Senate Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs Subcommittee on Securities, Insurance, and Investment Hearing
| Federal Information & News Dispatch, Inc. |
Mr. Chairman and honorable members, thank you for your kind invitation to speak before you today. I am Managing Partner for Practices at the law Firm of
We are a boutique firm with one of our focuses being on securities and capital formation. Most of our attorneys, including myself, come originally from some of the largest law firms in the nation. Our practice includes public and private securities, and we represent clients in various capacities of all sizes -from multi-billion dollar enterprises to fledgling start-ups, but the bulk of our practice resides amongst companies in the lower mid-market or smaller (clients with $5MM to $150MM of revenue), "
According to the
The current situation can be reduced to the following:
1) To date, little movement has occurred to implement those aspects of JOBS Act that address the needs of the lower middle market and smaller "
2) That lack of progress has resulted in a relative stagnation in the ability of smaller businesses in this country to raise capital and has placed further uncertainty into the broader economy.
3) "
4) Title IV of the Act, euphemistically referred to as "Regulation A+," presents the most potentially impactful legislation to aid "
5) The forms and procedures currently existing under Regulation A can be readily applied to A+, thus obviating the need for further delay in implementing Regulation A+.
6)
7)
8) Regulation A+, in turn, should provide greater investment options to the American public than what can be found now - with retail investors largely relegated to mutual or hedge funds or investment in private securities under Regulation D, which carry risks associated with being restricted and relatively non-transparent.
For lower mid-market and smaller businesses, options to capital are limited at best. Public registration is not a viable option in light of the enormous costs associated with an initial public registration and the ongoing regulatory burdens associated with reporting requirements, Sarbanes-Oxley and Dodd-Frank. These cost and regulatory factors have played a considerable role in narrowing the opportunity of utilizing public registration to companies well beyond the size of the mid-market and at deal sizes far past the needs of most "
Alternatively, the viable audience for private securities of lower mid-market and smaller businesses is severely constrained presently. Changes to the accredited investor definition found in Rule 501 of Regulation D, have further narrowed the number of potential accredited investors available to invest in such offerings. Some estimates have put the reduction of the accredited investor audience as a result by at least twenty percent (20%). n3 Currently, the Commission is considering increasing the
Since 2008, the accredited investor market has dramatically reduced in size and activity. Many accredited investors have eschewed illiquid, restricted securities after being unable to exit failing investments during the recession. That same phenomenon resulted in an influx of FINRA arbitration related to failed investments. Many broker-dealers and investment banks who would potentially work with lower mid-market and smaller businesses have ceased handling private placements beyond institutional investments as a result. Others are precluded entirely from placing private securities due to the unwillingness of Errors & Omissions insurance carriers to insure them for such activities.
Rules promulgated by the Commission related to general solicitation under Rule 506(c), pursuant to Title II of the Act, and new "bad boy" prohibitions from use of Regulations D promulgated pursuant to Dodd- Frank have further "chilled" any potential market beyond institutional investment in professionally distributed private placements. Instituting Title II's requirement that reasonable steps be taken to ensure accredited status of all investors, Rule 506(c) creates an uncertain "facts and circumstances" test as to the reasonableness of the method undertaken to assure accreditation, subject to limited
Added to these regulatory obstacles are the new "bad actor" rules instituted as required by Dodd-Frank. While we certainly agree with the intent of the "bad actor" rules, no one wants people previously convicted of securities fraud selling unregistered securities, it also cannot be argued that these rules add risk and uncertainty to the usage of Rule 506, especially in the context of an offering distributed through retail broker-dealers to multiple individual accredited investors. By visiting the sins of a single participant in an issuer's distribution network, or even potentially a single investor, upon the offering as a whole, the application of the "bad actor" rules can result in the loss of the Rule 506 exemption and severe consequences for the sale of unregistered securities by the issuer, its management and its distribution network. As a result, issuers and their distributors are forced to institute expensive and uncertain compliance procedures, or narrow the scope of their capital raising to limit risk. This leads to a greater emphasis on institutional or very high net worth capital. Institutional investment generally comes with demands for large returns on invested capital to offset risk associated with longer holds in restricted securities and exacerbated by a the volume of competition seeking the same dollars. As a result, innumerable companies which might present solid investments, but cannot credibly show double-digit returns or exponential growth on a short term basis are ignored.
Regulation A+ can give much broader variety of issuers and businesses the ability to offer their securities to a much broader segment of the population. Regulation A+ can provide the opportunity for many issuers who, for example, have solid fundamentals and can reliably produce dividends, but perhaps not the ability to achieve the prodigious return rates sought by institutional capital, to reach a much broader segment of the population with performance goals that are realistic and achievable.
At the same time, however - and I should emphasize that this really goes to the cruxt of the opportunity under Title IV that has been overlooked for so long - Regulation A+ combines that opportunity for the issuer with a requirement that the issuer submit to a "right-sized" disclosure and reporting regime that is designed to insure standards for complete and illustrative disclosure and a current picture of the status of that issuer. Thus, the issuer is provided access to a broader investing audience with a more diverse set of investment priorities in exchange for compliance with the same conceptual regulatory discipline as registration, but streamlined to account for the relative size of the issuer and offering. This has a number of salutary effects for the investing public, as well as the issuers:
1) Transparency - standardized disclosure and reporting can insure that investors and shareholders enjoy efficient dissemination of material information concerning offerings and issuer performance.
2) Liquidity - Regulation A+ securities are freely tradable, which presents a major advantage of restricted securities where no market exists for most of these securities. As such, investors who can no longer tolerate risk associated with their investments or otherwise find themselves in a situation where they need to exit the investment can. With standardized disclosure and reporting, pricing can be arrived at with confidence. To be clear, for the foreseeable future, we believe the vast amount of any trading activity in these securities will be episodic at best, given the size of most issuers and deals, with the bulk occurring as trades by appointment. But the critical piece will be that investors, brokers and investment advisors will have information at hand to use to discern amongst investments and to establish a price as required, and have confidence in the same. This presents an enormous leap forward from the restricted nature of most Regulation D securities with no information disseminated publicly and, thus, no market.
3) Investment Options - The average investor is relegated to public fund products (hedge, mutual, money market). Regulation A+ can give an investor the opportunity to invest in enterprises (such as those we typically represent) with confidence based on the information they can access and review with their broker or investment advisors. Because of the size of the issuers that we believe will utilize Regulation A+ consistently, we believe most deals will be distributed regionally, and the investor will see options presented in their own "backyard" by local and regional investment banks and brokerages, providing a further element of transparency as a result of local "word of mouth," but also those investment banks and brokerages being able to maintain contact with management and monitor status with relative ease.
We urge the Commission to implement Regulation A+ as soon as possible. The delay associated to date with its implementation has been somewhat baffling to us, as Form 1 -A provides a readily useable framework for disclosure under Regulation A+. As to ongoing reporting, we believe a straightforward regime of simple disclosure associated with the annual audited financial statements to be filed with
The largest issues in our mind is updating some of the mechanics of the offering process and the interplay between the feds and the states. That said, we do not believe those issues would be cause for the implementation of Regulation A+ to have been delayed as it has.
Offering Mechanics
Electronic filing through EDGAR is mandated by Title IV and will be a logical and effective means to ensure dissemination of material information concerning Reg A+ issuers. That said, revisions to current Regulation A, if the same general framework is to be used in the context of Reg A+, need to be made to account for public access to all reporting through EDGAR. Currently, Rule 251(d)(2) requires physical delivery of the offering circular to the prospective investor, the need for which is obviated by having all disclosure related to an issuer generally available with the click of a button through EDGAR. In short, a Reg A+ analog to Rule 172 will be critical to furthering the JOBS Act's congressional intent.
Furthermore, it is our expectation that the vast majority of Reg A+ deals will be done on a continuous, best efforts basis. This will result in necessary updates to offering circulars. Currently Rule 253(e) requires any updated or revised Offering Circular to be filed with an amended Offering Statement and re-qualified with the Commission. This re-qualification requirement places an unnecessary burden on issuers engaged in such offerings, and one not seen in the context of a public registration where only information tripping the requirements of Item 512 of Reg S-K requires a post-effective registration statement amendment and other updates to the prospectus may be filed under Rule 424. For instance, in a recent offering filed by our firm the issuer simply desired to add another jurisdiction and update some ancillary business information - disclosures which would, arguably, require requalification with significant offering disruption but with little or no investor protective impact. Again, an analog for Reg A+ needs to be adopted.
Blue Sky and the definition of "Qualified Purchaser"
In enacting Title IV,
First, just conceptually speaking, the notion of up to 50 different regulatory regimes being applied to an offering which has just gone through a thorough process of review by the Commission seems excessive and fraught with opportunities for delay or missteps.
Our experiences with state regulators in conducting these offerings have been diverse to say the least, ranging from the cooperative and efficient to the downright abusive, or even nonexistent. Of course, if the goal is to create an efficient system for "
For example, we have had multiple occasions where states have just simply failed to respond to filings. In one instance, a filing was made with the Commonwealth of
And in probably the most egregious example to date, we filed this summer a registration in the Commonwealth of
With the possibilities of such delays or the danger of arbitrary investigations which can be costly to an issuer, the state blue sky process stands right now as an enormous obstacle to the reliability of Regulation A+ as a credible channel for forming capital. Ironic, given that this fact could have the potential for issuers to remain focused on Regulation D, which is a largely unsupervised offering process presently at the state and federal level.
Nevertheless, I understand legislative reticence to completely preempt the states for a method of offering that has been largely underutilized in recent memory.
We believe the "qualified purchaser" exemption, if defined appropriately, will be a reasonable and workable option to any number of small and mid-size issuers over other options that might not provide the regulatory oversight of disclosure, transparency, and the potential liquidity for investors that Regulation A and A+ can provide. n9 At the same time, such definition would not only provide a balanced approach to state investor protection issues, but also allow the Commission to observe a "critical mass" of activity within the Regulation A and A+ so that the Commission can have the ability to determine what further regulation (or changes to present regulations) might be necessary to accomplish
I believe that a definition can easily be tailored that can address state concerns related to investor protection, while having the intended effect of providing a meaningfully broader audience for businesses to go to for capital. Specifically, we have proposed to the Commission a definition of "qualified purchaser" which combines a net worth/income test with a cap on the amount of investment by an investor in any one issuance. A qualified purchaser would be defined as a purchaser having, excluding (in the instance of natural persons) the value of a purchaser's primary residence, either:
- a net worth of at least
- a gross annual income of at least
Further, the amount of investment by a natural person(s) who would be a qualified purchaser may not exceed 20% of the net worth of such natural person(s).
We would note that this definition is well in excess of NASAA's standard guidelines for minimum investor suitability and is designed to permit small issuers to reach a broader investor audience while addressing investor protection concerns - demanding a requisite amount of sophistication from the investor to review and digest disclosure drafted to requirements of the Commission designed to be accessible to investors in the public marketplace and that has been reviewed and qualified previously by the Commission, at the same time, it limits the exposure that an individual could have to a potential loss in any given instance. n10
Without a measured exemption here, we believe the current approach by the states, coupled with the current realities of our economy, could combine to subvert
To date, the regulation of capital formation under our securities laws has been premised on the stark dichotomy between private offerings, typically made available to a very narrow audience of investors, and public registration with its attendant costs and regulatory burdens. The genesis of the JOBS Act was the notion of finding reasoned approaches for businesses to form capital, balanced against the need to protect the investing public. Title IV presents the most impactful of the approaches presented in this legislation, supported by an existing mechanism to make these securities available to the marketplace. The Commission needs to act NOW. Thank you.
n1
n2 Median deal size for initial public offerings ("IPO") in 2012 was $124MM. See 2012 IPO Market Annual Review.
n3 Alternative Criteria for Qualifying As An Accredited Investor Should Be Considered, GAO 9-10 (
n4 Id.
n5 Id.
n6
n7 See 21 VAC5-45-20.
n8 15 U.S.C. [Sec.] 77r(b)(4)(D)
n9 The GAO completed its required study in
n10 Certain commentators have proposed the use of the "accredited investor" definition found in Rule 502 of Regulation D, if a net worth test for a qualified purchaser is to be adopted. We disagree adamantly with this suggestion. Given the need for audits, mandated forms of disclosure and periodic reporting under Reg A+, adopting such a definition would only have the result of causing issuers to default to Rule 506(c) of Regulation D, rather than adopting Reg A+, which provides for greater transparency and regulatory oversight, for the formation of capital.
Read this original document at: http://www.banking.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=Files.View&FileStore_id=0f1e3c10-8810-4f87-9b99-6d28ecacd5e2
| Copyright: | (c) 2010 Federal Information & News Dispatch, Inc. |
| Wordcount: | 3911 |


Advisor News
- SEC settlement would require Tai Lopez, two others, to pay $6.8 million
- The Gen Z money paradox
- NAIFA applauds final SECURE 2.0 regulations
- What will Democrats in Congress do about healthcare and retirement?
- Election results cloud retirement legislation outlook, experts say
More Advisor NewsAnnuity News
- Best’s Market Segment Report: AM Best Maintains Stable Outlook on US Life/Annuity Insurance Segment
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company and Its Subsidiaries
- Boomers want retirement protection, but their actions don’t match their mindset
- NAIC task force to address LTC riders
- ‘It’s really shocking:’ Regulators scrutinize assets backing annuity sellers
More Annuity NewsHealth/Employee Benefits News
- Samantha Wildow: Mercy Health warns thousands of Medical Mutual of Ohio patients may go out-of-network in 2027
- Hooksett, Auburn, Candia, Londonderry schools face steep SchoolCare health insurance hikes
- 'Everybody missed this': Nevada's state worker insurance mismanaged for years, officials say
- Picking Medicare insurance plan is daunting task – Healthful Hints
- November Issue of Best’s Review Ranks US Life Reinsurers and More
More Health/Employee Benefits NewsLife Insurance News
- November Issue of Best’s Review Ranks US Life Reinsurers and More
- Nebraska widow’s big win against life insurer in legal limbo
- New York Life Announces Record $3.1 Billion in Policy Owner Dividends for 2027
- AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company and Its Subsidiaries
- U-Haul Holding Company to Participate in Deutsche Bank Conference
More Life Insurance News