Sat, Mar 8, 2014 / Updated 10:03 PM EST
Have you considered becoming an
See Your Ad Here
Property & Casualty
Dayton Daily News, Ohio, Tom Archdeacon column
Bipartisan Lawmakers Defend Medicare
Proposal Could Limit Access To Death File
Why unemployment insurance must continue
Big Changes Coming To Workplace Benefits
Reed Files Bill to Restore Emergency Unemployment Insurance for Six Months
Amusement parks rarely face fines for ride accidents
Permanent Life Insurance Experiences A Rebirth
Life Carriers Look At Bundling To Boost Sales
A Dip But Not A Crash In Life Applications In 2013
For Those Denied Insurance Because Of Preexisting Conditions, Health Reform Would Bring Major Change
November 04, 2009
Copyright 2009 San Jose Mercury NewsAll Rights Reserved
31, 2009 Saturday
For those denied
because of preexisting conditions, health reform would bring major change
By Mike Zapler
WASHINGTON Kelsey Jessup, 26, is a model of healthful living. The Palo Alto native runs five days a week, practices yoga and stays away from red meat. But none of that mattered when Jessup recently applied for health
. Because she had knee surgery to repair a high school soccer injury and went to the emergency room after fainting a few years ago, she was denied coverage by multiple insurers.
Ronald Sturm, 62, of San Jose is diabetic but has managed his condition for five years with regular insulin shots and by eating right. Otherwise he's in good shape, he says, pointing to his part-time job as a referee running up and down high school gymnasiums. But Sturm, too, can't get coverage; he pays out of pocket for doctor visits and medications and prays nothing major happens to him before he qualifies for Medicare at age 65.
"If I have a serious illness or get hit by a softball and have to go the ER," he said, "I'm in trouble."
The fear of going without health
and the frustration of not being able to do anything about it because of a preexisting condition is shared by millions of Americans who have tried unsuccessfully to buy
on their own or worry about someday having to do so.
With rising unemployment and fast-rising health care costs eroding the security of employer-provided medical benefits, those concerns are fueling Congress' push for sweeping new regulations of private health insurers.
While much of the
health care debate
has focused on whether or not to create a so-called public option, or government-run health plan, the most fundamental change that Congress is considering may be its move to outlaw insurers' policy of seeking the healthiest patients and weeding out those most likely to need medical care, a practice known as medical underwriting.
"For people buying
on their own, it would be a completely different" experience, said Gary Claxton, a vice president at the Kaiser Family Foundation, a nonprofit health care research foundation. "They'd have a menu of good benefits to shop for and buy, and insurers couldn't turn you down for a preexisting condition. That just doesn't happen much now."
Some of the stories about preexisting conditions and health
border on the absurd. In one recent case, a 4-month-old boy in Colorado was denied coverage because, at 17 pounds, the
company deemed him too fat. The Huffington Post reported this month that a Florida woman was rejected because she took anti-AIDS drugs after being raped, raising questions among insurers about whether she had HIV. And documents uncovered a few years ago by Consumer Watchdog detailed the underwriting practices of some large California insurers, which included automatically denying coverage to anyone with acne, asthma or attention deficit disorder, among other conditions, as well as expectant fathers and construction workers.
Short of those extremes are millions of other cases in which people with medical conditions, serious and minor, have found themselves at the mercy of private insurers because they don't have group coverage through a job. Plans provided by large employers do not discriminate against those with preexisting conditions, as their higher health care costs are offset by those of healthier employees.
When the Mercury News recently asked readers to share their experiences with the health care system, time and again they wrote of being denied
for reasons beyond their control.
Trish Curren, a 32-year-old mother of two from Santa Clara, applied for
but was turned away repeatedly because she previously had been diagnosed with gallstone pancreatitis and irritable bowel syndrome. She went uninsured for 18 months but later managed to get coverage from the department store where she works. But the bare-bones plan carries a $4,000 deductible, which she can't afford on her minimum wage salary.
Lately, when she's particularly stressed, Curren's face has gone numb and she feels heaviness in her chest symptoms that she fears could signal a heart condition. But she won't go to the doctor.
"It does worry me. I have two young kids," she said. "I'm trying to manage it the best I can on my own."
company representatives say their underwriting practices are driven by economic necessity. "
doesn't work if only the people who are likely to have expensive health care costs buy the
," said Patrick Johnston, president and CEO of the California Association of Health Plans.
To that end, the health reform proposals pending in Congress envision a grand trade-off. Insurers would have to accept all comers, regardless of health condition only a person's age, geographic location, family size and whether they smoke could be used to determine premiums.
In exchange, all Americans would be required to buy
, in many cases with the help of government subsidies, depending on their income. The so-called individual mandate could deliver tens of millions of new customers to
companies, including many young and healthy people who now forgo coverage.
industry recently has balked at the deal, worried that it will end up with the short end of the stick. Specifically, insurers are concerned that the subsidies to help people afford
and the penalties for not complying with the individual mandate are not adequate.
Those who can't get
now because of a preexisting condition say something has to change.
Sturm, who owns two carpet-cleaning franchises in addition to his work as a referee, is paying for his own diabetes medication and grateful to his doctor of 30 years for giving him a cut rate on office visits. The San Jose resident has been uninsured for four years, ever since he missed a premium payment when he traveled to Ohio for his mother's funeral, prompting his
company to cancel his plan.
Since then, he's tried repeatedly to get
on his own, to no avail. "I'm a diabetic on insulin," he said, "so they want nothing to do with me."
As she pursues a career as a musician and songwriter, Jessup is making ends meet as a waitress, a job that does not offer health benefits. The UCLA graduate, who now lives in Marina del Rey, said the reality of her situation crystallized recently when a friend who also lacks
broke her arm in a boating accident. The resulting hospital bill left her $20,000 in debt.
Jessup said she never imagined she'd be uninsured.
"The thing that's so infuriating to me is I'm one of the healthiest people I know," she said. "I was taught to be proactive about my health and now I feel like I'm being punished for it. It's like if you went to the doctor, they won't insure you. That's crazy."
Contact Mike Zapler at 202-662-8921.
companies to accept all applicants, regardless of health condition. Only age, geographic location, family size and whether a person smokes could be used to determine premiums. In the main Senate bill, an older person could be charged as much as four times more than a younger applicant for the same coverage; the House plan limits that range to 2 to 1. The same restrictions would apply when coverage is renewed. Bar insurers from rescinding coverage after a person becomes ill. Provide immediate assistance through a "high-risk pool" to people who have been uninsured for several months due to a preexisting condition. People would receive government subsidies to purchase health
until the other reforms take effect in 2013.
About 6.8 million Californians " almost 19 percent of the population " are uninsured for all or part of the year. Of those who are insured, approximately 2 million people buy health
through the individual market, and about 19.7 million Californians receive coverage through a job, while the rest are insured through government programs. The proportion of state residents with employer-based coverage dropped from 58 percent to 54 percent between 2000 and 2007.
Source: U.S. Census data, Mercury News research
November 3, 2009
Copyright © 2009 LexisNexis, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Terms and Conditions
comments powered by Disqus.
comments powered by
Back to Top
More Life Insurance News
RiverSource Boosts Universal Life With LTC Rider
2nd Person Gets Prison In Texas Investment Fraud
Ill. Insurance Department Warns About STOLIs
Nationwide Joins LPL Financial’s Worksite Financial Solutions Platform
Coalition To Address Issues Surrounding Death Master File
Gen X And Gen Y Showing The Right Retirement Savings Chromosomes
John Hancock Changes How 401(k) Plans Are Priced
Commissioner Revokes Iowa Insurance Producer's License
LIMRA: Changes In Consumer Expectations Present Challenge For Industry
How ING Advisors Are Using Social Media To Connect With Clients
MassMutual CEO's Pay Down 29% To $14.4 Million
Iowa Insurance Agent Pleads Guilty To Mail Fraud
Man Sentenced In Massachusetts Fraud Case
John Hancock Offers Improved LTC Rider On All Single Life Products
Many Plan To Put Their Tax Refund Toward Debt
More Life Insurance News
Most Popular Life Insurance News
Life Carriers Look At Bundling To Boost Sales
Insurers’ Net Income Soars 56% In 4Q
Electronic Signatures Assume Wider Usage With John Hancock Announcement
Life Insurance Industry Reacts To Tax Reform Proposal
State Farm Announces 2013 Financial Results
More Popular Life Insurance News
Hot off the Wires
County, state and congressional candidates line up for June 3 primary
Hoyer Statement on February Jobs Report
Congresswoman Duckworth Gives Floor Speech Calling on Unemployment Extension for 2 million Americans - 200,000 Veterans
Oklahoma GOP: Commissioner Doak: Obama Rearranges Chairs on the Titanic of Healthcare
King on Jobs Report: Congress Must Renew Emergency Unemployment Compensation Program
More Hot News
Denotes premium content. Learn more about becoming an Insider
No thanks, continue to article.
Life & Health
Property & Casualty
Mergers & Acquisitions
Subscription to Magazine
Advertise with Us
Top Insurance News
InsuranceNewsNet.com , Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Terms & Conditions of Service
. Not an Insider?
Advertise with Us