Thu, Apr 17, 2014 / Updated 5:52 AM EST
Have you considered becoming an
See Your Ad Here
Property & Casualty
Add Your FREE Listing To The National Insurance Directory for Consumers
Rep. Schweikert: Letter to Secretary Sebelius Calls for Appeal Request Rates
Obamacare tricky for Weld ag producers
Johnson & Johnson Acquires Stateside Underwriting Agency, Inc.
Introducing a Better Source for Merchant Cash Advance Loans, Thanks to Leading Alternative Lender, Business Cash Advance Guru, an Affordable Source for Capital
Testimony of Secretary of Labor Thomas E. Perez Before the Committee on Education and the Workforce, U.S. House of Representatives, March 26, 2014
$201 Million Policy Could Be Good Omen
DeFazio Praises Senate on Passage of Unemployment Benefits Extension
Other States Challenging Wealthy Taxpayers Who Claim Fla. Residency
Why Fixed Annuities Will Be Strong Sellers Through 2018
August 28, 2009
Health Care Reform Likely To Affect Workers Compensation
Copyright 2009 Crain CommunicationsAll Rights Reserved Business
August 24, 2009
NEWS; Pg. 0014
Health care reform likely to affect workers compensation
Changes made to the nation’s health care system likely will affect workers compensation, even though legislation under debate makes no mention of occupational medicine, industry experts say.
Because workers comp medical costs comprise just 3% of overall U.S. health care spending, according to the National Council of Compensation Insurance Inc., experts say it is unlikely Congress will address it as part of health reform legislation.
In addition, the workers comp industry has been fighting to make sure occupational medicine stays out of legislation to reform health care to prevent a repeat the 1990s Clinton administration effort to include it.
“If you’re trying to figure out how to reform the U.S. health care system, you’re probably going to focus on the big things first,” said Harry Shuford, chief economist at the Boca Raton, Fla.-based NCCI. “Work comp and bodily injury, liability, etc. are all very small. So they would be tertiary issues to address.”
“The big issues that policymakers are wrestling with don’t have much relevance to workers comp. Whether to have a public option, change the tax treatment of premiums paid by employers, I don’t see either of those having a significant role in workers comp,” Mr. Shuford said.
“Many people have made the comparison between this legislation and that which was proposed in the 1990s,” said Paul Mattera, chief public affairs officer at Liberty Mutual Insurance Co. in Boston. The Clinton administration plan “would have taken the 40% of the work comp dollar that went to pay medical benefits and folded it into nonoccupational medical care. As a result, work comp carriers would only be responsible for the disability portion and wouldn’t have been able to control any of the medical.”
But “this time around, there’s no explicit reference to work comp,” which has brought the industry some relief, Mr. Mattera said. “We don’t feel the same sense of panic this time, although there’s deep concern, partly because it’s unclear how it will play out as far as workers compensation is concerned.”
Regardless of the form that health care legislation takes, it likely will have an indirect effect on workers comp costs, industry experts say.
“You can’t fundamentally alter the national health care system and not affect workers comp,” said Dave North, president and chief executive officer of Sedgwick Claims Management Services Inc. in Memphis, Tenn.
“If you look back at the national dialogue that occurred at the start of the Clinton era, we saw in this country significant changes in health care in the years following, and there was no legislation passed. The heightened dialogue and awareness alone caused significantly positive health care reform for employers,” Mr. North said.
Any efforts that improve the overall health of the population also could affect workers comp costs.
“An area we don’t have an ability to touch from the occupational side is prevention and wellness,” Mr. North said. “And we know that comorbidities—specifically obesity, diabetes, mental health and substance abuse—affect workers compensation. Comorbidities affect both the likelihood that a worker will have an injury as well as their recovery period.”
“We see this in California,” said Mark Webb, vp-governmental relations at Employers Direct Insurance Co. in Thousand Oaks, Calif. “In many cases, these conditions need to be brought under control before the work comp system” can treat an occupational injury, he said.
Obesity also is driving up the cost of occupational injuries, with comp carriers in some cases paying for bariatric surgery in addition to the workplace injury suffered to enable a claimant to return to work sooner and less likely to suffer re-injury because of his or her lower weight, Mr. Webb said.
Should health care reform efforts reduce medical errors, that also could positively affect workers comp costs, said Rita Nowak, vp, commercial lines and workers comp, at the Property Casualty Insurers Assn. of America in Des Plaines, Ill. Insurers must pick up the tab for such errors if they occur in the treatment of an injured claimant, she said. Medical errors also can lead to longer disability periods while claimants recover, she said.
Because many doctors treat occupational and nonoccupational illnesses and injuries, pay-for-performance revisions could compensate them based on outcomes and using evidence-based medicine, NCCI’s Mr. Shuford said.
“If you start seeing a move from fee-for-service to some sort of pay-for-performance compensation structure” for health care, “you will see workers comp starting to adopt those as well,” Mr. Shuford said.
But if health reform includes price controls on provider reimbursements, “we would be concerned about potential cost-shifting” by providers to work comp insurers “to recoup lost revenue,” Ms. Nowak said.
“To the extent that this health reform creates a public plan, which seeks to reimburse providers at or below what they’re being reimbursed today, they are going to look to other payers to recapture some of those costs,” Liberty Mutual’s Mr. Mattera said. “So cost-shifting could potentially be exacerbated with reform.”
Likewise, any change in Medicare reimbursement rates would affect states that base their occupational health fee schedules on Medicare rates, leading to greater cost-shifting, Mr. Mattera said.
Workers comp pharmacy costs also are driven by state fee schedules that are linked indirectly to Medicare reimbursement rates, said Jay Krueger, chief strategy officer at Tampa, Fla.-based PMSI, a provider of pharmacy, medical services and equipment to the workers compensation and liability markets.
Mr. Krueger said health reform that requires providers to adopt technology also could increase costs in the workers comp system.
“Workers comp is not quite as technologically advanced as the group health side. To the extent that the federal government either mandates or provides stimulus money to adopt electronic solutions, that will represent wholesale change for the workers comp industry,” he said.
“Long term, this is good for the industry,” Mr. Krueger said, but “many companies have rather arcane (information technology) systems and the cost to upgrade them to meet health IT requirements is very significant.”
But adoption of electronic medical records, which would provide claimants’ full medical histories, could lead to quicker determinations of whether an injury is work-related, Mr. Webb said.
Copyright 2009 Crain Communications Inc. All Rights Reserved.
August 28, 2009
Copyright © 2009 LexisNexis, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Terms and Conditions
comments powered by Disqus.
comments powered by
Back to Top
More Property & Casualty
NICB: Where Storms Hit, Fraud Often Follows
Former Chiropractor, Co-Defendant Sentenced In Insurance Fraud Scheme
Democrats Shift From Climate 'Change' To 'Adaptation' To Woo Republicans
1 In 6 Car Buyers Skips Test-Drive
N.J. Officials Fight Distracted Driving
P&C Pricing Expectations Getting Worse
Endurance Bids $3.2 Billion For Aspen Insurance
The Top 10 Risks Facing Businesses In 2014
Senators Push FEMA On Flood Insurance
Fla. Home Insurance Rights Bill Advances, But Squabbles To Follow
Study: Terrorism Risk Insurance Act Protects American Taxpayers
Below-Average 2014 Atlantic Hurricane Season Predicted
Mass. Judge Blasts AIG In $7M Decision
Head Of Car Title Scam Pleads Guilty
Texas Hailstorm Caused An Estimated $300M In Damage
More Property & Casualty
Most Popular Property & Casualty
South Florida Insurer Cancels Thousands Before Storm Season
Ohio's Insurance Industry Needs 26,000 Workers By 2020
Governors Show Support For State-Based Insurance Regulation
Federal Disaster Aid For Colorado Flooding Tops $304 Million
Wash. State Disciplines, Fines Insurance Producers $23,050
More Popular Property & Casualty
Hot off the Wires
Changing outcomes at a young age
Bank of America loses money in first quarter after settlement
New York Personal Injury Lawyer Kenneth A. Wilhelm Discusses Fatal Midtown Scaffolding Accident
Vince Holding Corp. Announces Independent Directors
Rockefeller, McCaskill, Thune, Heller Seek Information Regarding Delphi's Role in GM Recalls
More Hot News
Denotes premium content. Learn more about becoming an Insider
No thanks, continue to article.
Life & Health
Property & Casualty
Mergers & Acquisitions
Subscription to Magazine
Advertise with Us
Top Insurance News
InsuranceNewsNet.com , Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Terms & Conditions of Service
. Not an Insider?
Advertise with Us