Twenty years ago the world held its breath as South African surgeon
Here's a look at some Carolinians intimately involved -- the recipients, donors and doctors.
In the second-floor operating room at
It is now 7:55, and a dramatic moment has arrived:
The patient, a 48-year-old man, lies on the operating table, draped with blue-green cloths that expose only his gaping chest.
His sternum has been cut from neck to navel; his ribs are forced apart at least 6 inches by a metal retractor.
His old, diseased heart -- just cut out by surgeon
The 3-pound lump of flaccid muscle still beats intermittently.
[READ MORE: 29 years ago, I watched him get a new heart. This month I got to meet]
"Nice heart, " agrees Stiegel.
Off to the side, a silent machine, connected by clear tubes to the patient, takes blood from his veins, cools it, fills it with oxygen, and pumps it back to his arteries to keep him alive until a heart beats in his chest again.
By 8:05, Hess begins sewing in the new heart.
An hour later, Hess unclamps the aorta, and the patient's blood flows through his new heart.
From one man's chest in
Operation Now Routine
It was the 24th operation performed at the hospital in 23 months.
Once front page news, heart transplants have become so routine in the Carolinas and the nation that each operation no longer rates a mention in local newspapers.
"It is just another heart operation, " says Dr.
Robicsek says he still finds each transplant novel and exciting, but he agrees the procedure has become routine.
"We are doing, every week, heart operations which are higher risk and more complicated than transplants, " says Robicsek, referring to other open-heart operations.
"The technique of transplant is more logistics than surgical brilliance, " he says. "Get the (donor) heart. Fly there. Pick it up. Right now you have four hours to get it out, transport it and put it in."
Washkansky lived only 18 days after that first transplant, but his death did little to dampen interest or enthusiasm.
However, it soon became apparent that the rest of medicine wasn't able to take over when the surgeons finished. One after another, patients died from infection or rejecting their new hearts.
By the third anniversary of Barnard's milestone operation, 166 transplants had been performed, but only 23 patients were alive -- an 85 percent mortality rate.
By the early 1970s, scores of surgeons abandoned the technique -- except for a few, such as Dr.
In the '70s, Shumway pioneered the use of an anti-rejection drug called cyclosporine, a critical step in allowing heart transplant patients to survive.
In the early 1980s, the popularity -- and success -- of heart transplants began going up. The number has jumped twentyfold in seven years, from 49 in 1980 to 1,002 in 1986. One-year survival has increased from 20 percent to more than 80 percent.
Five-year survival is about 60 percent, although at a cost of
Ten-year survival is projected to be between 25 percent and 50 percent.
Still, with the vast progress, there are problems and worries that plague the operation. First is the shortage of donor hearts -- many more operations could be done if there were hearts to be transplanted.
"We will never have enough hearts, " says Robicsek.
Each year, only 10 percent to 15 percent of an estimated 20,000 hearts that could be transplanted are donated.
Nationally, about 14,000 patients would benefit from heart transplants, according to Dr.
At any given time, about 300 people are waiting for new hearts, Van Trigt said, but about 30 percent to 40 percent die waiting.
At least 29 states, including
The N.C. law, which became effective
But approaching a family about organ donation at what is always an emotional time requires sensitive, trained professionals, people other than the doctors on the case, he says.
"It's not so easy to go to some people and ask, especially if you're involved, " says Robicsek. "You always have guilty feeling if you lose a patient.... You want to get the hell out. You don't want to see any more crying. You cry yourself. Your heart is breaking."
Until artificial hearts make it past the experimental stage, the number of transplants will depend on the availability of donors, Robicsek says.
"We don't have a very excessive waiting list (at Charlotte Memorial), but we always have three or four people waiting at one time.... And some of them die."
Another issue surrounding heart transplants is the rapid growth in the number of medical centers performing the operation. That increases competition for hearts and raises the question of whether all can provide the best-quality care.
In the Carolinas, six medical centers have performed 58 heart transplants since the first operation at
More heart transplants have been done at Charlotte Memorial than any of the other medical centers in the Carolinas. The others, besides Duke, performing the operation in
There has been some resistance to the growing number of transplant centers.
Only 10 of the nation's medical centers -- none in the Carolinas -- have qualified. Shumway, in an interview with
He suggests that hospitals with empty beds will use transplants as loss leaders, hoping the publicity will bring them other types of cardiac surgery.
Doctors at the
"We're able to follow up our patients very carefully and closely, " Thomley said at an
"I don't know how a center like
The heart transplant procedure also is troubled by several ethical debates.
Because the operation is so expensive, many hospitals require patients to have insurance coverage -- most plans cover the cost of heart transplants -- or make hefty down payments. At least for now, Robicsek says, he and his colleagues don't choose transplant recipients on their ability to pay.
"I am in practice in
There is also debate over whether the patient's quality of life after the transplant justifies the procedure.
Some experts point to the extensive drug regimen -- sometimes 20 or more pills a day -- that over time can weaken the patients' bones and cause cancer and kidney dysfunction. Coronary artery disease also plagues half the patients after five years.
"I was a big skeptic to start with, " acknowledges surgeon Hess. "But I've become more and more convinced that it's worthwhile. "If somebody gets 15 or 16 years, and is mostly out of the hospital and working, that's certainly worthwhile."
Transplants for infants are a different matter, says Robicsek. He questions the value of transplanting the hearts of infants, only to have them die perhaps five years later.
"You have to consider what you're doing. You are not playing with hearts. You're playing with lives."
On the other hand, he believes a 60-year-old who could live 10 more years is as justified in receiving a transplant as a 40-year-old who can live until 50.
"We are not curing things (with transplants), we are delaying things, " Robicsek says. "The same number of people die from lung cancer as died before, only later. The same number of people die from breast cancer, only later. If I do heart surgery on a person, he's going to die from heart disease at one point, but I hope I can delay it by 10 or 15 or 20 years."
In the Charlotte Memorial operating room, the patient's new heart jerks regularly inside the bloody chest cavity.
It has been pumping for about 45 minutes.
Surgeons and the half-dozen others in the operating room -- the anesthesiologist, the anesthetist, nurses and other doctors -- closely watch the television monitor in an upper corner of the room.
Jagged red and yellow lines show the patient's pulse and blood pressure getting stronger. "How we doing?" Hess asks.
"Looking real good, " replies
Hess pulls the tubes from his patient's chest and sews up an incision in the groin where an artery was attached to one of the machine's many tubes.
At 10:30, Hess takes a break to tell the patient's family the operation is a success.
In the hallway outside the operating room, he leans against the wall.
He has been working since
He has another hour's work to close the patient's chest.
And he's scheduled to be back in the operating room at
But he's not complaining. And he doesn't appear tired.
"The thing that's been so gratifying to me, " Hess says, "is that the patients come in so sick. They're almost given up for dead, and a month later, they walk out of the hospital.
(c)2016 The Charlotte Observer (Charlotte, N.C.)
Visit The Charlotte Observer (Charlotte, N.C.) at www.charlotteobserver.com
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.