Dismissed: Wisconsin Veterans Affairs official who weathered harassment allegations fired under Evers
The 66-year-old
The incidents leading to those dismissals, along with other problems from his career, were detailed in Nitschke's 1,750-page personnel file, obtained by the Cap Times under the state's open records law.
The March incident that precipitated his second dismissal occurred when Nitschke was serving as commandant -- the top post -- at Union Grove Veterans Home making
The
Nitschke appealed the decision, according to his attorney,
Despite compiling a lengthy personnel file and facing discipline for an incident involving fellow employees, Nitschke was rehired and repeatedly promoted in a state agency that has come under scrutiny for its treatment of nursing home residents and staff.
At
Rice defended Nitschke's tenure at the agency, saying his length of service there was due to Nistschke being "an accomplished administrator" who oversaw financial successes at the
"I can assure you that
Statement
"I can assure you that
Meanwhile, DVA spokeswoman
"We want the veterans who live here to be proud to call this place 'home,'" she added in the statement.
Nitschke's history at DVA
Nitschke's personnel file indicates he started at DVA in
The reason for his termination is unclear and not laid out in his personnel file. But media reports from around that time show Nitschke filed a complaint with the state Equal Rights Division following his firing. He argued that Black -- who is
Nitschke also filed suit in federal court, a case that was later settled in fall 2012 for
The original federal complaint, from
The complaint also cited a
Black faced other lawsuits alleging he phased out an employee and declined to hire someone else because of their race and age. He resigned his post in
In
Nitschke's next few years were largely without incident. In
It also characterized his accomplishments -- such as improved
Both reviews called for improved communication, though the more recent one was more pointed in its critique. Although it praised Nitschke as "innovative and resourceful," it suggested Nitschke make "some improvement on self-development," and demonstrating leadership in engaging with staff. The document shows Nitschke disagreed.
Rice, Nitschke's attorney, said his client's time at the agency featured "many positive things" while he labored "in a very regulated and underfunded operation ... providing quality care and a positive work environment."
He added that when taking Nitschke's full history into account at DVA, "his positive contributions significantly outweighed the negative perceptions or events that come with the territory."
Harassment allegations
For Nitschke, the close of 2015 was marked by a ban from driving state-owned vehicles and a three-day suspension following an investigation into harassment allegations made against him.
The investigation centered on "potentially intimidating, harassing and threatening communications," according to a
Nitschke made what state investigators determined were false allegations that a former Veterans Affairs deputy secretary,
Both Trepanier and Nikolai, who later filed a discrimination complaint against the agency, denied the charges. In fact, Nikolai alleges it was Nitschke who had been harassing her.
"
Specifically, Nikolai's complaint -- later dismissed -- argued that Nitschke "began a campaign of unlawful sexual harassment" against her in 2014 that included hundreds of "personal text messages which were inappropriately personal and intimate."
Following the Nitschke investigation, Nikolai's complaint said she was reassigned to "less desirable duties and circumstances on at least two separate occasions." She was also investigated by the agency for allegedly disclosing personal contact information of another
The ban on Nitschke's use of state cars came about after a number of violations or "at-fault accidents in the past two years," according to a letter from the state. Nitschke appealed the ban, but lost.
Nitschke's performance review from around that time --
But it noted Nitschke could improve in "recognizing boundaries in his conversations with colleagues and subordinates, to avoid over-sharing information that other employees sometimes find too personal."
In
'I handled it my way'
The incident that led to Nitschke's firing this summer took place at
While that March incident precipitated his dismissal, it was closely tied to a separate one that happened at
During the party, the resident's wife and two sons were visiting him at Boland Hall, a three-story building on the eastern edge of campus. As the family entered an elevator, one of the sons began swearing, prompting a nurse to intervene and urge him to "keep the Christmas spirit going," according to multiple witness interviews included in Nitschke's personnel file.
The son continued swearing, repeatedly called the nurse a "black bitch" and flipped her off as he left the elevator with his family and went to his father's room.The family members' names are redacted in the file.
As the nurse took a break to compose herself, two employees headed to the resident's room, where they were told that staff was lazy and that the room's bathroom wasn't clean -- complaints one staffer called "a diversion tactic." The other staffer described the family's comments as "verbally violent" and said the sons "were very loud and agitated."
Nitschke then entered the room with security in tow. He introduced himself, shook hands with the family members and pledged to "take care of your concerns," according to a staffer present, which calmed the family.
But he never asked them to leave campus. When the nurse who was shouted at returned to the floor following her break, she discovered administrators and security had already left the area though the family remained.
When the family left, the nurse said one of the sons again swore at her, flipped her off and called her a "black bitch." The comments were overheard by a therapist working that day. Shaken up, the nurse was unable to leave because her supervisor said she had no one to cover for her.
"My anxiety is on 10 and I'm just worried that he'll come up here while I'm working and can anyone guarantee my safety?" her supervisor recalled her saying. The nurse took time off work following the incident.
Safety
"My anxiety is on 10 and I'm just worried that he'll come up here while I'm working and can anyone guarantee my safety?"
In subsequent interviews, other staffers complained about how Nitschke handled the situation and lamented the lack of a staff debriefing. While HR didn't interview Nitschke immediately following the incident, he later denied knowing that racist language was part of it.
"There are some employees that felt I didn't handle it right," he told investigators in May. "They thought I knew everything (that) happened, that they were in the elevator making racial comments."
He also said: "Staff felt I should have been tough and thrown them out. I handled it my way."
Five days after the incident, on
An email from a DVA nursing director to staff nearly a week after the incident warned employees not to confront the sons if they returned to the campus. Instead, the directive said, "the police should be called as they aren't allowed on the property." Nitschke said he repeated the order when he conducted in-person "welfare rounds" with staffers.
A 'lack of response'
The family didn't abide by the "no trespassing" orders for long.
Three months after the Christmas party, one of the sons showed up with his mother at Boland Hall in what staff described as a disguise: a hat supporting President
"It was a big red flag," one supervisor told investigators regarding the son's appearance.
While the timeline is muddled, the staffer recalled first seeing the son around
In the intervening period, five supervisors, along with Nitschke, were notified that the son could be at Boland. But an investigation summary in Nitschke's personnel file shows no one, including Nitschke, followed the directive to call 911 immediately. In fact, Nitschke reportedly advised a staffer to not call 911 and said he'd handle the situation himself.
One official -- Deputy Commandant
A nurse involved in the December incident later slammed the deputy's response in her investigatory interview, saying: "My black coworkers were told to go hide in a closet. This is like a movie. Don't serve sub sandwiches and act like the sandwiches are more important than us."
After he was initially notified, Nitschke experienced a few delays in getting to the resident's room because he was in a meeting. When he arrived, he asked the son to identify himself and mentioned the "no trespassing" order. A witness told investigators the wife and son both "got hostile" and called Nitschke "a dirty old man," due to the past harassment allegations. Nitschke then left the floor and later called 911, per the investigation summary.
Other staffers reported seeing the wife and son leaving the resident's room. Both of them got on the elevator, but only the wife exited it on the main floor and employees "could not figure out where (the son) got off and went," witnesses told investigators.
One staffer reported hearing someone say loudly and repeatedly that he would "kill the (n-words)" as he was entering the elevator. She told investigators she tried to report the threat to supervisors at a meeting later that day, but "no one let me speak and say what I heard."
Ultimately, the son left the building and joined his mother in the car in the parking lot where he called the police non-emergency line at
The resident no longer lives at
Denying blame
Nitschke was put on paid leave just two days after the March incident, a suspension that continued until his dismissal in June. In interviews with administrative officials, he maintained that he appropriately handled the situation.
"My intention was never to leave (the meeting)," he said in a
While Nitschke argued it only took him five to 10 minutes to report to the resident's room after he was first notified, investigators concluded it's "likely" that it took more than an hour for Nitschke to respond to the incident.
"The fact that [the son] was in disguise and not positively identified does not mitigate Nitschke's extended delay in contacting the police," the summary noted.
Still, Nitschke denied the assertion that he didn't call 911 immediately, telling officials he did "as soon as I verified it" and positively identified the son.
The issue was complicated by the fact that "a large portion" of
Nitschke, in his interviews, placed blame on other management officials, including Bruce, his deputy commandant, for failing to properly respond to the issue. During his first interview, Nitschke said he was planning to investigate why his subordinates didn't follow the "chain of command policy."
"Why didn't they handle it? Why didn't the layers of supervisors handle it?" he asked.
The deputy was also investigated in a separate probe for potentially violating three work rules by failing to comply with the "no trespassing" order and putting employees' and residents' safety at risk, according to DVA. But she resigned over the summer, before the investigation ran its course.
Officials didn't hire anyone to fill her position and the campus no longer has a deputy commandant, Vigue of DVA said, "due to a reorganized structure." But the agency has brought on
She started in the role
Safety, security improvements at
In the weeks after the March incident, when Nitschke was on paid leave, officials began to make changes to beef up security protocols at the veterans home, according to Nitschke's personnel file.
Meanwhile, staff and the agency are grappling with
The facility's two-star rating -- out of five -- is based on health inspections, staffing and quality of care measures. The health inspection score was the lowest, with one star or "much below average," while staffing was at five stars and resident care was four.
The investigation, in part, sought to explore "steps we can take to prevent such incidents from happening in the future," according to an email DVA Deputy Secretary
A few employees in their interviews with administration officials last spring cited security concerns. One nursing supervisor on
"We fear for our members of color as well," she told investigators.
Some of the changes implemented earlier this year include updating the security access code for the entrances, which some staffers said in interviews with investigators had been the same for years and were known by former employees.
The facility also hired an additional security position to supplement the original two guards, Bruce told management during an early April interview. They're tasked with monitoring the front desk and walking the campus to keep an eye on things, she said.
Immediately after the incident, employees also noted that maintenance workers were coming in early to sit in the parking lot during shift changes to help bolster employee safety.
Additionally, the
Vigue, the DVA spokeswoman, stressed the importance of employee satisfaction to the agency and the long-term care industry as a whole.
"Our staff is very proud of what they do, deservedly so," she said. "We do all we can to ensure they have a place where they enjoy working."
___
(c)2019 The Wisconsin State Journal (Madison, Wis.)
Visit The Wisconsin State Journal (Madison, Wis.) at www.wisconsinstatejournal.com
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.


Morgan 911 employees to receive bonus
Ownership transition underway at Fladeboe Financial in Willmar
Advisor News
- Election results cloud retirement legislation outlook, experts say
- Planning for the missing chapter
- Semi-retirement: helping clients balance flexibility with financial security
- The 6X Formula for leveraging content marketing with AI
- When a home becomes difficult to insure, the plan changes
More Advisor NewsAnnuity News
- Athene CEO criticizes offshore reinsurance, risk-taking by competitors
- DOL, trade groups, state AGs file briefs supporting Alcoa in PRT lawsuit
- John Hancock launches new fixed indexed annuity suite
- Annuities to play a larger role in workplace retirement plans
- FHLBank Pittsburgh Announces Results in 2026 Board Election
More Annuity NewsHealth/Employee Benefits News
- Health insurers leave Ohio marketplace
- Rising hospital, drug costs boost health insurance premiums at fastest pace since start of Obamacare
- Patients with 3 health insurance plans lose access to Miami health network
- Weld County deputy struggling after being injured by DUI driver (photo gallery)
- Changes to Medicare Advantage plan offerings affect Montana seniors
More Health/Employee Benefits NewsLife Insurance News
- Best’s Market Segment Report: AM Best Maintains Stable Outlook on New Zealand’s Non-Life Insurance Segment
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Fubon Insurance Vietnam Co., Ltd.
- Three lawsuits put life insurers’ cost-of-insurance practices under scrutiny
- Military Briefs: November 12-18
- Security Benefit Series B Preferred Stock Dividend Rate Resets to 10.286%
More Life Insurance News