The next act for cyber insurance

Enterprises, small businesses and consumers all rely on connected devices, online accounts and digital payments. Yet, outside of corporations, coverage against cyber risks remains an underpenetrated market.

Despite gaps in cyber insurance coverage, demand is rising. Closing that gap requires more than coverage availability, and insurers can’t do it alone. The market must work like an orchestra, with each stakeholder bringing a different capability and working in concert to help customers understand, prepare for and recover from cyber events.

Property/casualty professionals don’t have to become digital experts to offer practical cyber insurance guidance. A collaborative playbook can help agents build on a familiar strength: explaining emerging risks to customers and matching them with practical cyber insurance protection.

While cyber insurance may not be familiar to many agents, a collective approach to industry best practices could make it easier for agents to explain and for customers to adopt.

Start with risks customers recognize

Cyber insurance conversations can lose momentum when risks seem abstract or unlikely. This is especially important in the small-business market, where the need may be greatest.

In many cases, small-business customers may not realize how difficult it would be to recover from a compromised email account, fraudulent payment or operational disruption until the practical consequences are made clear. Products may also need to be designed and priced for smaller organizations that don’t require the same business interruption coverage as a large enterprise.

The most relevant risks for small businesses are scenarios they’ve likely already contemplated. But many small businesses may underestimate the costs of operational disruptions, reputational damage, strained customer relationships or the deep personal stress for owners and employees alike. Making those implications tangible can help customers understand and recognize exposures they might otherwise overlook.

Resources that address the learning curve can help agents and customers bridge the knowledge gap. Carriers, agents and their partners must collectively support clear and consistent communications that help customers understand what cyber protection can and cannot do. This enables agents to have straightforward conversations that move cyber from an abstract risk to a practical insurance consideration.

Create a book strategy

For agents, cyber coverage can be difficult to prioritize when viewed one policy at a time. While a relatively modest premium may not be enough incentive to learn and sell a new product, evaluating the entire book of business can change the calculation.

Developing campaigns around key customer segments rather than identifying individual opportunities may be a more scalable approach. Targeted education and sales materials should speak to the issues most relevant to each group. It gives the industry a way to consistently deliver actionable insights to specific audiences, which is vital to strengthening protection at scale.

A small-business book, for example, could be segmented by industry, digital dependency or current coverage. Personal lines might be grouped according to factors such as net worth, homeowners coverage or existing identity protection.

A consistent outreach cadence for each segment is important. Policy renewal offers a natural opportunity to revisit coverage, but consistent conversations can also help reinforce key messages until they become familiar enough to prompt customer action.

A holistic, segment-based strategy allows the insurance industry to deliver relevant, consistent education with broader reach. When different market players reinforce the same core message, customers move from awareness to understanding, making it easier to have informed discussions about coverage and ultimately expand cyber protection across the market.

Give agents a simple story to tell

Carriers and P/C agents don’t need to explain every aspect of the cyber threat landscape before entering or expanding into the market. Success comes from being able to answer a customer's practical questions, including:

• What could happen?
• What would a cyber insurance policy cover?
• Why do I need it if I have other insurance?

Cyber program partners—from reinsurers and cyber service providers to legal resources and breach response experts—can help address knowledge gaps with segment-specific scripts and clear explanations of products and coverage features that agents and carriers can use in customer conversations.

Sample scenarios, coverage comparisons and customer-facing resources also make it easier to connect common cyber events to potential financial consequences, illustrating how existing coverage may or may not work.

The goal is to give agents a clear and repeatable story, not a technical subject to master.

Create natural progressions

The insurance industry has many successful examples of moving the market to broad adoption of new coverage types. Employment practices liability insurance, for example, became increasingly relevant to smaller businesses as awareness grew around risks like harassment and employment-related claims.

Today, EPLI can be purchased as a standalone policy or added to existing small-business coverage — and that flexibility matters. Rather than asking every small business to understand and purchase an entirely separate insurance product, insurers created new ways to make an emerging risk part of the broader coverage conversation.

Roadside assistance followed a similar path. What was once a specialized personal lines add-on became a familiar service attached to auto policies, giving insurers another way to provide value.

The cyber insurance market also offers examples. Identity theft protection was once an emerging concept. Today, it’s a familiar part of the consumer insurance conversation and increasingly becoming an addition to property coverage.

Insurers helped drive adoption of these products by making them easier to understand and access through gifted, embedded and opt-in models. These approaches can reduce the friction of introducing an unfamiliar risk. By helping customers recognize how much of their business or personal lives now depend on digital interactions, and pairing that awareness with an understandable, actionable solution, insurers can position cyber coverage as a natural extension of the protection customers already value.

Moving cyber protection from add-on to routine

There’s an opportunity in cyber insurance to move the market from an early-adopter category to a routine part of the insurance conversation. Achieving that shift will require contributions from all market players. Carriers and agents bring the customer relationship, reinsurers help support market capacity, cyber protection providers bring expertise and educational resources, and breach response and legal partners help customers navigate the consequences of an event.

When these stakeholders deliver a coordinated, consistent message, the market becomes better equipped to close the protection gap. This is how we will fulfill insurance's core promise: helping customers prepare for risks before they become losses.

© Entire contents copyright 2026 by InsuranceNewsNet.com Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this article may be reprinted without the expressed written consent from InsuranceNewsNet.com.

Matt Cullina is head of global cyber insurance business for TransUnion, leading the Cyberscout business line. Contact him at matt.cullina@innfeedback.com.