3 years after the date of injury or 1 year after the claimant discovers, or through the use of reasonable diligence should have discovered, the injury, whichever occurs first."31 The effect of this language is that a victim has, at most, 3 years, and as little as 1 year, to file suit.

31Id., Sec. 2 (emphasis added).

Although disguised as a 3-year statute of limitations, the effect of this provision is that the claimant often has exactly 1 year from the date of discovering the injury to file suit. A claimant will, quite often, "discover" an injury on the same day or shortly after an injury occurs. This provision also cuts in the opposite direction, hindering patients who are injured by diseases with long latency periods. For example, a patient who was infected with HIV through a negligent blood transfusion may not discover his injury until more than 3 years after the date of the injury because the symptoms of his injury may manifest more than 3 years after the negligent transfusion. To the extent that the bill's statute of limitations period is shorter than those currently available under state law, it works to deny victims their day in court.

C. LH.R. 1215 Makes It Harder for Victims To Obtain Adequate Legal Representation.

H.R. 1215 severely limits the amount an attorney may receive in the form of contingency fee payments. Contingency fee arrangements--where attorneys forgo immediate payment in exchange for a share of the damages if a plaintiff prevails in court--serve a useful and essential function in the legal system.32 Because contingency fee agreements require little or no money up front, injured plaintiffs who could not otherwise afford legal representation have access to counsel. In short, competent legal representation comes at a cost and H.R. 1215 would undermine the ability of plaintiffs to obtain such legal representation. Moreover, because attorneys who take losing cases are paid little or nothing for their efforts, contingency fees also serve as a screening mechanism for "frivolous" cases.33

32See Herbert M. Kritzer, Lawyer Fees and Lawyer Behavior in Litigation: What does the Empirical Literature Really Say?, 80 TEX. L. REV. 1943 (2002); Herbert M. Kritzer, Economic Policy Litigation Conference Seven Dogged Myths Concerning Contingency Fees, 80 WASH. U. L.Q. 739 (Fall 2002).

33Id.

H.R. 1215 would sharply erode the incentives provided by contingency fee arrangements and threaten the ability of injured plaintiffs to obtain legal representation by capping the total amount of all contingent fees for representing all claimants in a health care lawsuit to: (1) 40 percent of the first $50,000 recovered by the claimant(s), (2) 331/3 percent of the next $50,000 recovered by the claimant(s), (3) 25 percent of the next $500,000 recovered by the claimant(s), and (4) 15 percent of any amount by which the recovery by the claimant(s) is in excess of $600,000. The bill also authorizes the courts to approve fees lower than those provided for by this formula in cases involving a minor or incompetent person. This provision is clearly intended to dis-incentivize lawyers from taking health care cases and thereby make it harder for plaintiffs to have their day in court.

D. LBy Eliminating Joint and Several Liability for Economic and Noneconomic Damages, H.R. 1215 Makes It Very Difficult for Victims in Health Care Lawsuits To Be Made Whole.

H.R. 1215 eliminates joint and several liability for economic and noneconomic loss. Joint liability ensures that injured patients are fully compensated for their losses by allowing one lawsuit to be brought against multiple defendants and having the defendants apportion fault among them. The doctrine is designed to ensure that victims of wrongful conduct are able to recover the full amount of damages for their injuries, especially when one or more of the defendants is insolvent. Many states recognize joint and several liability based on the principle that it is the injured patient, rather than the multiple negligent providers, who rightly should be given the greatest measure of protection under the law. By eliminating joint and several liability, H.R. 1215 threatens the ability of plaintiffs to be made whole.

Given the harm to victims that would result from eliminating joint and several liability, Representative Jamie Raskin (D-MD) offered an amendment to strike this provision from the bill. The Committee, however, rejected this amendment by a party-line vote of 14 to 16.34

34Markup Tr. at 199.

E. LH.R. 1215 Unjustifiably Caps Noneconomic Damages, Which Will Have a Disproportionately Adverse Impact on Women, the Poor, and Other Vulnerable Groups.

H.R. 1215 caps noneconomic damages at an aggregate amount of $250,000, regardless of the total number of defendants or claims brought with respect to the same injury. Noneconomic damages, such as those for pain and suffering and loss of consortium, compensate victims for real injuries such as the loss of sight, loss of a limb, severe disfigurement, and loss of fertility. As a result of such an extremely restrictive cap on noneconomic damages, many victims injured as a result of medical malpractice of defective medical products will be denied full compensation. Women, children, the poor, the elderly, and the disabled will be particularly hurt by H.R. 1215's cap on noneconomic damages because they may have less substantial amounts of lost wages or other kinds of economic loss that must be documented for an award of economic damages.

Representative Jerrold Nadler (D-NY) explained that he would have offered two amendments to increase this $250,000 cap, a level that he noted was set more than 40 years ago in a California statute. One amendment would have indexed the $250,000 cap to inflation and the other would have increased the cap to reflect the present value of $250,000 in 1975 dollars and then indexed that amount to inflation.35 In the interest of time, however, he did not offer these amendments.

35Id. at 63-64.

F. LH.R. 1215 Inequitably Imposes the Risk of Loss on Victims Rather than Wrongdoers.

H.R. 1215 provides that, upon request of a party, payments of future damages--i.e., damages accrued after judgment, settlement, or resolution of the case--in excess of $50,000 may be made in periodic payments rather than a lump sum payment to victims. Periodic payment plans allow a negligent party to stall while the patient assumes the risk of loss. The defendant (or the defendant's insurance company) can, in the meantime, invest and earn interest on the compensation owed to the patient. If a defendant files for bankruptcy--or simply refuses to pay--it is the patient's responsibility to retain counsel and press the matter in court. This would be an unjust outcome.

IV. H.R. 1215 PROVIDES NO EXCEPTIONS TO ITS ONEROUS PROVISIONS FOR THOSE WHO HAVE SUFFERED EVEN THE MOST HORRIFIC INJURIES OR ARE THE VICTIMS OF THE WORST KINDS OF MISCONDUCT.

H.R. 1215's onerous requirements apply even in cases where a health care provider has intentionally harmed a patient or when the medical error is especially egregious. For instance, the bill's extremely low cap on noneconomic damages would likely prevent full compensation for a child who has been sexually molested by a health care provider, a woman who had a healthy breast removed after a misdiagnosis of breast cancer, or a low-income person who had the wrong leg amputated by a surgeon. The bill's other provisions would likewise make it far less likely that victims of such egregious medical misconduct will be fully compensated for their injuries or even have their day in court.

For the foregoing reasons, Ranking Member John Conyers, Jr. (D-MI) offered an amendment that would have exempted from H.R. 1215 all health care claims arising from an intentional tort. At a minimum, the bill's onerous provisions should not apply with respect to the most egregious kinds of conduct, such as rape, sexual assault, or other intentional harm caused by a health care provider. This amendment would have avoided the bill's many obstacles to justice for victims at least in cases where the underlying conduct was most serious and grave. Unfortunately, the Committee rejected this amendment by a party-line vote of 12 to 16.36

36Id. at 63.

Representative Sheila Jackson Lee (D-TX) offered an amendment that would have exempted from H.R. 1215 all cases concerning irreversible injury. At a minimum, victims of medical malpractice or defective medical products who suffer severe and permanent injury should be able to seek justice in court without the unnecessary and unjustified burdens imposed by this bill. Notwithstanding this concern, the Committee rejected this amendment by a party-line vote of 14 to 19.37

37Id. at 132.

Similarly, Constitution and Civil Justice Subcommittee Ranking Member Steve Cohen (D-TN) offered an amendment to exempt from H.R. 1215 all cases arising from a claim of wrong- site, wrong-patient surgery or where a device had been left inside of a patient. As with the intentional tort exemption, this narrow amendment would have provided relief from the bill's onerous and unfair provisions for victims of particularly egregious medical errors, such as cases where the wrong body part had been amputated or where the wrong patient was operated on through the negligence of a health care provider. Notwithstanding these concerns, the Committee rejected this amendment by a party-line vote of 12 to 16.38

38Id. at 87.

Finally, Representative Eric Swalwell (D-CA) offered an amendment to exempt from H.R. 1215 all cases concerning the provision of goods or services for treatment of an injury sustained by a rape or sexual assault victim as a result of such rape or sexual assault. This amendment would have protected victims of such horrific crimes from being further victimized by the bill's many hurdles to compensation for medical injuries. The Committee, however, rejected this amendment by a party-line vote of 13 to 17.39

39Id. at 183.

CONCLUSION

While House Republicans appear to proffer H.R. 1215 as part of their effort to "repeal and replace" the ACA and that law's guarantee of adequate and affordable health insurance coverage for all Americans, the bill actually undermines those goals by heightening the risks of harm to patients and consumers of medical products. It does this by significantly undermining their ability to pursue a case in court and by imposing various restrictions on victims' ability to be fully compensated for their injuries, making it harder to hold wrongdoers accountable and to deter future misconduct. Additionally, the bill represents a deep intrusion into state sovereignty as state legislatures and state courts traditionally set the rules governing tort liability. For these reasons, and those articulated above, we strongly oppose H.R. 1215.

Mr. Conyers, Jr.

Mr. Nadler.

Ms. Lofgren.

Ms. Jackson Lee.

Mr. Cohen.

Mr. Johnson, Jr.

Mr. Deutch.

Mr. Gutierrez.

Ms. Bass.

Mr. Richmond.

Mr. Jeffries.

Mr. Cicilline.

Mr. Swalwell.

Mr. Lieu.

Mr. Raskin.

Ms. Jayapal.

Myron Struck, editor, Targeted News Service, Springfield, Va., 703/304-1897; editor@targetednews.com; http://www.targetednews.com

-1298520

Older

EDITORIAL: Moving on: Who’ll fix Obamacare now?

Newer

House Energy & Commerce Committee Issues Report on Affordable Care Act

Advisor News

  • What will Democrats in Congress do about healthcare and retirement?
  • Election results cloud retirement legislation outlook, experts say
  • Planning for the missing chapter
  • Semi-retirement: helping clients balance flexibility with financial security
  • The 6X Formula for leveraging content marketing with AI
More Advisor News

Annuity News

  • Jackson Launches Direct-to-Consumer Annuity Offering
  • Global Atlantic launches ForeIncome Flex
  • Athene CEO criticizes offshore reinsurance, risk-taking by competitors
  • DOL, trade groups, state AGs file briefs supporting Alcoa in PRT lawsuit
  • John Hancock launches new fixed indexed annuity suite
More Annuity News

Health/Employee Benefits News

  • What will Democrats in Congress do about healthcare and retirement?
  • Forms, phone calls and portals: The hidden work that keeps American institutions functioning burdens parents most
  • Health Plans Expect Double-Digit Premium Increases Again in 2027
  • Best’s Special Report: Rising Costs Could Offset AI-Driven Efficiency Gains at US Health Insurers
  • Free Medicare counseling provided through LTADD
More Health/Employee Benefits News

Life Insurance News

  • California’s new solvency rules: What should life insurance advisors watch?
  • Navigating delayed death certificates: A guide for life insurance advisors
  • Jackson Launches Direct-to-Consumer Annuity Offering
  • Best’s Market Segment Report: AM Best Maintains Stable Outlook on New Zealand’s Non-Life Insurance Segment
  • AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Fubon Insurance Vietnam Co., Ltd.
More Life Insurance News

NEWS INSIDE

  • Companies
  • Earnings
  • Economic News
  • INN Magazine
  • Insurtech News
  • Newswires Feed
  • Regulation News
  • Washington Wire
  • Videos

FEATURED OFFERS

Press Releases

  • OpenRoad Insurance Data Shows 40% of Collector Vehicles Are Model Year 1980 or Newer
  • Insurvoice Lets Independent Insurance Agency Owners Analyze Every Customer Call in ChatGPT or Claude
  • Spectrum Weather & Specialty Insurance Celebrates 15 Years and Welcomes the Next Generation
  • Royal Neighbors of America® Increases Service Capacity
  • Benefits Studio Launches to Fill the Missing Middle of Benefits Navigation at $49/mo
More Press Releases > Add Your Press Release >

How to Write For InsuranceNewsNet

Find out how you can submit content for publishing on our website.
View Guidelines

Topics

  • Advisor News
  • Annuity Index
  • Annuity News
  • Companies
  • Earnings
  • Fiduciary
  • From the Field: Expert Insights
  • Health/Employee Benefits
  • Insurance & Financial Fraud
  • INN Magazine
  • Insiders Only
  • Life Insurance News
  • Newswires
  • Property and Casualty
  • Regulation News
  • Sponsored Articles
  • Washington Wire
  • Videos
  • ———
  • About
  • Meet our Editorial Staff
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Newsletters

Top Sections

  • AdvisorNews
  • Annuity News
  • Health/Employee Benefits News
  • InsuranceNewsNet Magazine
  • Life Insurance News
  • Property and Casualty News
  • Washington Wire

Our Company

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Meet our Editorial Staff
  • Magazine Subscription
  • Write for INN

Sign up for our FREE e-Newsletter!

Get breaking news, exclusive stories, and money- making insights straight into your inbox.

select Newsletter Options
Facebook Linkedin Twitter
© 2026 InsuranceNewsNet.com, Inc. All rights reserved.
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • InsuranceNewsNet Magazine

Sign in with your Insider Pro Account

Not registered? Become an Insider Pro.