Flouting consumer law, insurers refuse to pay medical bills for emergency care
Over the past two years, Flight for Life has airlifted car crash victims, premature babies and adults struggling to breathe to hospitals across southeastern
The amounts due for each emergency medical flight range from
"It was like a faucet they just shut off," said Flight for Life's executive director,
The insurer's willful nonpayment is the latest in a cascade of unintended consequences brought about by a widely supported law that was intended to protect patients from surprise medical bills.
The law, which took effect in 2022, calls for arbitrators to decide appropriate levels of reimbursement, and it has already triggered millions of disputes between medical care providers and insurers. Doctors have prevailed overwhelmingly, winning arbitration settlements that sometimes far exceeded the usual insurer rates.
Now, fed up with what they consider unfair outcomes, insurers are fighting back by refusing to pay.
The law, the No Surprises Act, was enacted with a large bipartisan majority to ensure patients never got excessive bills in situations, like emergencies, in which they could not pick their doctors.
The arbitration system set up by the law was supposed to resolve billing disputes when healthcare providers and insurers could not agree on a price: An arbitrator reviews a proposed dollar amount from each side and decides which one is most reasonable. Insurers are required to pay that amount within 30 days, and billing patients for anything beyond that is prohibited.
Lawmakers expected the system to be used rarely and to produce reasonable payments. Instead, doctors and other healthcare providers have been swamping arbitrators with millions of claims, often for amounts that far exceed what is customarily paid for a service. And they have won the vast majority of their cases - sometimes receiving sums such as
Insurers have sued doctors and lobbied
But with
Nearly 30% of arbitration awards has gone unpaid since 2024, according to an analysis of 400,000 such awards provided by a major medical billing firm that The New York Times reviewed.
The standoff has created dysfunction and lawlessness in a system that a growing number of lawmakers and administration officials say needs to be changed.
"The providers are succeeding in what feel like egregious award levels, and then the insurers are also doing some of this egregious behavior by not paying," said
Health plans, including
Most large health insurers told the
In the case of Flight for Life,
"More providers are submitting ineligible cases because ineligible cases aren't being dismissed like they should be," he said.
A spokesperson for the
Doctors and air ambulance companies have turned to the courts, filing hundreds of lawsuits to enforce the arbitrators' decisions, but three federal appeals courts have ruled that the No Surprises Act does not include a right to sue.
‘We just want
to get paid'
Doctors have said that the nonpayments make it hard to manage their practices. Some who have built their businesses around the arbitration system and its high payouts, have taken on debts to stay afloat.
Dr.
In January, it had to take out a line of credit to make payroll.
"We just want to get paid what we need to pay the people who saw the patients," she said.
PHI, a national air ambulance company, recently closed a base in
In an interview, PHI's chief executive,
"The insurance companies cannot unilaterally decide to breach a federal law if they don't like the end result," McCarty said. "That's essentially what they are doing."
The 400,000 claims that HaloMD shared with the
HaloMD spokesperson
The law set up a series of deadlines and procedures that doctors need to follow. They limited access to the system to certain situations. Cases in which the patient has a government plan, like Medicare or Medicaid, are not eligible. Nor are situations where the doctor already has a contract with the health plan.
But insurers expressed frustration that the system incentivizes arbitrators to find claims eligible. They get paid a flat fee for each dispute they resolve. If they rule a case is ineligible, they earn nothing.
New movement
in
The No Surprises Act gives the Trump administration authority to fine health insurers
Doctors have submitted hundreds of complaints about unpaid awards to the
"There has to be some enforcement," said
Spokespeople for both CMS and the
A Trump administration spokesperson told the
Sen.
Rep.
Pallone has been skeptical of arbitration supporting it as part of a compromise to get the surprise billing ban passed. He said the reality was even more chaotic than he had predicted. "We have the proof with the facts that shows that this arbitration system is out of hand," he said.
This article originally appeared in The New York Times.
Distributed by Newsbank, inc.


Best’s Market Segment Report: Health and Property Lines of Business Drive Hong Kong’s Non-Life Insurance Growth
Mark Cuban says he can lower NJ prescription drug prices
Advisor News
- Election results cloud retirement legislation outlook, experts say
- Planning for the missing chapter
- Semi-retirement: helping clients balance flexibility with financial security
- The 6X Formula for leveraging content marketing with AI
- When a home becomes difficult to insure, the plan changes
More Advisor NewsAnnuity News
- Jackson Launches Direct-to-Consumer Annuity Offering
- Global Atlantic launches ForeIncome Flex
- Athene CEO criticizes offshore reinsurance, risk-taking by competitors
- DOL, trade groups, state AGs file briefs supporting Alcoa in PRT lawsuit
- John Hancock launches new fixed indexed annuity suite
More Annuity NewsHealth/Employee Benefits News
- Soaring drug costs squeeze largest Mass. insurer, fueling $43.5M loss
- Health insurers leave Ohio marketplace
- Rising hospital, drug costs boost health insurance premiums at fastest pace since start of Obamacare
- Patients with 3 health insurance plans lose access to Miami health network
- Weld County deputy struggling after being injured by DUI driver (photo gallery)
More Health/Employee Benefits NewsLife Insurance News
- Navigating delayed death certificates: A guide for life insurance advisors
- Jackson Launches Direct-to-Consumer Annuity Offering
- Best’s Market Segment Report: AM Best Maintains Stable Outlook on New Zealand’s Non-Life Insurance Segment
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Fubon Insurance Vietnam Co., Ltd.
- Three lawsuits put life insurers’ cost-of-insurance practices under scrutiny
More Life Insurance News