Affordability of Employer Coverage for Family Members of Employees
Final regulations.
CFR Part: "26 CFR Part 1"
RIN Number: "RIN 1545-BQ16"
Citation: "87 FR 61979"
Document Number: "TD 9968"
Page Number: "61979"
"Rules and Regulations"
Agency: "
SUMMARY: This document contains final regulations under section 36B of the Internal Revenue Code (Code) that amend the regulations regarding eligibility for the premium tax credit (PTC) to provide that affordability of employer-sponsored minimum essential coverage (employer coverage) for family members of an employee is determined based on the employee's share of the cost of covering the employee and those family members, not the cost of covering only the employee. The final regulations also add a minimum value rule for family members of employees based on the benefits provided to the family members. The final regulations affect taxpayers who enroll, or enroll a family member, in individual health insurance coverage through a Health Insurance Exchange (Exchange) and who may be allowed a PTC for the coverage.
DATES:
These final regulations are effective on
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Background
I. Overview This document amends the Income Tax Regulations (26 CFR part 1) under section 36B of the Code. On
These final regulations provide that, for purposes of determining eligibility for PTC, affordability of employer coverage for individuals eligible to enroll in the coverage because of their relationship to an employee of the employer (related individuals) is determined based on the employee's share of the cost of covering the employee and the related individuals. As further explained in the Summary of Comments and Explanation of Revisions, the affordability rule for related individuals in these final regulations represents the better reading of the relevant statutes and is consistent with
FOOTNOTE 1 The term ACA in this preamble means the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, Pub. L. 111-148, 124 Stat. 119 (2010), as amended by the Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010, Pub. L. 111-152, 124 Stat. 1029 (2010). END FOOTNOTE
II. Eligibility for Employer Coverage Under Section 36B
Section 36B provides a PTC for applicable taxpayers who meet certain eligibility requirements, including that a member of the taxpayer's family enrolls in a qualified health plan through an Exchange (QHP or Exchange coverage) for one or more "coverage months." Under
Section 1.36B-3(d)(1) provides that the PTC for a coverage month is the lesser of: (i) the premiums for the month, reduced by any amounts that were refunded, for one or more QHPs in which a taxpayer or a member of the taxpayer's family enrolls (enrollment premiums); or (ii) the excess of the adjusted monthly premium for the applicable benchmark plan over 1/12 of the product of a taxpayer's household income and the applicable percentage for the taxable year (taxpayer's contribution amount).
Under section 36B(c)(2)(B) and
Section 36B(c)(2)(C) generally provides that an individual is not treated as eligible for employer coverage if the coverage offered is unaffordable or does not provide minimum value. However, if the individual enrolls in employer coverage, the individual is eligible for MEC, irrespective of whether the employer coverage is affordable or provides minimum value. See section 36B(c)(2)(C)(iii) and
Under the affordability test in section 36B(c)(2)(C)(i)(II), an employee who does not enroll in employer coverage is not treated as eligible for the coverage if "the employee's required contribution (within the meaning of section 5000A(e)(1)(B)) with respect to the plan exceeds 9.5 percent of the applicable taxpayer's household income." /2/ The flush language following this provision provides that "[t]his clause shall also apply to an individual who is eligible to enroll in the plan by reason of a relationship the individual bears to the employee."
FOOTNOTE 2 This required contribution percentage of 9.5 is indexed annually under section 36B(c)(2)(C)(iv). For simplicity, this preamble refers to 9.5 percent as the required contribution percentage. END FOOTNOTE
Section 5000A generally requires applicable individuals /3/ to make an individual shared responsibility payment /4/ with their tax return if they do not maintain minimum essential coverage for themselves and any dependents. Section 5000A(e)(1) establishes exemptions from the individual shared responsibility payment that would otherwise apply for "individuals who cannot afford coverage," which the statute defines in section 5000A(e)(1)(A) to be applicable individuals whose required contribution for coverage exceeds a specified percentage of their household income. Section 5000A(e)(1)(B)(i) provides that, for an employee eligible to purchase employer coverage, the term "required contribution" means "the portion of the annual premium which would be paid by the individual . . . for self-only coverage." For related individuals, the definition of "required contribution" in section 5000A(e)(1)(B)(i) is modified by a "special rule" in section 5000A(e)(1)(C). Section 5000A(e)(1)(C) provides that "[f]or purposes of [section 5000A(e)(1)](B)(i), if an applicable individual is eligible for minimum essential coverage through an employer by reason of a relationship to an employee, the determination [of affordability] under subparagraph (A) shall be made by reference to [the] required contribution of the employee." The regulations under section 5000A interpret section 5000A(e)(1)(C) as modifying the required contribution rule in section 5000A(e)(1)(B)(i) regarding coverage for related individuals to take into account the cost of covering the employee and the related individuals, not just the employee. Specifically, for related individuals,
FOOTNOTE 3 Section 5000A(d)(1) defines an applicable individual as any individual other than an individual with a religious conscience exemption, an individual who is not lawfully present or an individual who is incarcerated. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 4 Public Law 115-97 (2017), commonly referred to as the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, reduced the individual shared responsibility payment amount to zero for months beginning after
FOOTNOTE 5 For purposes of this exemption for unaffordable coverage, an employee or related individual who is otherwise exempt under
In contrast to the affordability rule for related individuals in
FOOTNOTE 6 Section 1.36B-1(m) defines family coverage as health insurance that covers more than one individual and provides coverage for the essential health benefits as defined in section 1302(b)(1) of the ACA. END FOOTNOTE
When the 2013 regulations were issued, the
As noted above, section 36B(c)(2)(C) generally provides that an individual is not treated as eligible for employer coverage if the coverage offered is unaffordable or does not provide minimum value. An eligible employer-sponsored plan provides minimum value under section 36B(c)(2)(C)(ii) and
On
III. E.O. 14009
On
IV. Proposed Regulations
On
The proposed regulations would not change the affordability rule for employees. As required by statute, employees have an offer of affordable employer coverage if the employee's required contribution for self-only coverage of the employee does not exceed the required contribution percentage of household income.
The proposed regulations also addressed the minimum value rules in section 36B. Under the proposed regulations, a separate minimum value rule would be provided for related individuals that is based on the level of coverage provided to related individuals under an eligible employer-sponsored plan. In addition, the proposed regulations withdrew the 2015 proposed regulations and re-proposed the rule regarding substantial coverage of inpatient hospitalization services and physician services. Thus, under the proposed regulations, an eligible employer-sponsored plan would provide minimum value only if the plan covers at least 60 percent of the total allowed costs of benefits provided to an employee under the plan and the plan benefits include substantial coverage of inpatient hospital services and physician services.
Finally, the proposed regulations would amend
Summary of Comments and Explanation of Revisions
I. Overview
FOOTNOTE 7 See https://legislature.maine.gov/legis/bills/getTestimonyDoc.asp?id=161949. END FOOTNOTE
Other commenters expressed the view that the separate affordability test and minimum value rule for related individuals in the proposed regulations are contrary to the language of section 36B, and that the
Some commenters suggested that the
Finally, many commenters supported the minimum value rule in the proposed regulations under which an eligible employer-sponsored plan would provide minimum value to an employee only if, in addition to covering at least 60 percent of the total allowed costs of benefits provided to an employee under the plan, the plan's benefits include substantial coverage of inpatient hospitalization services and physician services. In addition, many commenters supported the proposed amendment to
II. Comments on Legal Analysis
A. Statutory Analysis of Affordability Rule
Under section 36B(c)(2)(C)(i)(II), an employee who does not enroll in employer coverage is not considered eligible for the coverage if "the employee's required contribution (within the meaning of section 5000A(e)(1)(B)) with respect to the plan exceeds 9.5 percent of the applicable taxpayer's household income." The flush language following this provision provides that "[t]his clause shall also apply to an individual who is eligible to enroll in the plan by reason of a relationship the individual bears to the employee."
As discussed in the preamble to the proposed regulations, the flush language in section 36B(c)(2)(C)(i) does not state clearly and expressly how section 36B(c)(2)(C)(i)(II) applies to related individuals or how the cross-reference to section 5000A(e)(1)(B) applies to coverage for related individuals. Section 5000A(e)(1)(B)(i) provides that, for an employee eligible to purchase employer coverage, the term "required contribution" means "the portion of the annual premium which would be paid by the individual . . . for self-only coverage." For related individuals, the definition of "required contribution" in section 5000A(e)(1)(B)(i) is modified by a "special rule" in section 5000A(e)(1)(C). Section 5000A(e)(1)(C) provides that "[f]or purposes of [section 5000A(e)(1)](B)(i), if an applicable individual is eligible for minimum essential coverage through an employer by reason of a relationship to an employee, the determination under [section 5000(e)(1)(A)] shall be made by reference to [the] required contribution of the employee." The regulations under section 5000A interpret section 5000A(e)(1)(C) as modifying the required contribution rule in section 5000A(e)(1)(B)(i) for coverage for a related individual to provide that the determination under section 5000A(e)(1)(A) is made by reference to the required contribution of the employee for coverage for the employee and that related individual. Specifically, for related individuals,
FOOTNOTE 8 For purposes of this exemption for unaffordable coverage, an employee or related individual who is otherwise exempt under
FOOTNOTE 9 REG-148500-12 (78 FR 7314). END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 10 TD 9632 (78 FR 53646). END FOOTNOTE
Similar to the regulations implementing section 5000A, the proposed regulations provided an affordability rule for related individuals for section 36B purposes that looks to the cost of coverage for the employee and related individuals and is separate from the affordability rule for employees of the employer offering the coverage. Under the proposed regulations, affordability for related individuals would be based on the portion of the annual premium the employee must pay for coverage of the employee and all other individuals included in the employee's family, within the meaning of
Some commenters expressed the view that the affordability rule in the proposed regulations conflicts with the language in section 36B, that the 2013 affordability rule is correct, and that the affordability rule for related individuals in the proposed regulations should be withdrawn. These commenters argued that section 36B unambiguously establishes a single affordability test for both employees and related individuals that is based on the cost of self-only coverage to the employee. As explained later in this section II.A. of the Summary of Comments and Explanation of Revisions, however, the proposed rule's approach represents the better reading of the statute and the better means of implementing it. After careful consideration, the
[A related individual] shall not be treated as eligible for minimum essential coverage if such coverage (I) consists of an eligible employer-sponsored plan [ ], and (II) the employee's /11/ required contribution (within the meaning of section 5000A(e)(1)(B)) with respect to the plan exceeds 9.5 percent of the applicable taxpayer's household income.
FOOTNOTE 11 The term "employee" would not be replaced with "related individual" here because it is the employee who makes contributions (through salary reduction or otherwise) to pay for employer coverage, even if the employer coverage includes family members of the employee. END FOOTNOTE
This language includes four references to the coverage provided by the employee's employer: "minimum essential coverage," "such coverage," "eligible employer-sponsored plan," and "the plan." Without question, "such coverage" refers to the minimum essential coverage offered by the employee's employer to the related individual, as do references to "employer-sponsored plan" and "the plan." Unless a related individual is also employed by that employer, the related individual may not enroll in the employer's coverage on a self-only basis. Thus, the minimum essential coverage referred to in section 36B(c)(2)(C)(i), as it applies to related individuals, is the coverage the related individual may enroll in, which is the family coverage offered by the employer. Under this reading, the reference to "the employee's required contribution . . . with respect to the plan" is the required contribution for family coverage.
This reading gives full effect to section 36B(c)(2)(C)(i)(II)'s cross reference to section 5000A(e)(1)(B). As noted earlier in this section II.A of the Summary of Comments and Explanation of Revisions, section 36B(c)(2)(C)(i) specifies rules to determine the affordability of coverage under an eligible employer-sponsored plan both for an employee and for related individuals. Taken in isolation, section 5000A(e)(1)(B) would specify a rule for determining the affordability of a required contribution only with respect to coverage for an employee, even though the flush language in section 36B(c)(2)(C)(i) requires a calculation to be performed for related individuals as well. Section 5000A(e)(1)(C) provides a rule for that calculation by specifying a "special rule" for purposes of the calculation of the employee's required contribution for coverage that includes the related individual. As explained earlier in this section II.A. of the Summary of Comments and Explanation of Revisions, the
As noted in section I of this Summary of Comments and Explanation of Revisions, the vast majority of commenters supported the proposed affordability rule for related individuals, and several of these commenters provided detailed technical analyses in support of this interpretation of the statute. Some of those commenters argued that section 36B unambiguously establishes a separate affordability test for related individuals that is based on the cost of family coverage. For example, one commenter asserted that the proposed affordability rule for related individuals follows the plain language of the statute and that section 5000A(c)(1)(C) states on its face that it must be read into 5000A(c)(1)(B). Another commenter argued that the plain text of the statute indicates that a related individual's eligibility for the PTC is based on the cost of family coverage and that the affordability rule in the 2013 regulations reflected a strained reading of the statute. One commenter supported the proposed affordability rule for related individuals but disagreed that the rule adopts an "alternative" reading of the statute. Instead, the commenter opined that the interpretation in the proposed regulations is correct and that the affordability rule in the 2013 regulations reflected an erroneous interpretation of the ACA. Finally, one commenter stated that the 2013 regulations implementing section 36B badly misinterpret the statute and that section 36B mandates a family-based affordability test. The commenter noted that if
For reasons explained in section III of this Summary of Comments and Explanation of Revisions, the
FOOTNOTE 12 See H.R. Rep. No. 111-443 (2009). END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 13 https://www.healthaffairs.org/doi/10.1377/hlthaff.2015.1491. END FOOTNOTE
As explained earlier in this section II.A of the Summary of Comments and Explanation of Revisions, the
FOOTNOTE 14 The negative-implication canon of construction--expressio unius est exclusio alterius--means the expression of one thing implies the exclusion of the other. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 15 For purposes of this exemption for unaffordable coverage, an employee or related individual who is otherwise exempt under
In addition, the
FOOTNOTE 16 Notably, in
Moreover, had
Under section 36B(c)(4)(A), a PTC is not allowed for a month for the Exchange coverage of "an employee (or any spouse or dependent of such employee) if for such month the employee is provided a [QSEHRA] which constitutes affordable coverage." A QSEHRA is affordable for a month if the excess of (1) the monthly premium for the second lowest cost silver plan for self-only coverage of the employee offered in the Exchange for the rating area in which the employee resides, over (2) 1/12 of the employee's permitted benefit (as defined in section 9831(d)(
In contrast to the language in section 36B(c)(2)(C)(i)(II), section 36B(c)(4)(A) does not reference section 5000A(e)(1)(B) for the QSEHRA affordability determination or provide that "this clause shall also apply" to a related individual. Instead, it provides the same affordability rule for both employees and related individuals by stating that affordability for coverage under a QSEHRA for "an employee (or any spouse or dependent of such employee)" is based on the cost of self-only coverage of the employee. That is far different from the language in section 36B(c)(2)(C)(i)(II) and, therefore, it is reasonable to conclude that the affordability rule in section 36B(c)(2)(C)(i)(II) for related individuals is not the same as the affordability rule for related individuals in section 36B(c)(4)(A).
Additionally, the structure and context of sections 36B and 5000A suggest that
B. Consistency Between the Affordability Rules of Sections 36B and 5000A
The preamble to the proposed regulations noted that the proposed affordability rule under section 36B would create greater consistency between the section 36B affordability rules and the rules in section 5000A used to determine whether an individual is exempt from the individual shared responsibility payment under section 5000A because employer coverage is unaffordable. With the finalization of the proposed section 36B affordability rule in these final regulations, both rules provide that affordability for employees is based on the employee's cost for self-only coverage and that affordability for family members is generally based on the amount an employee must pay to cover the employee and the related individuals included in the employee's family. Thus, these final regulations promote consistency between these two affordability rules.
One commenter argued that
C. Legislative History of ACA
One commenter also argued that the legislative history underlying the ACA shows that
FOOTNOTE 17 111th
FOOTNOTE 18 H.R. 3590, 111th
The commenter further argued that, when the bill that became the ACA was introduced on the
D. Legislative Proposals To Change Affordability Rule
Several commenters also argued that a change to the affordability rule for related individuals should be accomplished by legislative action, rather than regulatory action. They argued that, despite requests to amend section 36B to provide that affordability of employer coverage for related individuals is based on the employee's cost for family coverage,
Although the commenters are correct that members of
E. Interpretation of
In a footnote in the preamble to the proposed regulations, the
A few commenters expressed the view that the original JCT report was in error and should not be viewed as evidence that the statutory language in section 36B(c)(2)(C)(i)(II) supports a separate affordability rule based on the cost of family coverage; these commenters noted that the
F. Relevance of Section 18081
The preamble to the proposed regulations noted that the proposed regulations would promote consistency between the affordability rules in sections 36B and 5000A and the rule in 42 U.S.C. 18081(b)(4)(C) (section 18081(b)(4)(C)). Section 18081(b)(4)(C) relates to information that a QHP enrollee must provide as part of the enrollee's QHP application if the enrollee wants to be determined eligible for advance payments of the PTC (APTC) or cost-sharing reductions. Under section 18081(b)(4)(C), if an employer offers minimum essential coverage to an individual seeking to enroll in a QHP, and the individual asserts that the offer does not preclude the individual from qualifying for APTC or cost-sharing reductions because it is not affordable, the QHP applicant must provide to the Exchange information on "the lowest cost option for the enrollee's or [related] individual's enrollment status and the enrollee's or [related] individual's required contribution (within the meaning of section 5000A(e)(1)(B) of title 26) under the employer-sponsored plan."
Certain commenters opined that they saw no inconsistency between the 2013 affordability rule under section 36B, the affordability rule under section 5000A, and the QHP applicant information rule in section 18081(b)(4)(C). One commenter stated that section 18081(b)(4)(C), by referencing section 5000A(e)(1)(B), merely instructs Exchanges to determine "the portion of the annual premium which would be paid by the individual . . . for self-only coverage" under the employer-sponsored plan. Another commenter argued that section 18081(b)(4)(C), by using the term "or" and not "and," requires the submission of information on the required contribution solely for the employee who is offered employer coverage, meaning the individual who would pay the required contribution, but that the individual enrolling in the QHP could be the employee or someone related to the employee. This commenter further argued that in either case, the only information required by section 18081(b)(4)(C) is the lowest cost option for self-only coverage and the required contribution for the applicable employee.
Section 18081 requires Exchanges to collect information from enrollees who are offered coverage under an employer plan on "the lowest cost option" that the employee, whether the enrollee or an individual related to the enrollee, must contribute for the employee's or individual's enrollment status. The language "lowest cost option for the . . . enrollment status" indicates that the amount may vary depending on whether the employee's enrollment status would be for self-only or family coverage. Otherwise, section 18081(b)(4)(C) would refer to "the lowest cost option for the enrollee for self-only coverage." Thus, the
G. Coordination With Section 4980H
One commenter asserted that the framework of section 4980H supports the view that a separate affordability test under section 36B for related individuals is not warranted. Section 4980H provides that an applicable large employer (ALE) generally must offer coverage to full-time employees and their dependents or potentially be subject to an employer shared responsibility payment. As the commenter noted, although
The commenter stated that the affordability of self-only coverage is the key determinant in whether an employer of a full-time employee must make a section 4980H payment and in whether the full-time employee and his or her dependents are allowed a PTC. The commenter argued that this framework shows
In addition, the goal of the ACA is to provide affordable, quality health care for all Americans, /19/ not just to full-time employees of
FOOTNOTE 19 See H.R. Rep. No. 111-443 (2009). END FOOTNOTE
H. Minimum Value Rule
As noted in the Background section of this preamble, an employee generally is not treated as eligible for coverage under an eligible employer-sponsored plan unless the coverage provides minimum value, as defined in section 36B(c)(2)(C)(ii). Under section 36B(c)(2)(C)(ii) and
The proposed regulations provided a minimum value rule for related individuals that is based on the plan's share of the total allowed cost of benefits provided to the related individuals. Under the proposed regulations, an eligible employer-sponsored plan satisfies the minimum value requirement for related individuals only if the plan's share of the total allowed costs of benefits provided to related individuals is at least 60 percent, similar to the existing rule in
The vast majority of commenters supported the separate minimum value rule for related individuals in the proposed regulations. However, two commenters stated that the minimum value requirement in section 36B applies only to employees and that the
Further, as stated in the preamble to the proposed regulations, without a separate minimum value rule for related individuals based on the costs of benefits provided to related individuals, a PTC would not be allowed for a related individual offered coverage under a plan that was affordable but provided minimum value only to employees and not to related individuals. This outcome would diminish the benefit a related individual would derive from the amendment of the affordability rule for related individuals. That is, the affordability of employer coverage for related individuals would be based on the employee's cost of covering the related individuals, but there would be no assurance that the affordable coverage offered to the related individuals provided a minimum value of benefits to the related individuals.
Moreover, as described by commenters supportive of the minimum value rule for related individuals, it is extremely rare for an employer plan to provide a different level of coverage for family members than the coverage level provided to the employee enrolled in the plan. This is because most employers that offer multiple benefits packages offer family coverage on the condition that the employee and the employee's family must enroll in the same benefits package, which will then have the same minimum value for the entire family. Thus, if an employer plan offered to employees provides minimum value, and that plan is also offered to related individuals, the plan generally will also provide minimum value to the family members. Nevertheless, because the lack of a separate minimum value rule for related individuals would be inconsistent with the goals of the ACA in providing comprehensive health coverage and improving access to quality and affordable health care, the final regulations provide that an eligible employer-sponsored plan provides minimum value for related individuals only if the plan's share of the total allowed costs of benefits provided to related individuals is at least 60 percent and the plan benefits include substantial coverage of inpatient hospital services and physician services.
III. Rationale for Change
At the time that the
FOOTNOTE 20 See https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/115th-congress-2017-2018/reports/53094-acaprojections.pdf. END FOOTNOTE
Despite the initial uncertainty about the ACA's effects, there has been substantial progress over the past several years toward meeting the goal of the ACA to give all Americans the opportunity to enroll in comprehensive health insurance at an affordable price. For individuals who were previously uninsured, the ACA expanded eligibility for Medicaid and created new Exchanges for eligible individuals to purchase QHPs subsidized by the PTC. Research has shown that these policies increased access to affordable health insurance and helped reduce the share of the population that was uninsured. /21/
FOOTNOTE 21 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/pam.22158. END FOOTNOTE
Despite this progress, roughly 26 million people still lack health insurance coverage. About 8 percent of the population is still uninsured. /22/ Because these people without health coverage face large, unpredictable bills when they seek medical care, many forgo necessary treatments. The key challenge for these families in obtaining coverage is the cost of coverage. According to the
FOOTNOTE 22 https://aspe.hhs.gov/reports/2022-uninsurance-at-all-time-low. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 23 https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/databriefs/db382-H.pdf. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 24 https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nhis/earlyrelease/earlyrelease202204.pdf. END FOOTNOTE
Premium costs are particularly challenging for families enrolling in employer coverage. Since the 2013 regulations were promulgated, the average annual employee contribution for family coverage has increased by over 30 percent--a growth rate that is nearly double the rate at which the Consumer Price Index increased over the same period. /25/ In 2021, the average annual employee contribution for a family plan offered by the employer was
FOOTNOTE 25 https://www.bls.gov/cpi/data.htm. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 26 https://www.kff.org/health-costs/report/2021-employer-health-benefits-survey/. END FOOTNOTE
For families that can afford employer coverage, the coverage is sometimes of limited value because of high levels of cost-sharing. In 2020, roughly 90 percent of employer plans had a deductible. /27/ Among family plans offered by employers with a deductible, the average amount of the deductible was roughly
FOOTNOTE 27 https://www.meps.ahrq.gov/data_files/publications/cb25/cb25.pdf. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 28 https://academic.oup.com/qje/article-abstract/132/3/1261/3769421;
https://www.nber.org/papers/w28439. END FOOTNOTE
Thus, although the ACA has succeeded in providing affordable health care to millions of Americans, some still cannot afford coverage. With increasingly higher premiums and out-of-pocket costs, the cost of family coverage offered by employers has become particularly unaffordable for some employees' family members. The self-only affordability rule for related individuals in the 2013 regulations exacerbates that problem. Although the
In addition to the data provided in the studies cited above, numerous health care advocates have written articles over the years describing the adverse effects of the 2013 affordability rule and recommending a rule change. /29/ Most recently, the proposed regulations themselves generated over 3,800 comments in support of the proposed rule. As noted earlier in this preamble, many of these commenters recounted personal stories of family members being uninsured due to the unaffordability of family coverage offered by an employer and the unavailability of a PTC for Exchange coverage. Finally, individuals have shared stories in other forums regarding the negative impact of the 2013 affordability rule on their lives. For example, one married couple testified to a state legislature that they divorced solely to retain the husband's eligibility for the PTC after his wife got a new job with an offer of family coverage at a cost of
FOOTNOTE 29 See, for example, Trapped by the Firewall: Policy Changes Are Needed to Improve Health Coverage for
FOOTNOTE 30 See https://legislature.maine.gov/legis/bills/getTestimonyDoc.asp?id=161949. END FOOTNOTE
Consistent with E.O. 14009, issued in
FOOTNOTE 31 See H.R. Rep. No. 111-443 (2009). END FOOTNOTE
In addition, the
FOOTNOTE 32 https://www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/forefront.20220420.498595/. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 33 https://academic.oup.com/qje/article/136/1/1/5911132; https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0047272718302408. END FOOTNOTE
In addition, several commenters cited publicly available studies that estimate how changing the affordability rule for related individuals could affect the number of people with health insurance coverage. /34/ One commenter presented estimates based on their own simulation of health insurance coverage decisions. Another commenter cited a study that focused specifically on the state of
FOOTNOTE 34 See https://www.kff.org/health-reform/issue-brief/the-aca-family-glitch-and-affordability-of-employer-coverage/; https://www.kff.org/health-reform/issue-brief/many-workers-particularly-at-small-firms-face-high-premiums-to-enroll-in-family-coverage-leaving-many-in-the-family-glitch/; https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2020-06/Patient_Protection_and_Affordable_Care_Enhancement_Act_0.pdf; https://www.urban.org/research/publication/changing-family-glitch-would-make-health-coverage-more-affordable-many-families; https://www.urban.org/research/publication/marketplace-subsidies-changing-family-glitch-reduces-family-health-spending-increases-government-costs; https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR1296.html; https://www.healthaffairs.org/doi/10.1377/hlthaff.2015.1491. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 35 https://laborcenter.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/Fact-Sheet-Family-Glitch.pdf. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 36 https://www.cbo.gov/system/files?file=2022-07/58313-Crapo_letter.pdf. END FOOTNOTE
The studies cited by commenters found that implementing a policy similar to the affordability rule described in the proposed regulations would increase the number of individuals eligible for financial assistance by between 3 million and 5.1 million. Other studies project that, out of those newly eligible, between 600,000 and 2.3 million individuals would choose to enroll in Exchange coverage. /37/ Estimates of the number of people who would be newly insured range from 80,000 to 700,000. These studies estimate that this change in eligibility and subsequent enrollment would increase the Federal deficit by between approximately
FOOTNOTE 37 Some studies estimated any Exchange enrollment while other studies estimated only subsidized Exchange enrollment. END FOOTNOTE
The studies also discussed which types of families would be most likely to benefit from the proposed affordability rule for related individuals. Families with incomes below 250 percent of the Federal poverty level and families with employees who work for small employers were expected to benefit the most. One study found that workers in industries such as service, agriculture, mining, and construction were more likely to be eligible for a PTC. /38/ Another study estimated that families switching from employer coverage to Exchange coverage would save an average of about
FOOTNOTE 38 https://www.kff.org/health-reform/issue-brief/many-workers-particularly-at-small-firms-face-high-premiums-to-enroll-in-family-coverage-leaving-many-in-the-family-glitch/. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 39 https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/104223/changing-the-family-glitch-would-make-health-coverage-more-affordable-for-many-families_1.pdf. END FOOTNOTE
These studies provide a range of estimated impacts on health coverage status and the Federal deficit. Each study relies on different data sources, modeling techniques, behavioral assumptions, and budgetary baselines. Additionally, the policies they simulate are different than the exact set of policies being adopted in the final regulations.
FOOTNOTE 40 None of the studies reviewed by the
In addition to these studies--those cited by commenters, as well as others reviewed by the
IV. Recommended Amendments to Proposed Rules
A. Cost of Family Coverage
Under the proposed regulations, an eligible employer-sponsored plan would be treated as affordable for related individuals if the portion of the annual premium the employee must pay for family coverage, that is, the employee's required contribution, does not exceed 9.5 percent of household income. For this purpose,
A few commenters requested a change to
FOOTNOTE 41 Under Public Health Service Act section 2714, which is incorporated into the Code through Code section 9815 and into the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) through section 715 of ERISA, group health plans and health insurance issuers offering group or individual health insurance coverage that offer dependent coverage for children must make that coverage available to employees' children until they attain age 26. See 26 CFR 54.9815-2714, 29 CFR 2590.715-2714, and 45 CFR 147.120. END FOOTNOTE
B. Determine Affordability for Employees Based on the Cost of Family Coverage
Under
Several commenters requested that the final regulations amend the affordability rule for employees to provide that, if an offer of employer coverage is unaffordable for an employee's family members, the offer would also be considered unaffordable for the employee. The commenters noted that separate affordability rules for employees and family members will sometimes result in a spouse or dependent of an employee having an offer of employer coverage that is unaffordable even though the employee has an affordable offer of self-only coverage. This could cause families to enroll in multiple plans or policies, the employee in the employer plan and the family members in a QHP, which would be burdensome and costly for families who must navigate different provider networks and drug formularies and incur separate deductibles and caps on out-of-pocket spending.
Although the
C. Multiple Offers of Coverage
The proposed regulations provided that an individual who has offers of employer coverage from multiple employers has an offer of affordable coverage if at least one of the offers of coverage is affordable. For example, if X has an offer of employer coverage from X's employer and also from the employer of X's spouse, Y, for a year for which X and Y file a joint return, X has an offer of affordable coverage if either X's required contribution for self-only coverage under X's employer's plan does not exceed 9.5 percent of X's and Y's household income, or if Y's required contribution for family coverage under Y's employer's plan does not exceed 9.5 percent of X's and Y's household income. One commenter suggested that the
The final regulations do not change the rule provided in the proposed regulations regarding affordability for individuals with multiple offers of coverage. Although the current section 36B regulations do not explicitly address situations involving multiple offers of employer coverage, as noted in the Background section of this preamble, a month is a coverage month for an individual only if the individual is not eligible for MEC, other than individual market coverage, for the month. Therefore, under the current regulations, an individual with multiple employer coverage offers for a month is eligible for MEC for that month if at least one of the offers of coverage is affordable and provides minimum value. The rule in the proposed regulations relating to multiple offers of coverage simply states expressly how the affordability rule in the current regulations applies to an individual with multiple offers of employer coverage.
Furthermore, an individual with multiple offers of employer coverage seeking to enroll in a QHP with APTC would provide information to the applicable Exchange concerning the required contribution for each coverage offer. The Exchange will determine if at least one of the offers is affordable, in which case APTC would not be allowed for the individual's Exchange coverage. This process should minimize any burden or confusion relating to whether an individual with multiple offers of coverage has an affordable offer that would deny the individual APTC and PTC for his or her Exchange coverage. In addition, for taxpayers for whom APTC is not paid for their or their family's QHP coverage, the
D. Comments Requiring Legislative Changes
One commenter suggested that the final regulations include a rule under which an employee and the employee's family members are not considered to have an offer of affordable coverage if the cost of coverage for the entire family is more than 15 percent of household income. One commenter asked that the rule in section 36B(c)(2)(B) be amended and that all individuals offered coverage under an employer plan be permitted to choose between the employer coverage and Exchange coverage with a PTC. Another commenter requested that the
FOOTNOTE 42 Section 12001 of Public Law 117-169, 136 Stat. 1818 (
E. ICHRA and QSEHRA Comments
In general,
One commenter stated it was unclear whether the affordability rule for related individuals in the proposed regulations applies to ICHRAs. The commenter also suggested that the final regulations include a rule under which family coverage amounts, not self-only coverage amounts, are used to determine whether an ICHRA offer to a related HRA individual is affordable.
The proposed regulations do not address the affordability rules relating to an ICHRA offer, and, consequently, the final regulations also do not address ICHRAs. Therefore, the rules for determining affordability of an ICHRA remain unchanged. However, the
Other commenters suggested that a PTC be allowed for family members in situations in which an employee is offered an affordable HRA, whether an ICHRA or a QSEHRA, and does not opt-out of the HRA. The commenters recommended that, in these situations, the employee and the family members would enroll in an Exchange family plan and the employee would not be allowed a PTC because of the affordable HRA, but the family members would be allowed a PTC.
The rules relating to QSEHRAs are specifically provided by statute in section 36B(c)(4). Because the
Under the rules for ICHRAs, if the terms of the ICHRA provide that reimbursements are allowed only for the medical expenses of the employee and not for the expenses of related individuals, a PTC may be allowed for the Exchange coverage of the related individuals, irrespective of whether the ICHRA is considered affordable under
F. Minimum Value
1. Minimum Value Rule for Related Individuals
The proposed regulations provided that an employer plan meets the minimum value requirement for related individuals if the plan's share of the total allowed costs of benefits provided to related individuals is at least 60 percent, similar to the minimum value requirement for employees. One commenter requested that the final regulations include a minimum value safe harbor rule under which an employer plan is considered to provide minimum value to related individuals if the coverage provided to employees under the plan meets minimum value requirements and the same benefits are provided to employees and family members. Other commenters recommended that the final regulations allow for the calculation of minimum value using a standard population that includes both employees and dependents to calculate a single, composite, minimum value for an employee and dependents, and that separate populations not be required for coverage provided to employees and coverage provided to related individuals.
As in the proposed regulations, the final regulations provide a minimum value rule for related individuals that is separate from the minimum value rule for employees, and that requires a plan's share of the total allowed costs of benefits provided to related individuals to be at least 60 percent. This minimum value rule for related individuals is not intended to require the use of a standard population for family members that is separate from the standard population for employees. Rather, the intent of the rule is to ensure that employers continue to provide a plan that has the same benefit design for employees and related individuals, and not to burden employers with having to offer different benefit packages for employees and related individuals. Consequently, the final regulations include a rule providing that an employer plan that provides minimum value to an employee also provides minimum value to related individuals if the scope of benefits and cost sharing (including deductibles, co-payments, coinsurance, and out-of-pocket maximums) under the plan are the same for employees and family members. If cost sharing varies based on whether related individuals are enrolled and/or the number of related individuals enrolled (that is, the tier of coverage), minimum value for related individuals is based on the tier of coverage that would, if elected, cover the employee and all related individuals (disregarding any differences in deductibles or out-of-pocket maximums that are attributable to a different tier of coverage, such as self plus one versus family coverage.) In addition, the final regulations do not require a departure from the practice of computing minimum value for employees and related individuals based on the provision of benefits to a standard population that includes both employees and related individuals.
2. Require Coverage of All Essential Health Benefits
The proposed regulations provided that, to be considered to provide minimum value, an eligible employer-sponsored plan must include substantial coverage of inpatient hospital services and physician services. One commenter asked that final regulations provide that an employer plan does not meet the minimum value requirements unless it provides coverage of all 10 essential health benefits that, under the ACA, certain plans must cover, not just inpatient hospital services and physician services. This comment requesting an expansion of the minimum value rule is outside the scope of these final regulations. Thus, as in the proposed regulations, the final regulations provide that an eligible employer-sponsored plan does not meet minimum value requirements unless it includes substantial coverage of inpatient hospital services and physician services.
3. Minimum Value Calculator
Under 45 CFR 156.145(a)(1), a minimum value calculator is to be made available by HHS and the
FOOTNOTE 43 Under 45 CFR 156.135, HHS is responsible for developing and updating an actuarial value calculator that issuers may use to determine the actuarial value of a health plan. END FOOTNOTE
G. Applicability Date of Final Regulations
The proposed regulations provided that the changes to [Sec.]
FOOTNOTE 44 Under section 12001 of the IRA, the temporary applicable percentages for 2021 and 2022 in section 36B(b)(3)(A)(iii) were extended through 2025 so taxpayers will not see a change in their PTC amount due to the potential policy change described by commenters. END FOOTNOTE
Although the commenters' concerns are appreciated, the
Another commenter urged that the
The section 1332 waiver program permits states to apply to waive certain provisions of the ACA, including section 36B of the Code, to undertake their own state-specific reforms to provide residents with access to high quality, affordable health insurance while retaining the basic protections of the ACA. A state applying for a section 1332 waiver must include in its application actuarial and economic analyses that demonstrate that the waiver proposal meets the statutory requirements for section 1332 waivers. /45/ /46/ If a waiver yields Federal savings on certain forms of Federal financial assistance under the ACA (such as the PTC), those savings are passed through to the state to help implement the state's approved waiver plan. Federal pass-through funding amounts are calculated annually by the
FOOTNOTE 45 See 31 CFR 33.108(f)(4)(i) and (ii); 45 CFR 155.1308(f)(4)(i) and (ii). END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 46 Section 1332(b)(1)(A)-(D) of the ACA. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 47 31 CFR 33.122 and 45 CFR 155.1322. END FOOTNOTE
V. Comments Regarding Outreach
Several commenters requested that HHS, the
The commenters who raised these concerns all supported the affordability rule for related individuals provided in the proposed regulations, but requested that the
In addition, the
Finally, HHS has informed the
The
In addition to the commenters requesting that HHS, the
As noted earlier, one commenter stated that the new rules will create new recordkeeping and compliance requirements for plan sponsors and administrators. However, nothing in the proposed rules specifically imposed any new requirements on plan sponsors or administrators and any such requirements would be outside the scope of section 36B. In addition, as discussed later, the new rules in these final regulations do not create, even indirectly, any new recordkeeping or compliance requirements for plan sponsors or administrators.
VI. Issues for Employers
A. Information Reporting
Multiple commenters pointed out that the proposed regulations did not address whether the regulations would impose new information reporting obligations on employers and other providers of minimum essential coverage under sections 6055 and 6056. Section 6055 requires providers of minimum essential coverage to report coverage information by filing information returns with the
B. Non-Calendar Year Plans
One commenter expressed concern about how the affordability rule for related individuals would affect family members enrolled in non-calendar year employer plans, especially individuals enrolled in employer coverage through section 125 cafeteria plans (cafeteria plans). The commenter noted that under current rules, spouses and dependents of employees cannot, without a qualifying event, discontinue their employer coverage during a plan year if the employee has elected under the cafeteria plan to cover the spouse or dependent under the employer plan. /48/ Thus, under current rules, if as of
FOOTNOTE 48 Although current cafeteria plan rules generally prohibit employees, spouses, and dependents from discontinuing their employer coverage during a plan year, Notice 2014-55, 2014-41 I.R.B. 672, permits a cafeteria plan to allow an employee to revoke his or her election under the cafeteria plan for coverage under the employer plan if certain conditions are met. The notice does not allow an employee to revoke an election solely for coverage of the employee's spouse or dependents under the employer plan. END FOOTNOTE
Spouses and dependents enrolled in non-calendar year employer plans not associated with cafeteria plans may, subject to the plan rules, disenroll from the employer plan effective on
For employer plans associated with cafeteria plans, the
FOOTNOTE 49 Employees who revoke coverage in an employer plan associated with a cafeteria plan for themselves or for family members will be eligible for a Special Enrollment Period to enroll in a QHP if a family member becomes newly eligible for APTC. See 45 CFR 155.420(d)(6)(iii). END FOOTNOTE
C. Section 4980H Liability
One commenter that supported the proposed regulations noted in a footnote that the proposed regulations would not have a direct effect on an ALE's liability for an employer shared responsibility payment with respect to the employees of that ALE.
The commenter also noted that the proposed regulations could have an indirect impact on an ALE's liability for an employer shared responsibility payment. That is, an ALE that does not offer affordable, minimum value coverage to some of its full-time employees could have an increase in its payment under section 4980H for full-time employees who were previously ineligible for a PTC based on an offer of coverage from their spouse's employer. The commenter did not request any change in the proposed regulations, but merely noted this scenario. Certainly, an ALE that has chosen not to offer affordable, minimum value coverage to the requisite number of its full-time employees may have a potential liability for a payment under section 4980H--a risk that the ALE knowingly accepts. Whenever more employees of such an ALE are allowed a PTC, for any reason, the ALE's liability may grow.
VII. Procedural Requirements for Regulations and Cost of New Rules
A few commenters argued that the proposed affordability rule for related individuals would be too costly, producing an inefficient use of Federal resources. These commenters all cited a report from the CBO estimating the costs of H.R. 1425, introduced during the 116th
FOOTNOTE 50 https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2020-06/Combined%20Tables.pdf. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 51 https://www.cbo.gov/system/files?file=2022-07/58313-Crapo_letter.pdf. END FOOTNOTE
Some of those commenters also criticized the
FOOTNOTE 52 5 U.S.C. 551-559. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 53
Another commenter asserted that the
The commenter first argued that the
As noted by the commenter, the Regulatory Flexibility Act generally requires the assessment of the numbers of small businesses potentially impacted by a proposed rule. However, section 605 of the Regulatory Flexibility Act provides an exception under which an assessment is not required if the agency certifies that the rule will not, if promulgated, have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities. If the exception applies, the agency must publish the certification in the
In the preamble to the proposed regulations, the
VIII. Effect of New Rules on Other Stakeholders
A. Effect of New Rules on Insurance Markets
Several commenters opined that the affordability rule for related individuals provided in the proposed regulations will have an adverse effect on the employer insurance market. In the view of the commenters, one result of changing the affordability rule for related individuals will be that a substantial number of dependents of employees, who are generally younger and healthier than the employees, will shift from employer plans to Exchange coverage. The commenters stated that this shifting of younger, healthier individuals from employer plans to Exchange coverage will result in increased premiums for employer plans. One commenter, however, opined that it is unlikely that the magnitude of the impact on premiums for employer plans would be large. Some commenters pointed out that the shift also will result in decreased premiums for Exchange coverage, but one commenter asserted that the potential impact on the individual market is likely to be minor. Finally, a few commenters expressed concern that the affordability rule for related individuals will cause employers to discontinue or reduce insurance contributions for the coverage of related individuals. One commenter also mentioned this concern but opined that relatively few employers would take this approach.
Because the rule is not expected to have a meaningful impact on premiums for employer coverage, the
B. Effect of New Rules on Individuals
Some commenters asserted that the proposed affordability rule for related individuals would harm individuals and families in various ways. In particular, commenters argued that individuals and families would face increased complexity as they navigate multiple plan choices, including the choice to enroll in "split coverage" in which the employee with an affordable offer enrolls in self-only employer coverage and the employee's family members separately enroll in Exchange coverage. Some commenters asserted that the shift to Exchange coverage caused by the proposed rule would be a poor trade-off for individuals and would harm individuals because Exchange coverage in general provides coverage that is inferior to and less generous than employer plans. These commenters asserted, for example, that Exchange coverage may be less expensive than an available employer plan but provide significantly higher deductibles, narrower networks, or lower actuarial value than the available employer plan.
Further, the
C. Effect of New Rules on States
A few commenters asserted that states will face adverse consequences because family members who seek Exchange coverage under the new affordability rule for related individuals may find instead that they qualify for Medicaid or the
FOOTNOTE 54 See Changing the "Family Glitch" Would Make Health Coverage More Affordable for Many Families |
As an initial matter, the
FOOTNOTE 55 Although the Federal government imposes certain mandatory coverage requirements, states primarily determine eligibility standards for these programs. See https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/R/R43357/16 and https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/R/R43949/19. END FOOTNOTE
In addition, despite the commenters' assertions that the final regulations will increase costs to states by increasing enrollment in state programs, the
FOOTNOTE 56 See https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/104223/changing-the-family-glitch-would-make-health-coverage-more-affordable-for-many-families_1.pdf at pg. 12. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 57 https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/pol.20190279. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 58 https://academic.oup.com/restud/article/87/2/792/5538992?login=false. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 59 For context, as of
One commenter asserted that Medicaid and CHIP are associated with narrow networks of medical providers, making it harder for families to find pediatricians and other primary care physicians, dentists, and medical specialists.
IX. Comments Exceeding Scope of Final Regulations
A number of commenters submitted comments on matters not within the purview of the
X. Severability
If any provision in this rulemaking is held to be invalid or unenforceable facially, or as applied to any person or circumstance, it shall be severable from the remainder of this rulemaking, and shall not affect the remainder thereof, or the application of the provision to other persons not similarly situated or to other dissimilar circumstances.
Special Analyses
I. Regulatory Planning and Review--Economic Analysis
EOs 12866 and 13563 direct agencies to assess costs and benefits of available regulatory alternatives and, if regulation is necessary, to select regulatory approaches that maximize net benefits (including potential economic, environmental, public health and safety effects, distributive impacts, and equity). E.O. 13563 emphasizes the importance of quantifying both costs and benefits, of reducing costs, of harmonizing rules, and of promoting flexibility.
These final regulations have been designated as subject to review under E.O. 12866 pursuant to the 2018 MOA between the
A. Background
1. Affordability of Employer Coverage for Family Members of an Employee
As noted earlier in this preamble, section 36B provides a PTC for applicable taxpayers who meet certain eligibility requirements, including that the taxpayer or one or more family members is enrolled in a QHP for one or more months in which they are not eligible for other MEC. However, an individual who is eligible to enroll in employer coverage, but chooses not to, is not considered eligible for the employer coverage if it is "unaffordable." Section 36B defines employer coverage as unaffordable for an employee if the employee's share of the self-only premium is more than 9.5 percent of the employee's household income.
Section 1.36B-2(c)(3)(v)(A)(2) provides that affordability of employer coverage for each related individual of the employee is determined by the cost of self-only coverage. Thus, the employee and any related individuals included in the employee's family, within the meaning of
2. Description of the Final Regulations
The final regulations revise
B. Baseline
C. Affected Entities
Some families with an offer of employer coverage to the employee and at least one other family member would be newly eligible for the PTC for the Exchange coverage of the non-employee family members. The final regulations will have no effect on families for whom self-only employer coverage costs more than 9.5 percent of household income--as family coverage is more expensive than self-only coverage--because the affordability status of their employer coverage is unchanged. Similarly, the final regulations will not affect families for whom the cost of family employer coverage does not exceed 9.5 percent of household income because their coverage is determined to be affordable either way. In contrast, the final regulations will affect only family members--other than the employee--for whom the employee's cost for the available employer coverage does not exceed 9.5 percent of household income for a self-only plan but does exceed 9.5 percent of household income for a family plan or for whom the offer of the family plan is affordable but does not provide minimum value.
Employers may see some of their employees shift from family coverage to self-only coverage when family members newly qualify for the PTC. The cost per enrollee could increase or decrease depending on the characteristics of those that remain covered. However, this shift will likely lead to a small decrease in the total amount employers are spending on health coverage--due to covering fewer total people--as the Federal government increases spending on PTC for the non-employee family members who move from employer coverage to Exchange coverage.
D. Economic Analysis of the Final Regulations
1. Overview
For some families, the final regulations will lower the premium contributions required to purchase coverage for all family members by allowing family members other than the employee to receive a PTC. For some families with offers of employer coverage who will be newly eligible for the PTC, the combined cost of split coverage (self-only employer coverage for the employee plus PTC-subsidized Exchange coverage for related individuals) will be lower than what they pay for family coverage through the employer. Some low-income families with uninsured individuals where the employee is offered low-cost, self-only employer coverage and relatively high-cost family employer coverage will gain access to a lower-cost option through eligibility for the PTC on behalf of one or more related individuals.
However, the cost for families to purchase Exchange coverage with PTC is determined in part by the applicable percentage and household income, which are the same regardless of the number of individuals actually covered. Therefore, if the number of individuals needing Exchange coverage is small--such as when some family members have access to other MEC--the cost of Exchange coverage per enrollee is relatively high when added to the cost of the employee share of self-only employer coverage. Furthermore, split coverage also means multiple deductibles and maximum out-of-pocket limits for the family, which potentially increases out-of-pocket costs for families. As a result of these features, many families with offers of employer coverage who will be newly eligible for the PTC under the final regulations--including families with some uninsured individuals--would not see any savings in the combined cost of out-of-pocket premiums and cost sharing. Lastly, many families may prefer the benefits and provider networks of employer coverage, compared to Exchange coverage.
Taking all these factors into account, the
FOOTNOTE 60 The predictions rely on various assumptions including, but not limited to, the economic and technical assumptions from the 2023 Mid-Session Review. The assumptions are based on the current law baseline as of
2. Benefits
Gain of health insurance coverage. For those individuals who are uninsured because the premiums for family coverage through a family member's employer are unaffordable, gaining access to the PTC for the purchase of Exchange coverage may make coverage more affordable and may prompt some of them to take up coverage.
Additional health insurance option. For those individuals who are covered by family coverage through a family member's employer that costs more than 9.5 percent of their household income, the final regulations will, by providing access to a PTC, give them an additional option that could provide coverage at a lower cost or with more comprehensive benefits.
3. Costs
Administrative costs. Adding this new option for eligibility for PTC increases the cost to the
4. Transfer Payments
Increased PTC costs for new Exchange enrollees. Because some individuals may be newly eligible for the PTC, some individuals may move from employer coverage or uninsured status to Exchange coverage. Thus, the final regulations may increase the amount of PTC being paid by the government and reduce employer contributions.
Decreased employer exclusion for people who drop employer coverage. If individuals drop their employer coverage, or do not enroll when they otherwise would have, to take up Exchange coverage, the amount of money that was going toward their employer coverage, which provides tax-preferred health benefits, will go into the employee's wages, other employees' wages, and/or employer profits and will no longer be tax exempt. Thus, the final regulations may increase the amount of tax revenue received from income and payroll taxes.
II. Paperwork Reduction Act
This final rule does not include information collections under the Paperwork Reduction Act (5 U.S.C. chapter 35).
III. Regulatory Flexibility Act
It is hereby certified that these final regulations will not have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities within the meaning of section 601(6) of the Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. chapter 6).
As mentioned in the response to commenters, the
Pursuant to section 7805(f) of the Code, these final regulations were submitted to the Chief Counsel for the
IV. Unfunded Mandates Reform Act
Section 202 of the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995 (UMRA) requires that agencies assess anticipated costs and benefits and take certain other actions before issuing a final rule that includes any Federal mandate that may result in expenditures in any one year by a state, local, or tribal government, in the aggregate, or by the private sector, of
V. Executive Order 13132: Federalism
E.O. 13132 (Federalism) prohibits an agency from publishing any rule that has Federalism implications if the rule either imposes substantial, direct compliance costs on state and local governments, and is not required by statute, or preempts state law, unless the agency meets the consultation and funding requirements of section 6 of the E.O. This rule does not have Federalism implications and does not impose substantial direct compliance costs on state and local governments or preempt state law within the meaning of the E.O.
VI. Congressional Review Act
Pursuant to the Congressional Review Act (5 U.S.C.
Statement of Availability of
Guidance cited in this preamble is published in the Internal Revenue Bulletin and is available from the Superintendent of Documents,
Drafting Information
The principal author of these regulations is
List of Subjects in 26 CFR Part 1 Income taxes, Reporting and recordkeeping requirements.
Adoption of Amendments to the Regulations
Accordingly, the
PART 1--INCOME TAXES
Paragraph 1. The authority citation for part 1 continues to read in part as follows:
Authority: 26 U.S.C. 7805 * * *
Par. 2. Section 1.36B-0 is amended by:
a. Adding an entry for
b. Adding entries for
c. Revising the entry for
The additions and revisions read as follows:
*****
*****
(c) * * *
(3) * * *
(v) * * *
(A) * * *
(8) Multiple offers of coverage.
*****
(a) * * *
(1) Employees.
(2) Related individuals
(i) In general.
(ii) Plans providing MV to employees.
*****
(g) * * *
(2) Exceptions.
Par. 3. Section 1.36B-2 is amended by:
a. Revising the first sentence and adding a new second sentence in paragraph (c)(3)(v)(A)(2).
b. Adding paragraph (c)(3)(v)(A)(8).
c. Revising the second sentence of paragraph (c)(3)(v)(B).
d. In paragraph (c)(3)(v)(D), Examples 1 through 9 are designated as paragraphs (c)(3)(v)(D)(1) through (9), respectively.
e. In newly designated paragraphs (c)(3)(v)(D)(3), (5), (6), (7), and (9), redesignating the paragraphs in the first column as the paragraphs in the second column:
Old paragraphs New paragraphs
(c)(3)(v)(D)( 3 )(i) through (ii) (c)(3)(v)(D)( 3 )( i
) through ( ii )
(c)(3)(v)(D)( 5 )(i) through (ii) (c)(3)(v)(D)( 5 )( i
) through ( ii )
(c)(3)(v)(D)( 6 )(i) through (ii) (c)(3)(v)(D)( 6 )( i
) through ( ii )
(c)(3)(v)(D)( 7 )(i) through (iv) (c)(3)(v)(D)( 7 )( i
) through ( iv )
(c)(3)(v)(D)( 9 )(i) through (ii) (c)(3)(v)(D)( 9 )( i
) through ( ii )
f. Revising newly redesignated paragraphs (c)(3)(v)(D)(1) and (2).
g. Redesignating paragraphs (c)(3)(v)(D)(3) through (9) as paragraphs (c)(3)(v)(D)(7) through (13), respectively.
h. Adding new paragraphs (c)(3)(v)(D)(3) through (6).
i. Revising the heading for newly redesignated paragraph (c)(3)(v)(D)(7), the heading and first sentence of newly redesignated paragraph (c)(3)(v)(D)(8), the heading of newly redesignated paragraph (c)(3)(v)(D)(9), and the first sentence of newly redesignated paragraph (c)(3)(v)(D)(9)(i).
j. In the headings for newly redesignated paragraphs (c)(3)(v)(D)(10) through (13), removing the first period and adding a colon in its place.
k. Revising paragraph (e)(1).
l. Adding paragraph (e)(5).
The revisions and additions read as follows:
*****
(c) * * *
(3) * * *
(v) * * *
(A) * * *
(2) * * * Except as provided in paragraph (c)(3)(v)(A)(3) of this section, an eligible employer-sponsored plan is affordable for a related individual if the employee's required contribution for family coverage under the plan does not exceed the required contribution percentage, as defined in paragraph (c)(3)(v)(C) of this section, of the applicable taxpayer's household income for the taxable year. For purposes of this paragraph (c)(3)(v)(A)(2), an employee's required contribution for family coverage is the portion of the annual premium the employee must pay for coverage of the employee and all other individuals included in the employee's family, as defined in
*****
(8) Multiple offers of coverage. An individual who has offers of coverage under eligible employer-sponsored plans from multiple employers, either as an employee or a related individual, has an offer of affordable coverage if at least one of the offers of coverage is affordable under paragraph (c)(3)(v)(A)(1) or (2) of this section.
(B) * * * Coverage under an eligible employer-sponsored plan is affordable for a part-year period if the annualized required contribution for self-only coverage, in the case of an employee, or family coverage, in the case of a related individual, under the plan for the part-year period does not exceed the required contribution percentage of the applicable taxpayer's household income for the taxable year. * * *
*****
(D) * * *
(1) Example 1: Basic determination of affordability. For all of 2023, taxpayer C works for an employer, X, that offers its employees and their spouses a health insurance plan under which, to enroll in self-only coverage, C must contribute an amount for 2023 that does not exceed the required contribution percentage of C's 2023 household income. Because C's required contribution for self-only coverage does not exceed the required contribution percentage of C's household income, under paragraph (c)(3)(v)(A)(1) of this section, X's plan is affordable for C, and C is eligible for minimum essential coverage for all months in 2023.
(2) Example 2: Basic determination of affordability for a related individual. (i) The facts are the same as in paragraph (c)(3)(v)(D)(1) of this section (Example 1), except that C is married to J, they file a joint return, and to enroll C and J, X's plan requires C to contribute an amount for coverage for C and J for 2023 that exceeds the required contribution percentage of C's and J's household income. J does not work for an employer that offers employer-sponsored coverage.
(ii) J is a member of C's family as defined in
(3) Example 3: Multiple offers of coverage. The facts are the same as in paragraph (c)(3)(v)(D)(2) of this section (Example 2), except that J works all year for an employer that offers employer-sponsored coverage to employees. J's required contribution for the cost of self-only coverage from J's employer does not exceed the required contribution percentage of C's and J's household income. Although the coverage offered by C's employer for C and J is unaffordable for J, the coverage offered by J's employer is affordable for J. Consequently, under paragraphs (c)(3)(v)(A)(1) and (8) of this section, J is eligible for minimum essential coverage for all months in 2023.
(4) Example 4: Cost of covering individuals not part of taxpayer's family. (i) D and E are married, file a joint return, and have two children, F and G, under age 26. F is a dependent of D and E, but G is not. D works all year for an employer that offers employer-sponsored coverage to employees, their spouses, and their children under age 26. E, F, and G do not work for employers offering coverage. D's required contribution for self-only coverage under D's employer's coverage does not exceed the required contribution percentage of D's and E's household income. D's required contribution for coverage of D, E, F, and G exceeds the required contribution percentage of D's and E's household income, but D's required contribution for coverage of D, E, and F does not exceed the required contribution percentage of the household income.
(ii) E and F are members of D's family as defined in
(5) Example 5: More than one family member with an employer offering coverage. (i) K and L are married, file a joint return, and have one dependent child, M. K works all year for an employer that offers coverage to employees, spouses, and children under age 26. L works all year for an employer that offers coverage to employees only. K's required contribution for self-only coverage under K's employer's coverage does not exceed the required contribution percentage of K's and L's household income. Likewise, L's required contribution for self-only coverage under L's employer's coverage does not exceed the required contribution percentage of K's and L's household income. However, K's required contribution for coverage of K, L, and M exceeds the required contribution percentage of K's and L's household income.
(ii) L and M are members of K's family as defined in
(6) Example 6: Multiple offers of coverage for a related individual. (i) The facts are the same as in paragraph (c)(3)(v)(D)(5) of this section (Example 5), except that L works all year for an employer that offers coverage to employees, spouses, and children under age 26. L's required contribution for coverage of K, L, and M does not exceed the required contribution percentage of K's and L's household income.
(ii) Although M is not eligible for affordable employer coverage under K's employer's coverage, paragraph (c)(3)(v)(A)(8) of this section dictates that L's employer coverage must be evaluated to determine whether L's employer coverage is affordable for M. Under paragraph (c)(3)(v)(A)(2) of this section, L's employer's coverage is affordable for M, because L's required contribution for K, L, and M does not exceed the required contribution percentage of K's and L's household income. Accordingly, M is eligible for minimum essential coverage for all months in 2023.
(7) Example 7: Determination of unaffordability at enrollment. * * *
(8) Example 8: Determination of unaffordability for plan year. The facts are the same as in paragraph (c)(3)(v)(D)(7) of this section (Example 7), except that X's employee health insurance plan year is
(9) Example 9: No affordability information affirmatively provided for annual redetermination. (i) The facts are the same as in paragraph (c)(3)(v)(D)(7) of this section (Example 7), except the Exchange redetermines D's eligibility for advance credit payments for 2015. * * *
*****
(e) * * *
(1) Except as provided in paragraphs (e)(2) through (5) of this section, this section applies to taxable years ending after
*****
(5) The first two sentences of paragraph (c)(3)(v)(A)(2), paragraph (c)(3)(v)(A)(8), the second sentence of paragraph (c)(3)(v)(B), paragraphs (c)(3)(v)(D)(1) through (6), and the first sentences of paragraphs (c)(3)(v)(D)(8) and (9) of this section apply to taxable years beginning after
Par. 4. Section 1.36B-3 is amended by revising paragraphs (d)(1)(i) and (n)(1) and adding paragraph (n)(3) to read as follows:
*****
(d) * * *
(1) * * *
(i) The premiums for the month, reduced by any amounts that were refunded in the same taxable year as the premium liability is incurred, for one or more qualified health plans in which a taxpayer or a member of the taxpayer's family enrolls (enrollment premiums); or
*****
(n) * * *
(1) Except as provided in paragraphs (n)(2) and (3) of this section, this section applies to taxable years ending after
*****
(3) Paragraph (d)(1)(i) of this section applies to taxable years beginning after
Par. 5. Section 1.36B-6 is amended by revising paragraphs (a) and (g)(2) to read as follows:
(a) In general--(1) Employees. An eligible employer-sponsored plan provides minimum value (MV) for an employee of the employer offering the coverage only if--
(i) The plan's MV percentage, as defined in paragraph (c) of this section, is at least 60 percent based on the plan's share of the total allowed costs of benefits provided to the employee; and
(ii) The plan provides substantial coverage of inpatient hospital services and physician services.
(2) Related individuals--(i) In general. An eligible employer-sponsored plan provides MV for an individual who may enroll in the plan because of a relationship to an employee of the employer offering the coverage (a related individual) only if--
(A) The plan's MV percentage, as defined in paragraph (c) of this section, is at least 60 percent based on the plan's share of the total allowed costs of benefits provided to the related individual; and
(B) The plan provides substantial coverage of inpatient hospital services and physician services.
(ii) Plans providing MV to employees. If an eligible employer-sponsored plan provides MV to an employee under paragraph (a)(1) of this section, the plan also provides MV for related individuals if--
(A) The scope of benefits is the same for the employee and related individuals; and
(B) Cost sharing (including deductibles, co-payments, coinsurance, and out-of-pocket maximums) under the plan is the same for the employee and related individuals under the tier of coverage that would, if elected, include the employee and all related individuals (disregarding any differences in deductibles or out-of-pocket maximums that are attributable to a different tier of coverage, such as self plus one versus family coverage).
*****
(g) * * *
(2) Exceptions. (i) Paragraph (a)(1)(ii) of this section applies for plan years beginning after
(ii) Paragraph (a)(2) of this section applies to taxable years beginning after
Deputy Commissioner for Services and Enforcement.
Approved:
Assistant Secretary of the
[FR Doc. 2022-22184 Filed 10-11-22;
BILLING CODE 4830-01-P


AAA warns: It’s peak time of year for deer collisions
Fed/Bowman: No sign of falling inflation, interest rate hikes remain on the table
Advisor News
- Survey: Most Americans still feel prosperous despite economic worries
- SEC settlement would require Tai Lopez, two others, to pay $6.8 million
- The Gen Z money paradox
- NAIFA applauds final SECURE 2.0 regulations
- What will Democrats in Congress do about healthcare and retirement?
More Advisor NewsAnnuity News
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Global Atlantic Financial Group Limited and Its Subsidiaries
- Best’s Market Segment Report: AM Best Maintains Stable Outlook on US Life/Annuity Insurance Segment
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company and Its Subsidiaries
- Boomers want retirement protection, but their actions don’t match their mindset
- NAIC task force to address LTC riders
More Annuity NewsHealth/Employee Benefits News
- EXPLORING INSULIN COST-SHARING CAPS FOR PATIENTS WITH PRIVATE COVERAGE
- THE AMERICAN DIABETES ASSOCIATION FIGHTS TO MAINTAIN ACCESS TO HEALTH INSURANCE
- Grand jury accuses veteran of making false disability claims that defrauded VA
- States push short-term insurance as healthcare costs climb
- Study Findings on Managed Care Are Outlined in Reports from Massachusetts General Hospital (A RUC Rescue of Primary Care?): Managed Care
More Health/Employee Benefits NewsLife Insurance News
- FORMER PRINCE GEORGE'S COUNTY INSURANCE AGENT SENTENCED FOR FELONY INSURANCE THEFT SCHEME
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Ameriprise Financial, Inc. and Its Subsidiaries
- AM Best Takes Various Credit Rating Actions on Certain Subsidiaries of Auto-Owners Insurance Group
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Global Atlantic Financial Group Limited and Its Subsidiaries
- AM Best Downgrades Credit Ratings of CICA Life Insurance Company of America
More Life Insurance News