Self-Regulatory Organizations; Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, Inc.; Notice of Filing of a Proposed Rule Change To Adopt FINRA Rules 0190…
Federal Information & News Dispatch, Inc. |
Self-Regulatory Organizations;
Citation: "79 FR 59322"
Document Number: "Release No. 34-73210; File No. SR-FINRA-2014-037"
Page Number: "59322"
"Notices"
September 25, 2014.
Pursuant to Section 19(b)(1) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 ("Act") /1/ and Rule 19b-4 thereunder, /2/ notice is hereby given that on
FOOTNOTE 1 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(1). END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 2 17 CFR 240.19b-4. END FOOTNOTE
I.
FINRA is proposing to adopt FINRA Rule 2040 (Payments to Unregistered Persons) regarding the payment of transaction-based compensation by members to unregistered persons, and Supplementary Material .01 (Reasonable Support for Determination of Compliance with Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act). The proposed rule change would streamline provisions of NASD Rule 2410 (Net Prices to Persons Not in Investment Banking or Securities Business), NASD Rule 2420 (Dealing with Non-Members), NASD IM-2420-1 (Transactions Between Members and Non-Members), NASD IM-2420-2 (Continuing Commissions Policy), Incorporated NYSE Rule 353 (Rebates and Compensation), Incorporated NYSE Rule Interpretation 345(a)(i)/01 (Compensation to Non-Registered Persons) and Incorporated NYSE Rule Interpretation 345(a)(i)/02 (Compensation Paid for Advisory Solicitations), which would be deleted from the current FINRA rulebook. The proposed rule change also would adopt the requirements of NASD Rule 1060(b) (Persons Exempt from Registration) and Incorporated NYSE Rule Interpretation 345(a)(i)/03 (Compensation to Non-Registered Foreign Persons Acting as Finders), as FINRA Rule 2040(c) (Nonregistered Foreign Finders) in the consolidated FINRA rulebook without material change. In addition, the proposed rule change would amend FINRA Rule 8311 (Effect of a Suspension, Revocation, Cancellation, or Bar), add new Supplementary Material .01 (Remuneration Accrued Prior to Effective Date of Sanction or Disqualification), and adopt the requirements of NASD IM-2420-1(a) (Non-members of the Association), as FINRA Rule 0190 (Effective Date of Revocation, Cancellation, Expulsion, Suspension or Resignation).
The text of the proposed rule change is available on FINRA's Web site at http://www.finra.org, at the principal office of FINRA and at the
II.
In its filing with the Commission, FINRA included statements concerning the purpose of and basis for the proposed rule change and discussed any comments it received on the proposed rule change. The text of these statements may be examined at the places specified in Item IV below. FINRA has prepared summaries, set forth in sections A, B, and C below, of the most significant aspects of such statements.
A.
1. Purpose
As part of the process of developing a new consolidated rulebook ("Consolidated FINRA Rulebook"), /3/ FINRA is proposing to adopt FINRA Rule 2040 (Payments to Unregistered Persons) regarding the payment of transaction-based compensation by members to unregistered persons, and Supplementary Material .01 (Reasonable Support for Determination of Compliance with Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act). The proposed rule change would streamline provisions of NASD Rule 2410 (Net Prices to Persons Not in Investment Banking or Securities Business), NASD Rule 2420 (Dealing with Non-Members), NASD IM-2420-1 (Transactions Between Members and Non-Members), NASD IM-2420-2 (Continuing Commissions Policy), NYSE Rule 353 (Rebates and Compensation), NYSE Rule Interpretation 345(a)(i)/01 (Compensation to Non-Registered Persons) and NYSE Rule Interpretation 345(a)(i)/02 (Compensation Paid for Advisory Solicitations), which would be deleted from the current FINRA rulebook. The proposed rule change also would adopt the requirements of NASD Rule 1060(b) (Persons Exempt from Registration) and NYSE Rule Interpretation 345(a)(i)/03 (Compensation to Non-Registered Foreign Persons Acting as Finders), as FINRA Rule 2040(c) (Nonregistered Foreign Finders) in the Consolidated FINRA Rulebook without material change. In addition, the proposed rule change would amend FINRA Rule 8311 (Effect of a Suspension, Revocation, Cancellation, or Bar), add new Supplementary Material .01 (Remuneration Accrued Prior to Effective Date of Sanction or Disqualification), and adopt the requirements of NASD IM-2420-1(a) (Non-members of the Association), as FINRA Rule 0190 (Effective Date of Revocation, Cancellation, Expulsion, Suspension or Resignation).
FOOTNOTE 3 The current FINRA rulebook consists of (1) FINRA Rules; (2) NASD Rules; and (3) rules incorporated from
A. Background
NASD Rule 1060(b) (Persons Exempt from Registration), NASD Rule 2410 (Net Prices to Persons Not in Investment Banking or Securities Business), NASD Rule 2420 (Dealing with Non-Members), NASD IM-2420-1 (Transactions Between Members and Non-Members), and NASD IM-2420-2 (Continuing Commissions Policy) (collectively, the "NASD Non-Member Rules") govern payments by members to unregistered persons. The NASD Non-Member Rules (other than NASD Rule 1060(b)) were developed in an era when a registered broker-dealer could engage in an over-the-counter securities business and elect not to be a member of a registered securities association. /4/ An original purpose of the NASD Non-Member Rules was to encourage non-members to become members by generally prohibiting members from providing commissions or discounts/concessions to non-members. /5/ Since the adoption of the NASD Non-Member Rules, the laws governing broker-dealers have changed, and today virtually all broker-dealers doing business with the public are FINRA members. /6/
FOOTNOTE 4 See
FOOTNOTE 5 Section 15A(e)(1) of the Exchange Act states that "[t]he rules of a registered securities association may provide that no member thereof shall deal with any nonmember professional (as defined in paragraph (2) of this subsection) except at the same prices, for the same commissions or fees, and on the same terms and conditions as are by such member accorded to the general public." Section 15A(e)(2) of the Exchange Act defines "nonmember professional" as "(A) with respect to transactions in securities other than municipal securities, any registered broker or dealer who is not a member of a registered securities association, except such a broker or dealer who deals exclusively in commercial paper, bankers' acceptances, and commercial bills, and (B) with respect to transactions in municipal securities, any municipal securities dealer (other than a bank or division or department of a bank) who is not a member of any registered securities association and any municipal securities broker who is not a member of any such association." The legislative reports from
FOOTNOTE 6 Section 15(b)(8) of the Exchange Act provides that "[i]t shall be unlawful for any registered broker or dealer to effect any transaction in, or induce or attempt to induce the purchase or sale of, any security (other than commercial paper, bankers' acceptances, or commercial bills), unless such broker or dealer is a member of a securities association registered pursuant to Section 15A of this title or effects transactions in securities solely on a national securities exchange of which it is a member." END FOOTNOTE
As a result, FINRA generally has interpreted the provisions of the NASD Non-Member Rules, through interpretive letters and other guidance, to prohibit the payment of commissions or fees derived from a securities transaction to any non-member that may be acting as an unregistered broker-dealer. Section 15(a)(1) of the Exchange Act generally requires any broker-dealer effecting transactions in securities to be registered with the
B. Proposed FINRA Rule 2040
FINRA is proposing to adopt new FINRA Rule 2040 (Payments to Unregistered Persons), which eliminates the current NASD Non-Member Rules and related NYSE Non-Member Rules (discussed further below) and replaces them with a more straightforward rule. The proposed rule expressly aligns with Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act and its related guidance to determine whether registration as a broker-dealer is required for certain persons to receive transaction-related compensation. As further discussed in Item II.C. below, the proposed rule change was published for comment in Regulatory Notice 09-69. /7/ FINRA received seven comment letters. A significant number of the commenters expressed concern regarding the potential regulatory burden of obtaining
FOOTNOTE 7 See Regulatory Notice 09-69 (
* Payments to Unregistered Persons
FINRA is proposing to adopt new FINRA Rule 2040(a), which prohibits members or associated persons from, directly or indirectly, paying any compensation, fees, concessions, discounts, commissions or other allowances to:
(1) any person that is not registered as a broker-dealer under Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act but, by reason of receipt of any such payments and the activities related thereto, is required to be so registered under applicable federal securities laws and SEA rules and regulations; or
(2) any appropriately registered associated person, unless such payment complies with all applicable federal securities laws, FINRA rules and SEA rules and regulations.
The proposed change would make the rule consistent with FINRA staff interpretations under NASD Rule 2420 and
FOOTNOTE 8 See FINRA Interpretative Letters issued under NASD Rule 2420: Letter to
FINRA is proposing to adopt Supplementary Material .01 (Reasonable Support for Determination of Compliance with Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act) to proposed FINRA Rule 2040 to provide guidance to members. In applying the proposed rule, FINRA will expect members to determine that their proposed activities would not require the recipient of the payments to register as a broker-dealer and to reasonably support such determination. Members that are uncertain as to whether an unregistered person may be required to be registered under Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act by reason of receiving payments from the member and the activities related thereto can derive support for their determination by, among other things, (1) reasonably relying on previously published releases, no-action letters or interpretations from the Commission or Commission staff that apply to their facts and circumstances; (2) seeking a no-action letter from the Commission staff; or (3) obtaining a legal opinion from independent, reputable U.S. licensed counsel knowledgeable in the area. The member's determination must be reasonable under the circumstances and should be reviewed periodically if payments to the unregistered person are ongoing in nature. In addition, a member must maintain books and records that reflect the member's determination.
* Retiring Representatives
FINRA is also proposing to adopt new FINRA Rule 2040(b), which codifies existing FINRA staff guidance on the payment by members of continuing commissions to retiring registered representatives. /9/ The proposal permits members to pay continuing commissions to retiring registered representatives of the member, after they cease to be associated with the member, that are derived from accounts held for continuing customers of the retiring registered representative regardless of whether customer funds or securities are added to the accounts during the period of retirement, provided that: (1) A bona fide contract between the member and the retiring registered representative providing for the payments was entered into in good faith while the person was a registered representative of the member and such contract, among other things, prohibits the retiring registered representative from soliciting new business, opening new accounts or servicing the accounts generating the continuing commission payments; and (2) the arrangement complies with applicable federal securities laws and SEA rules and regulations.
FOOTNOTE 9 See FINRA Interpretative Letters issued under NASD IM-2420-2: Letter to Name Not Public, dated
The proposal defines the term "retiring registered representative" to mean an individual who retires from a member (including as a result of a total disability) and leaves the securities industry. /10/ In the case of death of the retiring registered representative, the retiring registered representative's beneficiary designated in the written contract or the retiring registered representative's estate if no beneficiary is so designated may be the beneficiary of the respective member's agreement with the deceased representative.
FOOTNOTE 10 See SEC No-Action Letter to the
FINRA believes this proposal is consistent with
FOOTNOTE 11 See supra note 10. END FOOTNOTE
* Nonregistered Foreign Finders
As further discussed in Item II.C. below, in light of comments raised in response to Regulatory Notice 09-69, FINRA is proposing to transfer NASD Rule 1060(b) (Persons Exempt from Registration) and NYSE Rule Interpretation 345(a)(i)/03 (Compensation to Non-Registered Foreign Persons Acting as Finders) with minor technical changes into the Consolidated FINRA Rulebook as FINRA Rule 2040(c). /12/ As approved by the
FOOTNOTE 12 See supra note 7. END FOOTNOTE
(1) The member has assured itself that the finder who will receive the compensation is not required to register in
(2) the finder is a foreign national (not a U.S. citizen) or foreign entity domiciled abroad;
(3) the customers are foreign nationals (not U.S. citizens) or foreign entities domiciled abroad transacting business in either foreign or U.S. securities;
(4) customers receive a descriptive document, similar to that required by Rule 206(4)-3(b) of the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 ("Investment Advisers Act"), that discloses what compensation is being paid to finders;
(5) customers provide written acknowledgment to the member of the existence of the compensation arrangement and such acknowledgment is retained and made available for inspection by FINRA;
(6) records reflecting payments to finders are maintained on the member's books, and actual agreements between the member and the finder are available for inspection by FINRA; and
(7) the confirmation of each transaction indicates that a referral or finders fee is being paid pursuant to an agreement.
The rule provides that if all the conditions set forth in the rule are satisfied, members can pay transaction-related compensation to nonregistered foreign finders based on the business of non-U.S. customers that finders refer to members. Specifically, the rule permits compensation to "be made on an ongoing basis and tied to such variables as the level of business generated or assets under control, notwithstanding the fact that the foreign finders' sole involvement would be the initial referral to a member." /13/ The SEC Foreign Finders Approval Order states that "[t]he provision was intended to give members the opportunity to enhance their competitive position in foreign countries where new accounts are frequently opened on a referral basis with ongoing compensation for such referral." /14/
FOOTNOTE 13 See Securities Exchange Act Release No. 32431 (
FOOTNOTE 14 See supra note 13. END FOOTNOTE
Proposed FINRA Rule 2040(c) would have the same scope as the current rule and continue to allow on-going transaction-based payments to nonregistered foreign finders under the limited circumstances set forth in the current rule. As in the current rule, "[w]hile the foreign finders' sole involvement would be the initial referral to a member or member organization [of non-U.S. customers to the firm], compensation could be made on an ongoing basis and tied to such variables as the level of business generated or assets under control. All accounts referred by such foreign finders would be carried on the books of the member." /15/ Similar to NASD Rule 1060(b), any activities beyond the initial referral of non-U.S. customers and payment of transaction-based compensation for any such activities would not be within the permissible scope of the foreign finders exception as set forth in proposed FINRA Rule 2040(c). Based solely on its activities in compliance with proposed FINRA Rule 2040(c), the foreign finder would not be considered an associated person of the member. However, unless otherwise permitted by the federal securities laws or FINRA rules, a person who receives commissions or other transaction-based compensation in connection with securities transactions generally has to be a registered broker-dealer or an appropriately registered associated person of a broker-dealer who is supervised by a broker-dealer. Members that engage foreign finders would be required to have reasonable procedures that appropriately address the limited scope of activities permissible under such arrangements. /16/
FOOTNOTE 15 See Securities Exchange Act Release No. 34941 (
FOOTNOTE 16 See SEC Foreign Finders Approval Order. FINRA notes that the scope of permissible activities and associated regulatory requirements differ between foreign finders and foreign associates, who are registered persons of the member. See also NASD Rule 1100 (
C. Amendments to FINRA Rule 8311
* FINRA Rule 8311
FINRA is proposing amendments to FINRA Rule 8311 to eliminate duplicative provisions in NASD IM-2420-2 and to clarify the scope of the rule on payments by members to persons subject to suspension, revocation, cancellation, bar (each a "sanction") or other disqualification. The proposed rule provides that if a person is subject to a sanction or other disqualification, a member may not allow such person to be associated with it in any capacity that is inconsistent with the sanction imposed or disqualified status, including a clerical or ministerial capacity. The proposed rule further provides that a member may not pay or credit to any person subject to a sanction or disqualification, during the period of the sanction or disqualification or any period thereafter, any salary, commission, profit, or any other remuneration that the person might accrue, not just earn, during the period of the sanction or disqualification. However, a member may make payments or credits to a person subject to a sanction that are consistent with the scope of activities permitted under the sanction where the sanction solely limits an associated person from conducting specified activities (such as a suspension from acting in a principal capacity) or to a disqualified person that has been approved (or is otherwise permitted pursuant to FINRA rules and the federal securities laws) to associate with a member.
Specifically, the proposal clarifies that:
(1) Other disqualifications, not just suspensions, revocations, cancellations or bars, are subject to the rule (and the rule is not limited to orders issued by FINRA or the
(2) a member may not allow a person subject to a sanction or disqualification to "be" associated with such member in any capacity that is inconsistent with the sanction imposed or disqualified status, including a clerical or ministerial capacity, not simply "remain" associated;
(3) a member may not pay any remuneration to a person subject to a sanction or disqualification, not just payments that result directly or indirectly from any securities transaction; and
(4) the rule applies to any salary, commission, profit or remuneration that the associated person might "accrue," not just "earn" during the period of a sanction or disqualification, not just suspension.
FINRA is also proposing to add a new paragraph to the rule that would expressly permit a member to pay to any person subject to a sanction or disqualification any remuneration pursuant to an insurance or medical plan, indemnity agreement relating to legal fees, or as required by an arbitration award or court judgment. FINRA believes that these exceptions strike the correct balance by permitting certain key payments.
* Proposed Supplementary Material .01
In addition, FINRA is proposing to add new Supplementary Material .01 (Remuneration Accrued Prior to Effective Date of Sanction or Disqualification) that relates to commissions accrued by a person prior to the effective date of a sanction or disqualification. The proposed supplementary material would permit a member to pay a person that is subject to a sanction or disqualification remuneration that the member can evidence accrued to the person prior to the effective date of the sanction or disqualification. However, a member may not pay any remuneration that accrued to the person that relates to or results from the activity giving rise to the sanction or disqualification, and any such payment or credit must comply with applicable federal securities laws. FINRA believes that adopting this new provision is necessary to address questions by the industry on a member's ability to pay commissions and other remuneration that was accrued by the person prior to a sanction or disqualification going into effect. FINRA also believes the supplementary material, together with the proposed amendments discussed above, clarify that a member may not pay trail commissions to a person that may accrue during the period of the sanction or disqualification; rather, the member can only make such payments where the member can evidence that they accrued to the person prior to the effective date of the sanction or disqualification.
D. Adoption of New General Standard--FINRA Rule 0190
In addition, FINRA is proposing to adopt a new general standard, proposed FINRA Rule 0190 (Effective Date of Revocation, Cancellation, Expulsion, Suspension or Resignation), that is based largely on provisions of NASD IM-2420-1(a) and would provide that a member will be treated as a non-member of FINRA from the effective date of any order or notice from FINRA or the
E.
FINRA proposes to eliminate the following
* NASD Rule 2410
NASD Rule 2410 (Net Prices to Persons Not in Investment Banking and Securities Business) prohibits payments or concessions by members to "any person not actually engaged in the investment banking or securities business."
* NASD Rule 2420
NASD Rule 2420 (Dealing with Non-Members) generally prohibits members from dealing with, or making payments to, non-member broker-dealers, except at the same prices, fees or concessions offered to the general public. NASD Rule 2420(b) specifically prohibits members from joining any non-member broker-dealer syndicate or group in connection with the sale of securities. NASD Rule 2420(c) provides that members may pay concessions and fees to a non-member broker or dealer in a foreign country who is not eligible for membership, provided the member obtains an agreement from such foreign broker or dealer in making sales of securities within
* NASD IM-2420-1
NASD IM-2420-1 (Transactions between Members and Non-Members) provides certain exemptions from the general prohibition on arrangements with non-members set forth in NASD Rule 2420. For example, the rule provides exemptions for arrangements with certain non-members relating to transactions in "exempted securities," or transactions on a national securities exchange. The rule further clarifies that a firm that is suspended or expelled from FINRA membership, or whose registration is revoked by the
* NASD IM-2420-2
NASD IM-2420-2 (Continuing Commissions Policy) allows members to pay continuing commissions to former registered representatives after they cease to be employed by a member, if, among other things, a bona fide contract between the member and the registered representative calling for the payments was entered into in good faith while the person was a registered representative of the employing member. The rule states that such contracts cannot permit the solicitation of new business or the opening of new accounts by persons who are not registered, and must conform with all applicable laws and regulations. The rule also provides that NASD Rule 2830(c) (
* NYSE Rule 353
NYSE Rule 353 (Rebates and Compensation) prohibits a member, principal executive, registered representative or officer from, directly or indirectly, rebating to any person any part of the compensation he receives from the solicitation of orders for the purchase or sale of securities or other similar instruments for the accounts of customers of the member, or pay such compensation, or any part thereof, as a bonus, commission, fee or other consideration for business sought or procured for him or for any other member. NYSE Rule 353(b) further provides that a member, principal executive, registered representative or officer cannot be compensated for business done by or through his employer after the termination of his employment except as may be permitted by the
* NYSE Rule Interpretations 345(a)(i)/01 and/02
NYSE Rule Interpretation 345(a)(i)/01 (Compensation to Non-Registered Persons) prohibits a member from paying to nonregistered persons compensation based upon the business of customers they direct to the member if such compensation is, among other things, formulated as a direct percentage of commissions generated and is other than on an isolated basis.
NYSE Rule Interpretation 345(a)(i)/02 (Compensation Paid for Advisory Solicitations) provides that a member that is also registered with the
FINRA will announce the effective date of the proposed rule change in a Regulatory Notice to be published no later than 90 days following Commission approval. The effective date will be no later than 240 days following Commission approval.
2. Statutory Basis
FINRA believes that the proposed rule change is consistent with the provisions of Section 15A(b)(6) of the Exchange Act, /17/ which requires, among other things, that FINRA rules must be designed to prevent fraudulent and manipulative acts and practices, to promote just and equitable principles of trade, and, in general, to protect investors and the public interest. FINRA believes that the proposed rule change will clarify and streamline current
FOOTNOTE 17 15 U.S.C. 78 o -3(b)(6). END FOOTNOTE
B.
FINRA does not believe that the proposed rule change will result in any burden on competition that is not necessary or appropriate in furtherance of the purposes of the Act. FINRA believes the proposed rule change is consistent with Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act and its related guidance, and will promote the goal of clarity concerning the rules applicable to payments of transaction-based compensation to unregistered persons. Specifically, the proposed rule change will clarify and streamline current
As the proposed rule change aligns FINRA's requirements with the requirements of Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act, FINRA believes that the proposed rule change is appropriately tailored to minimize the burden and cost of complying with the proposed rule change. Moreover, FINRA believes that any burden from the proposal will be minimal because, while the proposal streamlines the current rule to make it more concise, the obligation of firms to analyze payment arrangements for compliance with Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act is not new. In addition, proposed Supplementary Material .01 (Reasonable Support for Determination of Compliance with Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act) to proposed FINRA Rule 2040 aims to assist compliance efforts by firms by providing guidance to members regarding the manner in which they can reasonably support a determination that an unregistered person is not required to be registered under Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act by reason of receiving payments from the member and the activities related thereto. Proposed Supplementary Material .01 (Remuneration Accrued Prior to Effective Date of Sanction or Disqualification) to FINRA Rule 8311 also provides guidance to firms regarding permissible payments.
C.
The proposed rule change was published for comment in Regulatory Notice 09-69 (
FOOTNOTE 18 See comment letters from
Most commenters appreciated the intent of the proposed rule change to more directly align the rules on payments made by FINRA members to unregistered persons with
As further discussed below, in light of the comments, FINRA is proposing to adopt Supplementary Material .01 (Reasonable Support for Determination of Compliance with Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act) to proposed FINRA Rule 2040 to provide guidance to members regarding the manner in which they can reasonably support a determination that an unregistered person is not required to be registered under Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act by reason of receiving payments from the member and the activities related thereto. FINRA is also proposing to retain NASD Rule 1060(b) and NYSE Rule Interpretation 345(a)(i)/03 relating to foreign finders as proposed FINRA Rule 2040(c).
(a) Foreign Finders (Proposed Deletion of NASD Rule 1060(b) and NYSE Rule Interpretation 345(a)(i)/03)
In the Notice, FINRA proposed deleting NASD Rule 1060(b) and NYSE Rule Interpretation 345(a)(i)/03 ("Existing Foreign Finders Rules"), which permit members to pay transaction-based compensation to nonregistered foreign finders under specified conditions. The Notice indicated that these largely identical rules would be deleted and the activity would be subject to the general requirement in proposed FINRA Rule 2040(a) that would require firms to look to
FOOTNOTE 19 See Intercam,
FOOTNOTE 20 See supra note 19. END FOOTNOTE
* Harm Business/Reduce Competitiveness
Several commenters expressed concern regarding the potential harm to current business models if NASD Rule 1060(b) is eliminated. /21/ One commenter stated that foreign "finders provide an important and necessary service in that they have introduced foreign customers to U.S. markets, which is consistent with the transition of the financial markets to be international in nature." /22/ Another commenter stated that the proposed elimination of the standard established by the
FOOTNOTE 21 See Intercam,
FOOTNOTE 22 See Monex. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 23 See Morgan Lewis. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 24 See Morgan Lewis. As noted above, if a foreign finder's activities go beyond an initial referral of non-U.S. customers to the member, the foreign finders provisions in proposed FINRA Rule 2040(c) would not be applicable. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 25 See Monex. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 26 See Monex and LeGaye Law. END FOOTNOTE
* SEC Guidance Relating to Foreign Finder Relationships is Not Clear
Four commenters noted that the
FOOTNOTE 27 See Intercam,
FOOTNOTE 28 See Morgan Lewis. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 29 See Monex and LeGaye Law. END FOOTNOTE
Several commenters urged FINRA to work with the
FOOTNOTE 30 See Monex, LeGaye Law and Morgan Lewis. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 31 See Morgan Lewis. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 32 See Monex and LeGaye Law. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 33 See Plexus. END FOOTNOTE
* Existing Foreign Finders Rules Provide Necessary Clarity
Several commenters expressed concern that the proposed elimination of the Existing Foreign Finders Rules would eliminate rules that the industry has relied on for decades to pay transaction-based compensation to foreign finders. /34/ One commenter stated that the Existing Foreign Finders Rules have "generally allowed FINRA members, under the enumerated conditions, to pay transaction-based compensation to a non-U.S. finder that solicits non-U.S. business for the member." /35/ The same commenter further stated that "there were a number of critical components that had to be met with respect to the rule, two of the fundamental conditions with respect to the payment of compensation to a foreign finder was: (1) That the foreign finder limit its activities so that the finder was not required to register in the U.S. as a broker-dealer; and (2) that the compensation arrangement not violate applicable foreign law." As a result, the commenter contended that "FINRA member firms should be able to rely on clear guidance with respect to these activities, and the current rules gave that guidance to members." /36/ Another commenter stated that "the existing rules with respect to foreign referrals and dealing with non-member firms are helpful and provide adequate protection to foreign customers that are referred to FINRA members." /37/
FOOTNOTE 34 See Intercam,
FOOTNOTE 35 See Monex. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 36 See supra note 35. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 37 See Morgan Lewis. END FOOTNOTE
* FINRA Response to Comments on Existing Foreign Finders Rules
In response to the commenters' concerns, FINRA is proposing to adopt the Existing Foreign Finders Rules, with minor technical changes, as new FINRA Rule 2040(c) in the Consolidated FINRA Rulebook. As in the current rule, a member could pay transaction-related compensation to nonregistered foreign finders where the finders' sole involvement is the initial referral to the member of non-U.S. customers to the member, and the member complies with all the conditions set forth in the rule.
(b) Continuing Commission Payments to Retiring Registered Representatives (Proposed FINRA Rule 2040(b)(2))
Proposed Rule 2040(b)(2) would permit FINRA members to pay continuing commissions to retiring registered representatives of the member after they cease to be associated with the member provided that (1) a bona fide contract between the member and the retiring registered representative providing for the payments was entered into in good faith while the person was a registered representative of the member and such contract, among other things, prohibits the retiring registered representative from soliciting new business, opening new accounts, or servicing the accounts generating the continuing commission payments; and (2) the arrangement complies with applicable federal securities laws, SEA rules and regulations. In the Notice, the proposed rule included text that provided that the arrangement also must comply with "published guidance issued by the
FOOTNOTE 38 See CAI. END FOOTNOTE
One commenter stated it is unclear whether the proposal is intended to add any substantive restrictions or requirements, or if it merely forbids members from making payments that are already otherwise prohibited. /39/ The commenter noted that FINRA members are already subject to
FOOTNOTE 39 See supra note 38. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 40 See supra note 38. END FOOTNOTE
Another commenter raised concerns regarding the open-ended nature of this provision. /41/ The commenter expressed concern regarding the extent of hidden fee arrangements between shadow parties who trade consumers' accounts and questioned, "[h]as there been consideration as to potential trigger points wherein these types of post `retirement' payment pose potential and/or actual conflicts of interest, the dangers to the underlying account holder whose assets are being used to generate fees that are split by multiple parties, and is full disclosure to consumers being provided?" /42/
FOOTNOTE 41 See NASAA. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 42 See supra note 41. END FOOTNOTE
FINRA believes that the
FOOTNOTE 43 See supra note 10. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 44 See SEC No-Action Letters:
Consistent with such
FOOTNOTE 45 See supra note 9. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 46 See supra note 9. END FOOTNOTE
(c) Transactions with Foreign Non-Members (Proposed Deletion of NASD Rule 2420(c))
NASD Rule 2420(c) generally provides that payments can be made to any non-member broker-dealer in a foreign country who is not eligible for membership in a registered securities association provided that, in any transaction with any such non-member broker-dealer where a selling concession, discount, or other allowance is allowed, the member making the payment secures from the foreign broker-dealer an agreement that, in making any sales to purchasers within the U.S. of securities acquired as a result of such transactions, the foreign broker-dealer will comply with paragraphs (a) and (b) of NASD Rule 2420 to the same extent the member must in connection with the transaction.
One commenter stated that "[w]hile this rule does not expressly address the relationship between U.S. clearing firms and their non-U.S. correspondents, it is frequently cited as confirmation that the FINRA rules permit members to enter into a variety of clearing and sub-clearing agreements and other brokerage arrangements with foreign non-members and to share fees or pay other forms of compensation without requiring the foreign firms or their personnel to register with the
FOOTNOTE 47 See Morgan Lewis. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 48 Id. END FOOTNOTE
FINRA declines to retain NASD Rule 2420(c) because, as discussed in detail above, proposed FINRA Rule 2040(a) expressly aligns with Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act and its related guidance to determine whether registration as a broker-dealer is required for persons to receive transaction-related compensation. In this regard, FINRA notes the commenter's suggestion that, if FINRA were to retain NASD Rule 2420(c), FINRA should replace the phrase "eligible for membership in a national securities association" with "not being required to be a registered broker-dealer in
FINRA also declines to eliminate the word "appropriately" and to narrow the scope of the pre-conditions in proposed FINRA Rule 2040(c) to require that the member only determine that a person receiving transaction-related compensation is registered and not subject to any statutory disqualification because FINRA believes that members need to determine that the person receiving the transaction-related compensation is registered in the appropriate category necessary to receive the type of compensation being paid, and that the payments are permissible under applicable laws, consistent with
(d) Compensation Paid for Advisory Solicitations (Proposed Deletion of NYSE Rule Interpretation 345(a)(i)/02)
One commenter stated "there has been substantial confusion related to the regulation of broker-dealers and investment advisers that were dually registered with the
FOOTNOTE 49 See LeGaye Law. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 50 NYSE Rule Interpretation 345/(a)(i)/02 (Compensation Paid for Advisory Solicitations) reads as follows: "A member organization, registered with the
FOOTNOTE 51 See Rule 206(4)-3 (Cash Payments for Client Solicitations) of the Investment Advisers Act, which generally makes it unlawful for any investment adviser that is required to be registered under the Investment Advisers Act to pay a cash fee, directly or indirectly, to a solicitor with respect to solicitation activities unless certain specified conditions are met. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 52 See supra note 49. END FOOTNOTE
FINRA does not believe that it is necessary to retain the content of NYSE Rule Interpretation 345(a)(i)/02. It is FINRA's view that proposed FINRA Rule 2040 does not narrow the scope of Rule 206(4)-3 under the Investment Advisers Act, which applies to cash payments by investment advisers for client solicitations for advisory business. Where Rule 206(4)-3 payments to an investment adviser by a dually registered broker-dealer do not require the solicitor to register under Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act, proposed FINRA Rule 2040 would continue to permit them. The question of whether activities permissible under Rule 206(4)-3 under the Investment Advisers Act would require the solicitor to be registered as a broker-dealer under Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act is determined by the
FOOTNOTE 53
(e) Burden of Obtaining SEC No-Action Relief
Two commenters raised concerns regarding the requirement in proposed FINRA Rule 2040 to look to
FOOTNOTE 54 See Monex and LeGaye Law. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 55 See Monex. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 56 See Monex, LeGaye Law, Morgan Lewis and NASAA. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 57 See supra note 55. END FOOTNOTE
FOOTNOTE 58 See supra note 55. END FOOTNOTE
FINRA believes that interpretation of Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act is a critical component in determining whether payments to unregistered persons are permissible under the federal securities laws. FINRA acknowledges that while Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act does not specifically address the numerous and varying arrangements that may exist with respect to payments to unregistered persons,
As described in Item 3 above, FINRA is proposing to adopt Supplementary Material .01 (Reasonable Support for Determination of Compliance with Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act) to proposed FINRA Rule 2040 to provide guidance to members regarding the manner in which they can reasonably support a determination that an unregistered person is not required to be registered under Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act by reason of receiving payments from the member and the activities related thereto. Members can derive support for their determination by, among other things, (1) reasonably relying on previously published releases, no-action letters or interpretations from the Commission or Commission staff that apply to their facts and circumstances; (2) seeking a no-action letter from the Commission staff; or (3) obtaining a legal opinion from independent, reputable U.S. licensed counsel knowledgeable in the area. The member's determination must be reasonable under the circumstances and should be reviewed periodically if payments to the unregistered person are ongoing in nature. In addition, a member must maintain books and records that reflect the member's determination.
(f) Proposal Does Not Recognize State Law Exemptions
One commenter expressed concern that the proposal does not address those FINRA members that engage in primarily an intra-state business, and the state of their domicile recognizes statutory exemptions for the payment of compensation in limited circumstances for certain finders. /59/ FINRA acknowledges that state rules and regulations may permit different types of payment arrangements, and where such payments are permissible under the federal securities laws and
FOOTNOTE 59 See LeGaye Law. END FOOTNOTE
(g) Payments to Sanctioned Persons (FINRA Rule 8311)
The proposed rule change prohibits FINRA members from allowing persons subject to suspension, revocation, cancellation of registration, bar from association with a member or other disqualification to be associated with the member in any capacity inconsistent with the sanction. The proposal also would prohibit payment to a person during the period of sanction or anytime thereafter if the payment might accrue during the time of sanction.
One commenter believed the proposal is unclear as to whether registered representatives subject to sanctions would be permitted to continue to receive compensation earned as a result of automatic payments to a variable annuity contract made during the period of sanction. /60/ The commenter recommended that registered representatives be permitted to receive these automatic payments, where such payments were arranged for during a time period that preceded the sanctions.
FOOTNOTE 60 See CAI. END FOOTNOTE
FINRA believes that proposed Supplementary Material .01 (Remuneration Accrued Prior to Effective Date of Sanction or Disqualification) to FINRA Rule 8311 addresses this question. Proposed Supplementary Material .01 provides that a member can pay or credit a person subject to a sanction salary, commission, profit or other remuneration that the member can evidence accrued to the person prior to the effective date of the sanction, unless such remuneration relates to results from the activity giving rise to the sanction. Accordingly, a member would need to demonstrate that the remuneration accrued prior to the effective date of the sanction in order to pay or credit the remuneration to the sanctioned individual.
The commenter also requested that FINRA clarify that the sanctions identified under the proposal do not in any way impact the current FINRA rules and guidance regarding registered representatives who are deemed to be "inactive" due to failure to complete the regulatory element of continuing education requirements in a timely manner under NASD Rule 1120 (now FINRA Rule 1250). /61/ FINRA notes that the proposal is not intended to alter existing guidance under FINRA Rule 1250 with respect to registered representatives who are deemed to be "inactive" due to failure to complete the regulatory element of continuing education requirements in a timely manner.
FOOTNOTE 61 The
III. Date of Effectiveness of the Proposed Rule Change and Timing for Commission Action
Within 45 days of the date of publication of this notice in the
(A) By order approve or disapprove such proposed rule change, or
(B) institute proceedings to determine whether the proposed rule change should be disapproved.
IV. Solicitation of Comments
Interested persons are invited to submit written data, views and arguments concerning the foregoing, including whether the proposed rule change is consistent with the Act. Comments may be submitted by any of the following methods:
Electronic Comments
* Use the Commission's Internet comment form (http://www.sec.gov/rules/sro.shtml); or
* Send an email to [email protected]. Please include File Number SR-FINRA-2014-037 on the subject line.
Paper Comments
* Send paper comments in triplicate to
All submissions should refer to File Number SR-FINRA-2014-037. This file number should be included on the subject line if email is used. To help the Commission process and review your comments more efficiently, please use only one method. The Commission will post all comments on the Commission's Internet Web site (http://www.sec.gov/rules/sro.shtml). Copies of the submission, all subsequent amendments, all written statements with respect to the proposed rule change that are filed with the Commission, and all written communications relating to the proposed rule change between the Commission and any person, other than those that may be withheld from the public in accordance with the provisions of 5 U.S.C. 552, will be available for Web site viewing and printing in the
For the Commission, by the
FOOTNOTE 62 17 CFR 200.30-3(a)(12). END FOOTNOTE
Kevin M. O'Neill,
Deputy Secretary.
[FR Doc. 2014-23308 Filed 9-30-14;
BILLING CODE 8011-01-P
Copyright: | (c) 2014 Federal Information & News Dispatch, Inc. |
Wordcount: | 11387 |
ALOM Hosts National Manufacturing Day Event For Future Supply Chain Professionals
Advisor News
Annuity News
Health/Employee Benefits News
Life Insurance News